| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Michael Cazares (fresh) SG - Frederick Humphrey (fresh) SF - Trey Lemieux (fresh) PF - Quentin Shue (fresh) C - Jerry Hawes (fresh) | |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Barry Schafer (fresh) SG - Louis Thompson (fresh) SF - Jacob Lindberg (fresh) PF - David Futral (fresh) C - Michael Gerardi (fresh) | |
| 20:00 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi wins the tip | 0-0 |
| Game Plan | Otterbein | Otterbein is playing a fastbreak offense and a fullcourt press (+1) | |
| Game Plan | John Carroll | John Carroll is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (0) | |
| 19:34 | John Carroll | Louis Thompson drills a jumper from the right block | 0-2 |
| 19:21 | Otterbein | Frederick Humphrey is whistled for a carry | 0-2 |
| 18:59 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi comes up short on the driving attempt near the basket but the foul's on Jerry Hawes - foul #1 on Jerry Hawes, team foul #1 | 0-2 |
| 18:59 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi makes the 1st free throw | 0-3 |
| 18:59 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi makes the 2nd free throw | 0-4 |
| 18:46 | Otterbein | Trey Lemieux connects on the fadeaway jumper from the right side on a nice dish by Quentin Shue | 2-4 |
| 18:23 | John Carroll | Barry Schafer makes the pull-up jumper from the left side on a nice dish by David Futral | 2-6 |
| 18:19 | Otterbein | Trey Lemieux can't connect on a fadeaway jumper from the right side | 2-6 |
| 18:18 | Otterbein | Jerry Hawes grabs the offensive rebound | 2-6 |
| 17:59 | Otterbein | Michael Cazares hits the front of the rim on the shot from the left block | 2-6 |
| 17:58 | John Carroll | Jacob Lindberg gets the rebound | 2-6 |
| 17:36 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi knocks in the fadeaway from close range | 2-8 |
| 17:31 | Otterbein | Trey Lemieux travels with the ball | 2-8 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Keith Parrett (SG) Frederick Humphrey | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund (PG), David Canada (PF), Steve Thompson (C) Barry Schafer, David Futral, Michael Gerardi | |
| 17:11 | John Carroll | Louis Thompson misses the 3pt jumper from the left wing | 2-8 |
| 17:09 | Otterbein | Quentin Shue grabs the board | 2-8 |
| 17:03 | Otterbein | Keith Parrett misses long on a 3pt shot from the right wing | 2-8 |
| 17:02 | John Carroll | Jacob Lindberg snags the defensive board | 2-8 |
| 16:47 | John Carroll | Louis Thompson can't throw it down but he's fouled by Trey Lemieux - foul #1 on Trey Lemieux, team foul #2 | 2-8 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Glen Hanstein (PG) Michael Cazares | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Ralph McManemy (SF) Jacob Lindberg | |
| 16:47 | John Carroll | Louis Thompson makes the 1st free throw | 2-9 |
| 16:47 | John Carroll | Louis Thompson makes the 2nd free throw | 2-10 |
| 16:28 | Otterbein | Louis Thompson is called for the reach on Quentin Shue - foul #1 on Louis Thompson, team foul #1 | 2-10 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | John Unrein (C) Louis Thompson | |
| 16:16 | Otterbein | Keith Parrett hits the front of the rim on the driving attempt in the paint | 2-10 |
| 16:14 | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund grabs the board | 2-10 |
| 16:04 | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund is called for 10 seconds | 2-10 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Frederick Humphrey (SG) Keith Parrett | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Barry Schafer (PG), Michael Gerardi (C) Kristopher Lund, John Unrein | |
| 15:57 | Otterbein | Glen Hanstein misses short on a driving attempt in the lane | 2-10 |
| 15:55 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi grabs the board | 2-10 |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Glen Hanstein (fresh) SG - Frederick Humphrey (fresh) SF - Trey Lemieux (fairly fresh) 2 pts. PF - Quentin Shue (fairly fresh) C - Jerry Hawes (fairly fresh) | |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Barry Schafer (fresh) 2 pts. SG - David Canada (fresh) SF - Ralph McManemy (fresh) PF - Steve Thompson (fresh) C - Michael Gerardi (fresh) 4 pts. | |
| 15:52 | John Carroll | David Canada is hacked by Frederick Humphrey in the backcourt - foul #1 on Frederick Humphrey, team foul #3 | 2-10 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | John Unrein (PF) Steve Thompson | |
| 15:39 | John Carroll | David Canada scores on a fadeaway from just outside the lane | 2-12 |
| 15:21 | Otterbein | Trey Lemieux hits a 3pt shot from the right corner set up by Frederick Humphrey | 5-12 |
| 15:19 | John Carroll | Frederick Humphrey picks off the pass by David Canada in the backcourt | 5-12 |
| 15:02 | Otterbein | Quentin Shue knocks in the driving attempt from close range | 7-12 |
| 14:45 | John Carroll | The short jumper by Ralph McManemy is denied by Quentin Shue | 7-12 |
| 14:44 | Otterbein | Jerry Hawes grabs the board | 7-12 |
| 14:40 | Otterbein | Glen Hanstein misses short on a 3 from straight away | 7-12 |
| 14:38 | Otterbein | The offensive rebound goes to Quentin Shue | 7-12 |
| 14:16 | Otterbein | Jerry Hawes misses short on a fadeaway from the left side | 7-12 |
| 14:14 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi gets the rebound | 7-12 |
| 14:08 | John Carroll | Ralph McManemy throws a bad pass out of bounds | 7-12 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Michael Cazares (PG), Keith Parrett (SG) Glen Hanstein, Frederick Humphrey | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund (PG), Louis Thompson (SG), Jacob Lindberg (SF), David Futral (PF), Steve Thompson (C) Barry Schafer, David Canada, Ralph McManemy, John Unrein, Michael Gerardi | |
| 14:01 | Otterbein | Keith Parrett throws a bad pass out of bounds | 7-12 |
| 13:47 | John Carroll | Louis Thompson throws a bad pass out of bounds | 7-12 |
| 13:22 | Otterbein | Keith Parrett comes up short on the 3pt jumper from the right corner | 7-12 |
| 13:20 | Otterbein | Trey Lemieux tips it home | 9-12 |
| 13:07 | John Carroll | David Futral buries a driving attempt from close range and he's fouled by Quentin Shue - foul #1 on Quentin Shue, team foul #4 | 9-14 |
| 13:07 | John Carroll | David Futral misses the free throw | 9-14 |
| 13:07 | John Carroll | The offensive rebound goes to David Futral | 9-14 |
| 12:53 | John Carroll | David Futral misses the driving attempt in the lane | 9-14 |
| 12:52 | Otterbein | The rebound goes to Quentin Shue | 9-14 |
| 12:47 | Otterbein | Trey Lemieux's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 9-14 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Frank Nieves (SG) Keith Parrett | |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| 12:45 | John Carroll | Michael Cazares steals it from Kristopher Lund in the backcourt | 9-14 |
| 12:44 | Otterbein | Michael Cazares throws it down | 11-14 |
| 12:24 | John Carroll | David Futral misses long on a 3pt shot from straight away | 11-14 |
| 12:22 | John Carroll | Louis Thompson pulls down the offensive rebound | 11-14 |
| 12:07 | John Carroll | Steve Thompson throws a bad pass out of bounds | 11-14 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Barry Schafer (PG), Ralph McManemy (SG), Samuel Miles (SF), David Canada (PF), Michael Gerardi (C) Kristopher Lund, Louis Thompson, Jacob Lindberg, David Futral, Steve Thompson | |
| 11:44 | Otterbein | Trey Lemieux hits a 3 from the left corner set up by Michael Cazares | 14-14 |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Michael Cazares (fairly fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. SG - Frank Nieves (fresh) SF - Trey Lemieux (tired) 10 pts. PF - Quentin Shue (tired) 2 pts. 3 reb. C - Jerry Hawes (tired) 2 reb. | |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Barry Schafer (fresh) 2 pts. SG - Ralph McManemy (fresh) SF - Samuel Miles (fresh) PF - David Canada (fresh) 2 pts. C - Michael Gerardi (fresh) 4 pts. 2 reb. | |
| 11:41 | John Carroll | Michael Cazares picks off the pass by David Canada in the backcourt | 14-14 |
| 11:41 | Otterbein | Otterbein calls a full timeout (2 :30 3 full remaining) | 14-14 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Glen Hanstein (PG), Frederick Humphrey (SG) Michael Cazares, Frank Nieves | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Louis Thompson (SG), Jacob Lindberg (SF) Ralph McManemy, Samuel Miles | |
| 11:27 | Otterbein | Glen Hanstein misses short on a 3pt attempt from the right corner | 14-14 |
| 11:25 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi pulls down the rebound | 14-14 |
| 11:16 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi scores on a runner in the paint on a great pass from Barry Schafer | 14-16 |
| 10:47 | Otterbein | Trey Lemieux misses short on a 3 from straight away | 14-16 |
| 10:46 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi pulls down the rebound | 14-16 |
| 10:24 | John Carroll | Jacob Lindberg buries a pull-up jumper from just outside the lane on a great pass from Michael Gerardi and the foul's on Trey Lemieux - foul #2 on Trey Lemieux, team foul #5 | 14-18 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Michael Cazares (PG), Keith Parrett (SG) Glen Hanstein, Frederick Humphrey | |
| Subs | John Carroll | David Futral (PF), Steve Thompson (C) David Canada, Michael Gerardi | |
| 10:24 | John Carroll | Jacob Lindberg misses the free throw | 14-18 |
| 10:24 | Otterbein | Quentin Shue gets the rebound | 14-18 |
| 10:06 | Otterbein | Michael Cazares misses short on a jumper from the right wing | 14-18 |
| 10:04 | Otterbein | Jerry Hawes pulls down the offensive rebound | 14-18 |
| 09:47 | Otterbein | Jerry Hawes can't connect on a 3pt attempt from straight away | 14-18 |
| 09:45 | John Carroll | Jacob Lindberg grabs the defensive rebound | 14-18 |
| 09:34 | John Carroll | Jacob Lindberg misses badly on a runner in the paint but he's fouled by Quentin Shue - foul #2 on Quentin Shue, team foul #6 | 14-18 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund (PG), Ralph McManemy (SG), David Canada (PF) Barry Schafer, Louis Thompson, David Futral | |
| 09:34 | John Carroll | Jacob Lindberg makes the 1st free throw | 14-19 |
| 09:34 | John Carroll | Jacob Lindberg makes the 2nd free throw | 14-20 |
| 09:18 | Otterbein | Michael Cazares misses the shot in the lane | 14-20 |
| 09:16 | John Carroll | Jacob Lindberg pulls down the rebound | 14-20 |
| 09:03 | John Carroll | Jacob Lindberg banks in the wide open layup | 14-22 |
| 08:44 | Otterbein | Trey Lemieux drills a runner from the baseline | 16-22 |
| 08:29 | John Carroll | Steve Thompson double dribbles | 16-22 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Glen Hanstein (PG), Frederick Humphrey (SG) Michael Cazares, Keith Parrett | |
| Subs | John Carroll | John Unrein (PF), Michael Gerardi (C) Jacob Lindberg, Steve Thompson | |
| 08:22 | Otterbein | Jerry Hawes misses short on a fadeaway jumper from just outside the lane | 16-22 |
| 08:20 | John Carroll | John Unrein grabs the board | 16-22 |
| 08:15 | John Carroll | David Canada is open and buries a jump hook near the basket set up by Kristopher Lund | 16-24 |
| 08:01 | Otterbein | Glen Hanstein misses the dunk attempt | 16-24 |
| 07:59 | John Carroll | David Canada grabs the board | 16-24 |
| 07:57 | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund's pass is off the mark and out of bounds in the backcourt | 16-24 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Jason Malley (PG), Louis Thompson (SG), David Futral (PF) Kristopher Lund, David Canada, John Unrein | |
| 07:46 | Otterbein | Frederick Humphrey misses the 3pt attempt from the left corner | 16-24 |
| 07:44 | John Carroll | Jason Malley snags the defensive board | 16-24 |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Glen Hanstein (fresh) SG - Frederick Humphrey (fresh) 1 ast. SF - Trey Lemieux (very tired) 12 pts. PF - Quentin Shue (tired) 2 pts. 4 reb. C - Jerry Hawes (very tired) 3 reb. | |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Jason Malley (fresh) SG - Louis Thompson (fresh) 4 pts. SF - Ralph McManemy (fresh) PF - David Futral (fresh) 2 pts. C - Michael Gerardi (fresh) 6 pts. 4 reb. | |
| 07:26 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi clanks a runner near the basket | 16-24 |
| 07:25 | Otterbein | Trey Lemieux grabs the defensive rebound | 16-24 |
| 07:21 | Otterbein | Frederick Humphrey hits a fadeaway from the left side | 18-24 |
| 07:19 | John Carroll | Glen Hanstein is called for the reach on Jason Malley in the backcourt - foul #1 on Glen Hanstein, team foul #7 | 18-24 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Michael Cazares (PG), Frank Nieves (SG) Glen Hanstein, Frederick Humphrey | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Samuel Miles (SF), John Unrein (C) Ralph McManemy, Michael Gerardi | |
| 07:19 | John Carroll | Jason Malley misses the 1st free throw | 18-24 |
| 07:19 | Otterbein | Jerry Hawes grabs the defensive rebound | 18-24 |
| 07:02 | Otterbein | Frank Nieves is fouled on the floor by Samuel Miles - foul #1 on Samuel Miles, team foul #2 | 18-24 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Barry Schafer (PG), David Canada (PF) Jason Malley, David Futral | |
| 06:57 | Otterbein | Michael Cazares is hacked by Barry Schafer - foul #1 on Barry Schafer, team foul #3 | 18-24 |
| 06:41 | Otterbein | Samuel Miles takes the ball from Jerry Hawes | 18-24 |
| 06:21 | John Carroll | John Unrein buries a runner near the basket on a great pass from Samuel Miles | 18-26 |
| 05:57 | Otterbein | Quentin Shue connects on the pull-up jumper from the right wing set up by Michael Cazares | 20-26 |
| 05:37 | John Carroll | Jerry Hawes is called for the reach on John Unrein - foul #2 on Jerry Hawes, team foul #8 | 20-26 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Glen Hanstein (PG), Frederick Humphrey (SG) Michael Cazares, Frank Nieves | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund (PG), Ralph McManemy (SG), Jacob Lindberg (SF), Michael Gerardi (C) Barry Schafer, Louis Thompson, Samuel Miles, David Canada | |
| 05:37 | John Carroll | John Unrein misses the 1st free throw | 20-26 |
| 05:37 | Otterbein | The rebound goes to Quentin Shue | 20-26 |
| 05:09 | Otterbein | Trey Lemieux's pass is intercepted by Ralph McManemy | 20-26 |
| 05:05 | John Carroll | Jacob Lindberg's pass is off the mark and out of bounds in the backcourt | 20-26 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | David Futral (PF) John Unrein | |
| 04:52 | Otterbein | Trey Lemieux misses short on a 3pt attempt from the right wing | 20-26 |
| 04:51 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi grabs the defensive rebound | 20-26 |
| 04:26 | John Carroll | David Futral is hacked by Quentin Shue - foul #3 on Quentin Shue, team foul #9 | 20-26 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Michael Cazares (PG), Keith Parrett (SG) Glen Hanstein, Frederick Humphrey | |
| Subs | John Carroll | David Canada (SG), Steve Thompson (C) Jacob Lindberg, Michael Gerardi | |
| 04:26 | Otterbein | Otterbein calls a full timeout (2 :30 2 full remaining) | 20-26 |
| 04:26 | John Carroll | David Futral misses the 1st free throw | 20-26 |
| 04:26 | John Carroll | Steve Thompson grabs the offensive board | 20-26 |
| 04:10 | John Carroll | David Canada can't finish the layup but he's fouled by Jerry Hawes - foul #3 on Jerry Hawes, team foul #10 | 20-26 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Glen Hanstein (PG) Michael Cazares | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Barry Schafer (PG), Jacob Lindberg (SF), Michael Gerardi (C) Kristopher Lund, Ralph McManemy, Steve Thompson | |
| 04:10 | John Carroll | David Canada makes the 1st free throw | 20-27 |
| 04:10 | John Carroll | David Canada makes the 2nd free throw | 20-28 |
| 03:44 | Otterbein | Jerry Hawes misses long on a 3 from the left wing | 20-28 |
| 03:42 | John Carroll | David Futral grabs the board | 20-28 |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Glen Hanstein (fresh) SG - Keith Parrett (fresh) SF - Trey Lemieux (very tired) 12 pts. 2 reb. PF - Quentin Shue (very tired) 4 pts. 5 reb. 3 pf. C - Jerry Hawes (very tired) 4 reb. 3 pf. | |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Barry Schafer (fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. SG - David Canada (fresh) 6 pts. SF - Jacob Lindberg (fresh) 6 pts. 4 reb. PF - David Futral (fairly fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. C - Michael Gerardi (fresh) 6 pts. 5 reb. | |
| 03:30 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi is open but comes up short on the driving attempt from the right block | 20-28 |
| 03:29 | Otterbein | Trey Lemieux gets the rebound | 20-28 |
| 03:23 | Otterbein | Jerry Hawes misses long on a 3pt attempt from the left wing | 20-28 |
| 03:21 | Otterbein | The offensive rebound goes to Keith Parrett | 20-28 |
| 03:09 | Otterbein | Jacob Lindberg blocks the jumper by Trey Lemieux | 20-28 |
| 03:08 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi grabs the defensive rebound | 20-28 |
| 03:06 | John Carroll | Barry Schafer is hacked by Keith Parrett in the backcourt - foul #1 on Keith Parrett, team foul #11 | 20-28 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Michael Cazares (PG), Frederick Humphrey (SG) Glen Hanstein, Keith Parrett | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Louis Thompson (SG), Steve Thompson (C) David Futral, Michael Gerardi | |
| 03:06 | John Carroll | Barry Schafer makes the 1st free throw | 20-29 |
| 03:06 | John Carroll | Barry Schafer makes the 2nd free throw | 20-30 |
| 02:44 | Otterbein | Michael Cazares is hacked by Barry Schafer - foul #2 on Barry Schafer, team foul #4 | 20-30 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Ralph McManemy (SF) Jacob Lindberg | |
| 02:28 | Otterbein | Jerry Hawes scores on a pull-up jumper from just outside the lane and he's hacked by Steve Thompson - foul #1 on Steve Thompson, team foul #5 | 22-30 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund (PG), John Unrein (C) Barry Schafer, David Canada | |
| 02:28 | Otterbein | Jerry Hawes misses the free throw | 22-30 |
| 02:28 | John Carroll | John Unrein gets the rebound | 22-30 |
| 02:12 | John Carroll | Trey Lemieux steals the ball from Louis Thompson | 22-30 |
| 01:56 | Otterbein | Jerry Hawes misses short on a 3 from the left wing | 22-30 |
| 01:55 | John Carroll | Steve Thompson pulls down the rebound | 22-30 |
| 01:42 | John Carroll | Steve Thompson comes up short on the jump hook in the lane but he's fouled by Quentin Shue - foul #4 on Quentin Shue, team foul #12 | 22-30 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Glen Hanstein (PG), Keith Parrett (SG) Michael Cazares, Frederick Humphrey | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Jacob Lindberg (SF), Michael Gerardi (C) Ralph McManemy, John Unrein | |
| 01:42 | John Carroll | Steve Thompson misses the 1st free throw | 22-30 |
| 01:42 | John Carroll | Steve Thompson makes the 2nd free throw | 22-31 |
| 01:26 | Otterbein | Jerry Hawes is called for the illegal screen - foul #4 on Jerry Hawes, team foul #13 | 22-31 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | David Canada (PF) Steve Thompson | |
| 01:12 | John Carroll | Jacob Lindberg misses short on a shot near the basket | 22-31 |
| 01:10 | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund grabs the offensive rebound | 22-31 |
| 00:55 | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund misses long on an open fadeaway from the right wing | 22-31 |
| 00:54 | Otterbein | Glen Hanstein pulls down the rebound | 22-31 |
| 00:52 | Otterbein | Glen Hanstein is hacked by Kristopher Lund in the backcourt - foul #1 on Kristopher Lund, team foul #6 | 22-31 |
| Subs | Otterbein | Michael Cazares (PG), Frank Nieves (SG) Glen Hanstein, Keith Parrett | |
| Subs | John Carroll | Barry Schafer (PG), Ralph McManemy (SG), John Unrein (C) Kristopher Lund, Louis Thompson, Michael Gerardi | |
| 00:30 | Otterbein | Trey Lemieux misses the lay-in but the foul's on David Canada - foul #1 on David Canada, team foul #7 | 22-31 |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| Subs | John Carroll | David Futral (PF) Jacob Lindberg | |
| 00:30 | Otterbein | Trey Lemieux makes the 1st free throw | 23-31 |
| 00:30 | Otterbein | Trey Lemieux makes the 2nd free throw | 24-31 |
| 00:05 | John Carroll | Ralph McManemy makes the jumpshot from the left wing on a great pass from Barry Schafer | 24-33 |
| 00:00 | Otterbein | Michael Cazares can't connect on a jumper from just outside the lane | 24-33 |