| Lineup | Keuka | PG - Rickey Edgell (fresh) SG - Nicholas Ashton (fresh) SF - Darrell Epley (fresh) PF - Thomas Ikard (fresh) C - Brandon Gochenour (fresh) | |
| Lineup | Muhlenberg | PG - Henry Boyd (fresh) SG - Joseph Hubbell (fresh) SF - Leland Santo (fresh) PF - Abraham Keys (fresh) C - Terrence Fiqueroa (fresh) | |
| 20:00 | Muhlenberg | Terrence Fiqueroa wins the tip | 0-0 |
| Game Plan | Keuka | Keuka is playing a triangle offense and a fullcourt press (0) | |
| Game Plan | Muhlenberg | Muhlenberg is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (0) | |
| 19:43 | Muhlenberg | Leland Santo misses badly on a runner from the left block | 0-0 |
| 19:41 | Keuka | Darrell Epley snags the defensive board | 0-0 |
| 19:21 | Keuka | Darrell Epley buries a 3pt jumper from the right corner on a great pass from Rickey Edgell | 3-0 |
| 19:08 | Muhlenberg | Joseph Hubbell misses the 3 from the left wing | 3-0 |
| 19:06 | Keuka | Rickey Edgell snags the defensive board | 3-0 |
| 19:01 | Keuka | Rickey Edgell misses short on a fadeaway from the right wing but the foul's on Henry Boyd - foul #1 on Henry Boyd, team foul #1 | 3-0 |
| 19:01 | Keuka | Rickey Edgell makes the 1st free throw | 4-0 |
| 19:01 | Keuka | Rickey Edgell makes the 2nd free throw | 5-0 |
| 18:54 | Muhlenberg | Terrence Fiqueroa misses the easy layup | 5-0 |
| 18:53 | Muhlenberg | Terrence Fiqueroa tips it but misses | 5-0 |
| 18:51 | Muhlenberg | Leland Santo snags the offensive board | 5-0 |
| 18:41 | Muhlenberg | Terrence Fiqueroa blows the layup but he's hacked by Brandon Gochenour - foul #1 on Brandon Gochenour, team foul #1 | 5-0 |
| 18:41 | Muhlenberg | Terrence Fiqueroa makes the 1st free throw | 5-1 |
| 18:41 | Muhlenberg | Terrence Fiqueroa makes the 2nd free throw | 5-2 |
| 18:30 | Keuka | Darrell Epley hits the front of the rim on the 3pt attempt from the left wing | 5-2 |
| 18:28 | Muhlenberg | Abraham Keys grabs the defensive rebound | 5-2 |
| 18:25 | Muhlenberg | Terrence Fiqueroa is hacked by Brandon Gochenour in the backcourt - foul #2 on Brandon Gochenour, team foul #2 | 5-2 |
| Subs | Keuka | Joel Edwards (C) Brandon Gochenour | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | | |
| 18:16 | Muhlenberg | Terrence Fiqueroa connects on the open runner from close range on a great pass from Henry Boyd | 5-4 |
| 17:56 | Keuka | Rickey Edgell knocks in the 3pt shot from the right wing on a great pass from Nicholas Ashton | 8-4 |
| 17:36 | Muhlenberg | Abraham Keys makes the jumpshot from the left side on a nice dish by Joseph Hubbell | 8-6 |
| 17:23 | Keuka | Darrell Epley can't connect on a 3pt attempt from the left wing | 8-6 |
| 17:21 | Muhlenberg | Abraham Keys grabs the defensive rebound | 8-6 |
| 17:01 | Muhlenberg | Leland Santo knocks in the shot from the free throw line | 8-8 |
| 16:36 | Keuka | Terrence Fiqueroa is called for the reach on Nicholas Ashton - foul #1 on Terrence Fiqueroa, team foul #2 | 8-8 |
| Subs | Keuka | Francis Cohen (PG), Charles Caron (SG), Tyrone Baxter (SF), Marshall Hannon (PF), Robert Servantes (C) Rickey Edgell, Nicholas Ashton, Darrell Epley, Thomas Ikard, Joel Edwards | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Shawn Hooper (PG), Brian Hansen (SG), John Ingersoll (SF), Thomas Granger (PF), Michael Paredes (C) Henry Boyd, Joseph Hubbell, Leland Santo, Abraham Keys, Terrence Fiqueroa | |
| 16:27 | Keuka | Francis Cohen can't connect on a pull-up jumper from the left wing | 8-8 |
| 16:25 | Muhlenberg | Michael Paredes grabs the defensive rebound | 8-8 |
| 16:23 | Muhlenberg | Brian Hansen's pass is intercepted by Charles Caron in the backcourt | 8-8 |
| 16:21 | Keuka | Charles Caron blows the layup | 8-8 |
| 16:19 | Keuka | Tyrone Baxter snags the offensive board | 8-8 |
| 16:02 | Keuka | Charles Caron's pass is intercepted by Michael Paredes | 8-8 |
| Lineup | Keuka | PG - Francis Cohen (fresh) SG - Charles Caron (fresh) SF - Tyrone Baxter (fresh) PF - Marshall Hannon (fresh) C - Robert Servantes (fresh) | |
| Lineup | Muhlenberg | PG - Shawn Hooper (fresh) SG - Brian Hansen (fresh) SF - John Ingersoll (fresh) PF - Thomas Granger (fresh) C - Michael Paredes (fresh) | |
| 15:43 | Muhlenberg | John Ingersoll makes the wide open fadeaway from the baseline on a nice dish by Michael Paredes | 8-10 |
| 15:17 | Keuka | Tyrone Baxter misses long on a shot from just outside the lane but he's fouled by John Ingersoll - foul #1 on John Ingersoll, team foul #3 | 8-10 |
| Subs | Keuka | Malik Sanders (SG), Thomas Ikard (PF), Joel Edwards (C) Charles Caron, Marshall Hannon, Robert Servantes | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Henry Boyd (PG) Brian Hansen | |
| 15:17 | Keuka | Tyrone Baxter makes the 1st free throw | 9-10 |
| 15:17 | Keuka | Tyrone Baxter misses the 2nd free throw | 9-10 |
| 15:17 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Granger grabs the defensive rebound | 9-10 |
| 15:00 | Muhlenberg | Michael Paredes loses the dribble to Joel Edwards | 9-10 |
| 14:48 | Keuka | Francis Cohen buries a shot from the right wing set up by Tyrone Baxter | 11-10 |
| 14:44 | Muhlenberg | Henry Boyd is fouled in the backcourt by Malik Sanders - foul #1 on Malik Sanders, team foul #3 | 11-10 |
| Subs | Keuka | Rickey Edgell (PG), Darrell Epley (SF) Francis Cohen, Tyrone Baxter | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Joseph Hubbell (SG), William Vaughn (SF), Abraham Keys (PF), Terrence Fiqueroa (C) Shawn Hooper, John Ingersoll, Thomas Granger, Michael Paredes | |
| 14:28 | Muhlenberg | Rickey Edgell picks off the pass by William Vaughn | 11-10 |
| 14:12 | Keuka | Malik Sanders is called for a charge - foul #2 on Malik Sanders, team foul #4 | 11-10 |
| Subs | Keuka | Nicholas Ashton (SG), Marshall Hannon (PF), Robert Servantes (C) Malik Sanders, Thomas Ikard, Joel Edwards | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Brian Hansen (SG) Joseph Hubbell | |
| 13:51 | Muhlenberg | Henry Boyd is fouled on the floor by Marshall Hannon - foul #1 on Marshall Hannon, team foul #5 | 11-10 |
| 13:37 | Muhlenberg | Brian Hansen can't connect on a 3 from the left corner | 11-10 |
| 13:36 | Muhlenberg | The offensive rebound goes to Abraham Keys | 11-10 |
| 13:22 | Muhlenberg | Henry Boyd comes up short on the pull-up jumper from the left side but the foul's on Rickey Edgell - foul #1 on Rickey Edgell, team foul #6 | 11-10 |
| Subs | Keuka | Charles Caron (PG), Joel Edwards (C) Rickey Edgell, Robert Servantes | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Joseph Hubbell (SG), Thomas Granger (PF), Michael Paredes (C) Brian Hansen, Abraham Keys, Terrence Fiqueroa | |
| 13:22 | Muhlenberg | Henry Boyd makes the 1st free throw | 11-11 |
| 13:22 | Muhlenberg | Henry Boyd makes the 2nd free throw | 11-12 |
| 13:03 | Keuka | Michael Paredes blocks the jumper by Joel Edwards | 11-12 |
| 13:02 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Granger snags the defensive board | 11-12 |
| 12:45 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Granger hits the front of the rim on the floater near the basket but the foul's on Marshall Hannon - foul #2 on Marshall Hannon, team foul #7 | 11-12 |
| Subs | Keuka | Francis Cohen (PG), Thomas Ikard (PF) Nicholas Ashton, Marshall Hannon | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Shawn Hooper (PG), John Ingersoll (SG), Leland Santo (SF) Henry Boyd, Joseph Hubbell, William Vaughn | |
| 12:45 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Granger misses the 1st free throw | 11-12 |
| 12:45 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Granger makes the 2nd free throw | 11-13 |
| 12:28 | Keuka | Joel Edwards clanks a 3pt jumper from the left wing | 11-13 |
| 12:27 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Granger snags the defensive board | 11-13 |
| 12:14 | Muhlenberg | John Ingersoll comes up short on the shot from the right side but he's fouled by Charles Caron - foul #1 on Charles Caron, team foul #8 | 11-13 |
| Subs | Keuka | Rickey Edgell (PG), Tyrone Baxter (SF) Charles Caron, Darrell Epley | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Terrence Fiqueroa (C) Thomas Granger | |
| 12:14 | Muhlenberg | John Ingersoll makes the 1st free throw | 11-14 |
| 12:14 | Muhlenberg | John Ingersoll makes the 2nd free throw | 11-15 |
| 11:55 | Keuka | Tyrone Baxter buries a shot from the baseline set up by Rickey Edgell | 13-15 |
| Lineup | Keuka | PG - Rickey Edgell (fresh) 5 pts. 2 ast. SG - Francis Cohen (fresh) 2 pts. SF - Tyrone Baxter (fresh) 3 pts. PF - Thomas Ikard (fairly fresh) C - Joel Edwards (tiring) | |
| Lineup | Muhlenberg | PG - John Ingersoll (fresh) 4 pts. SG - Shawn Hooper (fresh) SF - Leland Santo (fresh) 2 pts. PF - Michael Paredes (fresh) C - Terrence Fiqueroa (fairly fresh) 4 pts. | |
| 11:40 | Muhlenberg | Terrence Fiqueroa is alone and drills a jump hook near the basket set up by Shawn Hooper | 13-17 |
| 11:16 | Keuka | Joel Edwards hits a 3pt jumper from the left corner on a great pass from Francis Cohen and he's fouled by John Ingersoll - foul #2 on John Ingersoll, team foul #4 | 16-17 |
| Subs | Keuka | Nicholas Ashton (SG), Robert Servantes (C) Francis Cohen, Tyrone Baxter | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Brian Hansen (PG), Joseph Hubbell (SG), William Vaughn (SF), Abraham Keys (PF), Thomas Granger (C) John Ingersoll, Shawn Hooper, Leland Santo, Michael Paredes, Terrence Fiqueroa | |
| 11:16 | Keuka | Joel Edwards misses the free throw | 16-17 |
| 11:16 | Muhlenberg | Abraham Keys grabs the board | 16-17 |
| 10:53 | Muhlenberg | Joseph Hubbell is called for the illegal screen - foul #1 on Joseph Hubbell, team foul #5 | 16-17 |
| Subs | Keuka | Darrell Epley (SF) Joel Edwards | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | | |
| 10:27 | Keuka | Rickey Edgell clanks a pull-up jumper from the right side | 16-17 |
| 10:26 | Muhlenberg | Joseph Hubbell pulls down the rebound | 16-17 |
| 10:12 | Muhlenberg | William Vaughn is fouled on the floor by Thomas Ikard - foul #1 on Thomas Ikard, team foul #9 | 16-17 |
| Subs | Keuka | Charles Caron (PG) Rickey Edgell | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Shawn Hooper (PG), Terrence Fiqueroa (C) Joseph Hubbell, Thomas Granger | |
| 10:12 | Muhlenberg | William Vaughn misses the 1st free throw | 16-17 |
| 10:12 | Keuka | Nicholas Ashton pulls down the rebound | 16-17 |
| 09:55 | Keuka | Darrell Epley misses badly on a fadeaway jumper from just outside the lane | 16-17 |
| 09:53 | Muhlenberg | The rebound goes to Abraham Keys | 16-17 |
| 09:49 | Muhlenberg | Abraham Keys connects on the jump hook near the basket set up by Terrence Fiqueroa | 16-19 |
| 09:36 | Keuka | Nicholas Ashton clanks a floater from just outside the lane | 16-19 |
| 09:34 | Muhlenberg | The rebound goes to Abraham Keys | 16-19 |
| 09:32 | Muhlenberg | Robert Servantes takes the ball from Brian Hansen in the backcourt | 16-19 |
| 09:13 | Keuka | Charles Caron clanks a 3 from the right corner | 16-19 |
| 09:11 | Muhlenberg | Abraham Keys grabs the defensive rebound | 16-19 |
| 09:09 | Muhlenberg | Darrell Epley is called for the reach on William Vaughn in the backcourt - foul #1 on Darrell Epley, team foul #10 | 16-19 |
| Subs | Keuka | Rickey Edgell (PG), Francis Cohen (SG), Tyrone Baxter (SF), Joel Edwards (C) Charles Caron, Nicholas Ashton, Darrell Epley, Robert Servantes | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Henry Boyd (PG), Joseph Hubbell (SG), Thomas Granger (PF), Michael Paredes (C) Shawn Hooper, Brian Hansen, Abraham Keys, Terrence Fiqueroa | |
| 09:09 | Muhlenberg | William Vaughn misses the 1st free throw | 16-19 |
| 09:09 | Muhlenberg | William Vaughn makes the 2nd free throw | 16-20 |
| 08:49 | Keuka | Thomas Ikard throws a bad pass out of bounds | 16-20 |
| Subs | Keuka | | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Leland Santo (SF) William Vaughn | |
| 08:32 | Muhlenberg | Henry Boyd misses long on a 3pt attempt from the right wing | 16-20 |
| 08:30 | Keuka | The rebound goes to Rickey Edgell | 16-20 |
| 08:23 | Keuka | Francis Cohen misses short on a jumper from the left side but he's fouled by Henry Boyd - foul #2 on Henry Boyd, team foul #6 | 16-20 |
| Subs | Keuka | | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Shawn Hooper (PG) Henry Boyd | |
| 08:23 | Keuka | Francis Cohen misses the 1st free throw | 16-20 |
| 08:23 | Keuka | Francis Cohen misses the 2nd free throw | 16-20 |
| 08:23 | Muhlenberg | Leland Santo grabs the board | 16-20 |
| 07:55 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Granger clanks a jump hook from the right block but he's hacked by Thomas Ikard - foul #2 on Thomas Ikard, team foul #11 | 16-20 |
| Subs | Keuka | Nicholas Ashton (SG), Darrell Epley (SF), Robert Servantes (PF) Francis Cohen, Tyrone Baxter, Thomas Ikard | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | | |
| 07:55 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Granger makes the 1st free throw | 16-21 |
| 07:55 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Granger makes the 2nd free throw | 16-22 |
| Lineup | Keuka | PG - Rickey Edgell (fairly fresh) 5 pts. 2 ast. SG - Nicholas Ashton (fairly fresh) 1 ast. SF - Darrell Epley (tiring) 3 pts. PF - Robert Servantes (fairly fresh) C - Joel Edwards (tiring) 3 pts. | |
| Lineup | Muhlenberg | PG - Shawn Hooper (fresh) 1 ast. SG - Joseph Hubbell (tiring) 1 ast. SF - Leland Santo (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. PF - Thomas Granger (fairly fresh) 3 pts. 3 reb. C - Michael Paredes (fresh) | |
| 07:42 | Keuka | Thomas Granger steals the ball from Darrell Epley | 16-22 |
| 07:32 | Muhlenberg | Joseph Hubbell is called for 10 seconds | 16-22 |
| Subs | Keuka | Charles Caron (PG) Rickey Edgell | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Terrence Fiqueroa (C) Thomas Granger | |
| 07:25 | Keuka | Darrell Epley misses badly on a 3 pointer from the left wing | 16-22 |
| 07:24 | Keuka | Nicholas Ashton pulls down the offensive rebound | 16-22 |
| 07:07 | Keuka | Nicholas Ashton makes the shot from just outside the lane on a nice dish by Robert Servantes | 18-22 |
| 06:39 | Muhlenberg | Joseph Hubbell hits the front of the rim on the wide open fadeaway jumper from just outside the lane | 18-22 |
| 06:37 | Muhlenberg | Terrence Fiqueroa grabs the offensive board | 18-22 |
| 06:31 | Muhlenberg | Leland Santo misses the easy layup | 18-22 |
| 06:30 | Keuka | Nicholas Ashton pulls down the rebound | 18-22 |
| 06:23 | Keuka | Terrence Fiqueroa is called for the reach on Robert Servantes - foul #2 on Terrence Fiqueroa, team foul #7 | 18-22 |
| Subs | Keuka | Rickey Edgell (PG), Francis Cohen (SG), Tyrone Baxter (SF) Charles Caron, Nicholas Ashton, Darrell Epley | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Brian Hansen (PG), William Vaughn (SF), Abraham Keys (PF), Thomas Granger (C) Joseph Hubbell, Leland Santo, Michael Paredes, Terrence Fiqueroa | |
| 06:23 | Keuka | Robert Servantes makes the 1st free throw | 19-22 |
| 06:23 | Keuka | Robert Servantes makes the 2nd free throw | 20-22 |
| 06:11 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Granger clanks a runner near the basket | 20-22 |
| 06:10 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Granger tips it back up and in | 20-24 |
| 05:52 | Keuka | Rickey Edgell hits the front of the rim on the jumpshot from just outside the lane | 20-24 |
| 05:50 | Muhlenberg | Abraham Keys snags the defensive board | 20-24 |
| 05:43 | Muhlenberg | Shawn Hooper connects on the jumpshot from the right wing on a great pass from William Vaughn and the foul's on Joel Edwards - foul #1 on Joel Edwards, team foul #12 | 20-26 |
| Subs | Keuka | Darrell Epley (SF) Tyrone Baxter | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | | |
| 05:43 | Muhlenberg | Shawn Hooper makes the free throw | 20-27 |
| 05:30 | Keuka | Rickey Edgell connects on the floater from the free throw line | 22-27 |
| 05:16 | Muhlenberg | Shawn Hooper's pass is intercepted by Robert Servantes | 22-27 |
| 05:10 | Keuka | Joel Edwards clanks a 3pt jumper from the left corner | 22-27 |
| 05:08 | Keuka | Darrell Epley hits the follow up shot | 24-27 |
| 04:48 | Muhlenberg | Abraham Keys misses long on a 3pt jumper from the left wing | 24-27 |
| 04:46 | Keuka | Joel Edwards grabs the board | 24-27 |
| 04:33 | Keuka | Francis Cohen is fouled on the floor by William Vaughn - foul #1 on William Vaughn, team foul #8 | 24-27 |
| Subs | Keuka | Nicholas Ashton (SG), Tyrone Baxter (SF) Rickey Edgell, Darrell Epley | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Joseph Hubbell (SG), James Bergland (SF), Michael Paredes (C) Shawn Hooper, William Vaughn, Thomas Granger | |
| 04:33 | Keuka | Francis Cohen makes the 1st free throw | 25-27 |
| 04:33 | Keuka | Francis Cohen makes the 2nd free throw | 26-27 |
| 04:17 | Muhlenberg | Joseph Hubbell clanks a 3 pointer from the right wing | 26-27 |
| 04:15 | Muhlenberg | Michael Paredes gets the offensive rebound | 26-27 |
| 04:07 | Muhlenberg | Joel Edwards is called for the reach on Michael Paredes - foul #2 on Joel Edwards, team foul #13 | 26-27 |
| Subs | Keuka | Charles Caron (PG), Brandon Gochenour (C) Francis Cohen, Joel Edwards | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Leland Santo (SF) James Bergland | |
| 04:07 | Muhlenberg | Michael Paredes makes the 1st free throw | 26-28 |
| 04:07 | Muhlenberg | Michael Paredes makes the 2nd free throw | 26-29 |
| 03:58 | Keuka | Charles Caron makes the 3pt shot from the right corner | 29-29 |
| 03:53 | Muhlenberg | Charles Caron is called for the reach on Brian Hansen in the backcourt - foul #2 on Charles Caron, team foul #14 | 29-29 |
| Subs | Keuka | Malik Sanders (SG), Marshall Hannon (PF) Nicholas Ashton, Robert Servantes | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Henry Boyd (PG), Terrence Fiqueroa (C) Joseph Hubbell, Abraham Keys | |
| 03:53 | Muhlenberg | Brian Hansen makes the 1st free throw | 29-30 |
| 03:53 | Muhlenberg | Brian Hansen makes the 2nd free throw | 29-31 |
| Lineup | Keuka | PG - Charles Caron (fresh) 3 pts. SG - Malik Sanders (fresh) SF - Tyrone Baxter (fairly fresh) 3 pts. PF - Marshall Hannon (fresh) C - Brandon Gochenour (fresh) | |
| Lineup | Muhlenberg | PG - Henry Boyd (fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. SG - Brian Hansen (fairly fresh) 2 pts. SF - Leland Santo (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. PF - Michael Paredes (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. C - Terrence Fiqueroa (fairly fresh) 6 pts. 2 reb. | |
| 03:44 | Keuka | Leland Santo is called for the reach on Charles Caron - foul #1 on Leland Santo, team foul #9 | 29-31 |
| Subs | Keuka | Darrell Epley (SF) Tyrone Baxter | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | John Ingersoll (SG) Brian Hansen | |
| 03:44 | Keuka | Charles Caron misses the 1st free throw | 29-31 |
| 03:44 | Muhlenberg | Michael Paredes grabs the board | 29-31 |
| 03:42 | Muhlenberg | John Ingersoll double dribbles in the backcourt | 29-31 |
| 03:16 | Keuka | Charles Caron is called for a charge - foul #3 on Charles Caron, team foul #15 | 29-31 |
| Subs | Keuka | Nicholas Ashton (SG) Charles Caron | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | James Bergland (SF), Thomas Granger (PF) Leland Santo, Michael Paredes | |
| 03:03 | Muhlenberg | Terrence Fiqueroa is by himself and knocks in the jumper in the lane | 29-33 |
| 02:46 | Keuka | Brandon Gochenour makes the jump hook in the lane | 31-33 |
| 02:26 | Muhlenberg | The jumper by Henry Boyd is denied by Brandon Gochenour | 31-33 |
| 02:25 | Keuka | Darrell Epley snags the defensive board | 31-33 |
| 02:18 | Keuka | Henry Boyd picks off the pass by Marshall Hannon | 31-33 |
| 01:55 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Granger comes up short on the 3pt attempt from the right wing | 31-33 |
| 01:53 | Keuka | Brandon Gochenour grabs the board | 31-33 |
| 01:35 | Keuka | Darrell Epley misses long on a 3pt attempt from straight away | 31-33 |
| 01:34 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Granger gets the rebound | 31-33 |
| 01:09 | Muhlenberg | Thomas Granger hits a jump hook from the left block set up by John Ingersoll | 31-35 |
| 00:51 | Keuka | Nicholas Ashton is fouled on the floor by John Ingersoll - foul #3 on John Ingersoll, team foul #10 | 31-35 |
| Subs | Keuka | Rickey Edgell (PG), Tyrone Baxter (SF), Thomas Ikard (PF) Malik Sanders, Darrell Epley, Marshall Hannon | |
| Subs | Muhlenberg | Joseph Hubbell (SG), Leland Santo (SF), Abraham Keys (PF), Michael Paredes (C) John Ingersoll, James Bergland, Thomas Granger, Terrence Fiqueroa | |
| 00:51 | Keuka | Nicholas Ashton makes the 1st free throw | 32-35 |
| 00:51 | Keuka | Nicholas Ashton misses the 2nd free throw | 32-35 |
| 00:51 | Muhlenberg | Michael Paredes grabs the defensive rebound | 32-35 |
| 00:34 | Muhlenberg | The short jumper by Joseph Hubbell is denied by Brandon Gochenour | 32-35 |
| 00:32 | Muhlenberg | Henry Boyd tips it but misses | 32-35 |
| 00:31 | Muhlenberg | Leland Santo misses the tip | 32-35 |
| 00:29 | Keuka | Nicholas Ashton grabs the defensive rebound | 32-35 |
| 00:05 | Keuka | Nicholas Ashton misses short on a 3pt jumper from the right wing | 32-35 |
| 00:04 | Muhlenberg | Henry Boyd pulls down the rebound | 32-35 |
| 00:00 | Muhlenberg | Henry Boyd can't connect on a halfcourt shot | 32-35 |