| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Barry Schafer (fresh) SG - Louis Thompson (fresh) SF - Jerry Barnes (fresh) PF - David Futral (fresh) C - Michael Gerardi (fresh) | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Frank Nieves (fresh) SG - Frederick Humphrey (fresh) SF - Norman Curtiss (fresh) PF - Quentin Shue (fresh) C - Robert Wisnoski (fresh) | |
| 20:00 | Otterbein | Robert Wisnoski wins the tip | 0-0 |
| Game Plan | John Carroll | John Carroll is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (0) | |
| Game Plan | Otterbein | Otterbein is playing a fastbreak offense and a fullcourt press (+1) | |
| 19:46 | Otterbein | Frederick Humphrey hits a 3pt shot from the left corner on a nice dish by Quentin Shue | 0-3 |
| 19:28 | John Carroll | Barry Schafer buries a floater near the basket | 2-3 |
| 19:01 | Otterbein | David Futral is called for the reach on Quentin Shue - foul #1 on David Futral, team foul #1 | 2-3 |
| 18:43 | Otterbein | Michael Gerardi steals the ball from Quentin Shue | 2-3 |
| 18:15 | John Carroll | Jerry Barnes misses badly on the uncontested 3pt shot from straight away | 2-3 |
| 18:14 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi can't tip it in | 2-3 |
| 18:13 | Otterbein | Quentin Shue grabs the board | 2-3 |
| 18:09 | Otterbein | Norman Curtiss lays it in on a nice dish by Frank Nieves | 2-5 |
| 17:49 | John Carroll | Barry Schafer connects on the open floater from close range | 4-5 |
| 17:21 | Otterbein | Frank Nieves throws a bad pass out of bounds | 4-5 |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Arnold Robertson (PG), Keith Parrett (SG), Newton Willmon (SF), Ryan Johnson (C) Frank Nieves, Frederick Humphrey, Norman Curtiss, Robert Wisnoski | |
| 17:09 | John Carroll | Jerry Barnes misses short on a 3pt attempt from the right wing | 4-5 |
| 17:08 | John Carroll | Barry Schafer pulls down the offensive rebound | 4-5 |
| 16:48 | John Carroll | Arnold Robertson is called for the reach on Barry Schafer - foul #1 on Arnold Robertson, team foul #1 | 4-5 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Steve Thompson (PF), John Unrein (C) David Futral, Michael Gerardi | |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| 16:42 | John Carroll | Barry Schafer can't connect on a 3 pointer from the right wing | 4-5 |
| 16:41 | Otterbein | Keith Parrett grabs the board | 4-5 |
| 16:37 | Otterbein | Keith Parrett is called for traveling | 4-5 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund (PG), Rick Markovitz (SF) Barry Schafer, Jerry Barnes | |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| 16:26 | John Carroll | John Unrein's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 4-5 |
| 16:06 | Otterbein | Newton Willmon misses badly on a fadeaway from the right side | 4-5 |
| 16:04 | John Carroll | John Unrein gets the rebound | 4-5 |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Kristopher Lund (fresh) SG - Louis Thompson (fairly fresh) SF - Rick Markovitz (fresh) PF - Steve Thompson (fresh) C - John Unrein (fresh) | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Arnold Robertson (fresh) SG - Keith Parrett (fresh) SF - Newton Willmon (fresh) PF - Quentin Shue (fairly fresh) C - Ryan Johnson (fresh) | |
| 15:42 | John Carroll | Steve Thompson hits the front of the rim on the fadeaway from the left side | 4-5 |
| 15:41 | Otterbein | Keith Parrett grabs the board | 4-5 |
| 15:34 | Otterbein | Quentin Shue misses the runner in the lane | 4-5 |
| 15:32 | John Carroll | Steve Thompson pulls down the rebound | 4-5 |
| 15:30 | John Carroll | Rick Markovitz is fouled in the backcourt by Newton Willmon - foul #1 on Newton Willmon, team foul #2 | 4-5 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Barry Schafer (PG), Jerry Barnes (SF), Michael Gerardi (C) Louis Thompson, Rick Markovitz, John Unrein | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Frank Nieves (PG), Frederick Humphrey (SG), Larry Austin (SF), Alex Cohen (C) Arnold Robertson, Keith Parrett, Newton Willmon, Ryan Johnson | |
| 15:25 | John Carroll | Barry Schafer is by himself and knocks in the 3pt attempt from the left corner on a great pass from Kristopher Lund | 7-5 |
| 15:16 | Otterbein | Frederick Humphrey hits the front of the rim on the 3pt attempt from straight away | 7-5 |
| 15:14 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi gets the rebound | 7-5 |
| 15:01 | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund comes up short on the fadeaway from the right side | 7-5 |
| 15:00 | John Carroll | Barry Schafer tips it in | 9-5 |
| 14:53 | Otterbein | Frederick Humphrey connects on the floater from the left side on a great pass from Frank Nieves | 9-7 |
| 14:48 | John Carroll | Jerry Barnes is whistled for traveling in the backcourt | 9-7 |
| Subs | John Carroll | David Futral (PF) Steve Thompson | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Norman Curtiss (SF), Robert Wisnoski (C) Larry Austin, Alex Cohen | |
| 14:39 | Otterbein | Frank Nieves makes the fadeaway jumper from the left side | 9-9 |
| 14:26 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi misses long on a floater near the basket | 9-9 |
| 14:24 | John Carroll | The offensive rebound goes to Michael Gerardi | 9-9 |
| 14:15 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi's layup is rejected by Quentin Shue | 9-9 |
| 14:13 | Otterbein | Frederick Humphrey gets the rebound | 9-9 |
| 13:53 | Otterbein | Quentin Shue misses the jumper from the left block but he's fouled by David Futral - foul #2 on David Futral, team foul #2 | 9-9 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Jason Malley (PG), Louis Thompson (SG), Rick Markovitz (SF), Steve Thompson (PF), John Unrein (C) Barry Schafer, Kristopher Lund, Jerry Barnes, David Futral, Michael Gerardi | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Arnold Robertson (PG), Keith Parrett (SG), Newton Willmon (SF) Frank Nieves, Frederick Humphrey, Norman Curtiss | |
| 13:53 | Otterbein | Quentin Shue misses the 1st free throw | 9-9 |
| 13:53 | Otterbein | Quentin Shue misses the 2nd free throw | 9-9 |
| 13:53 | John Carroll | John Unrein gets the rebound | 9-9 |
| 13:51 | John Carroll | Arnold Robertson steps in front of the John Unrein pass in the backcourt | 9-9 |
| 13:49 | Otterbein | Newton Willmon lays it up and in on a great pass from Arnold Robertson | 9-11 |
| 13:20 | John Carroll | Jason Malley hits the front of the rim on the jumpshot from the left wing | 9-11 |
| 13:19 | Otterbein | The rebound goes to Quentin Shue | 9-11 |
| 13:15 | Otterbein | Newton Willmon hits a jumper from the free throw line on a great pass from Robert Wisnoski | 9-13 |
| 13:00 | John Carroll | Jason Malley steps out of bounds on the sideline | 9-13 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Al Brown (PF) Steve Thompson | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Frank Nieves (PG), Larry Austin (SG), Julius Chatman (SF), Ryan Johnson (C) Arnold Robertson, Keith Parrett, Newton Willmon, Robert Wisnoski | |
| 12:46 | Otterbein | Julius Chatman clanks a shot from the right wing | 9-13 |
| 12:44 | John Carroll | Louis Thompson grabs the defensive rebound | 9-13 |
| 12:40 | John Carroll | Jason Malley is fouled in the backcourt by Quentin Shue - foul #1 on Quentin Shue, team foul #3 | 9-13 |
| 12:34 | John Carroll | Rick Markovitz is whistled for a carry | 9-13 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Robert Oshiro (PG), Michael Gerardi (C) Jason Malley, Rick Markovitz | |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| 12:14 | Otterbein | Julius Chatman hits the front of the rim on the jumpshot from the right side but he's hacked by Al Brown - foul #1 on Al Brown, team foul #3 | 9-13 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Barry Schafer (PG), Jerry Barnes (SF) Robert Oshiro, John Unrein | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Norman Curtiss (SG), Alex Cohen (PF) Frank Nieves, Ryan Johnson | |
| 12:14 | Otterbein | Julius Chatman misses the 1st free throw | 9-13 |
| 12:14 | Otterbein | Julius Chatman makes the 2nd free throw | 9-14 |
| 11:58 | John Carroll | Barry Schafer scores on a shot from the free throw line on a nice dish by Jerry Barnes | 11-14 |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Barry Schafer (fresh) 11 pts. SG - Louis Thompson (fairly fresh) SF - Jerry Barnes (fresh) PF - Al Brown (fresh) C - Michael Gerardi (fresh) 3 reb. | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Julius Chatman (fresh) 1 pts. SG - Norman Curtiss (fresh) 2 pts. SF - Larry Austin (fresh) PF - Alex Cohen (fresh) C - Quentin Shue (tiring) 2 reb. | |
| 11:53 | Otterbein | Larry Austin lays it up and in on a great pass from Quentin Shue and he's fouled by Michael Gerardi - foul #1 on Michael Gerardi, team foul #4 | 11-16 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund (SG), Steve Thompson (C) Louis Thompson, Michael Gerardi | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Frederick Humphrey (SG) Julius Chatman | |
| 11:53 | Otterbein | Larry Austin makes the free throw | 11-17 |
| 11:41 | John Carroll | Jerry Barnes drills a pull-up jumper from just outside the lane set up by Barry Schafer | 13-17 |
| 11:16 | Otterbein | Norman Curtiss can't connect on a 3 pointer from straight away | 13-17 |
| 11:15 | Otterbein | Alex Cohen grabs the offensive rebound | 13-17 |
| 11:02 | Otterbein | Frederick Humphrey clanks a 3pt shot from the right wing | 13-17 |
| 11:00 | John Carroll | Steve Thompson pulls down the rebound | 13-17 |
| 10:40 | John Carroll | Larry Austin is called for the reach on Barry Schafer - foul #1 on Larry Austin, team foul #4 | 13-17 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Jason Malley (PG), Louis Thompson (SG), Rick Markovitz (SF), John Unrein (PF), Michael Gerardi (C) Barry Schafer, Kristopher Lund, Jerry Barnes, Al Brown, Steve Thompson | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Frank Nieves (PG), Keith Parrett (SG), Newton Willmon (SF), Ryan Johnson (C) Larry Austin, Frederick Humphrey, Norman Curtiss, Alex Cohen | |
| 10:27 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi is wide open but clanks a 3pt jumper from the right corner | 13-17 |
| 10:25 | John Carroll | Louis Thompson snags the offensive board | 13-17 |
| 10:13 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi hits a 3pt attempt from the right wing | 16-17 |
| 09:55 | Otterbein | Louis Thompson picks off the pass by Quentin Shue | 16-17 |
| 09:52 | John Carroll | Newton Willmon picks off the pass by Jason Malley in the backcourt | 16-17 |
| 09:34 | Otterbein | Frank Nieves clanks a fadeaway jumper from the left wing | 16-17 |
| 09:33 | Otterbein | Quentin Shue pulls down the offensive rebound | 16-17 |
| 09:28 | Otterbein | Keith Parrett hits the front of the rim on the jumper from the right side but he's hacked by Rick Markovitz - foul #1 on Rick Markovitz, team foul #5 | 16-17 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Robert Oshiro (PG), Jerry Barnes (SF), Steve Thompson (PF) Jason Malley, Rick Markovitz, John Unrein | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Arnold Robertson (PG), Julius Chatman (SF), Robert Wisnoski (C) Frank Nieves, Newton Willmon, Ryan Johnson | |
| 09:28 | Otterbein | Keith Parrett makes the 1st free throw | 16-18 |
| 09:28 | Otterbein | Keith Parrett misses the 2nd free throw | 16-18 |
| 09:28 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi gets the rebound | 16-18 |
| 09:14 | John Carroll | Louis Thompson misses short on a pull-up jumper from the right side | 16-18 |
| 09:13 | Otterbein | Julius Chatman snags the defensive board | 16-18 |
| 09:09 | Otterbein | Quentin Shue is hacked by Louis Thompson - foul #1 on Louis Thompson, team foul #6 | 16-18 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund (SG) Louis Thompson | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Frederick Humphrey (SG) Keith Parrett | |
| 08:52 | Otterbein | Julius Chatman buries a turnaround from the baseline on a great pass from Arnold Robertson and he's hacked by Robert Oshiro - foul #1 on Robert Oshiro, team foul #7 | 16-20 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Barry Schafer (PG) Robert Oshiro | |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| 08:52 | Otterbein | Julius Chatman makes the free throw | 16-21 |
| 08:32 | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 16-21 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Louis Thompson (SG), Al Brown (PF) Jerry Barnes, Steve Thompson | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Newton Willmon (SG) Frederick Humphrey | |
| 08:15 | Otterbein | Al Brown steals it from Newton Willmon | 16-21 |
| 07:59 | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund hits the front of the rim on the wide open turnaround from the baseline | 16-21 |
| 07:57 | Otterbein | The rebound goes to Robert Wisnoski | 16-21 |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Barry Schafer (fresh) 11 pts. 1 ast. SG - Louis Thompson (fairly fresh) SF - Kristopher Lund (fairly fresh) 1 ast. PF - Al Brown (fresh) C - Michael Gerardi (fairly fresh) 3 pts. 4 reb. | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Arnold Robertson (fairly fresh) 2 ast. SG - Newton Willmon (fresh) 4 pts. SF - Julius Chatman (fairly fresh) 4 pts. PF - Quentin Shue (very tired) 3 reb. C - Robert Wisnoski (fairly fresh) | |
| 07:50 | Otterbein | Quentin Shue's floater is knocked away by Michael Gerardi | 16-21 |
| 07:48 | Otterbein | Julius Chatman grabs the offensive rebound | 16-21 |
| 07:39 | Otterbein | The jump hook by Quentin Shue is blocked by Michael Gerardi | 16-21 |
| 07:38 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi grabs the board | 16-21 |
| 07:36 | John Carroll | Arnold Robertson steals the ball from Barry Schafer in the backcourt | 16-21 |
| 07:30 | Otterbein | Quentin Shue hits the front of the rim on the floater from the left wing | 16-21 |
| 07:28 | John Carroll | Al Brown grabs the board | 16-21 |
| 07:24 | John Carroll | Barry Schafer can't throw it down but he's hacked by Arnold Robertson - foul #2 on Arnold Robertson, team foul #5 | 16-21 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Jason Malley (SG), Rick Markovitz (SF), Steve Thompson (PF), John Unrein (C) Louis Thompson, Kristopher Lund, Al Brown, Michael Gerardi | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Frank Nieves (PG), Frederick Humphrey (SG), Norman Curtiss (SF), Alex Cohen (C) Arnold Robertson, Newton Willmon, Julius Chatman, Robert Wisnoski | |
| 07:24 | John Carroll | Barry Schafer misses the 1st free throw | 16-21 |
| 07:24 | John Carroll | Barry Schafer makes the 2nd free throw | 17-21 |
| 07:14 | Otterbein | Norman Curtiss misses long on a 3pt jumper from the right corner | 17-21 |
| 07:13 | John Carroll | Steve Thompson snags the defensive board | 17-21 |
| 06:58 | John Carroll | Barry Schafer scores on a 3pt attempt from straight away on a great pass from Rick Markovitz | 20-21 |
| 06:42 | Otterbein | Frederick Humphrey makes the 3 pointer from the left corner | 20-24 |
| 06:20 | John Carroll | John Unrein is called for traveling | 20-24 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Louis Thompson (SG), Jerry Barnes (SF), Michael Gerardi (C) Barry Schafer, Rick Markovitz, Steve Thompson | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Keith Parrett (SG), Larry Austin (SF), Ryan Johnson (C) Frederick Humphrey, Norman Curtiss, Alex Cohen | |
| 06:01 | Otterbein | Quentin Shue banks in the layup | 20-26 |
| 05:59 | John Carroll | Keith Parrett is called for the reach on Louis Thompson in the backcourt - foul #1 on Keith Parrett, team foul #6 | 20-26 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Robert Oshiro (PG), Al Brown (PF) Jason Malley, John Unrein | |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| 05:41 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi connects on the open turnaround from the baseline set up by Louis Thompson and he's fouled by Frank Nieves - foul #1 on Frank Nieves, team foul #7 | 22-26 |
| 05:41 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi makes the free throw | 23-26 |
| 05:24 | Otterbein | Frank Nieves is hacked by Robert Oshiro - foul #2 on Robert Oshiro, team foul #8 | 23-26 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund (PG), Steve Thompson (C) Robert Oshiro, Michael Gerardi | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Newton Willmon (SF) Larry Austin | |
| 05:24 | Otterbein | Frank Nieves makes the 1st free throw | 23-27 |
| 05:24 | Otterbein | Frank Nieves makes the 2nd free throw | 23-28 |
| 05:09 | John Carroll | Louis Thompson comes up short on the pull-up jumper from the left side | 23-28 |
| 05:07 | Otterbein | Quentin Shue grabs the defensive rebound | 23-28 |
| 05:02 | Otterbein | Keith Parrett knocks in the 3pt jumper from straight away set up by Frank Nieves | 23-31 |
| 04:56 | John Carroll | Jerry Barnes hits a 3 from straight away set up by Kristopher Lund | 26-31 |
| 04:42 | Otterbein | Louis Thompson steals the ball from Newton Willmon | 26-31 |
| 04:39 | John Carroll | Louis Thompson's pass is intercepted by Ryan Johnson in the backcourt | 26-31 |
| 04:25 | Otterbein | Keith Parrett misses badly on a jumper in the lane but he's hacked by Louis Thompson - foul #2 on Louis Thompson, team foul #9 | 26-31 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Jason Malley (PG), Rick Markovitz (SG), John Unrein (PF), Michael Gerardi (C) Kristopher Lund, Louis Thompson, Al Brown, Steve Thompson | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Frederick Humphrey (SG), Norman Curtiss (SF), Robert Wisnoski (C) Frank Nieves, Newton Willmon, Ryan Johnson | |
| 04:25 | Otterbein | Keith Parrett misses the 1st free throw | 26-31 |
| 04:25 | Otterbein | Keith Parrett makes the 2nd free throw | 26-32 |
| 04:19 | John Carroll | Jason Malley is hacked by Keith Parrett in the backcourt - foul #2 on Keith Parrett, team foul #8 | 26-32 |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Larry Austin (SF) Keith Parrett | |
| 04:19 | John Carroll | Jason Malley makes the 1st free throw | 27-32 |
| 04:19 | John Carroll | Jason Malley makes the 2nd free throw | 28-32 |
| 03:58 | Otterbein | Michael Gerardi steals it from Robert Wisnoski | 28-32 |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Jason Malley (fresh) 2 pts. SG - Rick Markovitz (fresh) SF - Jerry Barnes (fairly fresh) 5 pts. PF - John Unrein (fresh) 2 reb. C - Michael Gerardi (fairly fresh) 6 pts. 5 reb. 2 blk. 2 stl. | |
| Lineup | Otterbein | PG - Frederick Humphrey (fresh) 8 pts. SG - Norman Curtiss (fresh) 2 pts. SF - Larry Austin (fresh) 3 pts. PF - Quentin Shue (very tired) 2 pts. 4 reb. C - Robert Wisnoski (fresh) | |
| 03:40 | John Carroll | Jerry Barnes is called for traveling | 28-32 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Barry Schafer (PG), Louis Thompson (SG), David Futral (PF) Jason Malley, Jerry Barnes, John Unrein | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Arnold Robertson (PG) Norman Curtiss | |
| 03:29 | Otterbein | Frederick Humphrey loses the dribble to Michael Gerardi | 28-32 |
| 03:13 | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi hits a jump hook near the basket | 30-32 |
| 02:44 | Otterbein | Michael Gerardi steps in front of the Robert Wisnoski pass | 30-32 |
| 02:37 | John Carroll | Barry Schafer is called for traveling | 30-32 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Jason Malley (PG), Kristopher Lund (SG), Al Brown (SF), Steve Thompson (C) Barry Schafer, Louis Thompson, Rick Markovitz, Michael Gerardi | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Newton Willmon (SG), Julius Chatman (SF), Alex Cohen (C) Frederick Humphrey, Larry Austin, Robert Wisnoski | |
| 02:16 | Otterbein | Newton Willmon is fouled on the floor by Jason Malley - foul #1 on Jason Malley, team foul #10 | 30-32 |
| Subs | John Carroll | John Unrein (C) David Futral | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Keith Parrett (SG) Arnold Robertson | |
| 02:16 | Otterbein | Newton Willmon misses the 1st free throw | 30-32 |
| 02:16 | Otterbein | Newton Willmon makes the 2nd free throw | 30-33 |
| 02:03 | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund is whistled for a carry | 30-33 |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Frank Nieves (PG), Norman Curtiss (SF) Newton Willmon, Julius Chatman | |
| 01:51 | Otterbein | Norman Curtiss buries a 3 pointer from the left corner set up by Keith Parrett | 30-36 |
| 01:30 | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund comes up short on the 3pt shot from the right corner | 30-36 |
| 01:28 | John Carroll | Steve Thompson grabs the offensive rebound | 30-36 |
| 01:16 | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund knocks in the fadeaway from the right block and the foul's on Norman Curtiss - foul #1 on Norman Curtiss, team foul #9 | 32-36 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Barry Schafer (PG), Jerry Barnes (SF), David Futral (PF) Jason Malley, Al Brown, John Unrein | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Newton Willmon (SG), Julius Chatman (SF), Ryan Johnson (C) Keith Parrett, Norman Curtiss, Alex Cohen | |
| 01:16 | John Carroll | Kristopher Lund makes the free throw | 33-36 |
| 00:56 | Otterbein | Frank Nieves can't connect on a shot from the free throw line but the foul's on Barry Schafer - foul #1 on Barry Schafer, team foul #11 | 33-36 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Louis Thompson (SG) Kristopher Lund | |
| Subs | Otterbein | | |
| 00:56 | Otterbein | Frank Nieves makes the 1st free throw | 33-37 |
| 00:56 | Otterbein | Frank Nieves makes the 2nd free throw | 33-38 |
| 00:31 | John Carroll | Jerry Barnes is fouled on the floor by Julius Chatman - foul #1 on Julius Chatman, team foul #10 | 33-38 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Michael Gerardi (C) Steve Thompson | |
| Subs | Otterbein | Arnold Robertson (PG), Larry Austin (SG), Robert Wisnoski (C) Frank Nieves, Newton Willmon, Ryan Johnson | |
| 00:31 | John Carroll | Jerry Barnes misses the 1st free throw | 33-38 |
| 00:31 | John Carroll | Jerry Barnes makes the 2nd free throw | 34-38 |
| 00:18 | Otterbein | David Futral swats the layup by Julius Chatman | 34-38 |
| 00:17 | Otterbein | Robert Wisnoski misses the tip | 34-38 |
| 00:16 | John Carroll | David Futral gets the rebound | 34-38 |
| 00:01 | John Carroll | Louis Thompson makes the wide open shot from the left side | 36-38 |
| 00:00 | Otterbein | Arnold Robertson comes up short on the fullcourt shot | 36-38 |