| Lineup | Hampden-Sydney | PG - William Hershey (fresh) SG - Jonas Coon (fresh) SF - Edward Wright (fresh) PF - Scott Gay (fresh) C - Charles Doolin (fresh) | |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - David Kuehl (fresh) SG - Christopher Templeton (fresh) SF - John Lemons (fresh) PF - Albert Leftwich (fresh) C - David Whitt (fresh) | |
| 20:00 | Hampden-Sydney | Charles Doolin wins the tip | 0-0 |
| Game Plan | Hampden-Sydney | Hampden-Sydney is playing a flex offense and a man to man (0) | |
| Game Plan | John Jay | John Jay is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (0) | |
| 19:40 | Hampden-Sydney | Scott Gay comes up short on the shot in the paint but he's hacked by David Kuehl - foul #1 on David Kuehl, team foul #1 | 0-0 |
| 19:40 | Hampden-Sydney | Scott Gay makes the 1st free throw | 1-0 |
| 19:40 | Hampden-Sydney | Scott Gay makes the 2nd free throw | 2-0 |
| 19:38 | John Jay | William Hershey steals it from David Kuehl in the backcourt | 2-0 |
| 19:34 | Hampden-Sydney | William Hershey lays it in | 4-0 |
| 19:08 | John Jay | David Kuehl hits the front of the rim on the 3pt jumper from the left wing | 4-0 |
| 19:07 | John Jay | The offensive rebound goes to Christopher Templeton | 4-0 |
| 18:58 | John Jay | David Whitt throws a bad pass out of bounds | 4-0 |
| 18:50 | Hampden-Sydney | Edward Wright misses the fadeaway from the free throw line | 4-0 |
| 18:48 | Hampden-Sydney | Scott Gay pulls down the offensive rebound | 4-0 |
| 18:38 | Hampden-Sydney | Jonas Coon misses badly on a pull-up jumper from the right side | 4-0 |
| 18:37 | John Jay | David Whitt grabs the defensive rebound | 4-0 |
| 18:23 | John Jay | Albert Leftwich hits a 3 pointer from the left corner on a nice dish by David Kuehl | 4-3 |
| 18:09 | Hampden-Sydney | Jonas Coon clanks a 3pt shot from the left corner | 4-3 |
| 18:08 | Hampden-Sydney | Scott Gay tips it but misses | 4-3 |
| 18:06 | John Jay | John Lemons snags the defensive board | 4-3 |
| 18:02 | John Jay | David Kuehl loses the dribble to William Hershey | 4-3 |
| 17:42 | Hampden-Sydney | Edward Wright clanks a 3pt jumper from the left wing | 4-3 |
| 17:41 | John Jay | David Whitt pulls down the rebound | 4-3 |
| 17:37 | John Jay | David Kuehl's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 4-3 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | Stephen Pinnix (PG), Joseph Brewer (SG), Terry Comer (SF), Christopher Fiorentino (PF), Matthew Johnson (C) William Hershey, Jonas Coon, Edward Wright, Scott Gay, Charles Doolin | |
| Subs | John Jay | | |
| 17:18 | Hampden-Sydney | Terry Comer hits a jumpshot from the right side on a nice dish by Stephen Pinnix | 6-3 |
| 16:55 | John Jay | Albert Leftwich scores on a driving attempt from the baseline set up by David Kuehl | 6-5 |
| 16:30 | Hampden-Sydney | Matthew Johnson misses the shot from the right side but the foul's on John Lemons - foul #1 on John Lemons, team foul #2 | 6-5 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | William Hershey (PG), Scott Gay (PF) Stephen Pinnix, Christopher Fiorentino | |
| Subs | John Jay | Steven Watkins (PG), John Couture (SG), Hal Stewart (SF), Alan Dubuc (PF), James Castleberry (C) David Kuehl, Christopher Templeton, John Lemons, Albert Leftwich, David Whitt | |
| 16:30 | Hampden-Sydney | Matthew Johnson misses the 1st free throw | 6-5 |
| 16:30 | Hampden-Sydney | Matthew Johnson makes the 2nd free throw | 7-5 |
| 16:17 | John Jay | Steven Watkins knocks in the shot from the free throw line on a great pass from Alan Dubuc | 7-7 |
| 16:02 | Hampden-Sydney | William Hershey hits the finger roll set up by Terry Comer and he's hacked by Steven Watkins - foul #1 on Steven Watkins, team foul #3 | 9-7 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | Jonas Coon (SG), Edward Wright (SF), Charles Doolin (C) Joseph Brewer, Terry Comer, Matthew Johnson | |
| Subs | John Jay | | |
| 16:02 | Hampden-Sydney | William Hershey misses the free throw | 9-7 |
| 16:02 | John Jay | The rebound goes to Alan Dubuc | 9-7 |
| Lineup | Hampden-Sydney | PG - William Hershey (fresh) 4 pts. 2 stl. SG - Jonas Coon (fresh) SF - Edward Wright (fresh) PF - Scott Gay (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. C - Charles Doolin (fresh) | |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Steven Watkins (fresh) 2 pts. SG - John Couture (fresh) SF - Hal Stewart (fresh) PF - Alan Dubuc (fresh) C - James Castleberry (fresh) | |
| 15:46 | John Jay | John Couture is fouled on the floor by Jonas Coon - foul #1 on Jonas Coon, team foul #1 | 9-7 |
| 15:38 | John Jay | John Couture is called for traveling | 9-7 |
| 15:27 | Hampden-Sydney | John Couture is called for the reach on Jonas Coon - foul #1 on John Couture, team foul #4 | 9-7 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | Terry Comer (PF) Scott Gay | |
| Subs | John Jay | | |
| 15:17 | Hampden-Sydney | William Hershey hits a 3 from straight away on a nice dish by Terry Comer | 12-7 |
| 15:02 | John Jay | Steven Watkins's pass is intercepted by William Hershey | 12-7 |
| 14:59 | Hampden-Sydney | William Hershey misses the easy layup | 12-7 |
| 14:58 | John Jay | Hal Stewart gets the rebound | 12-7 |
| 14:48 | John Jay | Hal Stewart hits a 3pt jumper from the right wing on a great pass from Steven Watkins | 12-10 |
| 14:32 | Hampden-Sydney | Terry Comer hits the finger roll on a great pass from William Hershey and he's fouled by John Couture - foul #2 on John Couture, team foul #5 | 14-10 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | Stephen Pinnix (PG), Joseph Brewer (SG), Christopher Fiorentino (PF), Matthew Johnson (C) William Hershey, Jonas Coon, Edward Wright, Charles Doolin | |
| Subs | John Jay | David Kuehl (PG), Christopher Templeton (SG), John Lemons (SF), Albert Leftwich (PF), David Whitt (C) Steven Watkins, John Couture, Hal Stewart, Alan Dubuc, James Castleberry | |
| 14:32 | Hampden-Sydney | Terry Comer makes the free throw | 15-10 |
| 14:09 | John Jay | Stephen Pinnix is called for the reach on John Lemons - foul #1 on Stephen Pinnix, team foul #2 | 15-10 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | Dwayne Lewis (SF), Scott Gay (PF) Terry Comer, Matthew Johnson | |
| Subs | John Jay | | |
| 13:59 | John Jay | David Whitt misses short on a fadeaway from the free throw line but he's fouled by Dwayne Lewis - foul #1 on Dwayne Lewis, team foul #3 | 15-10 |
| 13:59 | John Jay | David Whitt makes the 1st free throw | 15-11 |
| 13:59 | John Jay | David Whitt makes the 2nd free throw | 15-12 |
| 13:50 | Hampden-Sydney | Stephen Pinnix connects on the fadeaway jumper from just outside the lane on a great pass from Joseph Brewer | 17-12 |
| 13:34 | John Jay | Christopher Templeton connects on the fadeaway jumper from the right side | 17-14 |
| 13:10 | Hampden-Sydney | Dwayne Lewis misses badly on a runner near the basket but he's fouled by Albert Leftwich - foul #1 on Albert Leftwich, team foul #6 | 17-14 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | Jonas Coon (SG) Joseph Brewer | |
| Subs | John Jay | Alan Dubuc (PF) Albert Leftwich | |
| 13:10 | Hampden-Sydney | Dwayne Lewis makes the 1st free throw | 18-14 |
| 13:10 | Hampden-Sydney | Dwayne Lewis makes the 2nd free throw | 19-14 |
| 12:50 | John Jay | David Whitt misses the easy layup but the foul's on Scott Gay - foul #1 on Scott Gay, team foul #4 | 19-14 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | William Hershey (PG), Edward Wright (SF), Terry Comer (PF), Charles Doolin (C) Stephen Pinnix, Dwayne Lewis, Scott Gay, Christopher Fiorentino | |
| Subs | John Jay | | |
| 12:50 | John Jay | David Whitt makes the 1st free throw | 19-15 |
| 12:50 | John Jay | David Whitt misses the 2nd free throw | 19-15 |
| 12:50 | Hampden-Sydney | Terry Comer pulls down the rebound | 19-15 |
| 12:27 | Hampden-Sydney | Terry Comer hits a turnaround in the paint on a nice dish by William Hershey | 21-15 |
| 12:14 | John Jay | Alan Dubuc connects on the floater from the right wing set up by David Kuehl | 21-17 |
| 12:02 | Hampden-Sydney | Terry Comer is whistled for traveling | 21-17 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | Joseph Brewer (SG) Jonas Coon | |
| Subs | John Jay | Steven Watkins (PG), James Castleberry (SG), Hal Stewart (SF), Albert Leftwich (PF) David Kuehl, Christopher Templeton, John Lemons, David Whitt | |
| Lineup | Hampden-Sydney | PG - William Hershey (fresh) 7 pts. 2 ast. 3 stl. SG - Joseph Brewer (fresh) SF - Edward Wright (fresh) PF - Terry Comer (fresh) 7 pts. C - Charles Doolin (fresh) | |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Steven Watkins (fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. SG - James Castleberry (fresh) SF - Hal Stewart (fresh) 3 pts. PF - Albert Leftwich (fresh) 5 pts. C - Alan Dubuc (fresh) 2 pts. | |
| 11:48 | John Jay | Albert Leftwich can't connect on a shot from just outside the lane but the foul's on Joseph Brewer - foul #1 on Joseph Brewer, team foul #5 | 21-17 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | Dwayne Lewis (SF), Scott Gay (PF), Matthew Johnson (C) Edward Wright, Terry Comer, Charles Doolin | |
| Subs | John Jay | David Whitt (C) Alan Dubuc | |
| 11:48 | John Jay | Albert Leftwich makes the 1st free throw | 21-18 |
| 11:48 | John Jay | Albert Leftwich makes the 2nd free throw | 21-19 |
| 11:27 | Hampden-Sydney | Matthew Johnson can't connect on a pull-up jumper from just outside the lane | 21-19 |
| 11:26 | John Jay | James Castleberry pulls down the rebound | 21-19 |
| 11:22 | John Jay | Steven Watkins hits a 3 from the left wing | 21-22 |
| 11:06 | Hampden-Sydney | David Whitt is called for the reach on Joseph Brewer - foul #1 on David Whitt, team foul #7 | 21-22 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | Stephen Pinnix (PG), Christopher Fiorentino (C) William Hershey, Matthew Johnson | |
| Subs | John Jay | Christopher Templeton (SG) David Whitt | |
| 11:06 | Hampden-Sydney | Joseph Brewer makes the 1st free throw | 22-22 |
| 11:06 | Hampden-Sydney | Joseph Brewer misses the 2nd free throw | 22-22 |
| 11:06 | Hampden-Sydney | The offensive rebound goes to Christopher Fiorentino | 22-22 |
| 10:52 | Hampden-Sydney | Albert Leftwich is called for the reach on Joseph Brewer - foul #2 on Albert Leftwich, team foul #8 | 22-22 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | Jonas Coon (SG) Dwayne Lewis | |
| Subs | John Jay | David Kuehl (PG), John Lemons (SF), David Whitt (C) Steven Watkins, Hal Stewart, Albert Leftwich | |
| 10:52 | Hampden-Sydney | Joseph Brewer misses the 1st free throw | 22-22 |
| 10:52 | John Jay | The rebound goes to David Whitt | 22-22 |
| 10:38 | John Jay | David Whitt hits a 3 from straight away on a nice dish by Christopher Templeton | 22-25 |
| 10:21 | Hampden-Sydney | Jonas Coon misses long on a jumpshot from just outside the lane | 22-25 |
| 10:20 | Hampden-Sydney | Christopher Fiorentino pulls down the offensive rebound | 22-25 |
| 10:06 | Hampden-Sydney | Christopher Fiorentino misses the floater from close range | 22-25 |
| 10:05 | John Jay | James Castleberry pulls down the rebound | 22-25 |
| 09:44 | John Jay | James Castleberry buries a pull-up jumper from the left side set up by David Kuehl | 22-27 |
| 09:26 | Hampden-Sydney | Joseph Brewer hits the front of the rim on the jump hook in the paint | 22-27 |
| 09:24 | John Jay | John Lemons pulls down the rebound | 22-27 |
| 09:19 | John Jay | John Lemons hits a jumper in the paint on a great pass from David Kuehl | 22-29 |
| 08:52 | Hampden-Sydney | Joseph Brewer misses badly on a 3 from the left wing | 22-29 |
| 08:51 | John Jay | David Whitt pulls down the rebound | 22-29 |
| 08:35 | John Jay | Christopher Templeton can't connect on a shot from the right side but he's fouled by Jonas Coon - foul #2 on Jonas Coon, team foul #6 | 22-29 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | William Hershey (PG), Dwayne Lewis (SG), Edward Wright (SF), Terry Comer (PF), Charles Doolin (C) Stephen Pinnix, Jonas Coon, Joseph Brewer, Scott Gay, Christopher Fiorentino | |
| Subs | John Jay | Steven Watkins (PG), Hal Stewart (SF), Alan Dubuc (PF) David Kuehl, John Lemons, James Castleberry | |
| 08:35 | John Jay | Christopher Templeton makes the 1st free throw | 22-30 |
| 08:35 | John Jay | Christopher Templeton makes the 2nd free throw | 22-31 |
| 08:19 | Hampden-Sydney | Terry Comer is called for traveling | 22-31 |
| 07:59 | John Jay | David Whitt's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 22-31 |
| Lineup | Hampden-Sydney | PG - William Hershey (fresh) 7 pts. 2 ast. 3 stl. SG - Dwayne Lewis (fresh) 2 pts. SF - Edward Wright (fresh) PF - Terry Comer (fresh) 7 pts. C - Charles Doolin (fresh) | |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Steven Watkins (fresh) 5 pts. 1 ast. SG - Christopher Templeton (fairly fresh) 4 pts. 1 ast. SF - Hal Stewart (fresh) 3 pts. PF - Alan Dubuc (fresh) 2 pts. C - David Whitt (fairly fresh) 6 pts. 4 reb. | |
| 07:34 | Hampden-Sydney | Terry Comer misses the driving attempt from the left block | 22-31 |
| 07:32 | Hampden-Sydney | Charles Doolin tips it in | 24-31 |
| 07:13 | John Jay | Steven Watkins is whistled for traveling | 24-31 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | Stephen Pinnix (SG) Dwayne Lewis | |
| Subs | John Jay | | |
| 06:55 | Hampden-Sydney | Christopher Templeton is called for the reach on Stephen Pinnix - foul #1 on Christopher Templeton, team foul #9 | 24-31 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | Joseph Brewer (SG) William Hershey | |
| Subs | John Jay | David Kuehl (PG), John Lemons (SF) Steven Watkins, Christopher Templeton | |
| 06:55 | Hampden-Sydney | Stephen Pinnix makes the 1st free throw | 25-31 |
| 06:55 | Hampden-Sydney | Stephen Pinnix makes the 2nd free throw | 26-31 |
| 06:38 | John Jay | Joseph Brewer steals it from Hal Stewart | 26-31 |
| 06:27 | Hampden-Sydney | Terry Comer scores on a floater from the free throw line on a nice dish by Stephen Pinnix | 28-31 |
| 06:14 | John Jay | John Lemons hits the front of the rim on the shot in the lane | 28-31 |
| 06:13 | John Jay | Hal Stewart snags the offensive board | 28-31 |
| 05:59 | John Jay | John Lemons comes up short on the fadeaway from the left side | 28-31 |
| 05:57 | John Jay | The offensive rebound goes to Hal Stewart | 28-31 |
| 05:50 | John Jay | David Kuehl misses badly on a jumpshot from just outside the lane | 28-31 |
| 05:49 | Hampden-Sydney | Joseph Brewer gets the rebound | 28-31 |
| 05:44 | Hampden-Sydney | Stephen Pinnix comes up short on the 3pt attempt from the left corner | 28-31 |
| 05:43 | John Jay | Alan Dubuc grabs the board | 28-31 |
| 05:38 | John Jay | Edward Wright steals the ball from David Whitt | 28-31 |
| 05:34 | Hampden-Sydney | Stephen Pinnix hits the finger roll set up by Edward Wright | 30-31 |
| 05:18 | John Jay | Hal Stewart misses badly on a jumper from the right side | 30-31 |
| 05:16 | Hampden-Sydney | Edward Wright snags the defensive board | 30-31 |
| 04:59 | Hampden-Sydney | Stephen Pinnix is whistled for a carry | 30-31 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | William Hershey (PG), Dwayne Lewis (SG), Scott Gay (PF), Matthew Johnson (C) Stephen Pinnix, Joseph Brewer, Terry Comer, Charles Doolin | |
| Subs | John Jay | Steven Watkins (PG), Christopher Templeton (SG), Richard Barry (SF), James Castleberry (PF) David Kuehl, Hal Stewart, John Lemons, David Whitt | |
| 04:41 | John Jay | James Castleberry clanks a 3pt shot from the left corner | 30-31 |
| 04:39 | Hampden-Sydney | Dwayne Lewis snags the defensive board | 30-31 |
| 04:25 | Hampden-Sydney | Scott Gay drills a jumper from just outside the lane set up by William Hershey | 32-31 |
| 04:21 | John Jay | Steven Watkins is fouled in the backcourt by Dwayne Lewis - foul #2 on Dwayne Lewis, team foul #7 | 32-31 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | Joseph Brewer (SG), Christopher Fiorentino (C) Dwayne Lewis, Matthew Johnson | |
| Subs | John Jay | | |
| 04:21 | John Jay | Steven Watkins misses the 1st free throw | 32-31 |
| 04:21 | Hampden-Sydney | Christopher Fiorentino snags the defensive board | 32-31 |
| 04:05 | Hampden-Sydney | Scott Gay banks in the layup set up by William Hershey | 34-31 |
| 04:01 | John Jay | Christopher Templeton buries a 3pt jumper from the left corner on a nice dish by Richard Barry | 34-34 |
| 03:55 | Hampden-Sydney | William Hershey's pass is off the mark and out of bounds in the backcourt | 34-34 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | Jonas Coon (SG) Edward Wright | |
| Subs | John Jay | John Couture (SG), Albert Leftwich (PF) Christopher Templeton, Alan Dubuc | |
| Lineup | Hampden-Sydney | PG - William Hershey (fresh) 7 pts. 4 ast. 3 stl. SG - Jonas Coon (fresh) SF - Joseph Brewer (fresh) 1 pts. PF - Scott Gay (fresh) 6 pts. 2 reb. C - Christopher Fiorentino (fresh) 3 reb. | |
| Lineup | John Jay | PG - Steven Watkins (fresh) 5 pts. 1 ast. SG - John Couture (fresh) SF - Richard Barry (fresh) 1 ast. PF - Albert Leftwich (fresh) 7 pts. C - James Castleberry (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. | |
| 03:31 | John Jay | James Castleberry drills a 3pt jumper from the left wing set up by Steven Watkins | 34-37 |
| 03:13 | Hampden-Sydney | Scott Gay drills a fadeaway jumper from the left wing on a great pass from Jonas Coon and he's fouled by Richard Barry - foul #1 on Richard Barry, team foul #10 | 36-37 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | Dwayne Lewis (SF), Matthew Johnson (C) Joseph Brewer, Christopher Fiorentino | |
| Subs | John Jay | David Kuehl (PG), John Lemons (SF) Steven Watkins, Richard Barry | |
| 03:13 | Hampden-Sydney | Scott Gay misses the free throw | 36-37 |
| 03:13 | John Jay | Albert Leftwich grabs the defensive rebound | 36-37 |
| 02:56 | John Jay | John Couture misses the floater from the left side | 36-37 |
| 02:55 | Hampden-Sydney | Dwayne Lewis snags the defensive board | 36-37 |
| 02:42 | Hampden-Sydney | John Lemons takes the ball from Matthew Johnson | 36-37 |
| 02:38 | John Jay | John Couture lays it in on a nice dish by John Lemons | 36-39 |
| 02:24 | Hampden-Sydney | Jonas Coon is fouled on the floor by John Couture - foul #3 on John Couture, team foul #11 | 36-39 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | Stephen Pinnix (PG), Terry Comer (PF) William Hershey, Scott Gay | |
| Subs | John Jay | Hal Stewart (SG), David Whitt (C) John Couture, James Castleberry | |
| 02:24 | Hampden-Sydney | Jonas Coon makes the 1st free throw | 37-39 |
| 02:24 | Hampden-Sydney | Jonas Coon misses the 2nd free throw | 37-39 |
| 02:24 | John Jay | David Whitt pulls down the rebound | 37-39 |
| 02:07 | John Jay | Terry Comer is called for the reach on David Kuehl - foul #1 on Terry Comer, team foul #8 | 37-39 |
| 02:07 | John Jay | David Kuehl makes the 1st free throw | 37-40 |
| 02:07 | John Jay | David Kuehl misses the 2nd free throw | 37-40 |
| 02:07 | Hampden-Sydney | Matthew Johnson pulls down the rebound | 37-40 |
| 01:52 | Hampden-Sydney | Dwayne Lewis misses short on a 3pt attempt from straight away | 37-40 |
| 01:50 | Hampden-Sydney | Matthew Johnson grabs the offensive rebound | 37-40 |
| 01:29 | Hampden-Sydney | Dwayne Lewis hits the front of the rim on the pull-up jumper from the right wing | 37-40 |
| 01:27 | John Jay | The rebound goes to David Whitt | 37-40 |
| 01:21 | John Jay | David Kuehl can't connect on a fadeaway jumper from the right wing | 37-40 |
| 01:19 | Hampden-Sydney | Terry Comer grabs the defensive rebound | 37-40 |
| 01:07 | Hampden-Sydney | Jonas Coon scores on a jumpshot from just outside the lane on a nice dish by Dwayne Lewis and he's hacked by John Lemons - foul #2 on John Lemons, team foul #12 | 39-40 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | Christopher Fiorentino (PF), Charles Doolin (C) Dwayne Lewis, Matthew Johnson | |
| Subs | John Jay | Steven Watkins (PG), Christopher Templeton (SG) David Kuehl, Hal Stewart | |
| 01:07 | Hampden-Sydney | Jonas Coon makes the free throw | 40-40 |
| 00:51 | John Jay | Terry Comer is called for the reach on John Lemons - foul #2 on Terry Comer, team foul #9 | 40-40 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | William Hershey (PG), Joseph Brewer (SF) Jonas Coon, Terry Comer | |
| Subs | John Jay | Alan Dubuc (C) David Whitt | |
| 00:51 | John Jay | John Lemons misses the 1st free throw | 40-40 |
| 00:51 | Hampden-Sydney | Charles Doolin snags the defensive board | 40-40 |
| 00:35 | Hampden-Sydney | Joseph Brewer can't connect on a 3 from the left corner | 40-40 |
| 00:33 | John Jay | Alan Dubuc gets the rebound | 40-40 |
| 00:26 | John Jay | Christopher Templeton is fouled on the floor by Christopher Fiorentino - foul #1 on Christopher Fiorentino, team foul #10 | 40-40 |
| Subs | Hampden-Sydney | Scott Gay (PF) Christopher Fiorentino | |
| Subs | John Jay | Hal Stewart (SF), James Castleberry (C) John Lemons, Alan Dubuc | |
| 00:26 | John Jay | Christopher Templeton misses the 1st free throw | 40-40 |
| 00:26 | John Jay | Christopher Templeton makes the 2nd free throw | 40-41 |
| 00:04 | Hampden-Sydney | Scott Gay misses long on a runner near the basket | 40-41 |
| 00:03 | John Jay | Albert Leftwich grabs the board | 40-41 |
| 00:00 | John Jay | Albert Leftwich misses badly on a halfcourt shot | 40-41 |