| Lineup | Valparaiso | PG - Michael Pierce (fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. SG - Jeffry Brown (fresh) 5 pts. 2 ast. SF - Travis Pettus (fresh) 2 pts. 6 reb. PF - Eric Smalling (fresh) 2 reb. C - Thomas Watkins (fresh) 6 pts. 2 reb. | |
| Lineup | Colgate | PG - Thomas Anaya (fresh) 2 pts. 1 ast. SG - John Graham (fresh) 6 pts. 1 ast. SF - Billy Piscitelli (fresh) 4 pts. 2 reb. PF - Richard Dixon (fresh) 2 pts. C - Jamal Lentz (fresh) 3 pts. 2 reb. | |
| 20:00 | Colgate | Billy Piscitelli inbounds the ball | 32-31 |
| Game Plan | Valparaiso | Valparaiso is playing a motion offense and a man to man (+1) | |
| Game Plan | Colgate | Colgate is playing a motion offense and a man to man (-2) | |
| 19:31 | Colgate | John Graham misses badly on a 3pt jumper from the left wing | 32-31 |
| 19:30 | Valparaiso | Travis Pettus grabs the defensive rebound | 32-31 |
| 19:25 | Valparaiso | Jeffry Brown throws a bad pass out of bounds | 32-31 |
| 19:06 | Colgate | Michael Pierce steals it from Richard Dixon | 32-31 |
| 18:47 | Valparaiso | Jamal Lentz steps in front of the Thomas Watkins pass | 32-31 |
| 18:31 | Colgate | John Graham misses the turnaround from close range but he's fouled by Jeffry Brown - foul #1 on Jeffry Brown, team foul #1 | 32-31 |
| 18:31 | Colgate | John Graham makes the 1st free throw | 32-32 |
| 18:31 | Colgate | John Graham makes the 2nd free throw | 32-33 |
| 18:20 | Valparaiso | Jeffry Brown scores on a 3pt jumper from the left wing set up by Travis Pettus | 35-33 |
| 17:56 | Colgate | Thomas Watkins steals the ball from Billy Piscitelli | 35-33 |
| 17:32 | Valparaiso | Eric Smalling scores on a turnaround in the paint | 37-33 |
| 17:06 | Colgate | Richard Dixon can't connect on a jumpshot from the right side | 37-33 |
| 17:05 | Valparaiso | Thomas Watkins snags the defensive board | 37-33 |
| 16:59 | Valparaiso | Jeffry Brown misses the 3pt attempt from the right wing | 37-33 |
| 16:57 | Colgate | Richard Dixon snags the defensive board | 37-33 |
| 16:39 | Colgate | Jamal Lentz misses long on a floater from the left block | 37-33 |
| 16:37 | Valparaiso | Eric Smalling pulls down the rebound | 37-33 |
| 16:18 | Valparaiso | Travis Pettus lays it in set up by Thomas Watkins and the foul's on Billy Piscitelli - foul #2 on Billy Piscitelli, team foul #1 | 39-33 |
| Subs | Valparaiso | Kenton Steinbach (PG), Anthony Todd (SG), Seth Mears (PF), Dennis Nicosia (C) Michael Pierce, Jeffry Brown, Eric Smalling, Thomas Watkins | |
| Subs | Colgate | David Raper (PG), Levi Tapia (SG), Fred Richart (SF), David Ward (PF), Wayne Harder (C) Thomas Anaya, John Graham, Billy Piscitelli, Richard Dixon, Jamal Lentz | |
| 16:18 | Valparaiso | Travis Pettus makes the free throw | 40-33 |
| 15:57 | Colgate | Fred Richart drills a jumpshot from the free throw line on a great pass from David Ward | 40-35 |
| Lineup | Valparaiso | PG - Kenton Steinbach (fresh) 4 pts. SG - Anthony Todd (fresh) 5 pts. 1 ast. 2 stl. SF - Travis Pettus (fairly fresh) 5 pts. 7 reb. PF - Seth Mears (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. C - Dennis Nicosia (fresh) 4 pts. | |
| Lineup | Colgate | PG - David Raper (fresh) 2 pts. SG - Levi Tapia (fresh) 2 pts. SF - Fred Richart (fresh) 5 pts. PF - David Ward (fresh) 5 pts. 3 reb. C - Wayne Harder (fresh) 2 pts. | |
| 15:40 | Valparaiso | Anthony Todd hits a 3pt jumper from straight away on a nice dish by Kenton Steinbach | 43-35 |
| 15:22 | Colgate | Travis Pettus steals it from David Ward | 43-35 |
| 15:01 | Valparaiso | Seth Mears comes up short on the 3 pointer from the right corner | 43-35 |
| 15:00 | Colgate | Wayne Harder grabs the board | 43-35 |
| 14:40 | Colgate | Seth Mears swats the shot by Levi Tapia | 43-35 |
| 14:39 | Colgate | The offensive rebound goes to David Ward | 43-35 |
| 14:22 | Colgate | David Raper is hacked by Anthony Todd - foul #3 on Anthony Todd, team foul #2 | 43-35 |
| Subs | Valparaiso | Michael Pierce (PG), Eric Smalling (PF), Thomas Watkins (C) Travis Pettus, Seth Mears, Dennis Nicosia | |
| Subs | Colgate | Thomas Anaya (PG), Jason Vogel (PF) Levi Tapia, Wayne Harder | |
| 14:06 | Colgate | Fred Richart throws a bad pass out of bounds | 43-35 |
| Subs | Valparaiso | Jeffry Brown (SG) Anthony Todd | |
| Subs | Colgate | John Graham (SG), Jamal Lentz (C) David Raper, Jason Vogel | |
| 13:52 | Valparaiso | Michael Pierce hits a jumpshot from the left side | 45-35 |
| 13:31 | Colgate | John Graham hits a fadeaway from the left side on a great pass from Thomas Anaya | 45-37 |
| 13:16 | Valparaiso | Jeffry Brown's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 45-37 |
| Subs | Valparaiso | Anthony Todd (SF) Kenton Steinbach | |
| Subs | Colgate | Billy Piscitelli (SF), Richard Dixon (PF) Fred Richart, David Ward | |
| 12:56 | Colgate | Thomas Anaya makes the 3pt shot from the left corner on a nice dish by John Graham | 45-40 |
| 12:34 | Valparaiso | Michael Pierce hits the front of the rim on the fadeaway jumper from the free throw line but he's hacked by Billy Piscitelli - foul #3 on Billy Piscitelli, team foul #2 | 45-40 |
| Subs | Valparaiso | Christopher Parker (SF), Seth Mears (PF), Dennis Nicosia (C) Jeffry Brown, Eric Smalling, Thomas Watkins | |
| Subs | Colgate | David Raper (PG), Levi Tapia (SG), Wayne Harder (C) Thomas Anaya, John Graham, Jamal Lentz | |
| 12:34 | Valparaiso | Michael Pierce makes the 1st free throw | 46-40 |
| 12:34 | Valparaiso | Michael Pierce makes the 2nd free throw | 47-40 |
| 12:22 | Colgate | Levi Tapia misses the fadeaway from the right wing | 47-40 |
| 12:20 | Colgate | Levi Tapia gets the offensive rebound | 47-40 |
| 12:07 | Colgate | Michael Pierce is called for the reach on David Raper - foul #2 on Michael Pierce, team foul #3 | 47-40 |
| Subs | Valparaiso | Kenton Steinbach (SG) Christopher Parker | |
| Subs | Colgate | Fred Richart (SG), David Ward (C) Levi Tapia, Wayne Harder | |
| 11:45 | Colgate | Billy Piscitelli misses long on a 3pt shot from the left wing | 47-40 |
| 11:44 | Colgate | Fred Richart gets the offensive rebound | 47-40 |
| Lineup | Valparaiso | PG - Michael Pierce (fresh) 6 pts. 1 ast. SG - Kenton Steinbach (fresh) 4 pts. 1 ast. SF - Anthony Todd (fairly fresh) 8 pts. 1 ast. 2 stl. 3 pf. PF - Seth Mears (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. 2 blk. C - Dennis Nicosia (fresh) 4 pts. | |
| Lineup | Colgate | PG - David Raper (fresh) 2 pts. SG - Fred Richart (fresh) 5 pts. SF - Billy Piscitelli (fairly fresh) 4 pts. 2 reb. 3 pf. PF - Richard Dixon (fairly fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. C - David Ward (fresh) 5 pts. 4 reb. | |
| 11:33 | Colgate | Billy Piscitelli misses long on a jumper from the free throw line | 47-40 |
| 11:31 | Valparaiso | Anthony Todd grabs the defensive rebound | 47-40 |
| 11:16 | Valparaiso | Seth Mears is hacked by Richard Dixon - foul #1 on Richard Dixon, team foul #3 | 47-40 |
| Subs | Valparaiso | Jeffry Brown (SG), Travis Pettus (SF), Eric Smalling (PF), Thomas Watkins (C) Michael Pierce, Anthony Todd, Seth Mears, Dennis Nicosia | |
| Subs | Colgate | Thomas Anaya (PG), John Graham (SG), Jamal Lentz (C) David Raper, Billy Piscitelli, Richard Dixon | |
| 11:06 | Valparaiso | Travis Pettus hits the front of the rim on the 3pt attempt from the left corner | 47-40 |
| 11:04 | Colgate | David Ward grabs the board | 47-40 |
| 10:44 | Colgate | John Graham's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 47-40 |
| 10:25 | Valparaiso | Jeffry Brown misses the pull-up jumper from the left side | 47-40 |
| 10:24 | Valparaiso | The offensive rebound goes to Travis Pettus | 47-40 |
| 10:06 | Valparaiso | Thomas Watkins drills a runner in the lane set up by Jeffry Brown | 49-40 |
| 09:46 | Colgate | Thomas Anaya hits the front of the rim on the jumpshot from just outside the lane | 49-40 |
| 09:44 | Valparaiso | Eric Smalling snags the defensive board | 49-40 |
| 09:26 | Valparaiso | Thomas Watkins's layup is rejected by Jamal Lentz | 49-40 |
| 09:24 | Colgate | David Ward grabs the board | 49-40 |
| 09:13 | Colgate | John Graham's pass is intercepted by Eric Smalling | 49-40 |
| 08:52 | Valparaiso | Jeffry Brown knocks in the 3 from the right wing on a nice dish by Kenton Steinbach | 52-40 |
| 08:36 | Colgate | John Graham drills a 3pt attempt from the left wing set up by Thomas Anaya | 52-43 |
| 08:17 | Valparaiso | Eric Smalling scores on a floater from the free throw line set up by Travis Pettus and he's hacked by Thomas Anaya - foul #1 on Thomas Anaya, team foul #4 | 54-43 |
| Subs | Valparaiso | Michael Pierce (PG), Anthony Todd (SG), Christopher Parker (SF), Dennis Nicosia (C) Kenton Steinbach, Jeffry Brown, Travis Pettus, Thomas Watkins | |
| Subs | Colgate | David Raper (PG), Levi Tapia (SG), Billy Piscitelli (SF), Richard Dixon (PF), Wayne Harder (C) Thomas Anaya, John Graham, Fred Richart, David Ward, Jamal Lentz | |
| 08:17 | Valparaiso | Eric Smalling makes the free throw | 55-43 |
| 08:01 | Colgate | Billy Piscitelli hits the finger roll and he's fouled by Dennis Nicosia - foul #1 on Dennis Nicosia, team foul #4 | 55-45 |
| Subs | Valparaiso | Seth Mears (PF) Eric Smalling | |
| Subs | Colgate | | |
| 08:01 | Colgate | Billy Piscitelli makes the free throw | 55-46 |
| 07:32 | Valparaiso | A charge is called on Dennis Nicosia - foul #2 on Dennis Nicosia, team foul #5 | 55-46 |
| Lineup | Valparaiso | PG - Michael Pierce (fresh) 6 pts. 1 ast. SG - Anthony Todd (fresh) 8 pts. 1 ast. 2 stl. 3 pf. SF - Christopher Parker (fresh) 2 pts. PF - Seth Mears (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. 2 blk. C - Dennis Nicosia (fresh) 4 pts. | |
| Lineup | Colgate | PG - David Raper (fresh) 2 pts. SG - Levi Tapia (fresh) 2 pts. SF - Billy Piscitelli (fresh) 7 pts. 2 reb. 3 pf. PF - Richard Dixon (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. C - Wayne Harder (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. | |
| 07:04 | Colgate | Wayne Harder can't finish the layup | 55-46 |
| 07:02 | Valparaiso | Dennis Nicosia grabs the board | 55-46 |
| 06:46 | Valparaiso | Anthony Todd loses the dribble to Wayne Harder | 55-46 |
| 06:28 | Colgate | Richard Dixon travels with the ball | 55-46 |
| Subs | Valparaiso | Kenton Steinbach (SG), Travis Pettus (SF) Anthony Todd, Christopher Parker | |
| Subs | Colgate | Thomas Anaya (PG), John Graham (SG) David Raper, Levi Tapia | |
| 06:08 | Valparaiso | Travis Pettus comes up short on the 3 from straight away | 55-46 |
| 06:06 | Colgate | Thomas Anaya snags the defensive board | 55-46 |
| 05:49 | Colgate | Richard Dixon clanks a runner in the lane | 55-46 |
| 05:47 | Colgate | Thomas Anaya tips it in | 55-48 |
| 05:28 | Valparaiso | Michael Pierce comes up short on the shot from the free throw line | 55-48 |
| 05:26 | Colgate | Richard Dixon pulls down the rebound | 55-48 |
| 05:09 | Colgate | Kenton Steinbach steps in front of the Billy Piscitelli pass | 55-48 |
| 05:09 | Valparaiso | Valparaiso calls a full timeout (2 :30 3 full remaining) | 55-48 |
| Subs | Valparaiso | Jeffry Brown (SG), Eric Smalling (PF), Thomas Watkins (C) Kenton Steinbach, Seth Mears, Dennis Nicosia | |
| Subs | Colgate | Jamal Lentz (C) Wayne Harder | |
| 04:46 | Valparaiso | Thomas Watkins drills a driving attempt in the paint on a nice dish by Jeffry Brown and he's hacked by Jamal Lentz - foul #2 on Jamal Lentz, team foul #5 | 57-48 |
| Subs | Valparaiso | | |
| Subs | Colgate | Fred Richart (SF), David Ward (PF) Billy Piscitelli, Richard Dixon | |
| 04:46 | Valparaiso | Thomas Watkins misses the free throw | 57-48 |
| 04:46 | Colgate | David Ward pulls down the rebound | 57-48 |
| 04:35 | Colgate | John Graham is hacked by Eric Smalling - foul #2 on Eric Smalling, team foul #6 | 57-48 |
| 04:22 | Colgate | Fred Richart comes up short on the 3pt shot from straight away | 57-48 |
| 04:20 | Valparaiso | Eric Smalling snags the defensive board | 57-48 |
| 04:00 | Valparaiso | Michael Pierce misses badly on a driving attempt from the baseline | 57-48 |
| 03:59 | Valparaiso | Michael Pierce tips it back up and in | 59-48 |
| Game Plan | Valparaiso | Valparaiso is playing a motion offense and a man to man (+1) | |
| Game Plan | Colgate | Colgate is playing a motion offense (uptempo) and a man to man (-2) | |
| 03:37 | Colgate | David Ward knocks in the driving attempt in the lane on a nice dish by Thomas Anaya | 59-50 |
| Game Plan | Valparaiso | Valparaiso is playing a motion offense (slowdown) and a man to man (+1) | |
| Game Plan | Colgate | Colgate is playing a motion offense (uptempo) and a man to man (-1) | |
| 03:13 | Valparaiso | Travis Pettus hits a 3 pointer from straight away on a great pass from Michael Pierce | 62-50 |
| Lineup | Valparaiso | PG - Michael Pierce (fresh) 8 pts. 2 ast. SG - Jeffry Brown (fresh) 11 pts. 4 ast. SF - Travis Pettus (fresh) 8 pts. 8 reb. PF - Eric Smalling (fresh) 5 pts. 5 reb. C - Thomas Watkins (fresh) 10 pts. 3 reb. 2 stl. | |
| Lineup | Colgate | PG - Thomas Anaya (fresh) 7 pts. 4 ast. SG - John Graham (fairly fresh) 13 pts. 2 ast. SF - Fred Richart (fresh) 5 pts. PF - David Ward (fresh) 7 pts. 7 reb. C - Jamal Lentz (fresh) 3 pts. 2 reb. 2 blk. | |
| 03:08 | Colgate | Fred Richart misses badly on a 3pt jumper from the right wing | 62-50 |
| 03:07 | Valparaiso | Thomas Watkins grabs the defensive rebound | 62-50 |
| 02:49 | Valparaiso | Jamal Lentz is called for the reach on Thomas Watkins - foul #3 on Jamal Lentz, team foul #6 | 62-50 |
| Subs | Valparaiso | Kenton Steinbach (PG), Anthony Todd (SG), Christopher Parker (SF), Seth Mears (PF), Dennis Nicosia (C) Michael Pierce, Jeffry Brown, Travis Pettus, Eric Smalling, Thomas Watkins | |
| Subs | Colgate | David Raper (PG), Levi Tapia (SG), Wayne Harder (C) Thomas Anaya, John Graham, Jamal Lentz | |
| 02:34 | Valparaiso | Kenton Steinbach's pass is off the mark and out of bounds | 62-50 |
| 02:22 | Colgate | Levi Tapia comes up short on the pull-up jumper from just outside the lane but he's fouled by Dennis Nicosia - foul #3 on Dennis Nicosia, team foul #7 | 62-50 |
| 02:22 | Colgate | Levi Tapia makes the 1st free throw | 62-51 |
| 02:22 | Colgate | Levi Tapia misses the 2nd free throw | 62-51 |
| 02:22 | Valparaiso | Dennis Nicosia pulls down the rebound | 62-51 |
| 02:03 | Valparaiso | Anthony Todd can't connect on a fadeaway jumper from the right side | 62-51 |
| 02:01 | Valparaiso | Anthony Todd pulls down the offensive rebound | 62-51 |
| 01:39 | Valparaiso | Anthony Todd misses long on a jumpshot from the left side | 62-51 |
| 01:37 | Colgate | David Raper snags the defensive board | 62-51 |
| 01:15 | Colgate | Fred Richart drills a 3 pointer from straight away | 62-54 |
| 01:15 | Valparaiso | Valparaiso calls a full timeout (2 :30 2 full remaining) | 62-54 |
| Subs | Valparaiso | Michael Pierce (PG), Jeffry Brown (SG), Travis Pettus (SF), Eric Smalling (PF), Thomas Watkins (C) Kenton Steinbach, Anthony Todd, Christopher Parker, Seth Mears, Dennis Nicosia | |
| Subs | Colgate | Thomas Anaya (PG), John Graham (SG), Billy Piscitelli (SF), Richard Dixon (PF), Jamal Lentz (C) David Raper, Levi Tapia, Fred Richart, David Ward, Wayne Harder | |
| 00:48 | Valparaiso | Jeffry Brown can't connect on a 3pt jumper from straight away | 62-54 |
| 00:47 | Colgate | Jamal Lentz grabs the board | 62-54 |
| Game Plan | Valparaiso | Valparaiso is playing a motion offense (slowdown) and a man to man (+1) | |
| Game Plan | Colgate | Colgate is playing a quick shot offense (quick shot) and a man to man (-1) | |
| 00:40 | Colgate | Jamal Lentz is hacked by Thomas Watkins - foul #2 on Thomas Watkins, team foul #8 | 62-54 |
| 00:40 | Colgate | Jamal Lentz makes the 1st free throw | 62-55 |
| 00:40 | Colgate | Jamal Lentz misses the 2nd free throw | 62-55 |
| 00:40 | Valparaiso | Eric Smalling pulls down the rebound | 62-55 |
| Game Plan | Valparaiso | Valparaiso is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (+1) | |
| Game Plan | Colgate | Colgate is playing a quick shot offense (quick shot) and intentionally fouling (-2) | |
| 00:38 | Valparaiso | Thomas Anaya is called for the reach on Eric Smalling in the backcourt - foul #2 on Thomas Anaya, team foul #7 | 62-55 |
| Subs | Valparaiso | Kenton Steinbach (SG) Jeffry Brown | |
| Subs | Colgate | | |
| 00:38 | Valparaiso | Eric Smalling makes the 1st free throw | 63-55 |
| 00:38 | Valparaiso | Eric Smalling makes the 2nd free throw | 64-55 |
| 00:34 | Colgate | Thomas Anaya comes up short on the 3pt jumper from the right wing | 64-55 |
| 00:33 | Valparaiso | Eric Smalling pulls down the rebound | 64-55 |
| Game Plan | Valparaiso | Valparaiso is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (+1) | |
| Game Plan | Colgate | Colgate is playing a quick shot offense (quick shot) and intentionally fouling (-1) | |
| 00:32 | Valparaiso | Thomas Anaya is called for the reach on Eric Smalling in the backcourt - foul #3 on Thomas Anaya, team foul #8 | 64-55 |
| 00:32 | Valparaiso | Eric Smalling makes the 1st free throw | 65-55 |
| 00:32 | Valparaiso | Eric Smalling misses the 2nd free throw | 65-55 |
| 00:32 | Colgate | Richard Dixon gets the rebound | 65-55 |
| 00:25 | Colgate | Billy Piscitelli throws a bad pass out of bounds | 65-55 |
| Subs | Valparaiso | Randall Benson (PG), Anthony Todd (SF), Seth Mears (PF), Willard Perales (C) Michael Pierce, Travis Pettus, Eric Smalling, Thomas Watkins | |
| Subs | Colgate | David Raper (PG), Levi Tapia (SG), Fred Richart (SF), David Ward (PF), Wayne Harder (C) Thomas Anaya, John Graham, Billy Piscitelli, Richard Dixon, Jamal Lentz | |
| Game Plan | Valparaiso | Valparaiso is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (+1) | |
| Game Plan | Colgate | Colgate is playing a quick shot offense (quick shot) and a man to man (-1) | |
| 00:00 | Valparaiso | Randall Benson runs out the clock | 65-55 |