| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Wilmer Shepherd (fresh) 2 pts. 3 ast. SG - Robert Whipple (fresh) 3 pts. 1 ast. SF - George Moore (fresh) PF - Willie Johns (fresh) 7 pts. 3 reb. C - Christopher Holcomb (fresh) 9 pts. 4 reb. 3 blk. | |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - Robert Patten (fresh) 5 pts. SG - Jarrod Haskins (fresh) 6 pts. 3 ast. SF - Paul Laflamme (fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. PF - Brad Daluz (fresh) 2 pts. C - Michael Shin (fresh) 8 pts. 5 reb. | |
| 20:00 | Muskingum | Paul Laflamme inbounds the ball | 33-31 |
| Game Plan | John Carroll | John Carroll is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (-1) | |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a flex offense and a man to man (-1) | |
| 19:52 | Muskingum | Jarrod Haskins hits the front of the rim on the jump hook from the right block | 33-31 |
| 19:51 | John Carroll | Christopher Holcomb grabs the defensive rebound | 33-31 |
| 19:42 | John Carroll | Wilmer Shepherd's pass is intercepted by Brad Daluz | 33-31 |
| 19:23 | Muskingum | Paul Laflamme is denied on a layup by Willie Johns | 33-31 |
| 19:21 | John Carroll | Wilmer Shepherd gets the rebound | 33-31 |
| 19:02 | John Carroll | Wilmer Shepherd buries a floater from close range on a nice dish by Robert Whipple | 35-31 |
| 18:42 | Muskingum | Brad Daluz scores on a jumper from the left wing on a great pass from Paul Laflamme | 35-33 |
| 18:24 | John Carroll | George Moore drills a floater from just outside the lane set up by Wilmer Shepherd | 37-33 |
| 18:03 | Muskingum | Jarrod Haskins comes up short on the fadeaway from the free throw line | 37-33 |
| 18:01 | Muskingum | The offensive rebound goes to Brad Daluz | 37-33 |
| 17:49 | Muskingum | Robert Patten lays it in on a nice dish by Jarrod Haskins | 37-35 |
| 17:32 | John Carroll | Willie Johns hits the front of the rim on the floater near the basket but he's fouled by Michael Shin - foul #3 on Michael Shin, team foul #1 | 37-35 |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Tommy Caudill (PF), Nicholas Sheaffer (C) Brad Daluz, Michael Shin | |
| 17:32 | John Carroll | Willie Johns misses the 1st free throw | 37-35 |
| 17:32 | John Carroll | Willie Johns makes the 2nd free throw | 38-35 |
| 17:14 | Muskingum | Jarrod Haskins connects on the 3 pointer from straight away on a nice dish by Robert Patten | 38-38 |
| 16:50 | John Carroll | Christopher Holcomb hits a jump hook in the lane on a nice dish by Wilmer Shepherd | 40-38 |
| 16:39 | Muskingum | Wilmer Shepherd steals it from Jarrod Haskins | 40-38 |
| 16:36 | John Carroll | Wilmer Shepherd hits the finger roll | 42-38 |
| 16:20 | Muskingum | Robert Patten's pass is intercepted by Willie Johns | 42-38 |
| 16:01 | John Carroll | Willie Johns scores on a 3pt jumper from the left corner | 45-38 |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Wilmer Shepherd (fairly fresh) 6 pts. 5 ast. SG - Robert Whipple (fairly fresh) 3 pts. 2 ast. SF - George Moore (fairly fresh) 2 pts. PF - Willie Johns (fairly fresh) 11 pts. 3 reb. 2 stl. C - Christopher Holcomb (fairly fresh) 11 pts. 5 reb. 3 blk. | |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - Robert Patten (fairly fresh) 7 pts. 1 ast. SG - Jarrod Haskins (fairly fresh) 9 pts. 4 ast. SF - Paul Laflamme (fairly fresh) 2 pts. 2 reb. PF - Tommy Caudill (fresh) C - Nicholas Sheaffer (fresh) 2 reb. | |
| 15:51 | Muskingum | Jarrod Haskins is fouled on the floor by Robert Whipple - foul #1 on Robert Whipple, team foul #1 | 45-38 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Wilson Pavon (PG), Scott Killian (SG), Jeffery McKinstry (SF), Robert Morrison (PF), John Hall (C) Wilmer Shepherd, Robert Whipple, George Moore, Willie Johns, Christopher Holcomb | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Benjamin Lane (PG), Charlie Dunn (SG), Efrain Burton (SF), Brad Daluz (PF), Michael Shin (C) Robert Patten, Jarrod Haskins, Paul Laflamme, Tommy Caudill, Nicholas Sheaffer | |
| 15:38 | Muskingum | Efrain Burton is called for a charge - foul #1 on Efrain Burton, team foul #2 | 45-38 |
| 15:15 | John Carroll | Scott Killian comes up short on the jumper from the left wing | 45-38 |
| 15:14 | Muskingum | Brad Daluz gets the rebound | 45-38 |
| 15:03 | Muskingum | Brad Daluz knocks in the 3pt jumper from the right corner set up by Efrain Burton | 45-41 |
| 14:34 | John Carroll | Robert Morrison is called for traveling | 45-41 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Wilmer Shepherd (PG) Wilson Pavon | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Robert Patten (PG) Benjamin Lane | |
| 14:09 | Muskingum | Brad Daluz's pass is intercepted by Wilmer Shepherd | 45-41 |
| 13:49 | John Carroll | John Hall drills a driving attempt from the right block on a nice dish by Wilmer Shepherd | 47-41 |
| 13:24 | Muskingum | Brad Daluz buries a fadeaway from the right side on a great pass from Robert Patten | 47-43 |
| 13:03 | John Carroll | Wilmer Shepherd knocks in the shot near the basket and the foul's on Robert Patten - foul #2 on Robert Patten, team foul #3 | 49-43 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Robert Whipple (SG), George Moore (SF), Willie Johns (PF), Christopher Holcomb (C) Scott Killian, Jeffery McKinstry, Robert Morrison, John Hall | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Jarrod Haskins (SG), Paul Laflamme (SF), Tommy Caudill (PF), Nicholas Sheaffer (C) Charlie Dunn, Efrain Burton, Brad Daluz, Michael Shin | |
| 13:03 | John Carroll | Wilmer Shepherd makes the free throw | 50-43 |
| 13:00 | Muskingum | Robert Patten double dribbles in the backcourt | 50-43 |
| 12:55 | John Carroll | George Moore clanks a jump hook from close range but he's fouled by Paul Laflamme - foul #1 on Paul Laflamme, team foul #4 | 50-43 |
| 12:55 | John Carroll | George Moore makes the 1st free throw | 51-43 |
| 12:55 | John Carroll | George Moore misses the 2nd free throw | 51-43 |
| 12:55 | Muskingum | The rebound goes to Tommy Caudill | 51-43 |
| 12:46 | Muskingum | Paul Laflamme is fouled on the floor by Wilmer Shepherd - foul #3 on Wilmer Shepherd, team foul #2 | 51-43 |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Benjamin Lane (PG) Robert Patten | |
| 12:22 | Muskingum | Paul Laflamme knocks in the shot in the paint on a great pass from Jarrod Haskins | 51-45 |
| 12:09 | John Carroll | Christopher Holcomb misses the turnaround from the right block but he's hacked by Nicholas Sheaffer - foul #2 on Nicholas Sheaffer, team foul #5 | 51-45 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Wilson Pavon (PG) Wilmer Shepherd | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Michael Shin (C) Nicholas Sheaffer | |
| 12:09 | John Carroll | Christopher Holcomb makes the 1st free throw | 52-45 |
| 12:09 | John Carroll | Christopher Holcomb makes the 2nd free throw | 53-45 |
| 11:53 | Muskingum | Tommy Caudill knocks in the turnaround from the right block set up by Jarrod Haskins and he's fouled by Willie Johns - foul #1 on Willie Johns, team foul #3 | 53-47 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Robert Morrison (PF) Willie Johns | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Robert Patten (PG) Benjamin Lane | |
| 11:53 | Muskingum | Tommy Caudill makes the free throw | 53-48 |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Wilson Pavon (fresh) 5 pts. SG - Robert Whipple (fresh) 3 pts. 2 ast. SF - George Moore (fresh) 3 pts. PF - Robert Morrison (fresh) 5 pts. 3 reb. 3 pf. C - Christopher Holcomb (fresh) 13 pts. 5 reb. 3 blk. | |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - Robert Patten (fresh) 7 pts. 2 ast. SG - Jarrod Haskins (fresh) 9 pts. 6 ast. SF - Paul Laflamme (fresh) 4 pts. 2 reb. PF - Tommy Caudill (fresh) 3 pts. C - Michael Shin (fresh) 8 pts. 5 reb. 3 pf. | |
| 11:34 | John Carroll | Robert Whipple hits a shot from the right wing | 55-48 |
| 11:16 | Muskingum | Tommy Caudill's pass is intercepted by Robert Morrison | 55-48 |
| 11:00 | John Carroll | A charge is called on Robert Whipple - foul #2 on Robert Whipple, team foul #4 | 55-48 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Wilmer Shepherd (PG) Wilson Pavon | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Brad Daluz (PF) Tommy Caudill | |
| 10:49 | Muskingum | Jarrod Haskins comes up short on the jumpshot from the free throw line but he's hacked by Wilmer Shepherd - foul #4 on Wilmer Shepherd, team foul #5 | 55-48 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Wilson Pavon (PG) Wilmer Shepherd | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Efrain Burton (SF), Nicholas Sheaffer (C) Paul Laflamme, Michael Shin | |
| 10:49 | Muskingum | Jarrod Haskins makes the 1st free throw | 55-49 |
| 10:49 | Muskingum | Jarrod Haskins makes the 2nd free throw | 55-50 |
| 10:26 | John Carroll | Robert Morrison misses long on a pull-up jumper from the right side | 55-50 |
| 10:25 | Muskingum | Brad Daluz grabs the board | 55-50 |
| 10:03 | Muskingum | Robert Patten loses the dribble to George Moore | 55-50 |
| 09:51 | John Carroll | Robert Morrison makes the 3 from the right wing | 58-50 |
| 09:35 | Muskingum | Nicholas Sheaffer misses short on a 3pt jumper from the left corner | 58-50 |
| 09:33 | Muskingum | Brad Daluz snags the offensive board | 58-50 |
| 09:18 | Muskingum | Efrain Burton misses short on a 3 from the left corner | 58-50 |
| 09:16 | John Carroll | Robert Morrison grabs the defensive rebound | 58-50 |
| 08:53 | John Carroll | Christopher Holcomb is hacked by Nicholas Sheaffer - foul #3 on Nicholas Sheaffer, team foul #6 | 58-50 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Jeffery McKinstry (PG), Scott Killian (SG), Gregory Wimberly (SF), Willie Johns (PF), John Hall (C) Wilson Pavon, Robert Whipple, George Moore, Robert Morrison, Christopher Holcomb | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Charlie Dunn (PG), Paul Laflamme (SF), Tommy Caudill (PF), Michael Shin (C) Robert Patten, Jarrod Haskins, Brad Daluz, Nicholas Sheaffer | |
| 08:37 | John Carroll | Gregory Wimberly loses the ball out of bounds | 58-50 |
| 08:19 | Muskingum | Tommy Caudill knocks in the turnaround from the baseline on a great pass from Efrain Burton | 58-52 |
| 07:52 | John Carroll | John Hall travels with the ball | 58-52 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Wilmer Shepherd (PG) Gregory Wimberly | |
| Subs | Muskingum | | |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Wilmer Shepherd (fresh) 9 pts. 6 ast. 2 stl. 4 pf. SG - Scott Killian (fresh) 2 ast. SF - Jeffery McKinstry (fresh) 2 reb. PF - Willie Johns (fresh) 11 pts. 3 reb. 2 stl. C - John Hall (fresh) 4 pts. | |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - Charlie Dunn (fresh) 3 pts. SG - Efrain Burton (fresh) 2 pts. 3 ast. SF - Paul Laflamme (fresh) 4 pts. 2 reb. PF - Tommy Caudill (fresh) 5 pts. C - Michael Shin (fresh) 8 pts. 5 reb. 3 pf. | |
| 07:32 | Muskingum | Efrain Burton is called for traveling | 58-52 |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Robert Patten (PG) Efrain Burton | |
| 07:09 | John Carroll | Scott Killian misses the shot from the left block | 58-52 |
| 07:07 | Muskingum | Tommy Caudill grabs the defensive rebound | 58-52 |
| 07:02 | Muskingum | Paul Laflamme comes up short on the shot near the basket but the foul's on Willie Johns - foul #2 on Willie Johns, team foul #6 | 58-52 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Robert Whipple (SG), Robert Morrison (PF), Christopher Holcomb (C) Jeffery McKinstry, Willie Johns, John Hall | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Jarrod Haskins (SG), Brad Daluz (PF) Charlie Dunn, Tommy Caudill | |
| 07:02 | Muskingum | Paul Laflamme makes the 1st free throw | 58-53 |
| 07:02 | Muskingum | Paul Laflamme misses the 2nd free throw | 58-53 |
| 07:02 | John Carroll | Christopher Holcomb snags the defensive board | 58-53 |
| 06:41 | John Carroll | Jarrod Haskins is called for the reach on Robert Whipple - foul #1 on Jarrod Haskins, team foul #7 | 58-53 |
| Subs | John Carroll | George Moore (SF) Scott Killian | |
| Subs | Muskingum | | |
| 06:41 | John Carroll | Robert Whipple makes the 1st free throw | 59-53 |
| 06:41 | John Carroll | Robert Whipple makes the 2nd free throw | 60-53 |
| 06:14 | Muskingum | Jarrod Haskins misses short on a 3 from the right corner | 60-53 |
| 06:12 | Muskingum | The offensive rebound goes to Brad Daluz | 60-53 |
| 05:54 | Muskingum | Jarrod Haskins connects on the 3pt shot from the left corner on a nice dish by Robert Patten | 60-56 |
| 05:39 | John Carroll | Robert Whipple buries a jumper from the left wing set up by Robert Morrison | 62-56 |
| 05:34 | Muskingum | Robert Patten buries a 3pt shot from the right corner set up by Brad Daluz | 62-59 |
| 05:10 | John Carroll | Christopher Holcomb double dribbles | 62-59 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Scott Killian (SG), Willie Johns (PF), John Hall (C) Robert Whipple, Robert Morrison, Christopher Holcomb | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Benjamin Lane (PG), Charlie Dunn (SG), Efrain Burton (SF), Tommy Caudill (PF), Nicholas Sheaffer (C) Robert Patten, Jarrod Haskins, Paul Laflamme, Brad Daluz, Michael Shin | |
| 04:44 | Muskingum | Tommy Caudill misses the lay-in | 62-59 |
| 04:43 | John Carroll | John Hall pulls down the rebound | 62-59 |
| 04:38 | John Carroll | Wilmer Shepherd is fouled on the floor by Tommy Caudill - foul #2 on Tommy Caudill, team foul #8 | 62-59 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Jeffery McKinstry (SF) George Moore | |
| Subs | Muskingum | | |
| 04:38 | John Carroll | Wilmer Shepherd makes the 1st free throw | 63-59 |
| 04:38 | John Carroll | Wilmer Shepherd makes the 2nd free throw | 64-59 |
| 04:17 | Muskingum | Tommy Caudill banks in the layup on a nice dish by Nicholas Sheaffer | 64-61 |
| 03:58 | John Carroll | Jeffery McKinstry connects on the 3pt jumper from the right wing on a great pass from Wilmer Shepherd | 67-61 |
| Lineup | John Carroll | PG - Wilmer Shepherd (fairly fresh) 11 pts. 7 ast. 2 stl. 4 pf. SG - Scott Killian (fresh) 2 ast. SF - Jeffery McKinstry (fresh) 3 pts. 2 reb. PF - Willie Johns (fresh) 11 pts. 3 reb. 2 stl. C - John Hall (fresh) 4 pts. 2 reb. | |
| Lineup | Muskingum | PG - Benjamin Lane (fresh) 3 pts. SG - Charlie Dunn (fresh) 3 pts. SF - Efrain Burton (fresh) 2 pts. 3 ast. PF - Tommy Caudill (fresh) 7 pts. 2 reb. C - Nicholas Sheaffer (fresh) 2 reb. 3 pf. | |
| 03:34 | Muskingum | Benjamin Lane is whistled for an offensive foul - foul #1 on Benjamin Lane, team foul #9 | 67-61 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Wilson Pavon (PG), Robert Whipple (SG), Robert Morrison (PF), Christopher Holcomb (C) Wilmer Shepherd, Scott Killian, Willie Johns, John Hall | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Robert Patten (PG), Jarrod Haskins (SG), Brad Daluz (PF), Michael Shin (C) Benjamin Lane, Charlie Dunn, Tommy Caudill, Nicholas Sheaffer | |
| 03:16 | John Carroll | Robert Whipple's pass is intercepted by Brad Daluz | 67-61 |
| 03:03 | Muskingum | Jarrod Haskins can't connect on a 3pt shot from the right wing | 67-61 |
| 03:01 | John Carroll | Wilson Pavon pulls down the rebound | 67-61 |
| 02:57 | John Carroll | John Carroll calls a full timeout (2 :30 3 full remaining) | 67-61 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Wilmer Shepherd (PG), George Moore (SF) Wilson Pavon, Jeffery McKinstry | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Paul Laflamme (SF) Efrain Burton | |
| 02:42 | John Carroll | George Moore is hacked by Brad Daluz - foul #2 on Brad Daluz, team foul #10 | 67-61 |
| 02:42 | John Carroll | George Moore makes the 1st free throw | 68-61 |
| 02:42 | John Carroll | George Moore makes the 2nd free throw | 69-61 |
| Game Plan | John Carroll | John Carroll is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (+1) | |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a flex offense (uptempo) and a man to man (-1) | |
| 02:22 | Muskingum | Michael Shin makes the 3 pointer from straight away on a nice dish by Jarrod Haskins | 69-64 |
| 02:02 | John Carroll | Robert Morrison scores on a jumpshot from the free throw line on a nice dish by Wilmer Shepherd | 71-64 |
| Game Plan | John Carroll | John Carroll is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (-1) | |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a flex offense and a man to man (-1) | |
| 01:38 | Muskingum | Robert Patten hits the front of the rim on the 3 pointer from straight away | 71-64 |
| 01:36 | Muskingum | Michael Shin can't tip it in | 71-64 |
| 01:35 | Muskingum | Paul Laflamme grabs the offensive rebound | 71-64 |
| 01:15 | Muskingum | Paul Laflamme buries a jumper in the lane on a nice dish by Robert Patten | 71-66 |
| 01:01 | John Carroll | Robert Morrison can't connect on a 3pt jumper from straight away | 71-66 |
| 01:00 | Muskingum | Michael Shin grabs the defensive rebound | 71-66 |
| Game Plan | John Carroll | John Carroll is playing a triangle offense and a man to man (-1) | |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a flex offense (uptempo) and a man to man (-1) | |
| 00:47 | Muskingum | Christopher Holcomb denies the turnaround by Michael Shin | 71-66 |
| 00:46 | John Carroll | Wilmer Shepherd gets the rebound | 71-66 |
| Game Plan | John Carroll | John Carroll is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (-1) | |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a flex offense (uptempo) and intentionally fouling (-1) | |
| 00:44 | John Carroll | Robert Patten is called for the reach on Wilmer Shepherd in the backcourt - foul #3 on Robert Patten, team foul #11 | 71-66 |
| 00:44 | John Carroll | Wilmer Shepherd misses the 1st free throw | 71-66 |
| 00:44 | John Carroll | Wilmer Shepherd makes the 2nd free throw | 72-66 |
| Game Plan | John Carroll | John Carroll is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (-1) | |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a quick shot offense (quick shot) and intentionally fouling (-1) | |
| 00:37 | Muskingum | Michael Shin misses long on a 3 from the right corner | 72-66 |
| 00:36 | Muskingum | Brad Daluz snags the offensive board | 72-66 |
| 00:32 | Muskingum | Robert Patten drills a 3 pointer from the right corner | 72-69 |
| 00:31 | John Carroll | Robert Morrison is hacked by Jarrod Haskins in the backcourt - foul #2 on Jarrod Haskins, team foul #12 | 72-69 |
| Subs | John Carroll | Wilson Pavon (PG) Wilmer Shepherd | |
| Subs | Muskingum | | |
| 00:31 | John Carroll | Robert Morrison makes the 1st free throw | 73-69 |
| 00:31 | John Carroll | Robert Morrison makes the 2nd free throw | 74-69 |
| 00:26 | Muskingum | Jarrod Haskins makes the pull-up jumper from the left wing set up by Brad Daluz | 74-71 |
| 00:24 | John Carroll | Robert Patten is called for the reach on Robert Morrison in the backcourt - foul #4 on Robert Patten, team foul #13 | 74-71 |
| 00:24 | John Carroll | Robert Morrison makes the 1st free throw | 75-71 |
| 00:24 | John Carroll | Robert Morrison misses the 2nd free throw | 75-71 |
| 00:24 | Muskingum | Brad Daluz pulls down the rebound | 75-71 |
| 00:18 | Muskingum | Jarrod Haskins loses the ball out of bounds | 75-71 |
| 00:17 | John Carroll | Robert Patten is called for the reach on Wilson Pavon in the backcourt - foul #5 on Robert Patten, team foul #14 | 75-71 |
| Subs | John Carroll | | |
| Subs | Muskingum | Charlie Dunn (PG) Robert Patten | |
| 00:17 | John Carroll | Wilson Pavon misses the 1st free throw | 75-71 |
| 00:17 | John Carroll | Wilson Pavon makes the 2nd free throw | 76-71 |
| 00:11 | Muskingum | Charlie Dunn misses short on a 3 from the right corner | 76-71 |
| 00:10 | John Carroll | Christopher Holcomb grabs the board | 76-71 |
| 00:07 | John Carroll | Christopher Holcomb is hacked by Jarrod Haskins in the backcourt - foul #3 on Jarrod Haskins, team foul #15 | 76-71 |
| 00:07 | John Carroll | Christopher Holcomb misses the 1st free throw | 76-71 |
| 00:07 | John Carroll | Christopher Holcomb makes the 2nd free throw | 77-71 |
| 00:02 | Muskingum | Robert Morrison steals it from Charlie Dunn | 77-71 |
| Game Plan | John Carroll | John Carroll is playing a spread offense (hold ball) and a man to man (-1) | |
| Game Plan | Muskingum | Muskingum is playing a quick shot offense (quick shot) and a man to man (-1) | |
| 00:00 | John Carroll | Robert Morrison runs out the clock | 77-71 |