| Pos | Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|---|
| SG | 87-88 Michael Jordan* | Michael and the Jordanaires | 42 |
| SG | 05-06 Kobe Bryant* | Black Hole Sun | 40 |
| SF | 12-13 Kevin Durant* | Slanted and Enchanted (W1) | 38 |
| PF | 87-88 Charles Barkley* | THE FIGHTING RED FORMANS | 36 |
| C | 93-94 Hakeem Olajuwon* | Caterpillar | 40 |
| SG | 16-17 James Harden | BLUE DOG | 35 |
| PG | 98-99 Jason Kidd | Black Hole Sun | 34 |
| SF | 82-83 Larry Bird | Black Hole Sun | 36 |
| SF | 80-81 Julius Erving | The Godfather Part II | 35 |
| C | 94-95 David Robinson | Endeavor | 36 |
| C | 68-69 Willis Reed | Hawaii 1-0 | 35 |
| PG | 65-66 Oscar Robertson | Caterpillar | 34 |
| * - Starter Players must have 1200 minutes played to qualify. | |||
| Pos | Name | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|---|
| PG | 71-72 Walt Frazier* | Ashland Mustangs | 33 |
| PG | 96-97 Gary Payton* | Y'all Need Jesus I | 33 |
| SF | 13-14 LeBron James* | Heimdallr | 42 |
| PF | 96-97 Karl Malone* | Y'all Need Jesus I | 41 |
| C | 65-66 Wilt Chamberlain* | House of NO EVIL | 53 |
| PG | 11-12 Chris Paul | ATLiens | 32 |
| SG | 00-01 Ray Allen | Y'all Need Jesus I | 30 |
| PF | 05-06 Kevin Garnett | Copperhead | 39 |
| PF | 16-17 Anthony Davis | Sir Bobby | 38 |
| C | 93-94 Shaquille O'Neal | The House That Jordan Built | 43 |
| C | 72-73 Kareem Abdul-Jabbar | BASEketball | 40 |
| C | 71-72 Artis Gilmore | Sir Bobby | 39 |
| * - Starter Players must have 1200 minutes played to qualify. | |||