WhatIfSports is the Internet's foremost authority on simulation for baseball, football, hockey, basketball & college sports.

Click to Learn More about WhatIfSports!

1886 New York Metropolitans

American Association
Record: 53 - 82

View All MLB Seasons

Learn more about this team at

SimLeague Baseball lets you put Ruth, Ichiro & Mays in the same outfield to square off against Koufax and Pedro!

Click to Try SimLeague Baseball for Free!

Positional Players from the 1886 New York Metropolitans

Bill HolbertCF482133501384146.205.232.251D+/A+/A+$1.62M
Charlie ReipschlagerCF6529149025212199.211.244.280D/A/B-$1.54M
Dave Orr1BF13671219379193165217.338.363.527B-/A-$7.21M
Tom Forster2BF67329491203392020.195.263.235D/D$1.12M
John Meister2BF4522844221351164.237.253.339D/D$909K
Elmer Foster2BF35161230716397.184.239.200D-/A+$453K
Frank Hankinson3BF13668612626366104649.241.306.299D+/A+$3.44M
Candy NelsonSSF1095759302389143564.225.332.252D/C+$2.56M
Tom McLaughlinSSF743333401627131526.136.220.156C-/B$1.12M
Chief RosemanOFF1347101275539064824.227.269.324D/C$3.07M
Steve BradyOFF12460511203956164035.240.298.279D/C+$2.51M
Steve BehelOFF592974601732161822.205.279.246D/C-$1.19M
Jim DonahueOFF4923937091411510.199.251.199D-/C+/A-$707K

Pitchers from the 1886 New York Metropolitans

Ed CushmanSF38391.00373.120.2221.161.6874.622.740.166$10.79M
Jack LynchSF51520.00503.950.2721.391.6644.012.410.208$10.37M
Al MaysSF41421.00413.390.2391.341.1644.193.600.180$9.27M
John ShafferSF883.0081.960.1621.001.2414.703.780.000$3.41M

The 1886 New York Metropolitans roster is above. All columns may be sorted by clicking the column name. Clicking on an individual player will display the player's career statistics including his time with the 1886 New York Metropolitans.

For information regarding statistical abbreviations, please View the Statistics Legend

Email Page to a Friend 

New [Terms of Use] [Customer Support] New [Privacy Statement]

1999-2018 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved.

WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.