Posted by phoenix01 on 11/3/2010 2:13:00 PM (view original):
That's a little better.

When you say "C or worse", are you saying C or C- only?  No C+?

So, when you say they can have one C and one B, that means one has to be C, C-, D+, D, D- and the other can't be B+, A-, A, A+?  Right?

this is correct

Posted by wylie715 on 11/3/2010 2:19:00 PM (view original):

Posted by phoenix01 on 11/3/2010 2:13:00 PM (view original):
That's a little better.

When you say "C or worse", are you saying C or C- only?  No C+?

So, when you say they can have one C and one B, that means one has to be C, C-, D+, D, D- and the other can't be B+, A-, A, A+?  Right?

this is correct

In that case, Arky Vaughn is not eligible, he has a C+.

Posted by wylie715 on 11/3/2010 2:10:00 PM (view original):
okay...the pickings for the powerball teams are a bit slim at 2B, SS, and C, and I'm willing to give a little flexibility for those positions, but I won't just do away with the defensive requirements...that's a big part of the league theme.  Here's what I would suggest: for those positions, and only those positions, the powerball teams can select a player with at least one of the ratings being a C (or in the catcher's case, 2 of the ratings)  It doesn't matter whether the range of the glove is the C but one must be a C ..and the other rating can not be any better than a B  No A or A-.  That gives you a little more flexibilty while not really ruining the theme idea.  In the conncept of fairness, the small ball teams can have that same option (at the same 3 positions) In other words at 2B, SS and C you can select a guy with one of the 2 defensive ratings that is worse than a B (but no worse than a C) (or 2 of the 3 at the C position.

If anyone has a real problem with this, let me know..

And phoenix01, I also show the 1935 Arky Vaughn as being eligible at SS

Personally, I vote let's go one step further and include C+ as best in one attribute and B+ as best in the other.

It would just be nice to have a choice regarding your players, not be stuck with what the rest of the league is using as well.

I can live with that as long as everyone else can

You know what, F it, just leave it as it is.  Changing it that little doesn't really add that many players to choose from.  Let's just keep it as is.

Especially since others have probably already chosen their teams.....although I doubt they have (or at least not correctly) if I'm the first to complain of the limited choices.

Your right Phoenix, I will need to make adjustments to my team

ATTENTION: THERE WILL BE NO CHANGES TO THE ORIGINAL LEAGUE REQUIREMENTS!!!

Please guys, verify your team carefully as you're picking them.  Keep an eye on SB's, they're easily forgotten.

using the filters can be a good thing

How do you limit SB to <10?  

I'm honestly asking, this is only my second league.

I'm starting to verify rosters...first roster verified is skidmark.

If I find errors on your roster I'll sitemail you

Posted by wylie715 on 11/5/2010 1:27:00 AM (view original):
sign ups:
smallball                                                    powerball                               undecided
wylie715                                                     skidmark                                
speedfreak                                                stevenfish                               
Heavy_PRB                                               mikemundt                              
finn2030                                                     teveritt
northof49                                                    deathinahole                                                   
llcoach                                                        phoenix01                                                  
Turn H2O-Bops                                          auggieward
dumpster                                                   msheaf1

if your name is underlined, your roster has been verified.  if your name is in bold, your team has been entered into the league.

As of right now, 8 teams entered, 1 roster verified

11/4/10

Posted by wylie715 on 11/6/2010 2:21:00 AM (view original):
sign ups:
smallball                                                    powerball                               undecided
wylie715                                                     skidmark                                
speedfreak                                                stevenfish                               
Heavy_PRB                                               mikemundt                              
finn2030                                                     teveritt
northof49                                                    deathinahole                                                   
llcoach                                                        phoenix01                                                  
Turn H2O-Bops                                          auggieward
dumpster                                                   msheaf1

if your name is underlined, your roster has been verified.  if your name is in bold, your team has been entered into the league.

As of right now, 8 teams entered, 3 roster verified

2 more rosters verified

I'm working to get mine fixed.