70mil – Five Man Acoustical Jam
I’m surprised to see the number of owners who felt that power was too expensive and/or not the way to go with this theme. I know that speed is the typical answer to a low-cap league so I started with Bob Boone ’82 at catcher, which will pretty much put the brakes on any speed teams I run into. Then I started looking at the pitchers in this era who were good value and I kept finding guys who kept the ball in the park very well. So I’ve got 5 SPs with HR/9 under 0.40 and HR/9+ over 250 – basically cheaper versions of my favorite 5-man rotation guy, ’81 Righetti, who I couldn’t afford here. (Magrane, Alejandro Pena, Tim Hudson, Lary Sorenson, Nabholz) I drafted 1291 “real” IP plus a mop-up guy, which might be a few too many innings.
On offense, I went with higher OAV guys and kept the walks to a minimum. Then I stuck the team in Tiger Stadium to keep the hits down. On offense I did add some speed (Vince Coleman, Kirk Gibson, Jerry Mumphrey) but also a lot of power in Gibson, Wallach, Greg Walker and Lou Whitaker. Anyone bringing HR-prone pitchers to my park will feel the pain. My fielders are all low-range guys so we won’t turn many DPs, but again, I figured that we’d see a lot of speed teams and it wouldn’t matter if we had A+ range all around. Typically for a 70mil team I have a 6-man bullpen and 3 platoons on offense to maximize the roster spots I am using.
Projection: 85 wins
80mil – Raines Maddux Inc
Eppa Rixey was the first guy I thought of, and apparently I wasn’t alone. I wanted to pair him with a power hitter since his HR/9+ numbers were so good, and I couldn’t find one. I tried Griffey Jr, Al Kaline, and Rocky Colavito with no success. I also thought of Red Lucas and Greg Maddux. I looked at pairing some speed guys with Maddux (Raines, Rickey, Amos Otis, Willie Wilson) and Raines was the only guy I really liked.
I still couldn’t get over Rixey so I went back to try again, pairing him with Mike Cameron and Dale Murphy, but I didn’t like those either. I couldn’t get enough defense behind Rixey who needed the gloves behind him so I went back to Maddux/Raines. The Maddux seasons I could afford were some of the cheaper ones (2000, 2001, 1991, 1988) so I needed a pitchers’ park. Playing in Olympic Stadium I wanted other guys who could take a walk and run a bit so I added Lu Blue and Delino Deshields. I skimped on infield range again but did buy a good catcher arm in Clint Courtney (A rated). The Raines/Rickey teams will still give him a little trouble but it shouldn’t be awful.
Projection: 82 wins
90mil – 1944 Philly Blue Jays + 6
In last season’s WISC, I spent forever on this theme, building about 15 teams. I didn’t really have a strong preference for how many players I wanted to add – I looked at great teams with 1 add, so-so teams in the middle, and awful teams to add 6 players. I didn’t think to do any research into teams that underperformed their real life records, or I might have liked the ’99 Royals too.
I was surprised to see that two of the teams I really liked but didn’t choose last year were still available – the 97 Braves and the 44 Phillies (who were known as the Blue Jays that season). There were also some new teams available that I liked – the 2009 Cards and the 2009 Braves both looked really interesting (St. Louis could use Holliday’s full season and add an ace, a CF and SS, Atlanta could add 2 aces and a better 3B). I would have gone with the ’09 Cards until I discovered they actually only get 2 additions. Oops!
I also still liked the ’72 Cubs from last season but their pitchers were a bit HR-prone for Wrigley and they didn’t have a good CF, and the ’97 Braves, who I loved but weren’t quite expensive enough. So I strongly considered the 1909 Pirates with their great pitching, but they needed a 1B most of all and there wasn’t anyone great to add. I would have added Eddie Collins out of position (or maybe an outfielder) but I decided to keep looking. I checked the ’86 Royals, the 1907 Cubs, and the 2008 Padres.
Ultimately I was just too curious about my runner-up team from last year so I decided to go with the 44 Jays. I added Lou Boudreau at catcher and a so-so Vern Stephens at SS, but it was better than any combination of available catchers and Boudreau at SS. I liked the Jays because they had about 700 usable innings and some good hitters (Buster Adams in CF, Ron Northey in LF, Tony Lupien at 1B). I looked at a lot of 1944 teams because there were 2 huge IP pitchers to add to any team (Dizzy Trout 371ip/1.19whip and Hal Newhouser 329ip/1.17whip). Plus I get to add one of my sim favorites – Snuffy Stirnweiss! Finally I added Ken Keltner (good glove, decent bat) as my 6th guy. The bullpen isn’t great other than closer Andy Karl but I have almost 1200 innings in my rotation, so I might run a 3-man rotation and shift Bill Lee to the bullpen at some point.
Projection: 88 wins
100mil – Semi-Twisted 2004 Yankees
This actually seemed like an easy theme at first. I would just find a team that was already historically great and make them a bit better. I tried a ton of Ruth-era Yankee teams (obviously 1927, also 1932 and 33 and then 1926). 1926 was the best of the bunch with Garland Braxton but I couldn’t make it work – either Gehrig was too expensive or too cheap.
I looked at the ’72 and ’75 Reds but their pitchers were too homer-prone and never really worked right even when I had them twisted. So I looked at one of my all-time favorites, the 2001 Mariners. They topped out at around 93mil and the rotation wasn’t great. I looked at the ’97 Braves, figuring that I wasn’t using them for the 90mil league. They didn’t have a good long reliever and the ‘pen was only pretty good. The first draft was around 102mil and the pitching was awesome. They were a frontrunner for a long time. So you’ll notice now that I passed on the ’97 Braves for BOTH of these themes. That might come back to haunt me.
Like all the people using the ’40 Yankees I wanted to try to find a Spud Chandler team as he is my 2nd favorite sim pitcher after Maddux95. So I tried the 46 Yankees but nothing really worked. I never thought to go back to 1940 though I did look at ’41 and ’43. Then I moved on to the 2005 Yankees and I also liked them a lot, but Jeter’s range and having to use Pavano as my SP4 scared me. They did have a great bullpen and a balanced offense and were a strong contender anyway.
After that I looked at the 1909 Pirates (infield not good enough), 1926 Cards (Hornsby – but the pitching wasn’t good enough) and the ’28 As. The ’28 As were a better version of what I was looking at for the 26 Cards with a bunch of mashers, but they only had 8 pitchers and one solid SP in Grove.
Then I looked at the ’49 Red Sox, I really liked them but all of their pitchers were either in the 250-300 IP range or the 100-150 IP range, I wasn’t sure I could manage the staff well enough. I checked the ’70 Cards which would have given me 2 awesome aces in Gibby ’68 and Carlton ’72 but they also had a weird IP mix and their up-the-middle guys were bad. I tried the ’69 Cards but the offense wasn’t good enough to spend all the money.
After 13 teams I stopped and did a little ranking, rating each team 1-13 on a few categories (AVG#, OBP#, SLG#, fielding, range, WHIP, HR/9+, HR/9, OAV#, BB/9#, catchers arm) and seeing who came out the best. The 2005 Yankees came out on top with the ’27 Yankees in second and the 97 Braves/28 As in 3rd.
Still searching, I looked at the ’46 Indians and ’51 Yankees but didn’t see anything I liked. Before I entered the 2005 Yankees I decided to look at the 2004 version. They didn’t have an ace in Johnson but they also didn’t have a crappy #4 in Pavano. They also had much better HR/9+ numbers, mostly for their relievers. So with a rotation of Mussina, Vazquez, Brown and Loaiza, this is the team I went with. It will be interesting to see how a rotation of 4 very similar righties fares. They have 11 pitchers and a killer bullpen. They have a great Giambi season but the compromise is a Homer Bush/Miguel Cairo platoon at 2B. I should note, I have had some 21st century Yankee twist teams in FK6 leagues and they haven’t done well. So why did I pick this team?
Projection: 91 wins
120mil – Fire Joe Morgan
I didn’t spend a lot of time on this team, partly because I was the commissioner for my league and needed to get them in. But really, there wasn’t a lot to think about … you could either go for a +HR park and try to mash or go for a –HR park and try to steal. No matter what I did I was going to have ptichers with good HR/9+ numbers and low HR/9 numbers in order to survive my road games. I figured that it was not impossible to prevent steals if I focused on keeping runners off base and getting the best catcher I could, so I went for a Piazza season (98) that was close to the top of the range of CS% guys available at 26.3%. I also wanted to focus on high SB success rates because in the research I’ve done, you can’t necessarily get guys with horrible SB/SBA rates to run successfully against bad catchers (now against unrated catchers, that’s a different story).
So I started out by building a team with ridiculously good pitching (1442ip, 0.86whip) but then the offense was just too ugly to compete. So I built a ridiculously good offensive team (315/423/511) but the pitching wasn’t really good enough. Plus the first version had Pedro99 who I’m not sure if I trust any more. So I ended up with a compromise of both. I’ve got Tiant, Pedro, Koufax and Randy Johnson all with OAV under .200 and BB# under 2.70. I’ve got a stacked bullpen. And I have a lot of guys with great SB success rates: Raines 90/104, Amos Otis 52/60, Bonds 40/47, Joe Morgan 58/70, and Barry Larkin 57/63. I also grabbed George Gore 1885 to DH, figuring he should reach on a lot of errors and steal against D- catchers (81sb/38cs).
Projection: 93 wins
140mil – Decades of Decadence
This was another seemingly easy theme that kind of drove me nuts. I am not sure I’ve ever played in a 140mil non-DH league before, so that was a little strange. I knew I’d be building around a few guys – Maddux95, Hughie Jennings to get something out of the 1890s, and Ruth. I figured I’d probably have Mays or Mantle from the 50s and maybe Williams from the 40s, plus Johnson from the teens and another guy from the aughts. I tried to build the best pitching staff I could but I was having a hard time building a good 3-man rotation with Johnson12, Joss08 and someone else. I tried to go 1/2/3a/3b with Johnson, 3-Finger Brown and Maddux95/Pedro00 but it seemed to be a little too much pitching. So ultimately I went with a 4-man rotation using Matty09, Dutch Leonard, Maddux95 and Pedro00. I’ve got the ever-reliable Howie Pollet as my long man and Joey Devine as my favorite closer.
After that I just had to fill in the hitters with the decades I had left. It was hard finding someone I wanted from the 30s but I ended up with a catcher platoon of Dickey and Brucker. I had Mantle from the 50s, Ruth26 and a platoon of Billy Hamilton and Jerry Mumphrey for my outfield. I used a lesser Jennings season at SS and Joe Morgan at 2B. Yes, my WISC fate is squarely in the hands of Joe Morgan, who I used on both my high-cap teams. I’m sure that will end well.
I initially planned to use my 1880s slot on RP Bill George but I needed a 1B and leadoff hitter so I went with Roger Connor instead. This team has a ton of great OBP guys, 3 platoons and 8 relievers. I only drafted 1455 IP which I worry won’t be enough, and I’ll be a bit short on PAs. Hopefully it will all work itself out – I stuck the team in Colt Stadium to minimize the damage.
Projection: 84 wins