hoopsrus,
let me see if I can help clarify. I'll use my team as an example since I'm filled up now.
5. Giter_Dunn - Lefty Gomez, Juan Marichial, Steve Carlton, David Wells, Burt Hooten
Round 1: I chose Gomez, Marichal, Carlton, Sutton and Garcia -> Gomez, Marichal and Carlton weren't picked by any else so they are mine exclusively
Round 2: I chose Burt Hooten and David Wells -> neither were picked so they are mine exclusively
If someone else had chosen David Wells in round 2, then I'd need to submit a name for round 3.
I see you have Hideo Nomo, Cole Hamels and C.C. Sabathia. Not sure if you picked them in round 1 or 2, but you need to submit 2 names (except for any names on the list 4 posts previous). To avoid picking duplicate starters, consider finding some top notch hitting you really like and back in a starter teammate you can work with.
Hope this helps some.