Survivor III *** Votes Read! Topic

That's correct tropicana. Error is fixed.
8/15/2010 9:00 PM
nfet is back & we're going to try to hook up today sometime.  Sitemailed acketyack as well...
I'll be available today from 3pm - 2am (EST) so hopefully we can get 'em in.
8/16/2010 5:02 AM
Ack's Cards defeated Toddleduc's Brewers 4-1
8/16/2010 12:44 PM
Posted by acketyack on 8/12/2010 12:51:00 PM (view original):
3-0 Ack beats Eman
Carpenter throws a one-hitter to defeat Carpenter
Looks like acketyack started Carpenter in both games. Teams must use two different starters in their two games. If the game vs. toddleduc can be replayed today, please do so using a different starter. If it can't be played today, it will be considered a forfeit.
8/16/2010 1:46 PM
Posted by joshkvt on 8/11/2010 12:18:00 AM (view original):

After two tribes have battled it out in challenges that emphasized the coasts, Survivor moves to the three-division era and into America’s heartland. As baseball did in 1994 with its alignment, our two tribes will be split into three. To reset the tribes, I used the Live ranking for the 15 remaining players. The top-ranked Live player, The Taint, was assigned to the first tribe. #2-ranked toddleduc went to tribe 2, #3-ranked eman7400 to tribe 3, #4 steveymer to tribe 1, and so on.

Each tribe will pick a league and a season, and will use five Central Division teams with one tribe member using the same team in two games, once against each of the other two tribes, for a total of 10 games per tribe. The team with the worse real-life record will play at home in each game. You must use a different starting pitcher in each of your two games. For example, if Tribe 1 picks the 2008 AL, one player would use the Indians twice, one would use the Tigers twice, etc.

Each tribe’s captain will be the player with the lowest Live ranking. The captains will send me the year and league you want to use, and a list of which player will use which team. If more than one tribe selects the same year/league, the first to submit it gets that division and the other(s) will have to repick.

Two of the three tribes will send someone home after the challenge, but one player from each losing tribe will receive immunity based on the best record in his two games, with runs-differential as a tiebreaker (runs allowed as a second tiebreaker, runs allowed at home as the third if needed, and then a coin flip if needed).

TRIBE 1
The Taint
steveymer
acketyack
dubrightway
kneeneighbor (captain)

TRIBE 2
toddleduc
FishNasty
tropicana
staindman
aljon1331 (captain)

TRIBE 3
eman7400
BastanRedsox
soxyanks12
deltagorfers
nfet (captain)

DEADLINES:
Team selections must be sent to me by midnight Tuesday. If the deadline is missed, I will use random.org to choose a league/division. If the captain has not submitted a list by Tuesday at 8 p.m. EST, another player from the tribe may submit the list.
Games must be played by midnight Tuesday (8/17).

If anything in the challenge is confusing, ask before submitting your choice.

Rules as originally posted
8/16/2010 1:56 PM
As promised, players on the winning tribe have been sent bonuses for their win. Here they are:

Toddleduc: You may expand the eligible seasons in picking a team by 3 years. For example, if the challenge requires a National League team from the 1980s, you could pick a team from 1977-1992.
FishNasty: You can demand an intentional walk once in one game (Pause the game and wait for acknowledgment from your opponent).
tropicana: You can ask me (and get a truthful answer) one time whether a specific player has an immunity idol or whether a specific idol has been found by anyone.
staindman: You may have the opposing pitcher ejected one time in the 7th or 8th inning.
aljon1331: One SP may be used twice by your tribe in a challenge that otherwise disallows it. To use this bonus, it must be announced to me before the matchups are posted.

Only one bonus may be used against each tribe in a given challenge. Once a bonus has been used in a series, no other bonus may be used in that series.

 

8/16/2010 9:54 PM (edited)
Oooooh!  Bonuses!  Nice!
8/16/2010 3:06 PM
Ack's Cards (with Mulder) beat Todd's Brewers (with Sabathia) 3-2

Izzy gets the save
8/16/2010 3:20 PM

Confirmed on the above.  Good Games ack !  Well done...

nfet & I will try to play at 9pm (EST)

2008 Ben Sheets vs. TBD

 

8/16/2010 3:22 PM

 CHALLENGE #4

DIVISION/TEAM SELECTIONS
TRIBE 1 (kneeneighbor)
2005 National League
.488 Cubs: The Taint (0-2)
.549 Astros: steveymer (1-1)
.617 Cardinals: acketyack (2-0)
.500 Brewers: dubrightway (1-1)
.451 Reds: kneeneighbor (0-2)

TRIBE 2 (aljon1331)
2008 National League
.414 Pirates: tropicana (1-1)
.602 Cubs: aljon1331 (2-0)
.534 Astros: FishNasty (2-0)
.556 Brewers: toddleduc (1-1)
.531 Cardinals: staindman (1-1)

TRIBE 3 (nfet)
2004 National League
.416 Brewers: BastanRedsox (0-2)
.648 Cardinals: eman7400 (1-1)
.447 Pirates: nfet (1-1)
.568 Astros: deltagorfers (1-1)
.549 Cubs: soxyanks12 (1-1)

Tribe 1 (’05 NL) vs Tribe 2 (’08 NL)
steveymer (T1 Astros-Pettite) at tropicana (T2 Pirates-Maholm) TRIBE 1 WINS 6-1
FishNasty (T2 Astros) at The Taint (T1 Cubs) TRIBE 2 WINS 13-4
aljon1331 (T2 Cubs-Dempster) at dubrightway (T1 Brewers-Sheets) TRIBE 2 WINS, 6-3
staindman (T2 Cardinals-Lohse) at kneeneighbor (T1 Reds) TRIBE 2 WINS 12-2
acketyack (T1 Cardinals-Mulder) at toddleduc (T2 Brewers-Sabathia) TRIBE 1 WINS 3-2

Tribe 2 (’08 NL) vs Tribe 3 (’04 NL)
toddleduc (T2 Brewers) at nfet (T3 Pirates)
deltagorfers (T3 Astros-Oswalt) at tropicana (T2 Pirates-Karstens) TRIBE 2 WINS 9-5
aljon1331 (T2 Cubs-Harden) at BastanRedsox (T3 Brewers-Sheet) TRIBE 2 WINS 7-1
eman7400 (T3 Cardinals-Morris) at staindman (T2 Cardinals-Wainright) TRIBE 3 WINS 8-6
soxyanks12 (T3 Cubs-Zambrano) at FishNasty (T2 Astros-Rodriguez) TRIBE 2 WINS 6-1

Tribe 3 (’04 NL) vs Tribe 1 (’05 NL)
steveymer (T1 Astros) at soxyanks12 (T3 Cubs)* TRIBE 3 WINS, 4-3
deltagorfers (T3 Astros-Clemens) at The Taint (T1 Cubs-Zambrano), TRIBE 3 WINS, 5-3
dubrightway (T1 Brewers-Davis) at BastanRedsox (T3 Brewers-Davis) TRIBE 1 WINS, 9-6
kneeneighbor (T1 Reds-Claussen) at nfet (T3 Pirates-Perez) TRIBE 3 WINS, 7-2
eman7400 (T3 Cardinals-Carpenter) at acketyack (T1 Cardinals-Carpenter) TRIBE 1 WINS, 3-0
   * home field based on lower finish in division standings

                    W     L
TRIBE 2     7     3
TRIBE 3     4     6
TRIBE 1     4     6

8/17/2010 10:25 PM (edited)
I lost to toddleduc 4-1
8/16/2010 9:13 PM
Good Game nfet !

todd & the '08 Brewers (Sheets) over nfet & the '04 Pirates (Benson)   4-1.

Sheets goes 8 and K's 9

8/16/2010 9:14 PM
Looks like nfet holds immunity then for tribe 3. Ackety in tribe 1.
8/16/2010 9:42 PM
Yes, nfet and acketyack have immujnity. Tribe 1 and Tribe 3 members need to send me a vote to send someone home. You may not vote for nfet or acketyack. Votes must be received by midnight Tuesday. In case of a tie in either tribe, those tied will play a one-game tiebreaker challenge.

If anyone on Tribe 1 or 3 has an immunity idol and wants to play it, do so when sending in your vote. If an idol is played before the votes are read, votes for that person will not count.
8/16/2010 10:39 PM (edited)
Josh - Are tribe two's prizes good for any time? Like my intentional walk, can I hold it for as long as I am in the game? Can I give it to someone else for whatever reason should I choose? Just curious, thanks
8/16/2010 10:49 PM
◂ Prev 1...26|27|28|29|30...64 Next ▸
Survivor III *** Votes Read! Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.