I am almost finished with a team I just created, but I am debating on one thing, here is my two lineups and I am deciding which one to go with. The lineups are the same except with the catcher position and the addition/subtraction a few pitchers.
LINE-UP A
1) 1980 Miguel Dilone - OF
2) 1900 John McGraw - 3B
3) 1898 Billy Hamilton - OF
4) 2000 David Segui - 1B
5) 1938 Earle Brucker/ 1936 Billy Sullivan - C
6) 1999 Omar Vizquel -SS
7) 1992 Bip Roberts -2B
8) Pitcher
9) 1981 Tim Raines -OF
Pitchers---
'08 Addie Joss, '09 Jack Pfiester, '18 Fred Toney, '19 Art Nehf, '25 Elmer Steele, '09 Larry Pape, '15 Cy Falkenberg, '04 Chick Robitaille, '06 Dennys Reyes, '88 Frank Gilmore
LINE-UP B
1) 1980 Miguel Dilone - OF
2) 1900 John McGraw - 3B
3) 1898 Billy Hamilton - OF
4) 2000 David Segui - 1B
5) 1999 Omar Vizquel - SS
6) 1992 Bip Roberts - 2B
7) 1981 Tim Raines - OF
8) Pitcher
9) 1892 Tom Daly - C
Pitchers---
All the same except with the addition of '02 Bill Bernhard, '41 Johnny Allen and the subtraction of '88 Frank Gilmore and '07 Jack Pfiester.
I am having a hard time deciding whether to go with a big upgrade in my catchers hitting and losing pitching or keeping a good value catcher and having solid pitching all the way around. Basically I would just like input on whether to go with two very good hitting catchers and losing '02 Bernhard and '41 Allen, or stick with '92 Tom Daly and have all 1,250-1,300 IP be quality IP.
My home field would be Target Field. I have created my entire team and I am just looking for some input on which decision would be a better way to go. I am not trying to have someone else create my team for me. This is my last team for a while and I have put a lot of thought in it. Please no posts ridiculing me if you think this post is not suitable for the sim forum. I am just looking for a little help with this decision. Thanks for all your input.