Posted by vandydave on 2/1/2011 10:38:00 AM (view original):
entertaining bot stove, and captured many of my basic HOF sentiments pretty well (not including the worn-out pedophile jokes, I did like the christmas tree one though). Grieve was a very good player for a time period based upon the basic parameters of HBD, glitchy or not. i'd gladly vote Grieve into the postseason HOF or the Tandem HOF. but based upon getting 5 votes a season, i cant make him one of my 5 vote getters this season based upon the other candidates out there.
Velandia is the only shoo-in to me, but I think Grieve has supporting evidence to suggest that he belongs there just as much as any other candidate, if not more.
And there's no such thing as a postseason Hall of Fame because postseason should play just as big an impact as regular season. Calling it the regular season Hall of Fame is stupid. Real HoF voters always consider postseason performance when voting. I don't see why someone should ignore it just because the stats immediately in front of them do.