Would you support a black ink/grey ink system for entry into the Hall of Fame I have seen some places? Every time you lead the league in a relevant category that is worth some amount of "points", if you are in the top 10 that is worth significantly few points, but is worth something. MVP's, GG's, SS's, All-Star Games, Cy Young, and ROY each have their own point value. In the end you either earn a certain number of points or not.
Does the LPGA (of all things?!) have the best HOF criteria in RL sports? Achieve 35 you are in, don't and you not. Simple, measurable, hard to achieve, perfect IMO.