My Nazareth team just won the National title in the Rupp world. After playing with a normal team for about 30 seasons as chapelhillne, I decided that it would be fun to create a profile with Billy Graham as the coach. He would coach at Nazareth (Jesus' birthplace), and only play Bible related schools. The kicker was that the only players that would be recruited were players with names that appeared in the Bible. This probably narrowed the pool down to about 25%, if that, of a normal pool.
The first season we had to recruit 7 players, I believe I recruited 6, and somehow my assistant recruited a 7th one, Victor Nolin, which is why he is on the team even though he didn't have a bible name. Surprisingly, I ended up with what I thought was a really good recruiting class.
Since there were only 5 players left on the team, I started 4 freshmen, and one sophomore that I recruited as a transfer student. In year one, we went 11-17. In year 2 we improved to 22-7. Last year we went 29-4 and made the Elite 8, and this year we just won the national title with a record of 34-1 - the only loss coming to Emmanuel.
Billy Graham has now amassed a record of 96-29, and has been named conference coach of the year for three consecutive years. The team has gone undefeated in conference play for two consecutive years. The Empire 8 conference was #2 in conference RPI, so it wasn't a super easy conference.
I was wondering if anyone else has had an experience like that with a themed team. I also think it would be cool to have a themed conference at some point.