Thoughts if class limits were 8 as opposed to 6...let's hear em.

I think it should be 7 to account for allowing a Redshirt freshman and then a 6 scholarship class of freshmen..... 8 is a bit much

What is wrong with 6?  

I'm happy with 6

Not broke, don't fix it.

They went to six for a good reason.

6 isn't enough...my predicament...I have 6 slots to fill and have some ****** sim ai guys on my team that I'd like to get rid of, but I can't/don't want to because I don't want to take on non-freshmen...that's pointless to me.  6 is too stringent, there aren't guidelines in real life to prevent the superclass...I don't really see why it's necessary here...with the way guys gripe about minutes nowadays in the game, wouldn't that segment your team if you had 12 from the same class?  Some would at the very least ***** and perhaps transfer.

It's clearly not real life.  In real life, no one would join you 8-person superclass.

There's a reason it's never been done in real life.

St. Johns had 10 seniors the other year. it happens.

I don't think citing a couple of times in the history of major college basketball is really a justification. 

Maybe I overstated, but the point was that players in real life players don't want to do that.  This isn't an "it works in real life so why can't we do it" kind of issue.

The point is, it's not illegal to do IRL...just because you don't like/prefer it in the game doesn't mean that it doesn't/can't happen.  I'm not even asking for superclasses to come back, just 2 more slots max.

The rule solved a problem, reverting back is bad for the game.

Not reverting back to it...8 isn't 12...and like I said, with the way that guys ***** about minutes nowadays, it would be tough to keep a superclass together even if they were in place.

Posted by colonels19 on 4/27/2012 2:45:00 PM (view original):
The point is, it's not illegal to do IRL...just because you don't like/prefer it in the game doesn't mean that it doesn't/can't happen.  I'm not even asking for superclasses to come back, just 2 more slots max.

Well, just because you choose not to have walkons or recruit JUCOs isn't a good reason to change the way the game is set up.

Just as an interesting aside, real life used to have the "5-8 Rule", which was in effect from approximately 2001-2005, which limited basketball programs to a maximum of 5 scholarships in a given year and 8 over a two-year period.