ROUND FIVE: League ONE - DONE! Topic


I went through and pulled all of the two-year “dynasties” since 1901 and put them in chronological order. A two-year dynasty as it plays in this theme is this: One of the two seasons involved had to have finished the season with a minimum Winning Percentage of .600. The year directly before or after it must have had a Winning Percentage of at least .590. There ended up being 165 of these “duos” so I split them up as evenly (but fairly) as I could. For example, there’s either 43 or 44 selections to choose from in Leagues 2, 3 and 4 and 35 to choose from in League 1. I did it that way so that all of the deadball teams would have their own league.

When it's your turn to pick, you must choose what duo you want and what division you choose to be in. Once everyone has chosen, you will begin the Free Agent selection:
.
FREE AGENT DRAFTING: You now get to add one Pitching Free Agent and one Hitting Free Agent from either of the two years that your duo covers. The key is that any Free Agent can’t come from a team that’s available to be chosen in the draft. For example, you could select the 1901-1902 Pirates. Since the 1901 Athletics and the 1902 Blues aren’t available to be chosen in any duo, you can use 1901 Nap Lajoie (Athletics) and 1902 Bill Bernhard (Blues) as your Free Agents. However, if you choose the 1915-1916 Red Sox, you cannot take 1915 Pete Alexander as a Free Agent since the 1915-1916 Phillies are available to be drafted. 1915 Alexander however is available as a Free Agent in the 1914-1915 time-frame draft since the 1914-1915 Phillies are not an option. Regardless of whether or not a particular duo ends up getting drafted, players from that duo are still not eligible to be chosen as Free Agents in that particular time-frame. This rule applies to each league individually. I know I’ll get asked this so I’ll address it now: If someone chooses one of the 1919-1920 duos in League 1, then yes, 1920 Babe Ruth is available as a Free Agent since the 1920 Yankees aren’t included in any duos “in League 1.” They are in League 2, however, so he wouldn’t be available in League 2 as a Free Agent.

If you are the only person who selects a particular two-season duo, then you simply get to choose which Free Agent Pitcher and Free Agent Hitter you want from those two years – as long as they don’t come from a duo that was available to be chosen during that two-year time-frame. For example, in League 1: If you choose the 1904-1905 Cubs and no one chooses the 1904-1905 Giants, you can go ahead and pick which Free Agent Pitcher and Hitter you want – as long as neither come from the 1904-1905 Giants. Any other team during that two-year stretch is fine.

If more than one owner selects a duo from a particular time-frame, they will have to draft their Free Agents in a separate thread. Once all duos have been selected and you know who and how many others are also in that two-year time-frame, you will move to a separate thread where the Free Agent drafting will take place.

IMPORTANT: There will be no snake-style drafting. The draft for Free Agents for each two-year time-frame will go in reverse order of the teams taken. For example, in League 1: If Owner 1 selects the 1908-1909 Cubs, Owner 2 selects the 1908-1909 Pirates and Owner 3 selects the 1908-1909 Giants, then Owner 3 will select his two Free Agents first, followed by Owner 2 and then Owner 1.

Any Free Agent can only be selected once in each two-year time-frame. Again, for example in League 1: If both of the 1907-1908 teams are selected, only 1 of them can take the 1908 version of Addie Joss. If the other owner wants the 1907 version of Joss, that’s fine. Then, in the 1908-1909 time-frame draft, 1908 Joss is available in that draft as well. Each draft will be separate from the others.

As in previous rounds, we'll have a 24-hour window once the draft boards are posted for anyone who would like to explore a trade of their draft spot/position.

Particulars:

CAP – None – build the best team you can with your two seasons.

Clones: None.

Designated Hitter: NO in League 1

Injuries – Turned On
Waiver Wire: No
Trades: No
A.A.A.: No

You may use either partial or full season stats of any player who had a split season - as long as the stats indicate it was for your franchise.

Stadium – You must use a ballpark that was the home ballpark for whatever franchise you’re playing during your two-year period.

8/10/2023 1:36 PM (edited)

Here are the duo's available:


LEAGUE ONE:

Pirates (1901-1902)

Pirates (1902-1903)


Americans (1903-1904)
Cubs (1903-1904)
Giants (1903-1904)

Cubs (1904-1905)
Giants (1904-1905)

Cubs (1905-1906)
Giants (1905-1906)
Pirates (1905-1906)
White Sox (1905-1906)

Cubs (1906-1907)
Pirates (1906-1907)

Cubs (1907-1908)
Pirates (1907-1908)

Cubs (1908-1909)
Giants (1908-1909)
Pirates (1908-1909)


Athletics (1909-1910)
Cubs (1909-1910)
Giants (1909-1910)

Athletics (1910-1911)
Cubs (1910-1911)
Giants (1910-1911)

Athletics (1911-1912)
Cubs (1911-1912)
Giants (1911-1912)


Athletics (1912-1913)
Giants (1912-1913)


Athletics (1913-1914)

Red Sox (1914-1915)

Phillies (1915-1916)
Red Sox (1915-1916)

Indians (1919-1920)
White Sox (1919-1920)



The Draft Order is as follows:

(01) PEDROCERRANO: 1901-1902 Pittsburgh Pirates - N.L. East
(02) SCHWARZE: 1902-1903 Pittsburgh Pirates - A.L. East
(03) FOOTBALLMM11: 1910-1911 Philadelphia Athletics - A.L. West
(04) REDCPED: 1909-1910 Philadelphia Athletics - N.L. West
(05) RICHIEBROWN6: 1914-1915 Boston Red Sox - A.L. Central
(06) PEDROCERRANO: 1904-1905 New York Giants - A.L. Central
(07) FOOTBALLMM11: 1909-1910 Chicago Cubs - N.L. Central
(08) KSTOBER: 1912-1913 New York Giants - N.L. Central
(09) BARRACUDA3: 1908-1909 Pittsburgh Pirates - N.L. Central
(10) YBJSPORTS: 1908-1909 Chicago Cubs - A.L. West
(11) TOYSBOYS: 1905-1906 Chicago Cubs - N.L. West
(12) EJSTOCKMAN: 1919-1920 Chicago White Sox - N.L. Central
(13) BEALLENDALL: 1906-1907 Chicago Cubs - A.L. East
(14) REDCPED: 1919-1920 Cleveland Indians - A.L. Central
(15) SCHWARZE: 1905-1906 New York Giants - N.L. East
(16) TOYSBOYS: 1912-1913 Philadelphia Athletics - A.L. East
(17) BARRACUDA3: 1903-1904 New York Giants - A.L. East
(18) FOOTBALLMM11: 1910-1911 New York Giants - A.L. Central
(19) SCHWARZE: 1913-1914 Philadelphia Athletics - A.L. West
(20) EMANES10: 1911-1912 Philadelphia Athletics - N.L. West
(21) RONTHEGENIUS: 1915-1916 Philadelphia Phillies - N.L. West
(22) CALHOOP: 1908-1909 New York Giants - N.L. East
(23) THEJUICE6: 1911-1912 New York Giants - A.L. West
(24) JOERAT1: 1911-1912 Chicago Cubs - N.L. East


N.L. EAST
(01) PEDROCERRANO: 1901-1902 Pittsburgh Pirates (1901 Nap Lajoie / 1901 Cy Young)
(02) SCHWARZE: 1905-1906 New York Giants (1905 Cy Young / 1906 Nap Lajoie)
(03) CALHOOP: 1908-1909 New York Giants (1908 Ed Walsh / 1909 Ty Cobb)
(04) JOERAT1: 1911-1912 Chicago Cubs (1911 Ty Cobb / 1912 Walter Johnson)

N.L. CENTRAL
(01) FOOTBALLMM11: 1909-1910 Chicago Cubs (1910 Nap Lajoie / 1910 Ed Walsh)
(02) KSTOBER: 1912-1913 New York Giants (1912 Ty Cobb / 1912 Walter Johnson)
(03) BARRACUDA3: 1908-1909 Pittsburgh Pirates (1908 Cy Young / 1909 Sam Crawford)
(04) EJSTOCKMAN: 1919-1920 Chicago White Sox (1919 Babe Adams / 1920 George Sisler)

N.L. WEST
(01) REDCPED: 1909-1910 Philadelphia Athletics (1910 Ty Cobb / 1910 Walter Johnson)
(02) TOYSBOYS: 1905-1906 Chicago Cubs (1905 Cy Seymour / 1906 Tully Sparks)
(03) EMANES10: 1911-1912 Philadelphia Athletics (1911 Ed Walsh / 1912 Tris Speaker)
(04) RONTHEGENIUS: 1915-1916 Philadelphia Phillies (1915 Walter Johnson / 1916 Tris Speaker)

A.L. EAST
(01) SCHWARZE: 1902-1903 Pittsburgh Pirates (1902 Ed Delahanty / 1902 Bill Bernhard)
(02) BEALLENDALL: 1906-1907 Chicago Cubs (1906 Nap Lajoie / 1906 Doc White)
(03) TOYSBOYS: 1912-1913 Philadelphia Athletics (1912 Tris Speaker / 1913 Walter Johnson)
(04) BARRACUDA3: 1903-1904 New York Giants (1904 Nap Lajoie / 1904 Jack Chesbro)

A.L. CENTRAL
(01) RICHIEBROWN6: 1914-1915 Boston Red Sox (1915 Pete Alexander / 1915 Ty Cobb)
(02) PEDROCERRANO: 1904-1905 New York Giants (1904 Jack Chesbro / 1904 Nap Lajoie)
(03) REDCPED: 1919-1920 Cleveland Indians (1919 Walter Johnson / 1920 Babe Ruth)
(04) FOOTBALLMM11: 1910-1911 New York Giants (1910 Ty Cobb / 1910 Walter Johnson)

A.L. WEST
(01) FOOTBALLMM11: 1910-1911 Philadelphia Athletics (1910 Ed Walsh / 1911 Ty Cobb)
(02) YBJSPORTS: 1908-1909 Chicago Cubs (1908 Addie Joss / 1909 Eddie Collins)
(03) SCHWARZE: 1913-1914 Philadelphia Athletics (1913 Walter Johnson / 1914 Tris Speaker)
(04) THEJUICE6: 1911-1912 New York Giants (1911 Joe Jackson / 1912 Joe Wood)


8/14/2023 9:50 AM (edited)
Athletics 1910-11
AL West
8/10/2023 1:44 AM
From my limited research and not actually building a bunch of rosters, my sense is this will work out as well as any option left. Gotta trust instincts because I don't have time to dig super deep.

Athletics (1909-1910)
NL West
8/10/2023 2:04 AM
Looks like the juggernauts are gone, so I'll take one Pete Alexander please.

1914-1915 Boston Red Sox
AL Central
8/10/2023 6:42 AM
1904-05 New York Giants
AL Central
8/10/2023 11:19 AM
1909-10 Chicago Cubs
NL Central
8/10/2023 12:42 PM
1912-1913 New York Giants, NL Central
8/10/2023 2:10 PM
Continuing to stare at this isn't going to make a good option magically appear.

Pirates (1908-1909)

and sure, I'll keep the NL Central run going. That's as good a division as any for me to finish last in...
8/10/2023 5:23 PM (edited)
08-09 CUB
AL WEST
8/10/2023 7:01 PM
NLW
05-06 Cubs

Yes, staring at this isn't going to make it any better.
8/10/2023 8:16 PM
Lets keep it going!
NL Central
19-20 White Sox
8/10/2023 8:39 PM
Free Agents
1902-03 Pittsburgh Pirates (1902 Ed Delahanty & 1902 Bill Bernhard)
8/11/2023 11:45 AM
Free Agents
1901-02 Pirates (1901 Lajoie - 1901 Cy Young)
8/11/2023 1:04 PM
Free Agents:
1914-15 Boston Red Sox (1915 Pete Alexander and 1915 Ty Cobb)
8/11/2023 1:35 PM
1234 Next ▸
ROUND FIVE: League ONE - DONE! Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.