Rule V Draft, Pre-1969 Edition v2 (Full) Topic

Season 1 of this theme worked well as a 24-team league, with two separate and distinct drafts.  The main difference between the last version and this version, is that I'm extending the years to include the deadball years (i.e., seasons 1901-1968).  But in an effort to prevent this league being dominated by deadball pitchers, I am instituting the following special rule:  Each team will be allowed to roster a maximum salary of $20 million in pitchers from the years 1901-1919.  Anyway, here are the rest of the rules.

1. Each owner chooses a franchise (not yet though).  The franchise draft order will be based on results from the previous season (see below for order).  The definition of franchise includes all team name and city variations (i.e., Brooklyn Robins, Brooklyn Dodgers, LA Dodgers are all part of the same franchise.  1901-02 Baltimore is not considered part of the Yankees franchise anymore). 

2. Each owner chooses five players from his selected franchise that he/she wishes to protect from that franchise (1901-1968) and submits that list via site-mail to me. Those players are the exclusive property of their respective owners.

3. After all the lists are submitted, they will be posted and a three round modified Rule V draft will be held, with draft order being in inverse order of each franchise's 1901-1968 cumulative winning percentage. (After a few more iterations of this theme, I will change the order to actual inverse sim league W-L%, similar to the current Rule V theme - need a bigger sample size).   During each drafting round, each owner drafts one unprotected player from a franchise other than their own. That player (associated with that specific franchise) is also theirs exclusively. No more than two players may be taken from any one franchise in any one round. Players from expansion franchises are not eligible to be drafted.  Players from the Federal League are not eligible to be drafted.  Players from franchises not selected are not eligible to be drafted.

4. At the end of the first and second rounds, each owner will choose an additional player they wish to protect. You will end up protecting seven in all, while drafting three. These ten players must appear on your roster. The rest of the roster is filled by players from your franchise during the given time period (1901-1968).

$120 Million Cap
No trades
No WW
No DH
No AAA
No Live play

No clones (same player, same franchise - if a player played for more than one franchise, he is available once for each franchise).  It is possible for one team to have two of the same player (i.e., I take Indians, protect Cle-Speaker and later draft an unprotected Bos-Speaker).
If a player split time between multiple teams in a season (as listed at WIS) his full season is available once for each team
Stadium must have been used by your franchise for at least one full season between 1901 and 1968

For those new to the Rule V fold:

There is much good-natured ribbing during the draft (we try not to be too player-specific, so as not to influence the draft, but sometimes the temptation is too much). Do not take it personally. Pick a draft strategy and stay the course, regardless.
 

8/4/2015 5:01 PM (edited)
Returning owners get first priority.  New owners will slot into an open spots.  Here is the franchise draft order.  Ties were broken randomly.  (Bold = in)

BLUE = Keepers sent

Owner________ Winning% Comment___ Franchise___
tridentric 0.358   Indians
mussopini23 0.401   Yankees
dilligafdbp 0.414   Athletics
calhoop 0.438  new owner Indians
specsman 0.451   Yankees
mllama54 0.451   Giants
AKlopp 0.481  new owner Cardinals
pumpkinmcp 0.494   Dodgers
shysters3 0.500  new owner White Sox
newarkwilder 0.500  new owner Cubs
DoctorKz 0.500  new owner Browns/Orioles
deathdealer 0.506   Browns/Orioles
Robin4 0.506   Giants
sinfonian11 0.506   Cardinals
thejuice6 0.519   Athletics
marlowe 0.543   Red Sox
llcoach 0.525 Playoff Braves
ozomatli 0.531 Playoff Phillies
jose can u c 0.549 Playoff Dodgers
buddhagamer 0.562 Playoff Twins/Senators
dvorr80 0.568 Playoff Pirates
schwarze 0.617 Playoff White Sox
alice 0.519 WS Runner-up Twins/Senators
toddleduc 0.562 new owner Phillies
8/10/2015 2:57 PM (edited)
The league split would be as follows...

The first person to take a franchise would be in draft 1, the second person to take that franchise would be in draft 2.  If a franchise is only selected once, the first franchise selected once would be in draft 1, the second franchise would be in draft 2.  

So let's assume 10 of the 16 franchises are selected twice and four franchises were each selected once.  The first and third franchise selected only once would be in draft 1, the second and fourth franchise selected only once would be part of draft 2.

Franchises designated for Draft 1 would all be placed in the NL.  Franchises designated for Draft 2 teams would all be placed in the AL. 

Since there is no real division alignment that makes sense, the divisions will be aligned by franchise winning% (i.e., the top 4 franchises in the East, the bottom in the West).
8/3/2015 9:48 AM (edited)
Sign up List:

1. schwarze
2. buddhagamer
3. ozomatli
4. tridentric
5. pumpkinmcp
6. marlowe
7. alice
8. deathdealer
9. jose can u c
10. sinfonian11
11. DoctorKz (replaces ybjsports)
12. dilligafdbp
13. mllama54
14. toddleduc (replaces rbow923)
15. Robin4
16. thejuice6
17. dvorr80
18. llcoach
19. specsman
20. shysters3 (replaces tjefferson)
21. calhoop (replaces kyleb63)
22. AKlopp (replaces ff09)
23. newarkwilder (replaces shaybee)
24. mussopini23

WaitList:
1. trenchfoot


Site-mail List
AKlopp; alice; buddhagamer; calhoop; deathdealer; dilligafdbp; DoctorKz; dvorr80; jose can u c; llcoach; marlowe; mllama54; mussopini23; newarkwilder; ozomatli; pumpkinmcp; Robin4; schwarze; shysters3; sinfonian11; specsman; thejuice6; toddleduc; tridentric
8/25/2015 11:21 AM (edited)
Franchise Winning% Owner1______ Owner2_____
Philadelphia Phillies 0.467 ozomatli toddleduc
Baltimore Orioles 0.476 DoctorKz deathdealer
Minnesota Twins 0.480 buddhagamer alice
Atlanta Braves 0.487 llcoach  
Oakland Athletics 0.488 dilligafdbp thejuice6
Chicago Cubs 0.502 newarkwilder  
Cincinnati Reds 0.503    
Chicago White Sox 0.505 shysters3 schwarze
Pittsburgh Pirates 0.508 dvorr80  
Detroit Tigers 0.508    
Cleveland Indians 0.509 tridentric calhoop
Boston Red Sox 0.517 marlowe  
St. Louis Cardinals 0.521 AKlopp sinfonian11
Los Angeles Dodgers 0.524 pumpkinmpc jose can u c
San Francisco Giants 0.537 mllama54 Robin4
New York Yankees 0.567 mussopini23 specsman
8/8/2015 6:22 PM (edited)
I will be back for another go.
8/2/2015 6:26 PM
Yep
8/2/2015 6:45 PM
Waitlist me
8/2/2015 7:10 PM
I 'm in
8/2/2015 8:07 PM
yeppers...
8/2/2015 8:17 PM
Yep. Lets see i I can improve this time.
8/2/2015 9:18 PM
sounds interesting....deal me in !
8/2/2015 10:02 PM
I'll return
8/2/2015 11:27 PM
I'm in again
8/3/2015 12:02 AM
Has ybj assimilated rbow? Is ybj actually the Borg? I have so many questions.
8/3/2015 7:42 AM
123456 Next ▸
Rule V Draft, Pre-1969 Edition v2 (Full) Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.