Round 2 140M Roster Analysis, 2018 Topic

$140M: Live by the Sword...
Choose 12 players. For each of them, draft two seasons. For each player, one of the seasons you draft must cost at least double what the other season costs.

Your 25th player must cost more than the most expensive of the 12 cheaper seasons, and cannot be the most expensive player on your roster. Your 25th player also cannot be the same as one of your 12 cloned players.

Other Specifics
Seasons: All
DH: No
WW: No
AAA: No
Trades: No
Clones: Yes, with restrictions
Injuries: Turned On
Multi-team players: No restrictions (i.e., you can use partial or combined)
Ballpark: Use the ballpark that your 25th player called home during the season of his that you choose
300K Exception: No
Team Name: Reference your 25th player
Division Alignment: Random
1/9/2019 12:55 AM
Players selected
Player______________ Total Selections___ Clone Selections___ Wildcard Selections
Ed Walsh 40 20 0
Babe Adams 24 12 0
Ty Cobb 23 11 1
Nap Lajoie 22 11 0
Mariano Rivera 18 9 0
Tris Speaker 18 9 0
Babe Ruth 14 7 0
Pete Alexander 14 7 0
Pedro Martinez 14 7 0
Rich Hill 12 6 0
Roger Connor 12 6 0
Greg Maddux 12 6 0
Honus Wagner 12 5 2
Jimmie Foxx 11 5 1
Rogers Hornsby 10 5 0
Jack Clements 8 4 0
Mike Adams 8 4 0
Kenley Jansen 8 4 0
Hughie Jennings 6 3 0
Vida Blue 6 3 0
Ed Reulbach 6 3 0
Lave Cross 6 3 0
John McGraw 6 3 0
Ed Delahanty 6 3 0
Joe Jackson 6 3 0
Ken Caminiti 6 3 0
Edd Roush 6 3 0
Elmer Valo 6 3 0
Duke Farrell 6 3 0
Pete Browning 6 3 0
Dan Brouthers 5 2 1
Frank Baker 5 2 1
Aroldis Chapman 4 2 0
Pablo Sandoval 4 2 0
King Kelly 4 2 0
Cecil Travis 4 2 0
Billy Wagner 4 2 0
Luke Appling 4 2 0
Billy Hamilton 4 2 0
Mickey Mantle 4 2 0
Randy Johnson 4 2 0
Roberto Alomar 4 2 0
Tony Fernandez 4 2 0
Rafael Betancourt 4 2 0
Mark Melancon 4 2 0
Alex Rodriguez 4 2 0
Art Nehf 4 2 0
Jake McGee 4 2 0
Stan Musial 4 2 0
Addie Joss 4 2 0
Dennis Eckersley 4 2 0
Wade Boggs 4 2 0
Chief Bender 4 2 0
Ozzie Smith 4 2 0
Mickey Cochrane 4 2 0
Joe Dimaggio 4 2 0
Bill Bernhard 4 1 2
Christy Mathewson 3 1 1
Ted Simmons 3 1 1
Claude Hendrix 3 1 1
Randy Winn 3 1 1
Clayton Kershaw 3 1 1
George Brett 3 0 3
Marshall Bridges 2 1 0
Yadier Molina 2 1 0
George Burns 2 1 0
Johnny Evers 2 1 0
Carlos Beltran 2 1 0
Hong-Chih Kuo 2 1 0
Joey Votto 2 1 0
Joe Evans 2 1 0
Sandy Koufax 2 1 0
Justin Verlander 2 1 0
Joe Mauer 2 1 0
Doyle Alexander 2 1 0
Ferdie Schupp 2 1 0
Hoyt Wilhelm 2 1 0
Andy Rincon 2 1 0
Joe Wood 2 1 0
Reb Russell 2 1 0
Terry Pendleton 2 1 0
Dale Murray 2 1 0
John Smoltz 2 1 0
Todd Pratt 2 1 0
Snuffy Stirnweiss 2 1 0
Troy Tulowitzki 2 1 0
Gavvy Cravath 2 1 0
Tyler Clippard 2 1 0
Trevor Hoffman 2 1 0
Eric Hinske 2 1 0
Terry Crowley 2 1 0
Hank Greenberg 2 1 0
Tony Gwynn 2 1 0
Jocko Milligan 2 1 0
Nomar Garciaparra 2 1 0
Larry Walker 2 1 0
Norm Charlton 2 1 0
Joe Torre 2 1 0
Charlie Hickman 2 1 0
Sam Thompson 2 1 0
Ray Caldwell 2 1 0
Darrell Porter 2 1 0
Gregg Jefferies 2 1 0
Red Schoendienst 2 1 0
Max Carey 2 1 0
Jacoby Ellsbury 2 1 0
Jonathan Papelbon 2 1 0
Arky Vaughan 2 1 0
Sean Doolittle 2 1 0
Stan Hack 2 1 0
Johnny Briggs 2 1 0
Zack Greinke 2 1 0
Rich Gossage 2 1 0
Arthur Rhodes 2 1 0
George Davis 2 1 0
Andrew Miller 2 1 0
George Kell 2 1 0
Charlie Smith 2 1 0
Dazzy Vance 2 1 0
Frankie Frisch 2 0 2
Cy Seymour 1 0 1
Mike Scott 1 0 1
Bill Joyce 1 0 1
Willie Mays 1 0 1
Elvis Andrus 1 0 1
Walter Johnson 1 0 1
1/9/2019 12:55 AM
Ordered by times cloned (note Ed Walsh on 20 of 24 teams)
Player______________ Total Selections___ Clone Selections___ Wildcard Selections
Ed Walsh 40 20 0
Babe Adams 24 12 0
Ty Cobb 23 11 1
Nap Lajoie 22 11 0
Mariano Rivera 18 9 0
Tris Speaker 18 9 0
Babe Ruth 14 7 0
Pete Alexander 14 7 0
Pedro Martinez 14 7 0
Rich Hill 12 6 0
Roger Connor 12 6 0
Greg Maddux 12 6 0
Honus Wagner 12 5 2
Jimmie Foxx 11 5 1
Rogers Hornsby 10 5 0
Jack Clements 8 4 0
Mike Adams 8 4 0
Kenley Jansen 8 4 0
Hughie Jennings 6 3 0
Vida Blue 6 3 0
Ed Reulbach 6 3 0
Lave Cross 6 3 0
John McGraw 6 3 0
Ed Delahanty 6 3 0
Joe Jackson 6 3 0
Ken Caminiti 6 3 0
Edd Roush 6 3 0
Elmer Valo 6 3 0
Duke Farrell 6 3 0
Pete Browning 6 3 0
Dan Brouthers 5 2 1
Frank Baker 5 2 1
Aroldis Chapman 4 2 0
Pablo Sandoval 4 2 0
King Kelly 4 2 0
Cecil Travis 4 2 0
Billy Wagner 4 2 0
Luke Appling 4 2 0
Billy Hamilton 4 2 0
Mickey Mantle 4 2 0
Randy Johnson 4 2 0
Roberto Alomar 4 2 0
Tony Fernandez 4 2 0
Rafael Betancourt 4 2 0
Mark Melancon 4 2 0
Alex Rodriguez 4 2 0
Art Nehf 4 2 0
Jake McGee 4 2 0
Stan Musial 4 2 0
Addie Joss 4 2 0
Dennis Eckersley 4 2 0
Wade Boggs 4 2 0
Chief Bender 4 2 0
Ozzie Smith 4 2 0
Mickey Cochrane 4 2 0
Joe Dimaggio 4 2 0
Bill Bernhard 4 1 2
Christy Mathewson 3 1 1
Ted Simmons 3 1 1
Claude Hendrix 3 1 1
Randy Winn 3 1 1
Clayton Kershaw 3 1 1
Marshall Bridges 2 1 0
Yadier Molina 2 1 0
George Burns 2 1 0
Johnny Evers 2 1 0
Carlos Beltran 2 1 0
Hong-Chih Kuo 2 1 0
Joey Votto 2 1 0
Joe Evans 2 1 0
Sandy Koufax 2 1 0
Justin Verlander 2 1 0
Joe Mauer 2 1 0
Doyle Alexander 2 1 0
Ferdie Schupp 2 1 0
Hoyt Wilhelm 2 1 0
Andy Rincon 2 1 0
Joe Wood 2 1 0
Reb Russell 2 1 0
Terry Pendleton 2 1 0
Dale Murray 2 1 0
John Smoltz 2 1 0
Todd Pratt 2 1 0
Snuffy Stirnweiss 2 1 0
Troy Tulowitzki 2 1 0
Gavvy Cravath 2 1 0
Tyler Clippard 2 1 0
Trevor Hoffman 2 1 0
Eric Hinske 2 1 0
Terry Crowley 2 1 0
Hank Greenberg 2 1 0
Tony Gwynn 2 1 0
Jocko Milligan 2 1 0
Nomar Garciaparra 2 1 0
Larry Walker 2 1 0
Norm Charlton 2 1 0
Joe Torre 2 1 0
Charlie Hickman 2 1 0
Sam Thompson 2 1 0
Ray Caldwell 2 1 0
Darrell Porter 2 1 0
Gregg Jefferies 2 1 0
Red Schoendienst 2 1 0
Max Carey 2 1 0
Jacoby Ellsbury 2 1 0
Jonathan Papelbon 2 1 0
Arky Vaughan 2 1 0
Sean Doolittle 2 1 0
Stan Hack 2 1 0
Johnny Briggs 2 1 0
Zack Greinke 2 1 0
Rich Gossage 2 1 0
Arthur Rhodes 2 1 0
George Davis 2 1 0
Andrew Miller 2 1 0
George Kell 2 1 0
Charlie Smith 2 1 0
Dazzy Vance 2 1 0
George Brett 3 0 3
Frankie Frisch 2 0 2
Cy Seymour 1 0 1
Mike Scott 1 0 1
Bill Joyce 1 0 1
Willie Mays 1 0 1
Elvis Andrus 1 0 1
Walter Johnson 1 0 1
1/9/2019 12:56 AM
Wildcard selections only

Player______________ Total Selections___ Clone Selections___ Wildcard Selections
George Brett 3 0 3
Honus Wagner 12 5 2
Bill Bernhard 4 1 2
Frankie Frisch 2 0 2
Ty Cobb 23 11 1
Jimmie Foxx 11 5 1
Dan Brouthers 5 2 1
Frank Baker 5 2 1
Christy Mathewson 3 1 1
Ted Simmons 3 1 1
Claude Hendrix 3 1 1
Randy Winn 3 1 1
Clayton Kershaw 3 1 1
Cy Seymour 1 0 1
Mike Scott 1 0 1
Bill Joyce 1 0 1
Willie Mays 1 0 1
Elvis Andrus 1 0 1
Walter Johnson 1 0 1
1/9/2019 12:56 AM
Wildcard selections by position (note that I marked the one use of 2016 Kershaw as an RP, not an SP, based on expected use)

Position___ Wildcard Selections
SP 6
3B 6
OF 5
1B 2
SS 2
C 1
2B 1
RP 1
1/9/2019 12:57 AM
Median Low Salary___ Median High Salary___ Median Wildcard Salary___ % Wildcards Pitcher
$1,322,920 $8,126,036 $9,306,443 29.2%
1/9/2019 12:57 AM
Average clone salary deltas

Player______________ Avg Clone Delta
Ed Walsh $17,537,880
Sandy Koufax $15,157,135
Pete Alexander $14,651,007
Christy Mathewson $13,889,307
Addie Joss $12,984,632
Greg Maddux $12,158,884
Claude Hendrix $11,562,280
Dazzy Vance $11,509,299
Vida Blue $10,760,112
Babe Ruth $9,635,066
Zack Greinke $9,256,885
Jacoby Ellsbury $9,150,629
Roger Connor $9,121,420
Rogers Hornsby $9,076,975
Sam Thompson $8,591,044
Tris Speaker $8,541,663
Ken Caminiti $8,498,075
Hank Greenberg $8,417,412
Justin Verlander $8,410,157
Luke Appling $8,388,197
Ed Delahanty $8,329,573
John McGraw $8,292,631
Hughie Jennings $8,162,516
Ed Reulbach $8,050,683
Ferdie Schupp $7,896,652
Jimmie Foxx $7,723,483
Lave Cross $7,581,377
Nomar Garciaparra $7,543,540
Snuffy Stirnweiss $7,461,730
Joe Mauer $7,459,292
Stan Musial $7,427,157
Pete Browning $7,325,403
Billy Hamilton $7,315,074
George Davis $7,221,975
Joe Jackson $7,117,988
Honus Wagner $7,113,976
Ozzie Smith $7,089,685
Ty Cobb $6,952,075
Joe Torre $6,930,439
Ted Simmons $6,893,888
Roberto Alomar $6,892,268
Dan Brouthers $6,889,483
Cecil Travis $6,802,291
Max Carey $6,799,150
Red Schoendienst $6,752,168
Alex Rodriguez $6,724,136
Wade Boggs $6,680,293
John Smoltz $6,676,112
Reb Russell $6,630,047
George Kell $6,606,414
Gregg Jefferies $6,545,720
Frank Baker $6,453,983
Randy Johnson $6,269,974
Carlos Beltran $6,223,366
Arky Vaughan $6,221,177
Tony Fernandez $6,153,323
Babe Adams $6,114,475
George Burns $6,083,550
Gavvy Cravath $6,077,963
Terry Pendleton $5,958,994
Pedro Martinez $5,898,354
King Kelly $5,795,599
Darrell Porter $5,790,789
Charlie Hickman $5,785,499
Johnny Evers $5,748,759
Nap Lajoie $5,736,652
Clayton Kershaw $5,716,375
Bill Bernhard $5,655,203
Chief Bender $5,647,910
Edd Roush $5,392,106
Joe Dimaggio $5,204,837
Ray Caldwell $5,131,870
Joey Votto $5,041,257
Yadier Molina $4,982,450
Larry Walker $4,951,744
Pablo Sandoval $4,795,688
Tony Gwynn $4,689,489
Randy Winn $4,644,305
Stan Hack $4,590,826
Troy Tulowitzki $4,558,179
Jack Clements $4,395,637
Hong-Chih Kuo $4,395,535
Mickey Cochrane $4,209,854
Dennis Eckersley $4,130,174
Jocko Milligan $3,846,894
Duke Farrell $3,804,028
Hoyt Wilhelm $3,737,002
Rich Gossage $3,636,168
Joe Wood $3,623,182
Mickey Mantle $3,618,900
Billy Wagner $3,580,420
Art Nehf $3,319,306
Rafael Betancourt $3,209,408
Doyle Alexander $3,202,739
Norm Charlton $3,017,285
Jonathan Papelbon $2,966,668
Mariano Rivera $2,941,066
Rich Hill $2,782,494
Dale Murray $2,715,892
Aroldis Chapman $2,619,947
Kenley Jansen $2,542,928
Mike Adams $2,477,162
Elmer Valo $2,427,580
Sean Doolittle $2,227,544
Tyler Clippard $2,152,521
Andrew Miller $2,121,846
Trevor Hoffman $2,003,938
Mark Melancon $1,848,967
Arthur Rhodes $1,657,452
Jake McGee $1,580,406
Todd Pratt $1,215,585
Andy Rincon $1,199,670
Marshall Bridges $913,792
Joe Evans $885,987
Charlie Smith $785,151
Johnny Briggs $393,970
Terry Crowley $213,209
Eric Hinske $203,481
1/9/2019 12:59 AM
Wildcard player by owner (interesting that mdc2276 and Donburgh both used 1902 Bernhard, but different versions)
Owner_________ Wildcard Player__________ Wildcard Salary___
rbow923 1914 Claude Hendrix $15,444,022
brianjw 1915 Walter Johnson $14,736,979
newarkwilder 1905 Christy Mathewson $14,341,519
dougpalm 1986 Mike Scott $12,354,070
ejstockman 1935 Jimmie Foxx $11,627,133
magicdreamer 1954 Willie Mays $11,267,636
mildnhazy 1910 Ty Cobb $10,116,322
mdc2276 1902 Bill Bernhard $9,542,392
dippedncrack 1912 Frank Baker $9,421,884
Donburgh 1902 Bill Bernhard $9,370,956
discodemo 1985 George Brett $9,340,540
jfranco77 1985 George Brett $9,340,540
justinlee_24 1886 Dan Brouthers $9,272,346
wink0094 1905 Cy Seymour $9,206,062
Jdh34 1903 Honus Wagner $8,185,864
buddhagamer 1924 Frankie Frisch $8,043,086
jbohrman 2016 Clayton Kershaw $7,766,928
jmissirlis 1921 Frankie Frisch $7,699,530
ozomatli 1979 George Brett $7,600,272
Humdogs 1900 Honus Wagner $7,545,316
redcped 2017 Elvis Andrus $7,252,933
crystalao 1977 Ted Simmons $6,938,311
odalisgagne 1894 Bill Joyce $6,622,484
mpitt76 2005 Randy Winn $4,875,073
1/9/2019 2:12 AM (edited)
Median clone delta by owner
Owner_________ Median Clone Delta___ Min Clone Delta___ Max Clone Delta
jbohrman $9,020,745 $785,151 $20,362,454
jmissirlis $8,163,901 $2,699,636 $18,610,612
Donburgh $8,000,082 $2,930,941 $13,051,917
mpitt76 $7,490,561 $2,275,978 $21,719,550
mildnhazy $7,316,445 $558,123 $18,610,612
Humdogs $6,893,078 $2,275,978 $16,064,515
rbow923 $6,845,401 $1,848,967 $18,610,612
Jdh34 $6,785,586 $2,678,345 $19,969,172
dougpalm $6,763,527 $2,825,009 $15,157,135
magicdreamer $6,648,944 $2,825,009 $11,446,135
wink0094 $6,604,082 $885,987 $20,362,454
jfranco77 $6,517,960 $1,199,670 $9,397,292
crystalao $6,376,036 $3,580,420 $18,610,612
dippedncrack $6,274,812 $2,893,903 $9,026,729
buddhagamer $6,144,472 $2,708,890 $21,719,550
justinlee_24 $6,018,074 $2,739,979 $21,719,550
odalisgagne $5,986,401 $1,215,585 $20,362,454
newarkwilder $5,916,155 $913,792 $18,610,612
brianjw $5,645,523 $2,121,846 $18,610,612
ozomatli $5,645,523 $1,848,967 $18,610,612
discodemo $5,601,263 $2,739,979 $18,610,612
redcped $5,495,272 $1,657,452 $18,610,612
mdc2276 $4,757,704 $393,970 $20,362,454
ejstockman $3,662,696 $203,481 $11,446,135
1/9/2019 1:01 AM
Ordered by minimum clone delta

Owner_________ Median Clone Delta___ Min Clone Delta___ Max Clone Delta
crystalao $6,376,036 $3,580,420 $18,610,612
Donburgh $8,000,082 $2,930,941 $13,051,917
dippedncrack $6,274,812 $2,893,903 $9,026,729
dougpalm $6,763,527 $2,825,009 $15,157,135
magicdreamer $6,648,944 $2,825,009 $11,446,135
justinlee_24 $6,018,074 $2,739,979 $21,719,550
discodemo $5,601,263 $2,739,979 $18,610,612
buddhagamer $6,144,472 $2,708,890 $21,719,550
jmissirlis $8,163,901 $2,699,636 $18,610,612
Jdh34 $6,785,586 $2,678,345 $19,969,172
mpitt76 $7,490,561 $2,275,978 $21,719,550
Humdogs $6,893,078 $2,275,978 $16,064,515
brianjw $5,645,523 $2,121,846 $18,610,612
rbow923 $6,845,401 $1,848,967 $18,610,612
ozomatli $5,645,523 $1,848,967 $18,610,612
redcped $5,495,272 $1,657,452 $18,610,612
odalisgagne $5,986,401 $1,215,585 $20,362,454
jfranco77 $6,517,960 $1,199,670 $9,397,292
newarkwilder $5,916,155 $913,792 $18,610,612
wink0094 $6,604,082 $885,987 $20,362,454
jbohrman $9,020,745 $785,151 $20,362,454
mildnhazy $7,316,445 $558,123 $18,610,612
mdc2276 $4,757,704 $393,970 $20,362,454
ejstockman $3,662,696 $203,481 $11,446,135
1/9/2019 1:01 AM
Ordered by maximum clone delta (hellooooo Ed Walsh)

Owner_________ Median Clone Delta___ Min Clone Delta___ Max Clone Delta
justinlee_24 $6,018,074 $2,739,979 $21,719,550
buddhagamer $6,144,472 $2,708,890 $21,719,550
mpitt76 $7,490,561 $2,275,978 $21,719,550
odalisgagne $5,986,401 $1,215,585 $20,362,454
wink0094 $6,604,082 $885,987 $20,362,454
jbohrman $9,020,745 $785,151 $20,362,454
mdc2276 $4,757,704 $393,970 $20,362,454
Jdh34 $6,785,586 $2,678,345 $19,969,172
crystalao $6,376,036 $3,580,420 $18,610,612
discodemo $5,601,263 $2,739,979 $18,610,612
jmissirlis $8,163,901 $2,699,636 $18,610,612
brianjw $5,645,523 $2,121,846 $18,610,612
rbow923 $6,845,401 $1,848,967 $18,610,612
ozomatli $5,645,523 $1,848,967 $18,610,612
redcped $5,495,272 $1,657,452 $18,610,612
newarkwilder $5,916,155 $913,792 $18,610,612
mildnhazy $7,316,445 $558,123 $18,610,612
Humdogs $6,893,078 $2,275,978 $16,064,515
dougpalm $6,763,527 $2,825,009 $15,157,135
Donburgh $8,000,082 $2,930,941 $13,051,917
magicdreamer $6,648,944 $2,825,009 $11,446,135
ejstockman $3,662,696 $203,481 $11,446,135
jfranco77 $6,517,960 $1,199,670 $9,397,292
dippedncrack $6,274,812 $2,893,903 $9,026,729
1/9/2019 1:01 AM
Just ran the correlations for owner rank vs the above metrics. Nothing registered very strongly. The highest was median clone delta at only .34, with higher ranked owners tending to have higher median deltas
1/9/2019 1:38 AM
Note that, for simplicity's sake, Cookie Score for this league will double count cloned players and single count wildcard players
Owner_________ Cookie Score
justinlee_24 14.0
ozomatli 13.9
buddhagamer 13.2
mildnhazy 13.2
jmissirlis 13.0
jbohrman 12.9
rbow923 12.9
jfranco77 12.8
dippedncrack 12.5
brianjw 11.9
crystalao 11.2
discodemo 11.1
wink0094 10.8
redcped 10.8
ejstockman 10.2
newarkwilder 9.7
Jdh34 9.7
Donburgh 9.5
mpitt76 9.2
odalisgagne 8.8
Humdogs 8.6
magicdreamer 8.2
dougpalm 7.6
mdc2276 7.4
1/9/2019 1:43 AM
Cookie Score has a decent correlation with Round 1 rank (.66), with higher ranked owners tending to have higher Cookie Scores
1/9/2019 1:44 AM
As expected, given the high Cookie Scores in this league, many teams have very few unique players.
Owner_________ Unique Players
magicdreamer 13
odalisgagne 11
newarkwilder 10
ejstockman 8
mpitt76 8
wink0094 7
dougpalm 7
buddhagamer 6
jfranco77 6
mdc2276 6
brianjw 5
redcped 5
jbohrman 4
crystalao 4
discodemo 4
Donburgh 4
justinlee_24 2
mildnhazy 2
rbow923 2
dippedncrack 2
Humdogs 2
ozomatli 0
jmissirlis 0
Jdh34 0
1/9/2019 1:47 AM
12 Next ▸
Round 2 140M Roster Analysis, 2018 Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.