Here is the cumulative W-L record by Draft pick. There is a slight advantage to picking early, but as you can see from the table below, teams picking as late as 9th (out of 12) are cumulatively over .500. Check out thejuice6's last pick in League 7 AL, 39-23!
.
Pick# WIN LOSS WIN% Best Team Owner League W-L
----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------------------------------------------------- -------------------- --------------- -----------
1 536 456 0.540 2019 HOU/NYY/MIN toysboys LG08AL 46-16
2 532 460 0.536 2001 Mariners A's Yankees contrarian23 LG07AL 41-21
3 539 453 0.543 1993 Barry's Braves-Giants-Phils redcped LG07NL 46-16
4 504 488 0.508 1930 A's/Senators/Yankees loyalcanuck LG03AL 40-22
5 516 476 0.520 1909 Tigers Athletics Americans thejuice6 LG01AL 39-23
6 475 517 0.479 1977 Dodgers Pirates Phillies thejuice6 LG06NL 40-22
7 490 502 0.494 1919 White Socked Yankee Native American harrelson LG02AL 40-22
8 487 505 0.491 1967 Tigers Twins Red Sox thejuice6 LG05AL 37-25
9 504 488 0.508 1906 CHC/NYG/PIT toysboys LG01NL 44-18
10 456 536 0.460 1951 Yanks/Sox/Indians firesalt LG04AL 38-24
11 468 524 0.472 1949 Yankees Indians Red Sox thejuice6 LG04AL 35-27
12 445 547 0.449 1995 Yankees Indians Red Sox thejuice6 LG07AL 39-23

8.4.3
9/28/2020 4:42 PM
Thru 62 games, 28 wins (.451) would get you into round 4. That's a 73-win pace.
8.4.3
9/28/2020 4:50 PM
juice is just crushing this round apparently

Thanks for posting the data; I did have a small concern that the absence of any FAs in this round might skew the results a little more, but honestly, this round is pretty ridiculously competitive so far.
9/28/2020 5:09 PM
I agree, and having an early pick guarantees nothing... Case in point...
.
I had first pick in League 4 NL
1953 Dodgers Braves Phillies 28-34

I had second pick in League 6 NL
1975 Reds Pirates Dodgers 31-31

I had fourth pick in League 7 NL
2002 Braves D'backs Cardinals 27-35
8.4.3
9/28/2020 5:49 PM
Quote post by contrarian23 on 9/28/2020 5:09:00 PM:
"juice is just crushing this round apparently"



...said noone ever until now.

Yeah, a few of my teams are really playing out of their heads. Cue the jinx right about.......NOW!


9/28/2020 7:31 PM
Thru 80 games, a record of 36-44 would be enough to get you into Round 4 - a 73-win pace.
10/4/2020 3:38 PM
The following update is thru 156 games. Note that for purposes of Round 4 calculations, I used 72-84 as the cutoff. (142 teams have 72+ wins, so if the season ended today, there would be two additional 71-win teams to get in - I didn't want to deal with the tie-breaker for this update). That means teams will probably need 74 total wins to clinch a round 4 spot (73 wins will probably need the tie-breaker).
10/29/2020 6:39 PM
Overall record by owner...
.
Owner Teams Wins Losses Win% Division Wildcard Playoff Rd 4
----------------------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- -----------
njbigwig 1 88 68 0.564 1 0.0 1.0 1
redcped 7 615 477 0.563 4 0.0 4.0 7
spinaldog 1 87 69 0.558 0 1.0 1.0 1
toysboys 8 688 560 0.551 5 1.0 6.0 7
pedrocerrano 6 515 421 0.550 3 2.0 5.0 6
schwarze 13 1115 913 0.550 6 1.0 7.0 12
ybjsports 2 171 141 0.548 1 1.0 2.0 2
SteveIzzy 3 254 214 0.543 0 1.0 1.0 3
firesalt 2 163 149 0.522 0.5 0.0 0.5 2
harrelson 2 163 149 0.522 0 2.0 2.0 2
contrarian23 20 1622 1498 0.520 7.5 0.0 7.5 18
coachgreat1 3 240 228 0.513 0.5 0.0 0.5 2
kstober 11 873 843 0.509 3 3.0 6.0 8
winterhawk 1 79 77 0.506 0 0.0 0.0 1
cardinaldave 1 79 77 0.506 0 0.0 0.0 1
loyalcanuck 6 474 462 0.506 2 0.0 2.0 5
thejuice6 14 1097 1087 0.502 6 1.0 7.0 10
Chisock 9 701 703 0.499 0 2.0 2.0 8
Jtpsops 3 232 236 0.496 2 0.0 2.0 2
DarthDurron 9 688 716 0.490 1 0.0 1.0 7
jetscanes 2 152 160 0.487 0 0.0 0.0 1
nocomm999 5 379 401 0.486 2 0.0 2.0 4
thebubbaq 3 225 243 0.481 0 0.0 0.0 2
specsman 2 149 163 0.478 0 0.0 0.0 1
calhoop 7 521 571 0.477 1 0.3 1.3 3
ff09 2 148 164 0.474 0 0.3 0.3 1
SAKABAKBRG 2 147 165 0.471 0 0.0 0.0 1
joerat1 3 220 248 0.470 1 0.0 1.0 1
markeking 2 146 166 0.468 0 0.0 0.0 2
Relkcirts 5 364 416 0.467 0 0.0 0.0 3
mllama54 4 291 333 0.466 0 0.3 0.3 3
dspahlinger 3 218 250 0.466 0 0.0 0.0 2
urband 6 435 501 0.465 0 0.0 0.0 5
hoopsrus 3 214 254 0.457 0 0.0 0.0 1
darny10 4 283 341 0.454 0.5 0.0 0.5 1
rswift30 3 206 262 0.440 0 0.0 0.0 1
beirnej1 2 137 175 0.439 0 0.0 0.0 1
3dayrotation 10 674 886 0.432 1 0.0 1.0 4
jrig21 1 63 93 0.404 0 0.0 0.0 0
midknight 1 60 96 0.385 0 0.0 0.0 0
10/29/2020 6:39 PM
Cumulative record by draft pick...
.
Pick# WIN LOSS WIN% Best Team Owner League W-L
----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------------------------------------------------- -------------------- --------------- -----------
1 1371 1125 0.549 2019 HOU/NYY/MIN toysboys LG08AL 100-56
2 1341 1155 0.537 2001 Mariners A's Yankees contrarian23 LG07AL 100-56
3 1368 1128 0.548 1993 Barry's Braves-Giants-Phils redcped LG07NL 108-48
4 1231 1265 0.493 1930 A's/Senators/Yankees loyalcanuck LG03AL 89-67
5 1316 1180 0.527 1915 Red Sox Tigers White Sox schwarze LG02AL 102-54
6 1245 1251 0.499 1977 Dodgers Pirates Phillies thejuice6 LG06NL 96-60
7 1219 1277 0.488 1915 PHI/BSN/BRK toysboys LG02NL 89-67
8 1222 1274 0.490 1967 Tigers Twins Red Sox thejuice6 LG05AL 91-65
9 1235 1261 0.495 1906 CHC/NYG/PIT toysboys LG01NL 97-59
10 1134 1362 0.454 1899 Beaneaters, Superbas, Phillies joerat1 LG01AL 90-66
11 1186 1310 0.475 1949 Yankees Indians Red Sox thejuice6 LG04AL 89-67
12 1108 1388 0.444 1931 STL|NYG|CHC steveizzy LG03NL 83-73
10/29/2020 6:41 PM
Here are the top 12 records (not that 13th place is 2 wins behind 12th)...
.
Year League Owner Pick# Team Name WIN LOSS
1993 LG07NL redcped 3 1993 Barry's Braves-Giants-Phils 108 48
1915 LG02AL schwarze 5 1915 Red Sox Tigers White Sox 102 54
1966 LG05NL redcped 5 1966 The Willies' Dodgers-Giants-Pirates 101 55
2001 LG07AL contrarian23 2 2001 Mariners A's Yankees 100 56
2019 LG08AL toysboys 1 2019 HOU/NYY/MIN 100 56
1978 LG06AL pedrocerrano 1 1978 AL - NYY-BOS-MILW 99 57
2005 LG08NL schwarze 2 2005 Cardinals Braves Astros 98 58
1906 LG01NL toysboys 9 1906 CHC/NYG/PIT 97 59
1981 LG06NL contrarian23 3 1981 Reds Dodgers Cardinals 96 60
1977 LG06NL thejuice6 6 1977 Dodgers Pirates Phillies 96 60
1909 LG01NL steveizzy 3 1909 PIT/CHC/NYG 95 61
1909 LG01AL thejuice6 5 1909 Tigers Athletics Americans 94 62
8.5.2
10/29/2020 6:43 PM
Thru 162 games, this is what I have as the top 144 teams... Note that two 74-win teams miss the cut due to tie-breaker...
.
Owner Pick# Team Name WIN LOSS Home RunDiff
redcped 3 1993 Barry's Braves-Giants-Phils 112 50 60-21 245
schwarze 5 1915 Red Sox Tigers White Sox 107 55 50-31 335
redcped 5 1966 The Willies' Dodgers-Giants-Pirates 104 58 59-22 186
toysboys 1 2019 HOU/NYY/MIN 104 58 55-26 199
contrarian23 2 2001 Mariners A's Yankees 103 59 52-29 183
schwarze 2 2005 Cardinals Braves Astros 102 60 51-30 247
pedrocerrano 1 1978 AL - NYY-BOS-MILW 102 60 47-34 243
thejuice6 6 1977 Dodgers Pirates Phillies 100 62 55-26 126
toysboys 9 1906 CHC/NYG/PIT 100 62 49-32 171
contrarian23 3 1981 Reds Dodgers Cardinals 98 64 48-33 178
steveizzy 3 1909 PIT/CHC/NYG 97 65 48-33 152
thejuice6 5 1909 Tigers Athletics Americans 97 65 48-33 137
schwarze 3 1985 Blue Jays Yankees Royals 95 67 48-33 111
jtpsops 3 27 Giant Pirate-eating Cardinals 95 67 38-43 136
thejuice6 8 1967 Tigers Twins Red Sox 94 68 53-28 95
schwarze 3 1912 Red Sox Senators Athletics 94 68 47-34 186
kstober 1 1961 Baltimore Yankeee Tigers 94 68 46-35 128
kstober 1 1946 Boston Yankee Tigers 94 68 44-37 150
joerat1 10 1899 Beaneaters, Superbas, Phillies 93 69 48-33 66
jetscanes 1 1908 Cubs, Pirates & Giants 93 69 45-36 145
pedrocerrano 1 2017 NL - ARIZ-LAD-WASH 93 69 45-36 121
contrarian23 5 1941 Yankees Red Sox White Sox 93 69 42-39 76
contrarian23 1 1998 Braves Astros Padres 92 70 48-33 142
schwarze 8 1933 Giants Pirates Cubs 92 70 47-34 96
njbigwig 1 1994 Cleveland Yankee Sox 92 70 42-39 170
loyalcanuck 4 1930 A's/Senators/Yankees 92 70 40-41 164
thejuice6 5 1921 Giants Pirates Cardinals 92 70 40-41 138
toysboys 6 1982 MIL/BAL/CAL 91 71 48-33 62
pedrocerrano 1 1931 AL Murderer's Row II - NYY-PHL-WASH 91 71 47-34 191
spinaldog 2 99 Braves Astros DBacks 91 71 47-34 82
thejuice6 11 1949 Yankees Indians Red Sox 91 71 45-36 28
toysboys 7 1915 PHI/BSN/BRK 91 71 40-41 12
ybjsports 2 1924 NYC 91 71 39-42 88
kstober 4 2003 Boston Athletic Yankees 90 72 50-31 49
contrarian23 3 1962 Giants Dodgers Reds 90 72 48-33 193
schwarze 2 1975 Reds Pirates Dodgers 90 72 43-38 130
kstober 4 1903 Chicago Giant Pirates 90 72 41-40 115
chisock 5 2019 ATL/LAD/WSH 90 72 41-40 50
loyalcanuck 2 1963 Dodgers/Cardinals/Giants 89 73 46-35 91
contrarian23 11 2008 Cubs Phillies Brewers 89 73 45-36 61
schwarze 1 1953 Dodgers Braves Phillies 89 73 43-38 91
sakabakbrg 8 1942 BOS/NYY/STL 88 74 47-34 109
harrelson 7 1919 White Socked Yankee Native American 88 74 45-36 -19
firesalt 10 1951 Yanks/Sox/Indians 88 74 43-38 51
pedrocerrano 1 1927 AL - Murderer's Row NYY-PHL-WASH 88 74 40-41 97
redcped 1 1985 Doc's Mets-Cards-Dodgers 88 74 39-42 115
redcped 2 1920 Babe's Yankees-Indians-ChiSox 88 74 38-43 99
kstober 4 2006 New York Twin Tigers 88 74 37-44 24
schwarze 2 1901 Pirates Phillies Superbas 87 75 49-32 98
pedrocerrano 2 1969 AL - Moonshot BALT-DET-MINN 87 75 47-34 65
nocomm999 2 1956 NL: The Robinsons 87 75 47-34 57
contrarian23 1 1941 Dodgers Cardinals Reds 87 75 45-36 50
urband 8 1980 NL 87 75 44-37 -5
ybjsports 2 1937 Graham SC 87 75 42-39 104
schwarze 11 1972 Pirates Reds Astros 87 75 42-39 88
toysboys 5 1934 STL/NYG/CHC 87 75 42-39 9
contrarian23 6 1918 Cubs Giants Reds 87 75 40-41 91
toysboys 4 1974 LAD/CIN/ATL 86 76 46-35 0
schwarze 3 1964 Yankees White Sox Orioles 86 76 44-37 120
calhoop 7 Juice 8AL - 2007 86 76 44-37 102
steveizzy 12 1931 STL|NYG|CHC 86 76 44-37 70
contrarian23 3 2011 Yankees Rangers Tigers 86 76 43-38 28
coachgreat1 8 Tribe of Sox Yankers 86 76 42-39 22
nocomm999 7 Bicentennial for Phils-Reds-Bucs 86 76 41-40 82
kstober 8 1911 Cleveland Athletic Tigers 86 76 41-40 68
coachgreat1 4 Giant Cubby Cards 86 76 41-40 43
chisock 9 1969 ATL/CHC/NYM 86 76 40-41 13
kstober 3 1939 Boston Yankee Indians 86 76 39-42 115
relkcirts 3 1930 Cubs/Cardinals/Giants 86 76 39-42 45
contrarian23 6 1953 Yankees Indians White Sox 85 77 45-36 46
redcped 9 1906 Addie's Naps-Highlanders-ChiSox 85 77 43-38 97
darthdurron 5 1907 Cubs/Pirates/Phillies 85 77 43-38 -38
darthdurron 5 1956 Yanks/Indians/White Sox 85 77 42-39 102
hoopsrus 7 St. Louis Showdown (1944) 85 77 42-39 23
darthdurron 9 1934 Yanks/Tigers/Indians 85 77 41-40 -58
schwarze 2 1954 Indians Yankees White Sox 85 77 38-43 12
calhoop 7 Juice 3AL - 1943 84 78 45-36 84
mllama54 6 1973 Red Dodger Giant 84 78 45-36 -21
specsman 6 1995 Cincy Brave Dodgers 84 78 43-38 20
winterhawk 4 1948- Indians,Red Sox,Yankees 84 78 42-39 3
nocomm999 9 Y2K 84 78 41-40 -30
kstober 9 1923 New York Indian Tigers 83 79 44-37 101
urband 3 2016 NL 83 79 44-37 -30
harrelson 7 Brooklyn's Brave Cardinals '57 83 79 42-39 -40
schwarze 5 2004 Yankees Red Sox Twins 83 79 40-41 3
calhoop 10 Juice 6AL - 1980 83 79 40-41 -11
chisock 10 1921 CLE/NYY/STB 83 79 39-42 19
contrarian23 12 1982 Cardinals Braves Phillies 83 79 38-43 16
darthdurron 6 2017 Red Sox/Indians/Astros 83 79 35-46 78
3dayrotation 11 49 NL: Hall of Famers with the Bat 82 80 42-39 43
loyalcanuck 3 1957 Yankees/White Sox/Red Sox 82 80 40-41 59
darthdurron 8 1924 Yanks/Tigers/Senators 82 80 39-42 -12
cardinaldave 11 1923 Pittsinnati Giants 82 80 37-44 39
mllama54 5 1988 Twins Red Sox Athletics 82 80 37-44 15
contrarian23 12 1971 Pirates Giants Cardinals 82 80 36-45 -25
firesalt 7 1913 Big Train no Shoes 81 81 42-39 -38
darthdurron 6 1968 Tigers/Orioles/Indians 81 81 40-41 38
chisock 2 1914 BOS/PHA/WSH 81 81 40-41 -18
toysboys 10 1951 NYG/BRK/STL 81 81 38-43 19
darny10 11 1973 American 80 82 47-34 -46
loyalcanuck 7 2011 Phillies/Brewers/D-Backs 80 82 43-38 -29
redcped 10 2013 Miggy's Tigers-RedSox-A's 80 82 40-41 42
thebubbaq 6 1916 Tiger Pink Sox 80 82 39-42 -37
thejuice6 3 1945 Cubs Dodgers Cardinals 80 82 39-42 -50
dspahlinger 6 1955 Dodgers, Braves, Giants 80 82 36-45 33
ff09 9 EIGHTY9 80 82 36-45 -40
chisock 9 1959 CHW/CLE/NYY 80 82 36-45 -47
thebubbaq 9 2014 Baltimore Angel Sox 80 82 35-46 -12
contrarian23 5 1971 Orioles A's Tigers 79 83 48-33 -31
darthdurron 7 1996 Braves/Padres/Dodgers 79 83 42-39 -17
nocomm999 1 1965 Dodgers-Giants-Pirates 79 83 42-39 -32
thejuice6 12 1995 Yankees Indians Red Sox 79 83 41-40 21
jtpsops 2 35 Giant Cardinal Cubs 79 83 41-40 -20
3dayrotation 4 88 NL: Gibby's HR 79 83 40-41 -12
thejuice6 6 1911 Pirates Giants Cubs 79 83 38-43 -105
contrarian23 11 1928 Yankees A's Browns 79 83 36-45 -11
rswift30 11 1940 Tigers/Yankees/Indians 79 83 36-45 -53
steveizzy 8 2015 STL|PIT|CHC 78 84 45-36 -58
markeking 9 1936 NYG Cubbie Cardinals 78 84 41-40 -28
chisock 11 2005 ANH/CHW/NYY 78 84 41-40 -36
chisock 7 1984 DET/NYY/TOR 78 84 40-41 -86
contrarian23 9 2010 Phillies Giants Braves 78 84 39-42 43
mllama54 8 1997 Yankees Orioles Mariners 78 84 39-42 -76
relkcirts 6 1999 Indians/Rangers/Yankees 78 84 36-45 -27
urband 8 1958 NL 78 84 36-45 -67
contrarian23 11 1992 Braves Pirates Reds 78 84 35-46 -20
redcped 4 1950 Jackie's Dodgers-Giants-Phils 78 84 34-47 -58
thejuice6 6 1932 Yankees Senators Athletics 77 85 43-38 -104
contrarian23 4 1902 A's Browns Americans 77 85 36-45 30
urband 9 2002 AL 77 85 36-45 -16
dspahlinger 3 1998 Yankees, Red Sox, Indians 77 85 34-47 -34
relkcirts 4 1929 A's/Indians/Yankees 76 86 37-44 -70
3dayrotation 8 16 AL: Killer B's in the Outfield 76 86 36-45 -63
contrarian23 9 1954 Giants Dodgers Braves 76 86 34-47 -14
coachgreat1 7 Athletic Tiger-Striped Sox 75 87 37-44 -56
pedrocerrano 12 1902 NL - Pittsburgh-Brooklyn-Boston 75 87 37-44 -84
markeking 10 1963 NYYTwinWhiteSox 75 87 37-44 -137
3dayrotation 5 94 NL: M and M's of 90's Pitching 75 87 32-49 -136
beirnej1 2 2009 Yanks, Bo Sox, Angels 75 87 29-52 -220
darny10 10 1943 National 74 88 41-40 -3
loyalcanuck 12 1905 A's/WhiteSox/Tigers 74 88 40-41 -66
darny10 11 1904 National 74 88 38-43 -63
chisock 6 1939 BRK/CIN/STL 74 88 37-44 -17
thejuice6 10 2009 Phillies Rockies Dodgers 74 88 35-46 -23
10/31/2020 6:35 PM
This is unofficial... thejuice6 has the final say.
8.5.2
10/31/2020 6:37 PM
Advancers to Round 4 by Draft order...
.
Pick# Round 4
----------- -----------
1 14
2 15
3 15
4 11
5 13
6 14
7 12
8 11
9 13
10 9
11 11
12 6
10/31/2020 6:37 PM
And just for fun (and because I still can't believe it), here are the teams that finished with a run differential between 0 and +20 runs, sorted by WINS
.
Owner Pick# Team Name WIN LOSS RunDiff Rank
toysboys 7 1915 PHI/BSN/BRK 91 71 +12 32
toysboys 5 1934 STL/NYG/CHC 87 75 +9 56
chisock 9 1969 ATL/CHC/NYM 86 76 +13 67
toysboys 4 1974 LAD/CIN/ATL 86 76 0 58
schwarze 2 1954 Indians Yankees White Sox 85 77 +12 76
specsman 6 1995 Cincy Brave Dodgers 84 78 +20 79
winterhawk 4 1948- Indians,Red Sox,Yankees 84 78 +3 80
chisock 10 1921 CLE/NYY/STB 83 79 +19 87
contrarian23 12 1982 Cardinals Braves Phillies 83 79 +16 88
schwarze 5 2004 Yankees Red Sox Twins 83 79 +3 85
mllama54 5 1988 Twins Red Sox Athletics 82 80 +15 94
toysboys 10 1951 NYG/BRK/STL 81 81 +19 99
schwarze 4 2002 Braves D'backs Cardinals 69 93 +15 171
.
Seriously. WTF?
10/31/2020 6:42 PM
If I displayed this same table except listed teams with -1 to -59 run differential, there would be 47 teams listed, the average wins would be 78.8 wins, and the worst team would have 70 wins.
8.5.2
10/31/2020 6:46 PM
12 Next ▸

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.