Best Year To Be Born $100M [FULL] Topic

I've been looking for a format for a league that uses more, different players, and I don't remember this one being tried before.

Each owner will be assigned a random year between 1857 and 2000, and build a $100M team from players born in that year. So, everyone's got their own different player pool to choose from. They're not all equal, but with the salary cap, if you draw a tougher year, you just look for more cookie players and hope to pull off an upset. Building your team will take a bit of research, but you don't have to wait on other owners, so hopefully we should get going fairly quickly.

Other rules:
No AAA, no trades, no WW - you play with your own 25 unique players.
Yes to DH, because there are plenty of hitters, and you're bound to be overstocked at some position
Injuries ON.

For home field, everyone should select a MANAGER that was born in your given year [they are conveniently listed at the bottom of your birth year page on Baseball Reference], and choose a stadium where he managed. If there was NO manager born in your designated year, select any player born that year as your manager [whether he's a player-manager or not], and use a stadium where he played.

I chose 1857-2000 because that's 144 years, and if this is popular, I'd hope to use every one of them over six seasons, plus a Tournament of Champions at the end for the final four playoff teams from each league. Not sure how many will participate in all six seasons - there's no obligation to do so - but if you do, we will include you in the ToC, even if it's with a team that someone else guided to the playoffs.

Instead of the draw being completely random each season, we'll group them by birth year, so that the ToC isn't dominated by one era of the game. The groups:

Group A: 1857-1880 birth years
Group B: 1881-1904
Group C: 1905-1928
Group D: 1929-1952
Group E: 1953-1976
Group F: 1977-2000

But we'll do these six randomly. Whoever signs up first should generate a random season for MY team [anywhere between 1857-2000], and then I will generate the seasons for everyone who signs up, based on which group my team falls into.

Want a sample of what happens? Here's my own birth year [1961]
www.baseball-reference.com/leagues/majors/1961-births.shtml

C: Bob Melvin, Mark Salas
1B: Don Mattingly, Andrews Galarraga, Glenn Davis. [that's why we have a DH]
2B: Curt Wilkerson, Rafael Belliard
SS: Greg Gagne, Spike Owen
3B: Steve Buechele, Jack Howell, Jim Presley
OF: John Kruk, Vince Coleman, Mike Aldrete
SP: Jimmy Key, Tim Belcher, Storm Davis, Scott Garrelts, Steve Ontiveros
RP; Rick Aguilera, Mike Henneman, Billy Taylor

Okay, I probably wouldn't win anything with those guys, but who knows? Every team will have some stars, and every team will have a hole or two to fill. Young teams can load up on bullpen arms. Let's give it a try.

Who wants to assign me a year and get this going?
4/26/2025 4:06 PM (edited)
Owners and seasons assigned:

1929 tdoak 2nd team
1930 joerat1
1931 tdoak
1932 Ribbentrop
1933 buckleslie
1934 zephyr1949
1935 mensu1954 second team
1936 contrarian23
1937 ybjsports
1938 whalers10
1939 strubrosll
1940 mensu1954
1941 bixman51
1942 rattlers
1943 2chair
1944 razorclams
1945 vilefileman
1946 Bill_James47
1947 jkorn11
1948 Boddicker
1949 bbondsmvp
1950 holleybard
1951 dhomard
1952 _JJP_

Owner list: tdoak;joerat1;Ribbentrop;buckleslie;zephyr1949;contrarian23;ybjsports;whalers10;strubrosll;mensu1954;bixman51;rattlers;2chair;razorclams;vilefileman;Bill_James47;jkorn11;Boddicker;bbondsmvp;holleybard;dhomard;_JJP_
5/8/2025 8:14 AM (edited)
I'll play.

Your random season is:

Here are your random numbers:

1931

Timestamp: 2025-04-26 13:50:07 UTC

Not bad...you get Mays, Mantle, Banks, Bunning, Eddie Mathews....

4/26/2025 9:51 AM
I'll play
4/26/2025 11:02 AM
I will play
4/26/2025 11:11 AM
Posted by contrarian23 on 4/26/2025 9:51:00 AM (view original):
I'll play.

Your random season is:

Here are your random numbers:

1931

Timestamp: 2025-04-26 13:50:07 UTC

Not bad...you get Mays, Mantle, Banks, Bunning, Eddie Mathews....

contrarian:

Thanks for starting us off -- and giving me the great draw! This puts our first season in Group D.

Here's a season back for you:

Here are your random numbers:

1936

Timestamp: 2025-04-26 15:32:47 UTC

4/26/2025 11:33 AM
Posted by _JJP_ on 4/26/2025 11:02:00 AM (view original):
I'll play
You're in:

Here are your random numbers:

1952

Timestamp: 2025-04-26 15:33:33 UTC

4/26/2025 11:34 AM
Posted by Ribbentrop on 4/26/2025 11:11:00 AM (view original):
I will play
Owner #4:

Here are your random numbers:

1932

Timestamp: 2025-04-26 15:34:29 UTC

4/26/2025 11:35 AM
Put me in please
4/26/2025 11:49 AM
Ouch...36 is tough - not much pitching other than Drysdale. A couple of mashers though...let's see how Killebrew and Hondo Howard can do.
4/26/2025 11:59 AM
Posted by jkorn11 on 4/26/2025 11:49:00 AM (view original):
Put me in please
You're in:

Here are your random numbers:

1947

Timestamp: 2025-04-26 16:05:31 UTC

4/26/2025 12:06 PM
1932 --- At First look did not recognize many Pitchers thinking they might start in 1952 or something but do have Johnny Podres (!?) And 3 or 4 Usable RP at $100M ... Noticed at once Maury Wills Player and Manager
4/26/2025 12:45 PM
I'll give this a try.
4/26/2025 1:06 PM
Posted by mensu1954 on 4/26/2025 1:06:00 PM (view original):
I'll give this a try.
Here's your draw:

Here are your random numbers:

1940

Timestamp: 2025-04-26 17:26:49 UTC

4/26/2025 1:28 PM
Posted by Ribbentrop on 4/26/2025 12:47:00 PM (view original):
1932 --- At First look did not recognize many Pitchers thinking they might start in 1952 or something but do have Johnny Podres (!?) And 3 or 4 Usable RP at $100M ... Noticed at once Maury Wills Player and Manager
I am enjoying the build so far. Even with all the stars I drew, winning is going to require some role players and the search for them has been interesting.
4/26/2025 1:30 PM
12345 Next ▸
Best Year To Be Born $100M [FULL] Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.