2025 PCL Keepers and Cuts Topic

gonoles777
Posts: 12252 (0)
Hall of Famer
984
Rookie
This is the Keeper/cut thread for the 2025 PCL (Progressive Century League)
**** You may keep up to 20 players ****
Keepers should be posted as soon as possible if possible ;)
To compensate for the number of low inning pitchers in this "modern era" as well as the number of position players with lower plate appearances, we will have a 8 round AAA draft of after the regular draft...this is also an opportunity for "prospect fishing"...remember that these players can be keepers for 2026 but count toward your maximum total of 20 keepers...UNLIKE IN THE PAST, you may select 4 pitchers AND 4 position players in the AAA draft

Also remember that you can only start a player at a position for which he is rated for in 2025...so keep track of sufficient PA's by position as you are choosing your keepers and planning your draft picks

Also remember that both the NL and the AL use the DH

To qualify for one of the first 4 picks in the 2026 draft, you must have won at least 40 games in the 2025 season
10/3/2025 10:19 AM
gonoles777
Posts: 12252 (0)
Hall of Famer
984
Rookie
2025 Cleveland Coasters - 17 keepers

C - Hunter Goodman, Gabriel Moreno

1B - Yandy Diaz, Spencer Horwitz

2B -

3B - Ernie Clement

SS -

OF - Yordan Alvarez, Michael Harris II, Lawrence Butler, Nathan Lukes, Victor Scott

DH -

Ps - Michael Wacha, Aaron Ashby, Brandon Pfaadt, Ronel Blanco, Yariel Rodriguez, Dennis Santana, David Bednar

I/R - Scott Kingery OF, Livan Soto 2B, Julian Merryweather P, Hunrter Strickland P, Coooper Criswell P, Braxton Garrett P

Cut - Adrian Del Castillo C, Amed Rosario 3B, Adolis Garcia OF, David Fry DH, Kevin Newman 2B, Matt Vierling OF, Cris Flexen P, Julio Teheran P, Tyler Megill P, Tristan Beck P, Justin Topa P, Blake Treinen P, Jason Foley P, Dylan Lee P, Colin Holderman P, Ryan Borucki P, Ryan Thompson P, Cade Povich P

Trades - None
10/20/2025 5:05 AM (edited)
dn3524
Posts: 8974 (0)
Hall of Famer
1536 7
Rookie
2025 BALTIMORE COLTS - 20 keepers

C - Shea Langeliers

1B -

2B - Brandon Lowe

3B - Alex Bregman

SS - Corey Seager

OF - Corbin Carroll, Ian Happ

DH - Giancarlo Stanton, Colt Keith

P - Logan Gilbert, Jesus Luzardo, Jack Flaherty, Kenley Jansen, Aroldis Chapman, Matt Strahm, Edwin Diaz, Jose Quintana, Jose Soriano, Justin Verlander, Gavin Williams, Edwin Uceta

I/R - Manny Pina (c), Joe Musgrove (p), Kutter Crawford (p), Trevor Rosenthal (p), Touki Toussaint (p)

Cut - Heston Kjerstad (of), Mitch Garver (c), Triston Casas (1b), Mark Vientos (3b), Tommy Edman (2b), Otto Lopez (ss), Marcell Ozuna (dh), Ryan Helsley (p), Ryan Fernandez (p), Dustin May (p), Fernando Cruz (p)

Retired - Yasmani Grandal (c)
10/3/2025 12:44 PM (edited)
CarrDoor
Posts: 205 (0)
Hall of Famer
109 1
Prospect

2025 New York Wu-Tangs - 20 keepers

C - Salvador Perez

1B -

2B - Gleyber Torres,

3B - Junior Caminero, Matt Chapman

SS - Xavier Edwards

OF - Pete Crow-Armstrong, Fernando Tatis Jr, Christian Yelich, Sal Frelick, Tyler Soderstrom, James Wood

Ps - Hunter Brown, Cole Ragans, Zack Littell, Andres Munoz, Luis Castillo, Nick Lodolo, Carlos Esteves, Robbie Ray, Adrian Morejon

Injured Reserve - Gavin Stone (P)

10/3/2025 1:48 PM
specsman
Posts: 14435 (2)
Hall of Famer
5209 252 1
Veteran
2025 Atlanta Falcons - 20 keepers

C - Francisco Alvarez Jose Trevino

1B - Ty France, Pavin Smith

2B - Miguel Rojas, Matt McLain

3B - Gio Urshela, Caleb Durbin

SS - Jared Triolo

OF - Tommy Pham, Cody Bellinger, Tyrone Taylor, Austin Martin, Jake Mangum

DH -

Ps - Paul Skenes, Merrill Kelly, Brady Singer, Walker Buehler, Lius Ortiz, Ryne Nelson, Mitchell Parker, Luis L Ortiz, Jacob deGrom, Chris Paddack, Brayden Smith

Cuts - 1B Donovan/ Solano, 1B Joc Pederson, 1B Jonah Bride, C Travis d'Arnaud, 3B Josh Rojas, 3B Andy Ibanez, P Chalie Morton, P Yuki Matsui

Retired - none

IR - Evan Marshall, John Gant, Spencer Watkins, Lance McCullers,, Brad Boxberger, Austin Nola, CJ Cron, Matt McLain, Harold Castro, Jesse Scholters, Jacob deGrom, H Ryu,
11/1/2025 10:43 AM (edited)
specsman
Posts: 14435 (2)
Hall of Famer
5209 252 1
Veteran
2025 DeTroit Tigers - 20 keepers

C - Wilson Contreras

1B - Wilmer Flores, Michael Toglia

2B - Jorge Polanco, Ketel Marte, DJ LeMeheiu

3B -

SS - Ha Kim, Zach Neto

OF - Riley Greene, Mickey Moniak, Jackson Merrill

Ps - Tyler Anderson, David Peterson, Geo. Kirby, Jhoan Duran, JP Sears, Ryan Walker, Logan Allen, Tanner Bibee, Cade Smith

Cuts - OF Jhonkensy Noel, 2B Leo Rivas, P Cal Quantrill, P Ben Brown

Retired - none

IR - Kevan Smith, Nicky Lopez, Garrett Cooper, Jr Guerra, Jimmy Nelson, Frank Schwindel, Antonio Senzatela, Wil Myers, Brad Keller, Giovanny Gallegos, Jose Miranda, Leo Jimenez
10/17/2025 10:59 AM (edited)
CarrDoor
Posts: 205 (0)
Hall of Famer
109 1
Prospect
Posted by specsman on 10/3/2025 1:53:00 PM (view original):
2025 Atlanta Falcons - keepers

C - Francisco Alvarez

1B -

2B - Andy Ibanez

3B - Gio Urshela, Donovan Solano, Jared Triolo

SS - Miguel Rojas

OF - Tommy Pham, Cody Bellinger, Tyrone Taylor

DH - Joc Pederson

Ps - Charlie Morton, Merrill Kelly, Brady Singer, Walker Buehler, Lius Ortiz, Ryne Nelson

Cuts -

Retired -

IR - Evan Marshall, John Gant, Spencer Watkins, Lance McCullers,, Brad Boxberger, Austin Nola, CJ Cron, Matt McLain, Harold Castro, Jesse Scholters, Jacob deGrom, H Ryu,
deGrom had an awesome year. Do not IR him lol
10/3/2025 2:02 PM
Sonofodin52
Posts: 1306 (2)
Hall of Famer
1100 2 427
Prospect
Milwaukee will keep 18
C Alejandro Kirk
C Carson Kelly
1B Luis Arraez
DH Rafael Devers
3B Gunnar Henderson
OF Randy Arozarena
OF Selya Suzuki
OF Jarren Duran
SS C.J. Abrams
SS Willy Adames
P Nick Pivetta,
P Yu Darvish
P Hoby Milner
P Logan Webb
P Colin Rea
P Tanner Scott
Luke Weaver
Lucas Erceg

Drops
OF Will Brennan
P Nick Sandlin
P Colin Poche
2b Ronny Mauricio
P Tyler Wells
P Orion Kerkering
OF Willi Castro
P Tyler Anderson

I/R Jared Jones
10/3/2025 5:04 PM (edited)
Tammyk
Posts: 10118 (3)
Hall of Famer
1046
Veteran
2025 Boston Pilgrims -
Keepers 17
Need - 8

C - Will Smith, William Contreras

1B - Spencer Torkelson

2B - Jackson Holliday, Jazz Chisholm

3B - Jordan Westburg

SS - Jeremy Pena

OF - Mike Trout, Lars Nootbaar, Alec Burleson, Ceddanne Rafaela, Kerry Carpenter

DH/Util -

Ps - Blake Snell, Max Fried, Corbin Burnes, Shane Baz, Simeon Woods-Richardson,


I/R - Zach Plesac, Alex Cobb, Shane McClanahan, A.J. Minter, Jose Urquidy Robert Stephenson, DJ Herz, Spencer Turnbull, Bryan Hoeing, Jace Jung

Cut - Johan Oviedo Tim Herring, Brant HurterJake McCarthy Cristian Javier, Tyler O’Neill, Yanier Cano, Jeff Hoffman Pedro Pages, Brooks Lee, Joey Lucchesi Matt Brash, Sean Manaea, Trevor Megill, Kyle Leahy, Tyler Mahle

traded Trout to San Francisco for Brandon Marsh and 2026 2nd round pick
11/28/2025 7:59 PM (edited)
Tammyk
Posts: 10118 (3)
Hall of Famer
1046
Veteran
Miami -
Keepers 16
Need - 9


C - Austin Wells,

1B - Matt Olson

2B -

3B - Austin Riley

SS - Francisco Lindor, Jacob Wilson

OF - Juan Soto, Wyatt Langford, Andy Pages

DH -

Ps - , Freddy Peralta, Zac Gallen, Emmanuel Clase, Jason Adam, Jeffrey Springs, Andrew Abbott, Gabe Speier, Andrew Kittredge

Cuts/ Retired - John Curtiss, Tanner Houck, Nestor Cortes, Reece Olson, Kelbert Ruiz, Brendan Rodgers, Luis Robert, Josh Lowe, Parker Meadows, Nolan Gorman, Tyler Fitzgerald, Christian Encarnacion-Strand, Daniel Lynch, JoJo Romero, Ryan Weathers, Connor Norby, Drew Thorpe, Cole Sands

I/R - Liam Hendriks, Adam Kolarek, Brusdar Graterol, Mike Clevinger, Kyle Wright, Zack Thompson, Rhett Lowder
10/4/2025 11:34 AM (edited)
mark102857
Posts: 5091 (0)
Hall of Famer
766 270 46 322
Rookie
Chitown White Sox
Keep - 18
Need - 7 + AAA

KEEPERS
C - Ryan Jeffers, Christian Vazquez
1B - Ryan Mountcastle, Carlos Santana
2B - Andres Gimenez, Edmundo Sosa
3B - Paul DeJong, Eugenio Suarez
SS -
OF - Aaron Judge, Mike Yastrzemski, Brent Rooker
P - Clay Holmes, Michael Lorenzen, Yusei Kikuchi, Griffin Canning, Bailey Falter, Jose Urena, Jared Koenig

I/R
C - Kory Lee
P - Kyle Gibson, Drew Smyly, Rick Farmer, James Paxton, Alec Marsh, Jason Foley, Beau Brieske, Jon Gray

CUTS
2B - Richie Palacios
SS - Max Schuemann
OF - Anthony Santander, Jared Kelenic
P - Kirby Yates, Taylor Scott
10/16/2025 1:18 PM (edited)
mark102857
Posts: 5091 (0)
Hall of Famer
766 270 46 322
Rookie
St Louis Wannabees
Keep - 19
Need - 6 + AAA

KEEPERS
C - JT Realmuto, Jonah Heim
1B - Pete Alonso, Josh Bell
2B - Jose Altuve, Jeff McNeil, Lenya Sosa
3B - Isaac Paredes
SS - JP Crawford, Bobby Witt Jr
OF - Taylor Ward
P - Chris Bassett, Andrew Heaney, MacKenzie Gore, Spencer Schwellenbach, Trevor Rogers, Ben Lively, Edward Cabrera, Mike Soroka

I/R
OF - Jesse Winker
P - Josh Winckowski, Joey Estes, Pedro Avila

CUTS
C - Jake Rogers
OF - Randall Grichuk, Alex Verdugo, Jacob Young, Britt Wisely
P - Joel Payamps, Bryce Wilson, Carson Fulmer, Trent Thornton, Hayben Wesneski
10/5/2025 3:36 PM
fillies
Posts: 1951 (0)
Hall of Famer
361
Pro
Philadelphia Stars
KEEPERS 20

C Luis Torrens
1B Nathaniel Lowe
2B Marcus Semien
3B Max Muncy
SS Ezequiel Tovar
OF George Springer,Mookie Betts,Heliot Ramos,Jasson Dominquez,Bryon Buxton
P Ranger Suarez,Aaron Nola,Dylan Cease,Tyler Glasnow,Drew Rasmussen,Tony Santillan,Ryan Pepiot,Will Vest,Matthew Boyd,Grant Holmes

IR Julio Urias,Alex Faedo,Dedniel Nunez,Tony Yepez

CUTS Emerson Hancock,Griffin Jax,Osvaldo Bido,Mark Leiter,Kevin Kelly,Jacob Stallings,Ben Rortvedt,Luke Raley,Rafael Marchan,Joey Ortiz
10/6/2025 7:38 AM
cheyenne2
Posts: 1738 (0)
Hall of Famer
206
Prospect
2025 Chicago Cubbies
Keepers - 13
IR - 10
Need - 12

C - Cal Raleigh
1B - Christian Walker
2B - Nico Hoerner
3B -Isiah Kiner-Falefa
SS - Elly De La Cruz
OF - Julio Rodriguez, Brendan Donovan, T.J. Friedl, Trevor Larnach

P - Hunter Greene, Shoja Iminaga, Shane Bieber, Tim Hill

IR - Ian Anderson p, Glenn Otto p, Ken Waldichuk p, Derek Law p, Justin Martinez p, David Robertson p, Sam Moll p, Eli Morgan p, Joe Jimenez p, Yimi Garcia p

Cuts - Tyler Stephenson c, Nick Castellanos of, JJ Bleday of, Robrefsnyder of, Garrett Mitchell of, Weston wilson of, Pavin Smith 1b, Aaron Civale p, Tyler Holten p, Austin Gomber p, Mitch Spence p, Porter Hodge p, Nabil Crismatt p, Trevor Williams p, Bowden Francis p, Devin Smeltzer p
10/6/2025 1:00 PM
MVW
Posts: 843 (0)
Hall of Famer
74 1
Prospect
2025 DC Nationals
Need 5

Keepers
C Bo Naylor
1B Freddy Freeman
2B Ozzie Albies
SS Trea Turner
3B Josh Jung
3B Royce Lewis
OF Evan Carter
OF Steven Kwan
OF Jake Meyers
DH Shohei Ohtani
P Sandy Alcantara
P Kyle Bradish
P Yusei Kikuchi
P Michael King
P Seth Lugo
P Mason Miller
P Eury Perez
P Robert Suarez
P Framber Valdez
P Bryan Woo

IR
2B Nicky Lopez
P Cody Bradford
P Robert Gasser
P Bobby Miller
P Grayson Rodriguez

Cuts
C Sean Murphy
1B LaMonte Wade
2B Nick Gonzalez
3B Oswaldo Cabrera
OF Dylan Crews
OF Nolan Jones
OF Blake Perkins
P Ryan Brasier
P Huascar Brazoban
P Tobias Myers
10/6/2025 6:32 PM
12 Next ▸
2025 PCL Keepers and Cuts Topic
△Top△Bottom

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.