Posted by tangplay on 11/28/2021 2:10:00 AM (view original):
If you want to claim that the Crusades were righteous because the Muslims didn't have a right to Jerusalem, that's a bit more justifiable, I guess, but the idea that the Crusades were to defend Europe from an Islamic invasion is just flatly false.
I'm genuinely curious where you got this idea from
I've said it was hyperbole.
There was never a true threat to "all of Europe". The Muslim conquests came to a halt in France once they began encountering larger and better equipped armies.
However, Muslim aggression and conquest didn't just halt entirely. They continued to attempt conquest throughout much of modern day Spain and even much more so in the Mediterranean region. By the time of the first crusades the Muslims had conquered nearly 2/3 of the ancient Christian world (most notable exception being Europe). The final straw was when they banned Christians from entering Jerusalem, the Holy city Christians would regularly make pilgrimage to.
Now, it has to also be made clear that from the very beginning (almost immediately after the first Christian churches emerged - Apostolic Age) the Romans actively persecuted Christians. It's spread was much more organic, but eventually (beginning in the 4th century or so) Rome adopted Christianity as it's own "State Religion".
This is where the Roman Catholic Church, began to really grow in power and authority. Conversion was accomplished by force and did not resemble early proselytizing. By this time the "religion" was more a tool used as a club to "convert" the "heathens", rather than espousing the gentle teachings of a loving Christ. With this new found authority and backing power of the greatest empire at the time, Christianity (at least in name if not in spirit) experienced a huge growth spurt.
Even at this tender age (from say 400 - 700) there was LOTS of in-fighting, struggles for power & persecution of the "heretics" who didn't conform to the Roman definition, appropriation and codification of Christianity.
11/28/2021 1:21 PM (edited)