Savage II Commentary Thread Topic

given that my lone remaining playoff team is matched up against tarheel1991, I'm not exactly filled with confidence
10/14/2020 6:18 AM
Posted by 20ks on 10/14/2020 6:16:00 AM (view original):
albiband0 mentioning he beat pexetera's 52 win team in the Savage III sign up thread got me to thinking. Here's how I did against each of you:

10-2 (.833) vs jpevans31
12-4 (.750) vs albiband0
15-8 (.652) vs amerk1180
11-6 (.647) vs jcred5
8-5 (.615) vs jhsukow
14-9 (.609) vs ysw128
12-10 (.546) vs dskantor
9-8 (.529) vs ashamael
13-12 (.520) vs pharrop
11-11 (.500) vs gerryred
10-12 (.455) vs robusk
7-9 (.438) vs pexetera
8-11 (.421) vs cmcafeeky
5-7 (.417) vs goetz93
7-10 (.412) vs mptrey
9-15 (.375) vs benhoidal
6-10 (.375) vs longtallbrad
6-11 (.353) vs dh555
6-11 (.353) vs mikee1
5-11 (.313) vs bds9992
4-9 (.308) vs dBKC
3-9 (.250) vs 24kpyrite
4-15 (.211) vs tarheel1991

Maybe my Savage 3 team names should be have a "cupcake" theme....
10/14/2020 8:46 AM
I believe I should have 12 first round points. One series win and two byes
10/14/2020 10:40 AM
@bds. the playoffs are 2 points per win, as opposed to the regular season which is 1 point per win. Therefore, the one series win you have is represented by the 8 points under "1st round points so far" For the two first round byes you were given 16 points which is was already added to your end of regular season total and already represented in the 249 points under "points entering 1st round" column. Your new point total entering the 2nd round of 257 is correct. Please double check my math and add your regular season wins and then add 24 points for your 3 teams that made it past the 1st round.
10/14/2020 11:14 AM
OK, yeah, makes sense. For some reason I was under the impression that playoff wins were still one point and byes were four
10/14/2020 11:49 AM
Final Rank Owner Points Entering 1st Round 1st Round Points Points Entering 2nd Round Remaining Playoff Teams Worlds
pexetera 310 4 314 4 1,3,4,5
dBKC 272 16 288 4 1,2,3,5
mptrey 250 38 288 4 1,2,4,5
dh555 259 259 3 1,2,3
bds9992 249 8 257 3 1,2,5
ashamael 230 20 250 2 1,4
24kpyrite 234 14 248 1 2
longtallbrad 226 20 246 2 2,3
gerryred 225 20 245 2 4,5
pharrop 230 12 242 2 2,5
benhoidal 217 20 237 2 3,5
tarheel1991 224 8 232 2 2,4
cmcafeeky 214 10 224 1 3
robusk 204 14 218 1 3
amerk1180 205 6 211 1 1
dskantor 209 209 2 4,5
20ks 195 10 205 1 4
mikee1 194 8 202 1 3
jcred5 197 197 1 4
goetz93 181 8 189 1 1
21 jhsukow 173 0 173 0
22 ysw128 158 158 0
23 jpevans31 140 140 0
24 albiband0 124 124 0
10/15/2020 2:26 PM
11 teams technically with a chance to win it all. 3 realistically.
10/15/2020 2:43 PM
Correct me if I'm mistaken, but doesn't it just come down to matchups in each world at this point?
10/15/2020 2:48 PM
I won my first Savage League playoff series!
10/15/2020 2:51 PM
should be a deciding round. dBKC and mptrey are even going into the 2nd round.
dBKC and dh555 face off 2x in worlds 1 and 2.
mptrey and bds9992 face off 2x in worlds 1 and 2.
ash and pex face off 2x in worlds 1 and 4.
10/15/2020 2:53 PM
Final Rank Owner Points Entering 2nd Round 2nd Round Points so far New Point Total Remaining Playoff Teams Worlds
pexetera 314 314 4 1,3,4,5
dBKC 288 288 4 1,2,3,5
mptrey 288 288 4 1,2,4,5
dh555 259 259 3 1,2,3
bds9992 257 257 3 1,2,5
ashamael 250 250 2 1,4
24kpyrite 248 248 1 2
longtallbrad 246 246 2 2,3
gerryred 245 245 2 4,5
pharrop 242 242 2 2,5
benhoidal 237 237 2 3,5
tarheel1991 232 232 2 2,4
cmcafeeky 224 224 1 3
robusk 218 218 1 3
amerk1180 211 211 1 1
dskantor 209 209 2 4,5
20ks 205 205 1 4
mikee1 202 202 1 3
jcred5 197 197 1 4
goetz93 189 189 1 1
21 jhsukow 173 173 0
22 ysw128 158 158 0
23 jpevans31 140 140 0
24 albiband0 124 124 0
10/15/2020 2:55 PM
Posted by bds9992 on 10/15/2020 2:48:00 PM (view original):
Correct me if I'm mistaken, but doesn't it just come down to matchups in each world at this point?
I think so. Even if you have 4 teams in the playoffs, your #4 could be going up against someone else's #1. Our best teams are not all going head to head. It's a minefield.

I think it's hard for someone who gets 5 teams in the playoffs to win a league because the only way you get 5 teams in the playoffs is if you divide your talent, but then it's very difficult to beat someone else's best team who didn't divide their talent as evenly. That's why I voted for the 20 points bonus if you get 5 teams in.

if the points leader gets 5 teams in the playoffs and gets the 20 point bonus, then you would most likely need to win 2 championships to overcome that. and then I would say if you win 2 out of 5 leagues then you should probably be crowned the king anyway.
10/15/2020 7:47 PM (edited)
Thank you tar, agreed
10/15/2020 3:13 PM
Final Rank Owner Points Entering 2nd Round 2nd Round Points so far New Point Total Remaining Playoff Teams Worlds
pexetera 314 12 326 4 1,3,4,5
dBKC 288 12 300 4 1,2,3,5
mptrey 288 8 296 4 1,2,4,5
dh555 259 8 267 3 1,2,3
bds9992 257 14 271 3 1,2,5
ashamael 250 6 256 2 1,4
24kpyrite 248 6 254 1 2
longtallbrad 246 6 252 2 2,3
gerryred 245 8 253 2 4,5
pharrop 242 2 244 2 2,5
benhoidal 237 6 243 2 3,5
tarheel1991 232 8 240 2 2,4
cmcafeeky 224 4 228 1 3
robusk 218 2 220 1 3
amerk1180 211 4 215 1 1
dskantor 209 6 215 2 4,5
20ks 205 2 207 1 4
mikee1 202 2 204 1 3
jcred5 197 2 199 1 4
goetz93 189 2 191 1 1
21 jhsukow 173 0 173 0
22 ysw128 158 158 0
23 jpevans31 140 140 0
24 albiband0 124 124 0
10/17/2020 2:00 PM
Thanks for keeping it close enough where I can pretend that I have a shot, Pex
10/17/2020 2:19 PM
◂ Prev 1...121|122|123|124|125...132 Next ▸
Savage II Commentary Thread Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.