Quote: Originally Posted By zhawks on 3/11/2010Go figure, you missed every single point brought up in this thread so far. It has a lot of meaning to recruiting.

(Fail, once again, on your part for not understanding HD, yet speaking as if you do

I understand its benefits, however since it has ZERO recruiting value as you say, then its WAY overpriced and should at max only cost $100. Let's face it though, this part of the game is largely irrelevant. Give the players what they want and they'll stay, period.

Quote: Originally Posted By colonels19 on 3/11/2010

Quote: Originally Posted By zhawks on 3/11/2010
Go figure, you missed every single point brought up in this thread so far. It has a lot of meaning to recruiting.

(Fail, once again, on your part for not understanding HD, yet speaking as if you do)

I understand its benefits, however since it has ZERO recruiting value as you say, then its WAY overpriced and should at max only cost $100. Let's face it though, this part of the game is largely irrelevant. Give the players what they want and they'll stay, period

Again, until you have done recruiting at every single level in HD, you can not speak to this. Your belief is based on no knowledge what-so-ever and because of that it is false. There is a ton of benefit from them, ones that you can't understand because you have not experianced them.

Quote: Originally Posted By colonels19 on 3/11/2010

Quote: Originally Posted By zhawks on 3/11/2010
Go figure, you missed every single point brought up in this thread so far. It has a lot of meaning to recruiting.

(Fail, once again, on your part for not understanding HD, yet speaking as if you do)

I understand its benefits, however since it has ZERO recruiting value as you say, then its WAY overpriced and should at max only cost $100. Let's face it though, this part of the game is largely irrelevant. Give the players what they want and they'll stay, period.

ahahahhhaahhaahldhfhhahahahahahahahaahah omg. really? Really? colonels you're an idiot. You clearly show, yet again, how much you don't understand about HD.

(Also you lack of reading comprehension skills show greatly)

Quote: Originally Posted By zhawks on 3/11/2010

Quote: Originally Posted By colonels19 on 3/11/2010

Quote: Originally Posted By zhawks on 3/11/2010
Go figure, you missed every single point brought up in this thread so far. It has a lot of meaning to recruiting.

(Fail, once again, on your part for not understanding HD, yet speaking as if you do)

I understand its benefits, however since it has ZERO recruiting value as you say, then its WAY overpriced and should at max only cost $100. Let's face it though, this part of the game is largely irrelevant. Give the players what they want and they'll stay, period.

Again, until you have done recruiting at every single level in HD, you can not speak to this. Your belief is based on no knowledge what-so-ever and because of that it is false. There is a ton of benefit from them, ones that you can't understand because you have not experianced them

I literally laughed at this. If there's ZERO recruiting value and its just going to tell you how likely the guy is to stay on your team or rat you out for booster gifts, then I'm never using it and its basically irrelevant and the cost seems 1500% too high. I don't see exactly how repeating the information you've said is "false"

Quote: Originally Posted By zhawks on 3/11/2010

Quote: Originally Posted By colonels19 on 3/11/2010

Quote: Originally Posted By zhawks on 3/11/2010
Go figure, you missed every single point brought up in this thread so far. It has a lot of meaning to recruiting.

(Fail, once again, on your part for not understanding HD, yet speaking as if you do)

I understand its benefits, however since it has ZERO recruiting value as you say, then its WAY overpriced and should at max only cost $100. Let's face it though, this part of the game is largely irrelevant. Give the players what they want and they'll stay, period.

ahahahhhaahhaahldhfhhahahahahahahahaahah omg. really? Really? colonels you're an idiot. You clearly show, yet again, how much you don't understand about HD

And you like to tout me as a name-caller, but somehow its ok for you to do....classy...

Quote: Originally Posted By colonels19 on 3/11/2010

Quote: Originally Posted By zhawks on 3/11/2010
Again, until you have done recruiting at every single level in HD, you can not speak to this. Your belief is based on no knowledge what-so-ever and because of that it is false. There is a ton of benefit from them, ones that you can't understand because you have not experianced them.

I literally laughed at this. If there's ZERO recruiting value and its just going to tell you how likely the guy is to stay on your team or rat you out for booster gifts, then I'm never using it and its basically irrelevant and the cost seems 1500% too high. I don't see exactly how repeating the information you've said is "false

You are dense. You aren't understanding anything (likely not even reading it) of what I have said. You haven't ever recruited at d1 have you? Game, set match me. (for so many reasons that even beginning to try and explain to you would be a waste of my time because a) you wouldn't understand and b) you wouldn't even try to).

Colonels, these are used almost exclusively at d1, since you have not ever coached at d1 you don't understand their use and therefore you do not have the knowledge required to, not only understand them but also understand their use and because of this your argument here doesn't even come close to holding water.

You don't have an argument because you do not have the knowledge that is required to judge these.

Give the players what they want and they'll stay, period - That comment is false. Anyone with half a brain would tell you that.

If there's ZERO recruiting value - Again, also false. While there is 0 direct recruiting value, there is very much so an indirect value that is very useful.

Zach, coach_billyg among others said that a personality test tells you 2 things...the likelyhood a guy will leave your team, and the likelyhood he will rat you out for booster gifts....for $1500 and no recruiting value, that's an incredible rip-off for something that I don't see a great value in using in the first place. If the recruiting value is 0...why is this even in recruiting? Its just WIS getting "cutesy" and its overdone, and relatively irrelevant...the highest level you've coached at doesn't matter either.

If you spend $1500 recruiting bucks for this, then you're an idiot...note how I'm not calling any one person an idiot, unlike yourself.

Quote: Originally Posted By zhawks on 3/11/2010
Colonels, these are used almost exclusively at d1, since you have not ever coached at d1 you don't understand their use and therefore you do not have the knowledge required to, not only understand them but also understand their use and because of this your argument here doesn't even come close to holding water.

You don't have an argument because you do not have the knowledge that is required to judge these.

Give the players what they want and they'll stay, period - That comment is false. Anyone with half a brain would tell you that.

If there's ZERO recruiting value - Again, also false. While there is 0 direct recruiting value, there is very much so an indirect value that is very useful.

You're a bad spin doctor.

Quote: Originally Posted By colonels19 on 3/11/2010
Zach, coach_billyg among others said that a personality test tells you 2 things...the likelyhood a guy will leave your team, and the likelyhood he will rat you out for booster gifts....for $1500 and no recruiting value, that's an incredible rip-off for something that I don't see a great value in using in the first place. If the recruiting value is 0...why is this even in recruiting? Its just WIS getting "cutesy" and its overdone, and relatively irrelevant...the highest level you've coached at doesn't matter either.

If you spend $1500 recruiting bucks for this, then you're an idiot...note how I'm not calling any one person an idiot, unlike yourself.

So you are calling me an idiot now? For 1) you have never recruited at d1. At the very least (and you should agree, but won't) you know that you have never recruited there and do not understand the dynamics of that level and therefore you can't speak to something that is 100% geared towards that level.

Quote: Originally Posted By colonels19 on 3/11/2010

Quote: Originally Posted By zhawks on 3/11/2010

Colonels, these are used almost exclusively at d1, since you have not ever coached at d1 you don't understand their use and therefore you do not have the knowledge required to, not only understand them but also understand their use and because of this your argument here doesn't even come close to holding water.

You don't have an argument because you do not have the knowledge that is required to judge these.

Give the players what they want and they'll stay, period - That comment is false. Anyone with half a brain would tell you that.

If there's ZERO recruiting value - Again, also false. While there is 0 direct recruiting value, there is very much so an indirect value that is very useful.

You're a bad spin doctor

How did I spin anything ? I spun nothing. Both of your statements, that were not taken out of context, were 100% false.

Give the players what they want and they'll stay, period - That comment is false. Anyone with half a brain would tell you that.

If there's ZERO recruiting value - Again, also false. While there is 0 direct recruiting value, there is very much so an indirect value that is very useful.

Please tell me right now then, how your comments are correct. Prove it to me or else you are wrong. (Since that is how it works in your world)

Unless there is something I missed when I used it before, they are useless. I tried different things when the old pulldown method got fixed and using this and the 50 dollar things were both tried and both were useless IMHO.

Quote: Originally Posted By colonels19 on 3/11/2010

Zach, coach_billyg among others said that a personality test tells you 2 things...the likelyhood a guy will leave your team, and the likelyhood he will rat you out for booster gifts....for $1500 and no recruiting value, that's an incredible rip-off for something that I don't see a great value in using in the first place. If the recruiting value is 0...why is this even in recruiting? Its just WIS getting "cutesy" and its overdone, and relatively irrelevant...the highest level you've coached at doesn't matter either.

If you spend $1500 recruiting bucks for this, then you're an idiot...note how I'm not calling any one person an idiot, unlike yourself.

Either of those is big for a d1 program. For $1500 with a 100k buget its worth it