I would go RHP, 2B, C, LHP... I don't really like that C a ton because of the low PC, but he can hit enough to make up. The 2B looks like a legit fielder at 2B with a very nice bat.  I would be VERY dissappointed to get a pitcher with mid-60's splits AS PROJECTIONS with the #4 pick

The 2B has a 45 makeup...he's not going to hit projections.  The catcher will be a nice hitter, .300-.390-.510....something like that.  I wouldn't worry too much about the PC, just get a great defensive catcher to  be your defensive specialist.  The catcher has great durability and health, too...he'll start every game...if you use a "D" guy to back him up.

That said, I would take the RHP. He'll be very nice. #2 would be the catcher, then...well, I don't really like either of the other guys.

moe