Spend the 10 dollars and call the coach. He'll tell you for sure, yes or no, if you're able to pull the player down. You can pull players from D1 to D2 with a C- prestige, absolutely. Maybe not quite the "quality" that you'd prefer, but if you're dying to have a D1 player on your roster, then yes, a C- prestige D2 team can pull D1 players.