100M Roster Analysis Topic

I really tried to get a Schofield team to work.  Love the starting rotation of Marichal, Koufax and Gibson.  But couldn't quite fit in the offense I wanted ('69 Petrocelli, '71 Torre, etc.) under the salary cap.  I ended up dropping Marichal to load up on offense, but eventually scrapped it.  If the cap were a little higher, I would've gone with Schofield for sure.
7/30/2015 5:17 PM
It looks like I have the highest salary overall for my clones. Chipper needs to come through in a big way. For whatever reason, I rarely use what end up being the most popular player/team/year etc. when building my teams. Yet this year I ended up with the most used clone, the most used "Ugly" team, and the second most used player in can't catch/move. Given my track record I have no idea if this is a good omen for my teams or a bad omen for those who thought like I did. Should be fun either way.
7/30/2015 5:43 PM
In addition to Chipper, I also looked at Jim Wynn, Belliard, Mike Mordecai, Reggie Jackson, Mel Ott, and Davey Lopes just to name a few. I'll be interested to see how the Roush and Foxx teams do because it was hard finding pre-WWII clones who would have good enough pitching in a league like this.
7/30/2015 6:12 PM
Buckner is prob. A below avg. Offensive player In SIM. On the other hand he played for alot of teams over 20 years so he provides an awful lot of options. Maybe more than anyone else......toddcommish your thoughts?
7/30/2015 6:17 PM
I tried really hard to make a Kevin Mitchell team work starting him at 3B, DH, and in the OF, but couldn't get a rotation that I liked. Love the Tommy Davis rotation.
7/30/2015 6:25 PM
I had a great Tris Speaker team built, until I realized I had put in a 1920-2014 years restriction. In my defense, it was at least a month after I came up with that theme that I started to work on that roster.
7/30/2015 6:33 PM
Betting on 72 Sutton 86 Clemens and 89 Saberhagen to get it done for me in this league........
7/30/2015 7:38 PM
The team I have that I really wanted to use was Mickey Mantle.  Can't believe no one used him.  Last year I had great success in the sister theme to this using Vic Raschi.  So I liked the continuity of bringing him back via Mantle.  But, alas, I went for the pitching that came with Schofield Sr.
7/30/2015 9:09 PM
Other teams I built, more or less;
  • Rube Bressler
  • Edd Roush
  • Doc Cramer
  • Paul Richards
  • Gus Mancuso
  • Babe Herman
  • Eddie Mayo
  • Maury Wills
  • Tim Raines
  • Mickey Mantle
  • Frankie Frisch
7/30/2015 9:21 PM
I chose my clone (Roush) by choosing the pitching staff first. Love the HR suppression from those Cincinnati teams. I felt choosing HR suppression trumped all in the more restrictive themes. Ott may hit 50 HR for me
7/31/2015 2:26 PM (edited)

The next few posts will list the seasons take for each owner's clones

7/31/2015 2:29 PM
These are the clones taken only once... sorted by name of clone.

Owner____________ Clone_____________ Team
River_Rats Aaron, Hank 1958 Milwaukee Braves
River_Rats Aaron, Hank 1961 Milwaukee Braves
River_Rats Aaron, Hank 1962 Milwaukee Braves
River_Rats Aaron, Hank 1963 Milwaukee Braves
River_Rats Aaron, Hank 1964 Milwaukee Braves
     
mllama54 Baerga, Carlos 1995 Cleveland Indians
mllama54 Baerga, Carlos 1996 Cleveland Indians
mllama54 Baerga, Carlos 1999 San Diego Padres
mllama54 Baerga, Carlos 2002 Boston Red Sox
mllama54 Baerga, Carlos 2003 Arizona Diamondbacks
mllama54 Baerga, Carlos 2004 Arizona Diamondbacks
     
rmdriskill Bautista, Danny 1993 Detroit Tigers
rmdriskill Bautista, Danny 1996 Atlanta Braves
rmdriskill Bautista, Danny 1997 Atlanta Braves
rmdriskill Bautista, Danny 2001 Arizona Diamondbacks
rmdriskill Bautista, Danny 2004 Arizona Diamondbacks
finn2030 Belliard, Rafael 1990 Pittsburgh Pirates
     
finn2030 Belliard, Rafael 1993 Atlanta Braves
finn2030 Belliard, Rafael 1994 Atlanta Braves
finn2030 Belliard, Rafael 1996 Atlanta Braves
     
EasyE7273 Blair, Paul 1968 Baltimore Orioles
EasyE7273 Blair, Paul 1969 Baltimore Orioles
EasyE7273 Blair, Paul 1973 Baltimore Orioles
EasyE7273 Blair, Paul 1977 New York Yankees
EasyE7273 Blair, Paul 1978 New York Yankees
     
mick33 Burgess, Smoeky 1954 Philadelphia Phillies
mick33 Burgess, Smoeky 1960 Pittsburgh Pirates
mick33 Burgess, Smoeky 1961 Pittsburgh Pirates
mick33 Burgess, Smoeky 1964 Chicago White Sox
mick33 Burgess, Smoeky 1966 Chicago White Sox
mick33 Burgess, Smoeky 1967 Chicago White Sox
     
thebubbaq Callison, Johnny 1958 Chicago White Sox
thebubbaq Callison, Johnny 1962 Philadelphia Phillies
thebubbaq Callison, Johnny 1963 Philadelphia Phillies
thebubbaq Callison, Johnny 1964 Philadelphia Phillies
thebubbaq Callison, Johnny 1970 Chicago Cubs
thebubbaq Callison, Johnny 1973 New York Yankees
     
kyleb63 Colavito, Rocky 1961 Detroit Tigers
kyleb63 Colavito, Rocky 1962 Detroit Tigers
kyleb63 Colavito, Rocky 1964 Kansas City Athletics
kyleb63 Colavito, Rocky 1967 Chicago White Sox
kyleb63 Colavito, Rocky 1968 New York Yankees
     
daronb Dawson, Andre 1981 Montreal Expos
daronb Dawson, Andre 1992 Chicago Cubs
daronb Dawson, Andre 1993 Boston Red Sox
daronb Dawson, Andre 1996 Florida Marlins
     
joshkvt Foxx, Jimmie 1927 Philadelphia Athletics
joshkvt Foxx, Jimmie 1928 Philadelphia Athletics
joshkvt Foxx, Jimmie 1931 Philadelphia Athletics
joshkvt Foxx, Jimmie 1941 Boston Red Sox
     
nordawg Hansen, Ron 1964 Chicago White Sox
nordawg Hansen, Ron 1966 Chicago White Sox
nordawg Hansen, Ron 1971 New York Yankees
     
redsox666666 Hunter, Torii 2006 Minnesota Twins
redsox666666 Hunter, Torii 2011 Anaheim Angels
redsox666666 Hunter, Torii 2013 Detroit Tigers
     
dougpalm McCarver, Tim 1961 St. Louis Cardinals
dougpalm McCarver, Tim 1968 St. Louis Cardinals
dougpalm McCarver, Tim 1972 Philadelphia Phillies
dougpalm McCarver, Tim 1975 Boston Red Sox
dougpalm McCarver, Tim 1976 Philadelphia Phillies
dougpalm McCarver, Tim 1977 Philadelphia Phillies
dougpalm McCarver, Tim 1978 Philadelphia Phillies
     
yankeeso7 McGee, Willie 1985 St. Louis Cardinals
yankeeso7 McGee, Willie 1989 St. Louis Cardinals
yankeeso7 McGee, Willie 1990 Oakland Athletics
yankeeso7 McGee, Willie 1993 San Francisco Giants
     
Donburgh Musial, Stan 1942 St. Louis Cardinals
Donburgh Musial, Stan 1944 St. Louis Cardinals
Donburgh Musial, Stan 1952 St. Louis Cardinals
Donburgh Musial, Stan 1959 St. Louis Cardinals
Donburgh Musial, Stan 1962 St. Louis Cardinals
     
dlchow Offerman, Jose 1991 Los Angeles Dodgers
dlchow Offerman, Jose 1995 Los Angeles Dodgers
dlchow Offerman, Jose 1998 Kansas City Royals
dlchow Offerman, Jose 2002 Boston Red Sox
dlchow Offerman, Jose 2004 Minnesota Twins
dlchow Offerman, Jose 2005 New York Mets
     
jjgreen14 Pendleton, Terry 1985 St. Louis Cardinals
jjgreen14 Pendleton, Terry 1994 Atlanta Braves
jjgreen14 Pendleton, Terry 1996 Florida Marlins
     
shysters3 Perez, Eddie 1997 Atlanta Braves
shysters3 Perez, Eddie 1998 Atlanta Braves
shysters3 Perez, Eddie 1999 Atlanta Braves
shysters3 Perez, Eddie 2004 Atlanta Braves
     
brianjw Rettenmund, Merv 1968 Baltimore Orioles
brianjw Rettenmund, Merv 1969 Baltimore Orioles
brianjw Rettenmund, Merv 1970 Baltimore Orioles
brianjw Rettenmund, Merv 1971 Baltimore Orioles
brianjw Rettenmund, Merv 1973 Baltimore Orioles
brianjw Rettenmund, Merv 1975 Cincinnati Reds
brianjw Rettenmund, Merv 1976 San Diego Padres
brianjw Rettenmund, Merv 1977 San Diego Padres
     
beaneball Roush, Edd 1920 Cincinnati Reds
beaneball Roush, Edd 1922 Cincinnati Reds
beaneball Roush, Edd 1923 Cincinnati Reds
beaneball Roush, Edd 1924 Cincinnati Reds
beaneball Roush, Edd 1928 New York Giants
beaneball Roush, Edd 1929 New York Giants
     
evil_twin Sheffield, Gary 1988 Milwaukee Brewers
evil_twin Sheffield, Gary 1992 San Diego Padres
evil_twin Sheffield, Gary 1996 Florida Marlins
evil_twin Sheffield, Gary 2006 New York Yankees
7/31/2015 2:29 PM
These are the clones taken twice... It's fun to compare to see what others did using your same clone.

Owner____________ Clone_____________ Team
skilly006 Buckner, Bill 1970 Los Angeles Dodgers
skilly006 Buckner, Bill 1972 Los Angeles Dodgers
skilly006 Buckner, Bill 1979 Chicago Cubs
skilly006 Buckner, Bill 1986 Boston Red Sox
skilly006 Buckner, Bill 1989 Kansas City Royals
     
toddcommish Buckner, Bill 1972 Los Angeles Dodgers
toddcommish Buckner, Bill 1984 Chicago Cubs
toddcommish Buckner, Bill 1986 Boston Red Sox
toddcommish Buckner, Bill 1989 Kansas City Royals
     
     
bardin Cabrera, Miguel 2003 Florida Marlins
bardin Cabrera, Miguel 2004 Florida Marlins
bardin Cabrera, Miguel 2007 Florida Marlins
bardin Cabrera, Miguel 2011 Detroit Tigers
bardin Cabrera, Miguel 2013 Detroit Tigers
     
hersheybear Cabrera, Miguel 2003 Florida Marlins
hersheybear Cabrera, Miguel 2004 Florida Marlins
hersheybear Cabrera, Miguel 2011 Detroit Tigers
hersheybear Cabrera, Miguel 2012 Detroit Tigers
hersheybear Cabrera, Miguel 2013 Detroit Tigers
     
     
bighooze Cedeno, Cesar 1972 Houston Astros
bighooze Cedeno, Cesar 1980 Houston Astros
bighooze Cedeno, Cesar 1981 Houston Astros
bighooze Cedeno, Cesar 1985 St. Louis Cardinals
     
cubbies84 Cedeno, Cesar 1972 Houston Astros
cubbies84 Cedeno, Cesar 1981 Houston Astros
cubbies84 Cedeno, Cesar 1985 St. Louis Cardinals
cubbies84 Cedeno, Cesar 1986 Los Angeles Dodgers
     
     
odalisgagne Colbrunn, Greg 1992 Montreal Expos
odalisgagne Colbrunn, Greg 1996 Florida Marlins
odalisgagne Colbrunn, Greg 1997 Atlanta Braves
odalisgagne Colbrunn, Greg 1998 Colorado Rockies
odalisgagne Colbrunn, Greg 2001 Arizona Diamondbacks
odalisgagne Colbrunn, Greg 2003 Seattle Mariners
     
slainte Colbrunn, Greg 1992 Montreal Expos
slainte Colbrunn, Greg 1993 Montreal Expos
slainte Colbrunn, Greg 1996 Florida Marlins
slainte Colbrunn, Greg 1997 Atlanta Braves
slainte Colbrunn, Greg 1998 Atlanta Braves
slainte Colbrunn, Greg 2001 Arizona Diamondbacks
     
     
dorkster Garciaparra, Nomar 1999 Boston Red Sox
dorkster Garciaparra, Nomar 2000 Boston Red Sox
dorkster Garciaparra, Nomar 2002 Boston Red Sox
dorkster Garciaparra, Nomar 2004 Boston Red Sox
dorkster Garciaparra, Nomar 2006 Los Angeles Dodgers
dorkster Garciaparra, Nomar 2009 Oakland Athletics
     
SpotSell Garciaparra, Nomar 1999 Boston Red Sox
SpotSell Garciaparra, Nomar 2002 Boston Red Sox
SpotSell Garciaparra, Nomar 2003 Boston Red Sox
SpotSell Garciaparra, Nomar 2004 Boston Red Sox
SpotSell Garciaparra, Nomar 2005 Chicago Cubs
     
     
buddhagamer Lofton, Kenny 1997 Atlanta Braves
buddhagamer Lofton, Kenny 1999 Cleveland Indians
buddhagamer Lofton, Kenny 2004 New York Yankees
buddhagamer Lofton, Kenny 2005 Philadelphia Phillies
buddhagamer Lofton, Kenny 2007 Cleveland Indians
     
tridentric Lofton, Kenny 1997 Atlanta Braves
tridentric Lofton, Kenny 2002 San Francisco Giants
tridentric Lofton, Kenny 2004 New York Yankees
tridentric Lofton, Kenny 2005 Philadelphia Phillies
tridentric Lofton, Kenny 2006 Los Angeles Dodgers
tridentric Lofton, Kenny 2007 Cleveland Indians
     
     
alice Rose, Pete 1965 Cincinnati Reds
alice Rose, Pete 1968 Cincinnati Reds
alice Rose, Pete 1969 Cincinnati Reds
alice Rose, Pete 1973 Cincinnati Reds
alice Rose, Pete 1977 Cincinnati Reds
alice Rose, Pete 1981 Philadelphia Phillies
     
marlowe Rose, Pete 1965 Cincinnati Reds
marlowe Rose, Pete 1970 Cincinnati Reds
marlowe Rose, Pete 1971 Cincinnati Reds
marlowe Rose, Pete 1977 Cincinnati Reds
marlowe Rose, Pete 1980 Philadelphia Phillies
marlowe Rose, Pete 1981 Philadelphia Phillies
     
     
Chisock Vizcaino, Jose 1992 Chicago Cubs
Chisock Vizcaino, Jose 1994 New York Mets
Chisock Vizcaino, Jose 1996 Cleveland Indians
Chisock Vizcaino, Jose 2000 Los Angeles Dodgers
Chisock Vizcaino, Jose 2003 Houston Astros
Chisock Vizcaino, Jose 2006 St. Louis Cardinals
     
npg32433 Vizcaino, Jose 1994 New York Mets
npg32433 Vizcaino, Jose 2000 New York Yankees
npg32433 Vizcaino, Jose 2005 Houston Astros
npg32433 Vizcaino, Jose 2006 St. Louis Cardinals
7/31/2015 2:32 PM
These clones were selected three times...

Owner____________ Clone_____________ Team
beauchamp Davis, Willie 1960 Los Angeles Dodgers
beauchamp Davis, Willie 1962 Los Angeles Dodgers
beauchamp Davis, Willie 1966 Los Angeles Dodgers
beauchamp Davis, Willie 1970 Los Angeles Dodgers
beauchamp Davis, Willie 1972 Los Angeles Dodgers
     
besterateam Davis, Willie 1960 Los Angeles Dodgers
besterateam Davis, Willie 1964 Los Angeles Dodgers
besterateam Davis, Willie 1969 Los Angeles Dodgers
besterateam Davis, Willie 1972 Los Angeles Dodgers
besterateam Davis, Willie 1975 Texas Rangers
besterateam Davis, Willie 1979 California Angels
     
sprintracer Davis, Willie 1960 Los Angeles Dodgers
sprintracer Davis, Willie 1961 Los Angeles Dodgers
sprintracer Davis, Willie 1964 Los Angeles Dodgers
sprintracer Davis, Willie 1965 Los Angeles Dodgers
sprintracer Davis, Willie 1972 Los Angeles Dodgers
     
     
dodgebob Jackson, Reggie 1969 Oakland Athletics
dodgebob Jackson, Reggie 1971 Oakland Athletics
dodgebob Jackson, Reggie 1973 Oakland Athletics
dodgebob Jackson, Reggie 1978 New York Yankees
dodgebob Jackson, Reggie 1987 Oakland Athletics
     
glowguy Jackson, Reggie 1971 Oakland Athletics
glowguy Jackson, Reggie 1972 Oakland Athletics
glowguy Jackson, Reggie 1978 New York Yankees
     
hacker7 Jackson, Reggie 1969 Oakland Athletics
hacker7 Jackson, Reggie 1972 Oakland Athletics
hacker7 Jackson, Reggie 1977 New York Yankees
hacker7 Jackson, Reggie 1978 New York Yankees
hacker7 Jackson, Reggie 1980 New York Yankees
     
     
Hoofhearted Schofield, Dick 1965 San Francisco Giants
Hoofhearted Schofield, Dick 1966 Los Angeles Dodgers
Hoofhearted Schofield, Dick 1968 St. Louis Cardinals
Hoofhearted Schofield, Dick 1970 Boston Red Sox
Hoofhearted Schofield, Dick 1971 St. Louis Cardinals
     
Humdogs Schofield, Dick 1965 San Francisco Giants
Humdogs Schofield, Dick 1966 Los Angeles Dodgers
Humdogs Schofield, Dick 1968 St. Louis Cardinals
Humdogs Schofield, Dick 1970 Boston Red Sox
Humdogs Schofield, Dick 1971 St. Louis Cardinals
     
ybjsports Schofield, Dick 1957 St. Louis Cardinals
ybjsports Schofield, Dick 1961 Pittsburgh Pirates
ybjsports Schofield, Dick 1963 Pittsburgh Pirates
ybjsports Schofield, Dick 1966 Los Angeles Dodgers
ybjsports Schofield, Dick 1968 St. Louis Cardinals
ybjsports Schofield, Dick 1969 Boston Red Sox
ybjsports Schofield, Dick 1970 Boston Red Sox
ybjsports Schofield, Dick 1971 St. Louis Cardinals
7/31/2015 2:34 PM
Clones selected four times...

Owner____________ Clone_____________ Team
batandball Davis, Tommy 1962 Los Angeles Dodgers
batandball Davis, Tommy 1963 Los Angeles Dodgers
batandball Davis, Tommy 1964 Los Angeles Dodgers
batandball Davis, Tommy 1967 New York Mets
batandball Davis, Tommy 1971 Oakland Athletics
batandball Davis, Tommy 1972 Baltimore Orioles
batandball Davis, Tommy 1976 Kansas City Royals
     
mpitt76 Davis, Tommy 1962 Los Angeles Dodgers
mpitt76 Davis, Tommy 1963 Los Angeles Dodgers
mpitt76 Davis, Tommy 1964 Los Angeles Dodgers
mpitt76 Davis, Tommy 1965 Los Angeles Dodgers
mpitt76 Davis, Tommy 1966 Los Angeles Dodgers
mpitt76 Davis, Tommy 1969 Houston Astros
mpitt76 Davis, Tommy 1971 Oakland Athletics
mpitt76 Davis, Tommy 1972 Baltimore Orioles
     
rickysdad44 Davis, Tommy 1964 Los Angeles Dodgers
rickysdad44 Davis, Tommy 1968 Chicago White Sox
rickysdad44 Davis, Tommy 1970 Chicago Cubs
rickysdad44 Davis, Tommy 1971 Oakland Athletics
     
whoscraig Davis, Tommy 1962 Los Angeles Dodgers
whoscraig Davis, Tommy 1963 Los Angeles Dodgers
whoscraig Davis, Tommy 1965 Los Angeles Dodgers
whoscraig Davis, Tommy 1969 Houston Astros
whoscraig Davis, Tommy 1971 Oakland Athletics
whoscraig Davis, Tommy 1972 Chicago Cubs
     
     
justinlee_24 Ramirez, Manny 1995 Cleveland Indians
justinlee_24 Ramirez, Manny 1996 Cleveland Indians
justinlee_24 Ramirez, Manny 1999 Cleveland Indians
justinlee_24 Ramirez, Manny 2002 Boston Red Sox
justinlee_24 Ramirez, Manny 2008 Los Angeles Dodgers
     
markeking Ramirez, Manny 1995 Cleveland Indians
markeking Ramirez, Manny 1999 Cleveland Indians
markeking Ramirez, Manny 2002 Boston Red Sox
markeking Ramirez, Manny 2007 Boston Red Sox
markeking Ramirez, Manny 2010 Los Angeles Dodgers
     
rbow923 Ramirez, Manny 2000 Cleveland Indians
rbow923 Ramirez, Manny 2002 Boston Red Sox
rbow923 Ramirez, Manny 2003 Boston Red Sox
rbow923 Ramirez, Manny 2004 Boston Red Sox
rbow923 Ramirez, Manny 2008 Los Angeles Dodgers
rbow923 Ramirez, Manny 2010 Chicago White Sox
     
Yaz2Schill Ramirez, Manny 1999 Cleveland Indians
Yaz2Schill Ramirez, Manny 2000 Cleveland Indians
Yaz2Schill Ramirez, Manny 2002 Boston Red Sox
Yaz2Schill Ramirez, Manny 2004 Boston Red Sox
Yaz2Schill Ramirez, Manny 2010 Los Angeles Dodgers
7/31/2015 2:35 PM
◂ Prev 1234 Next ▸
100M Roster Analysis Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.