Oh got an answer to my question(sort of)

Yeah, the season will end up being a little longer due to the second recruiting period, but not by a whole lot.

Great now it will take even longer to move up

can you please give us some more concrete answers besides yes expect it to be longer or it will be easier, but maybe an estimate of 3 days longer or a few months to fully understand recruiting etc.

I think private camps should bring in talent based on prestige, otherwise I'd expect to see some annoying occurances of an A+ school holding a camp and getting nothing but D4 talent and a lucky C- prestige school holds a camp and gets nothing but NC material, makes it seem like recruiting is going to be very luck based for finding talent.

this is not helping my outlook towards the updates.

Any school can sign any recruit???? Wow so Carmelo playing for Carnegie Melon is going to be fascinating to watch, and play against.

Posted by kevodaphenom on 3/4/2016 11:40:00 AM (view original):
Any school can sign any recruit???? Wow so Carmelo playing for Carnegie Melon is going to be fascinating to watch, and play against.

i think he means Melo wouldn't so up at all to any non power school, so any non power school wouldn't even know about melo?

Wow .... team A at 1000 pts would "probably" sign player instead of team B at 100-200 pts.

That's kind of a huge multiple to have a "probably" on

Is there going to be a certain point where Team A is going to get the recruit 100% like if team A is 1000 points and team B is 100 points or even 200 points? (the0nlyis - Hall of Famer - 11:41 AM)

Only teams at Moderate or higher interest level can sign a player, so in your example, Team A would probably get him due to Team B being lower interest level.

Give a freaking concrete answer, that doesn't address my concern at all. what is a moderate or higher interest level. Is there a point where Team A is gaurenteed to sign him?

I don't want Team B coming in last minute with a start/scholly and signing him with the 1% chance it happens.

Posted by guyo26 on 3/4/2016 11:43:00 AM (view original):
Wow .... team A at 1000 pts would "probably" sign player instead of team B at 100-200 pts.

That's kind of a huge multiple to have a "probably" on

Thought the exact same thing.

The update seems good, and the private camps seem interesting. There just seems to be too much luck involved.

With the private camps and discovering talent... Will it be 100% random? Or will I bring in like 50 recruits who are my prestige level and 50 random recruits (good or bad)? (jaymc2007 - Pro - 11:44 AM)

It's random based on geography. For public camps, you'll see an overall grade to give you an idea of the talent level.

This has to be one of the dumbest idea's so far.

I feel like the camps thing came from ... was it the Wolverine Studios game that had camps? I know I saw it at some other college bb sim

Posted by guyo26 on 3/4/2016 11:47:00 AM (view original):
I feel like the camps thing came from ... was it the Wolverine Studios game that had camps? I know I saw it at some other college bb sim

yes wolverine studio's had camps, but it was basically like FSS, but for a whole region, however based on attending a camp you might see a few guys potential change for the better/worse.

It seems geography is now even more important at D2/D3 if that was possible and more important than prestige at 2/3 as well.

neither of these chats has really helped, only added more confusion, some half-assed answers and still thousands of questions

Are you expecting this recruiting to change to fix D1 problems, or will there be updates in maybe 2020 that finally address the real problems?

This has 0% chance of being answered.