Didn't like Let's Wrestle as much on second listen...all though it has its moments. Has a really Art Brut sound at times...so if you like that.
Fang Island, however...I absolutely love. But, fair warning--there's a chance that there's a Veronica Mars effect here. It's heavily indebted to 70's guitar rock...Slade, Toto, Queen, Boston, ELP, etc. A lot of fun, and really inventive, but nothing remotely edgy.