BNL #8 Draft - APB! Topic

Time to quit tinkering on my team too (I lied. I have edited once already since posting). Team Name Montana Giant Red Bears, playing in Shibe Park
Payroll: $79,953,893

38 Red Sox (7)
C Gene Desautels $2,842,743
C Johnny Peacock $1,283,467
1B Jimmie Foxx $9,410,195
3B Pinky Higgins $3,949,770
3B Jim Tabor $440,394
SS Eric McNair $250,100
OF Ben Chapman $4,969,565

78 Cubs (6)
SS Ivan DeJesus $5,393,707
OF Gene Clines $1,130,167
P Dennis Lamp $5,037,987
P Mike Krukow $2,904,756
P Bruce Sutter $2,555,824
P Willie Hernandez $930,666

48 Phillies (6)
2B Emil Verban $708,683
OF Del Ennis $4,462,384
OF Harry Walker $2,832,903
P Dutch Leonard $5,780,070
P Ken Heintzelman $3,140,527
P Charlie Bicknell $202,250

78 Giants (6)
1B Mike Ivie $2,308,554
2B Bill Madlock $3,938,302
OF Hector Cruz $932,369
P Vida Blue $6,842,221
P Ed Halicki $6,022,859
P Randy Moffitt $1,683,430
4/5/2024 1:49 PM (edited)
Posted by seay00 on 4/5/2024 4:34:00 AM (view original):
Ribbentrop- Feel free to dagger the 1948 St. Louis Browns.
23 seay00 ... 38 Cubs, 48 Browns, 78 Indians, 78 Tigers

First of all Pitching 1948 St. Louis Browns

Seems 1948 Sam Zoldak Or 1948 Cliff Fannin Possible SP but neither very good --- stats later if needed

Already see 1938 Bill Lee 1938 Clay Bryant 1938 Charlie Root 1978 Rick Waits 1978 Dave Rozema available
All seem to be uniformly Or median low 3ish ERC# 3.11-17 and 1 3.29 --- SP subpar but 1948 putrid and no help ... Just by glancing RPs available non 1948 above average

Catcher --- Good with 1938 Gabby Hartnett (377) and multiple combinations there sin 1948 but 1948 Les Moss (404) quite good

1B --- 1938 Ripper Collins (592) and 1978 Andre Thornton (629) and 1978 Jason Thompson (669) Only Listed at 1B ... But 1948 has just only 2 Ninnies Listed costing $1,716,113 and $1,537,839 Lucky You !

2B --- I would use the 2B B/A+ (.981/5.92)
1938 Billy Herman Chicago Cubs Position: 2B Salary: $5,693,741
Not to mention 1978 Lou Whitaker (567) ...
Interestingly enough Ninny 1978 Steve Dillard Detroit Tigers Position: 2B Salary: $526,218 Daggered !!
And lastly 1978 Duane Kuiper (601) The Plebe Of the Class and costing Salary: $3,156,545 with RC27 3 OPS# .649 B-/D+ (.979/5.01)
Actually other 2B 1948 Jerry Priddy St. Louis Browns Position: 2B Salary: $5,485,378 quite a plum
(696) RC27 6 with OPS# 8.23 and C/A- (.968/5.68)
So every 2B only Listed there at Second Base ...

So it seems to complete the planned (Dillard 2B Daggered) fait accompli I should look no further

and Dagger 1948 2B Jerry Priddy following the logic of the First Dagger

So spending at 2B $3,156,545 for say 1978 Duane Kuiper and either $4,257,968 Whitaker or $5,693,741 Herman
4/5/2024 4:58 PM (edited)
seay00 you can dagger my 1948 Reds.
4/5/2024 11:57 AM
Team Name: Really Silly in Philly
Ballpark: Veterans Stadium
Total Salary: $79,995,076

1978 Phillies
C 1978 Bob Boone $4,304,032
1B 1978 Richie Hebner $3,321,523
3B 1978 Mike Schmidt $4,996,458
SS 1978 Larry Bowa $4,841,966
2B 1978 Jim Morrison $508,704
RP 1978 Ron Reed $3,227,097
RP 1978 Gene Garber $1,340,750

1968 Cubs
2B 1968 Glenn Beckert $5,099,871
OF 1968 Billy Williams $4,890,615
OF 1968 Willie Smith $926,445
SP 1968 Fergie Jenkins $8,661,361
SP 1968 Bill Hands $6,610,503
RP 1968 Phil Regan $3,170,284

1968 Dodgers
3B 1968 Bill Sudakis $923,610
OF 1968 Len Gabrielson $1,944,700
SP 1968 Don Sutton $5,932,898
SP 1968 Don Drysdale $6,444,288
RP 1968 Mudcat Grant $3,055,089
RP 1968 Hank Aguirre $1,179,027

1988 Phillies
C 1988 Darren Daulton $643,546
1B 1988 Ricky Jordan $1,856,117
SS 1988 Jackie Gutierrez $231,809
OF 1988 Milt Thompson $3,288,376
OF 1988 Ron Jones $1,081,725
RP 1988 Mike Maddux $1,514,282

Overall Lines
Hitting Actual: 5504 PA .278 .336 .418 $38,859,497
Pitching: 1,514 IP 2.48 .230 1.07 $41,135,579
(this includes a 90 IP mop/spot starter in Mike Maddux, without him it's 1,424 IP 2.40 .227 1.05)
4/5/2024 12:28 PM (edited)
BeAllEndAll - 68 Indians, 88 Braves, 38 Bees, 88 Brewers
1st Dagger - Jim Hitchcock - SS -
stadium dagger - Braves field

My task was to dagger another player from the 38 Bees. The first dagger was a good one by removing the only cheap SS sub he will be forced to roster two crappy SS for more than they are worth.

My evaluation of this team is that they are going to struggle with offense in a severe way. Their pitching will be excellent.

So looking at this team position by position....

C - No real dagger options here becasue he has other catchers and combinations of subs that are better

1B - I could dagger Elbie Fletcher who is cheap and has a 5RC27. However, Gerald Perry is about the same.

2B - Tony Cuccinello is an option but he is not better than Gant or Gantner.

3B - Two sucky options but one is a potentially cheap sub. However, he has another cheap sub in Riles but it would force him to pick another player from this crappy team.

SS - already daggered one of them and it doesn't help to roster Rabbit over anyone else he has.

OF - This is interesting. He is going to need to roster Yount and probably Deer but he needs another OF and the options here are Vince "the third" Dimaggio or Debs Garms. Dimaggio is not good but Garms provides a solid avg, obp, and 5RC27. He only gives 500 PAs but that is better than anyone else he has. I could also dagger his only cheap sub that is left and force him to roster a platoon that spends a little more.

Pitching - He has a couple of options he could go with here. The best is MacFayden but he doesn't really strike fear in the hearts of batters so probably not a dagger option.

I was torn between daggering Garms or cheap sub Maggert but every time I roster it I would rather have Garms bat than any platoon combo I could come up with. It also takes away about the only real useful offensive player on this team. Therefore, I dagger OF - Debs Garms.

Good luck
4/5/2024 3:47 PM (edited)
Two more secondary daggers complete - I think all the first daggers have landed but a couple of people still need to offer teams for 2nd dagger.

More than a couple of teams are fully approved (see page 1). I will be sending out MLB numbers backchannel over the weekend to those with approved teams.

My hope is that we get all the daggers thrown over the weekend so that we can getting into the league by Monday and playing games by mid-week. I hope that works out!
4/5/2024 4:06 PM
Team name: Its not the sample from Under Pressure
Stadium: Cleveland Stadium
Salary: $79,923,721

1938 Chicago Cubs: 6

C- Ken O'Dea $1,369,098
SS- Tony Lazzeri $849,923
C- Bob Garbark $350,959
SP- Bill Lee $7,566,352
SP- Clay Bryant $8,359,005
RP- Dizzy Dean $3,031,963

1948 St. Louis Browns: 6

OF- Al Zarilla $4,783,284
1B- Hank Arft $1,537,839
OF- Don Lund $826,949
SP- Fred Sanford $4,529,946
RP- Sam Zoldack $829,170
RP- Blackie Schwamb $250,159

1978 Detroit Tigers: 6

2B Lou Whitaker $4,257,968
OF- Ron LeFlore $ 6,044,582
OF- Steve Kemp $ 4,245,866
3B- Phil Mankowski $ 1,209,380
SP- Milt Wilcox $4,492,380
RP- John Hiller $ 2,898,817

1978 Cleveland Indians: 7

1B- Andre Thornton $5,168,575
3B- Buddy Bell $5,301,452
SS- Tom Veryzer $2,173,114
2B- Duane Kuiper $3,156,545
Util- Gary Alexander $2,017,432 (will play primarily at catcher. Meets roster requirement as 5th OF)
RP- Sid Monge $2,025,569
RP- Jim Kern- $2,647,394
4/5/2024 7:03 PM (edited)
Beallendall may dagger the 88 Texas Rangers
4/5/2024 4:38 PM
C_Burns04 - Time for the final dagger from your 1988 White Sox.

The 88 White Sox are not very good (below avg. at the plate and lower on the hill) but knowing you have to have 6 of them and looking at the teams you have doesn't present too many obvious options. That could be both good and bad for you when building your team. A very nice choice by your neighbor for sure.

Your first choice of the Reds is solid as they present options.

The Angels staff sucks but you get Bryan Harvey and some decent choices at the plate.

The Tigers have options at the plate but an expensive starter at Hal Newhouser and OK with 2 other SP's but the rest are garbage.

Onto the White Sox - O. Guillen is a nice fielder with great D. Concepcion from the Reds is nice but forcing you to choose other White Sox bats is intriguing.

Your Pitching seems to be the tough spot in making your roster IMHO. I could take away a Harold Baines but his crappy D-/D- defense I might not be intrigued to remove him.

I have come down to hurting the staff as I think O. Guillen at the plate isn't so terrifying so if your chose him you can have good D doesn't hurt as much as limiting your pitching options.

I am therefore taking out LHP Dave LaPoint - he is has the best advanced stats and would like you to have to choose the from that horrific staff to make your team.







4/5/2024 6:36 PM
whalers10,
There's not much hitting help on this team other than a decent hitting, good fielding Chet Lemon but you have other options at OF. There are 3 relief pitching options but the best value is Mike Proly so, I will dagger him.
4/5/2024 9:38 PM
Peckham Roses
Memorial Stadium - Baltimore
$79,806,149

48 White Sox
C Mike Tresh $815,824
3B Luke Appling $4,859,475 (playing SS)
P Howie Judson $2,214,526
P Earl Caldwell $375,577
P Randy Gumpert $2,375,084
P Ike Pearson $660,079

58 Orioles
1B Jim Marshall $845,636
SS Foster Castleman $676,771
SS Willy Miranda $726,428
OF Bob Nieman $3,479,029
OF Joe Taylor $429,885
P Jack Harshman $7,411,988

58 Braves
1B Frank Torre $3,121,973
OF Hank Aaron $6,561,558
OF Harry Hanebrink $530,544
P Humberto Robinson $1,221,726
P Joey Jay $3,457,228
P Lew Burdette $7,817,728
P Warren Spahn $9,991,929

68 Reds
C Johnny Bench $5,082,441
2B Tommy Helms $4,221,116
2B Chico Ruiz $686,929
3B Tony Perez $4,941,838
OF Alex Johnson $4,004,033
P Clay Carroll $3,296,804
4/6/2024 9:03 AM (edited)
ermo asked me to double check his roster. It is legal.
4/6/2024 12:21 AM
Putting up 58 Athletics for dagger
4/6/2024 9:57 AM
New York Raiders Shea Stadium
79,839,517
39,993,947 hitters
39,845,570 pitchers


78 Chicago White Sox (6)
C Bill Nahorodny 1,918,677
2B Jorge Orta 3,114,304
3B Eric Soderholm 3,305,087
OF Wayne Nordhagen 1,222,779
P Ken Kravec 4,090,385
P Lerrin Lagrow 1,521,077


88 Houston Astros (7)
1B Glenn Davis 5,293,595
SS Rafael Ramirez 3,386,778
SS Craig Reynolds 669,508
C Alan Ashby 1,174,026
3B Denny Walling 884,665
P Mike Scott 6,962,701
P Juan Augosto 2,348,719

78 New York Mets (6)
OF Lee Mazzilli 5,432,310
2B Bobby Valentine 827,546
OF Bruce Boisclair 976,955
P Craig Swan 6,162,536
P Skip Lockwood 2,018,608
P Tom Hausman 748,658


88 New York Mets (6)
OF Kevin McReynolds 4,506,613
OF Darryl Strawberry 5,276,558
1B Dave Magadan 2,004,546
P David Cone 7,280,933
P Sid Fernandez 6,268,548
P Randy Myers 2,443,405

88 Mets as a base team gave me a whole staff I could have taken. Cone and Fernandez give me 2 power arms and Myers will close. Strawberry and McReynolds will be my corner outfielders with power. Had to take Magadan at 2 million as backup 1b because my cheapest 1b Squires from 78 Chisox was daggered. He will mostly ph and spell Soderholm at 3b.

78 Mets gave us Mazzilli who will play cf with an A- range. Valenine will platoon at 2b with Orta. Boisclair was my cheapest of backup option, but pricey at almost 1 million. Swan was a no brainer as a starter and Lockwood will set up Myers. Hausman will mop up.

78 White Sox were a challenge. Lost Squires and Proly to daggers. Definitely would have rostered both of them. Orta and Soderholm make up half my infield. Nordhagen is a power bat off the bench who can also catch. I took Kravec over Ojeda as fifth starter to save some money. It's a big downgrade but ultimately couldn't afford a fifth starter with a 1.00 WHIP. I Wanted Stearns from 78 Mets to catch but couldn't afford him so went with Nahorodny and Ashby from 88 Astros. They don't hit much but did combine for 15 homers.

88 Astros were my final team selection. I had wanted the 38 Reds but they were taken early in round 4. I needed a team with a backup SS as I didn't have one yet. Another team loaded with pitching options. Ryan, Scott, Deshaies, Darwin all good starters. Davis was my best 1b. Ramirez was my best SS, my weakest position by far. Reynolds will backup ss, Walling 3b. Ashby will share catching duties. Scott gives me 2 aces with Cone and Agosto is a valuable bullpen asset.

I chose Shea to play in over the Astrodome. It's still a pitchers park, but not as restrictive to homers as the Dome would be. We will rely on starting pitching and power hitting. Team BA is a little low at .267 and OBP is .332. Little too heavy on PA but my lack of cheap bench players forced my hand.

Hitters 6141 PA, 179 HR, .267, .332, .422
Pitchers 1450 IP, 3.01 ERA, .221 BAA, 1.14 WHIP, 1103 K
4/6/2024 10:42 AM (edited)
NebHusker, you can dagger my 38 Phillies.
4/6/2024 12:13 PM
◂ Prev 1...21|22|23|24|25|26 Next ▸
BNL #8 Draft - APB! Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.