Depends on who you ask. If two players have identical secondary ratings, it's probably wise to go with the one who has the higher core ratings despite results. IOW, 80/80/80/80/80 is better than 78/80/74/72/58. But, if the secondary ratings(speed, baserunning, push/pull, bunt) are different and you're getting better results with the "lesser" hitter, I think it's almost stupid to insist on playing the "better" hitter.