LEAGUE 7 - HITTING
(Min 297 PA to qualify, sorted by biggest underachievers, measured by OPS difference)
.

Leag	Name	Year__	Team Name	Sim OPS	Act OPS	DIFF
7	Trammell, Alan	1987	L7: Tigers	0.642	0.953	-0.311
7	Cobb, Ty	1922	L7: Tigers	0.761	1.027	-0.266
7	Cobb, Ty	1925	DET 1935-1945-1903-2023-1925	0.802	1.066	-0.264
7	Evers, Hoot	1950	15,38,50,69,20 Tigers	0.725	0.959	-0.234
7	Seymour, Cy	1905	Reds 05/26//40/61/78	0.757	0.988	-0.231
7	Votto, Joey	2018	Reds 1924, 1970, 2014, 2018, 1982	0.605	0.836	-0.231
7	Frey, Lonny	1939	CIN 1923-1939-1965-2012-2022	0.621	0.840	-0.219
7	Walker, Gee	1937	Make Sparky Proud	0.663	0.879	-0.216
7	Greenberg, Hank	1940	Here There Be Tygers	0.888	1.103	-0.215
7	Robinson, Frank	1965	CIN 1923-1939-1965-2012-2022	0.715	0.926	-0.211
7	Greenberg, Hank	1934	Tigers 1912,1934,1955,2009,2016	0.795	1.004	-0.209
7	Griffey Sr., Ken	1977	Reds 42, 71, 77, 90 19	0.649	0.856	-0.207
7	Gehringer, Charlie	1937	Make Sparky Proud	0.773	0.978	-0.205
7	Votto, Joey	2015	Cincinnati Reds 15-18-62-75-15	0.799	1.000	-0.201
7	Morgan, Joe	1975	Cincinnati Reds 15-18-62-75-15	0.774	0.974	-0.200
7	Kell, George	1950	15,38,50,69,20 Tigers	0.689	0.887	-0.198
7	Gehringer, Charlie	1936	Detroit Tigers 14-18-36-49-61	0.788	0.986	-0.198
7	Larkin, Barry	1995	Reds 25/73/80/95/10	0.694	0.886	-0.192
7	Cobb, Ty	1924	Puzzle Tigers	0.677	0.868	-0.191
7	Cobb, Ty	1921	Tigers' Cobb x 2	0.859	1.048	-0.189
7	Cochrane, Mickey	1935	DET 1935-1945-1903-2023-1925	0.720	0.902	-0.182
7	Kaline, Al	1959	Tigers: 1959/1962/1983/2011/2015	0.758	0.940	-0.182
7	York, Rudy	1940	Here There Be Tygers	0.811	0.993	-0.182
7	Delahanty, Jim	1911	L7: Tigers	0.696	0.874	-0.178
7	Werber, Billy	1939	CIN 1923-1939-1965-2012-2022	0.602	0.777	-0.175
7	Lipon, Johnny	1950	15,38,50,69,20 Tigers	0.571	0.746	-0.175
7	Robinson, Frank	1964	Reds: 1920/1964/1967/1988/2011	0.769	0.944	-0.175
7	Roush, Edd	1923	CIN 1923-1939-1965-2012-2022	0.763	0.937	-0.174
7	Roush, Edd	1925	Reds 25/73/80/95/10	0.704	0.877	-0.173
7	Gehringer, Charlie	1930	Tigers 1909, 1917, 1984, 1967, 1930	0.767	0.938	-0.171
7	Perez, Tony	1969	5 Reds 1968 1969 1991 2007 2020	0.713	0.883	-0.170
7	Choo, Shin-Soo	2013	Bigwig's Reds (09/19/74/87/13)	0.716	0.885	-0.169
7	Cabrera, Miguel	2013	Here There Be Tygers	0.910	1.078	-0.168
7	Gehringer, Charlie	1934	Tigers 1912,1934,1955,2009,2016	0.801	0.967	-0.166
7	Robinson, Frank	1956	Reds1944, 56, 81, 2005, 17	0.773	0.937	-0.164
7	Greenberg, Hank	1937	Make Sparky Proud	0.944	1.104	-0.160
7	Bench, Johnny	1972	L7: Reds	0.760	0.920	-0.160
7	Suarez, Eugenio	2019	Reds 42, 71, 77, 90 19	0.770	0.930	-0.160
7	Bench, Johnny	1969	5 Reds 1968 1969 1991 2007 2020	0.683	0.840	-0.157
7	Polanco, Placido	2007	Curtis, My Man	0.691	0.846	-0.155
7	Heilmann, Harry	1927	Here There Be Tygers	0.937	1.091	-0.154
7	Heilmann, Harry	1923	Curtis, My Man	0.961	1.113	-0.152
7	Cabrera, Miguel	2011	Tigers: 1959/1962/1983/2011/2015	0.883	1.034	-0.151
7	Fryman, Travis	1997	L7: Tigers	0.615	0.766	-0.151
7	Bench, Johnny	1973	Reds 25/73/80/95/10	0.623	0.774	-0.151
7	Guillen, Carlos	2004	Curtis, My Man	0.772	0.921	-0.149
7	Morgan, Joe	1973	Reds 25/73/80/95/10	0.751	0.899	-0.148
7	Foster, George	1977	Reds 42, 71, 77, 90 19	0.867	1.013	-0.146
7	Post, Wally	1955	Reds 04-32-55-76-89	0.800	0.946	-0.146
7	McManus, Marty	1930	Tigers 1909, 1917, 1984, 1967, 1930	0.729	0.871	-0.142
7	Votto, Joey	2013	Bigwig's Reds (09/19/74/87/13)	0.785	0.926	-0.141
7	May, Lee	1971	Reds 42, 71, 77, 90 19	0.729	0.864	-0.135
7	Concepcion, Dave	1974	Bigwig's Reds (09/19/74/87/13)	0.597	0.732	-0.135
7	Rolen, Scott	2010	Reds 25/73/80/95/10	0.720	0.855	-0.135
7	Kluszewski, Ted	1955	Reds 04-32-55-76-89	0.833	0.967	-0.134
7	Morgan, Joe	1972	L7: Reds	0.718	0.852	-0.134
7	Sanders, Reggie	1995	Reds 25/73/80/95/10	0.844	0.976	-0.132
7	Gehringer, Charlie	1935	DET 1935-1945-1903-2023-1925	0.779	0.911	-0.132
7	Bench, Johnny	1970	Reds 1924, 1970, 2014, 2018, 1982	0.804	0.932	-0.128
7	Votto, Joey	2011	Reds: 1920/1964/1967/1988/2011	0.822	0.947	-0.125
7	Jones, Bob	1921	Tigers' Cobb x 2	0.606	0.731	-0.125
7	Cobb, Ty	1911	L7: Tigers	0.966	1.088	-0.122
7	Pinson, Vada	1961	Reds 05/26//40/61/78	0.761	0.883	-0.122
7	Groh, Heinie	1918	Cincinnati Reds 15-18-62-75-15	0.670	0.791	-0.121
7	Robinson, Frank	1961	Reds 05/26//40/61/78	0.895	1.015	-0.120
7	Cobb, Ty	1916	Tigers' Cobb x 2	0.827	0.945	-0.118
7	Bench, Johnny	1974	Bigwig's Reds (09/19/74/87/13)	0.753	0.870	-0.117
7	Tolan, Bobby	1969	5 Reds 1968 1969 1991 2007 2020	0.704	0.821	-0.117
7	Cobb, Ty	1912	Tigers 1912,1934,1955,2009,2016	0.924	1.040	-0.116
7	Martinez, Victor	2014	Puzzle Tigers	0.858	0.974	-0.116
7	Whitaker, Lou	1983	Tigers: 1959/1962/1983/2011/2015	0.721	0.837	-0.116
7	Veach, Bobby	1921	Tigers' Cobb x 2	0.801	0.916	-0.115
7	Cochrane, Mickey	1934	Tigers 1912,1934,1955,2009,2016	0.725	0.840	-0.115
7	Crawford, Sam	1912	Tigers 1912,1934,1955,2009,2016	0.730	0.843	-0.113
7	Heilmann, Harry	1925	DET 1935-1945-1903-2023-1925	0.914	1.026	-0.112
7	York, Rudy	1938	15,38,50,69,20 Tigers	0.884	0.996	-0.112
7	Bench, Johnny	1975	Cincinnati Reds 15-18-62-75-15	0.770	0.878	-0.108
7	Freehan, Bill	1968	Here There Be Tygers	0.713	0.820	-0.107
7	Larkin, Barry	1990	Reds 42, 71, 77, 90 19	0.648	0.754	-0.106
7	Cobb, Ty	1917	Tigers 1909, 1917, 1984, 1967, 1930	0.910	1.014	-0.104
7	Morgan, Joe	1974	Bigwig's Reds (09/19/74/87/13)	0.819	0.921	-0.102
7	Crawford, Sam	1911	L7: Tigers	0.862	0.964	-0.102
7	McCosky, Barney	1940	Here There Be Tygers	0.798	0.899	-0.101
7	Kuenn, Harvey	1955	Tigers 1912,1934,1955,2009,2016	0.669	0.770	-0.101
7	Morgan, Joe	1976	Reds 04-32-55-76-89	0.921	1.020	-0.099
7	Cobb, Ty	1918	Detroit Tigers 14-18-36-49-61	0.856	0.955	-0.099
7	Heilmann, Harry	1921	Tigers' Cobb x 2	0.952	1.050	-0.098
7	Lopez, Felipe	2005	Reds1944, 56, 81, 2005, 17	0.741	0.838	-0.097
7	Pinson, Vada	1962	Cincinnati Reds 15-18-62-75-15	0.721	0.818	-0.097
7	Cabrera, Miguel	2012	Make Sparky Proud	0.905	0.999	-0.094
7	Higgins, Pinky	1944	Puzzle Tigers	0.708	0.801	-0.093
7	Fox, Pete	1937	Make Sparky Proud	0.756	0.848	-0.092
7	Bassler, Johnny	1923	Curtis, My Man	0.667	0.759	-0.092
7	Veach, Bobby	1915	15,38,50,69,20 Tigers	0.734	0.824	-0.090
7	Trammell, Alan	1981	Tigers' Cobb x 2	0.580	0.669	-0.089
7	Larkin, Barry	1991	5 Reds 1968 1969 1991 2007 2020	0.795	0.884	-0.089
7	Morgan, Joe	1977	Reds 42, 71, 77, 90 19	0.807	0.895	-0.088
7	Kell, George	1949	Detroit Tigers 14-18-36-49-61	0.804	0.891	-0.087
7	Rose, Pete	1972	L7: Reds	0.713	0.799	-0.086
7	Perez, Tony	1967	Reds: 1920/1964/1967/1988/2011	0.732	0.818	-0.086
7	Bench, Johnny	1977	Reds 42, 71, 77, 90 19	0.802	0.888	-0.086
7	Crawford, Sam	1902	L7: Reds	0.763	0.847	-0.084
7	Yost, Eddie	1959	Tigers: 1959/1962/1983/2011/2015	0.788	0.871	-0.083
7	Greenberg, Hank	1935	DET 1935-1945-1903-2023-1925	0.957	1.039	-0.082
7	Concepcion, Dave	1982	Reds 1924, 1970, 2014, 2018, 1982	0.626	0.708	-0.082
7	Rose, Pete	1978	Reds 05/26//40/61/78	0.702	0.783	-0.081
7	Phillips, Tony	1993	Puzzle Tigers	0.761	0.841	-0.080
7	Trammell, Alan	1984	Tigers 1909, 1917, 1984, 1967, 1930	0.770	0.850	-0.080
7	Hargrave, Bubbles	1923	CIN 1923-1939-1965-2012-2022	0.860	0.940	-0.080
7	Bush, Donie	1914	Detroit Tigers 14-18-36-49-61	0.591	0.668	-0.077
7	Phillips, Brandon	2007	5 Reds 1968 1969 1991 2007 2020	0.740	0.816	-0.076
7	Cobb, Ty	1910	Make Sparky Proud	0.931	1.007	-0.076
7	Rose, Pete	1969	5 Reds 1968 1969 1991 2007 2020	0.865	0.940	-0.075
7	Freehan, Bill	1967	Tigers 1909, 1917, 1984, 1967, 1930	0.762	0.836	-0.074
7	Granderson, Curtis	2007	Curtis, My Man	0.840	0.913	-0.073
7	Guillen, Carlos	2006	Make Sparky Proud	0.846	0.919	-0.073
7	Lush, Billy	1903	DET 1935-1945-1903-2023-1925	0.696	0.769	-0.073
7	Heilmann, Harry	1924	Puzzle Tigers	0.888	0.961	-0.073
7	Concepcion, Dave	1978	Reds 05/26//40/61/78	0.690	0.762	-0.072
7	Rose, Pete	1970	Reds 1924, 1970, 2014, 2018, 1982	0.787	0.855	-0.068
7	Cobb, Ty	1909	Tigers 1909, 1917, 1984, 1967, 1930	0.881	0.948	-0.067
7	Owen, Marv	1934	Tigers 1912,1934,1955,2009,2016	0.769	0.836	-0.067
7	Perez, Tony	1970	Reds 1924, 1970, 2014, 2018, 1982	0.924	0.990	-0.066
7	Kaline, Al	1955	Tigers 1912,1934,1955,2009,2016	0.902	0.967	-0.065
7	Robinson, Frank	1962	Cincinnati Reds 15-18-62-75-15	0.982	1.045	-0.063
7	Whitaker, Lou	1981	Tigers' Cobb x 2	0.652	0.713	-0.061
7	Kaline, Al	1961	Detroit Tigers 14-18-36-49-61	0.848	0.908	-0.060
7	Pinson, Vada	1965	CIN 1923-1939-1965-2012-2022	0.776	0.836	-0.060
7	Wingo, Al	1925	DET 1935-1945-1903-2023-1925	0.924	0.983	-0.059
7	Crawford, Sam	1909	Tigers 1909, 1917, 1984, 1967, 1930	0.760	0.818	-0.058
7	Gehringer, Charlie	1938	15,38,50,69,20 Tigers	0.855	0.911	-0.056
7	McCormick, Frank	1940	Reds 05/26//40/61/78	0.793	0.849	-0.056
7	Larkin, Barry	1996	L7: Reds	0.923	0.977	-0.054
7	Phillips, Brandon	2011	Reds: 1920/1964/1967/1988/2011	0.759	0.810	-0.051
7	Cozart, Zack	2017	Reds1944, 56, 81, 2005, 17	0.883	0.933	-0.050
7	Burgess, Smoky	1955	Reds 04-32-55-76-89	0.826	0.872	-0.046
7	Roush, Edd	1920	Reds: 1920/1964/1967/1988/2011	0.793	0.839	-0.046
7	Rose, Pete	1976	Reds 04-32-55-76-89	0.811	0.854	-0.043
7	Cobb, Ty	1915	15,38,50,69,20 Tigers	0.933	0.973	-0.040
7	Rose, Pete	1973	Reds 25/73/80/95/10	0.800	0.838	-0.038
7	Critz, Hughie	1926	Reds 05/26//40/61/78	0.650	0.687	-0.037
7	Veach, Bobby	1922	L7: Tigers	0.809	0.845	-0.036
7	Cardenas, Leo	1965	CIN 1923-1939-1965-2012-2022	0.753	0.786	-0.033
7	Gennett, Scooter	2018	Reds 1924, 1970, 2014, 2018, 1982	0.815	0.847	-0.032
7	Rodriguez, Ivan	2006	Make Sparky Proud	0.737	0.769	-0.032
7	Rogell, Billy	1935	DET 1935-1945-1903-2023-1925	0.723	0.755	-0.032
7	Gennett, Scooter	2017	Reds1944, 56, 81, 2005, 17	0.842	0.873	-0.031
7	Rose, Pete	1971	Reds 42, 71, 77, 90 19	0.764	0.794	-0.030
7	Herman, Babe	1932	Reds 04-32-55-76-89	0.904	0.930	-0.026
7	Kell, George	1946	Curtis, My Man	0.782	0.804	-0.022
7	Cobb, Ty	1923	Curtis, My Man	0.864	0.882	-0.018
7	Larkin, Barry	1988	Reds: 1920/1964/1967/1988/2011	0.760	0.776	-0.016
7	Roush, Edd	1918	Cincinnati Reds 15-18-62-75-15	0.807	0.823	-0.016
7	Votto, Joey	2010	Reds 25/73/80/95/10	1.013	1.024	-0.011
7	Greenberg, Hank	1938	15,38,50,69,20 Tigers	1.117	1.121	-0.004
7	Daniels, Kal	1988	Reds: 1920/1964/1967/1988/2011	0.856	0.860	-0.004
7	Trammell, Alan	1990	Here There Be Tygers	0.824	0.826	-0.002
7	Roush, Edd	1919	Bigwig's Reds (09/19/74/87/13)	0.815	0.811	0.004
7	Cash, Norm	1961	Detroit Tigers 14-18-36-49-61	1.153	1.149	0.004
7	Votto, Joey	2012	CIN 1923-1939-1965-2012-2022	1.046	1.041	0.005
7	Roberts, Bip	1992	L7: Reds	0.838	0.825	0.013
7	Larkin, Barry	1992	L7: Reds	0.850	0.831	0.019
7	Concepcion, Dave	1975	Cincinnati Reds 15-18-62-75-15	0.705	0.679	0.026
7	Rose, Pete	1968	5 Reds 1968 1969 1991 2007 2020	0.892	0.861	0.031
7	Groh, Heinie	1919	Bigwig's Reds (09/19/74/87/13)	0.865	0.823	0.042
7	Tolan, Bobby	1970	Reds 1924, 1970, 2014, 2018, 1982	0.908	0.859	0.049

LEAGUE 7 - PITCHING
(Min 96 IP to qualify, sorted by biggest underachievers, measured by ERA difference)
.

Player	Year__	Team	Sim ERA	Act ERA	ERA Diff
Luque, Dolf	1927	L7: Reds	7.85	3.20	4.65
Rijo, Jose	1992	L7: Reds	7.09	2.56	4.53
McLain, Denny	1968	Here There Be Tygers	6.05	1.96	4.09
Lolich, Mickey	1972	Tigers' Cobb x 2	6.29	2.50	3.79
Rixey, Eppa	1923	CIN 1923-1939-1965-2012-2022	6.54	2.80	3.74
Eller, Hod	1919	Bigwig's Reds (09/19/74/87/13)	6.03	2.39	3.64
Hoeft, Billy	1955	Tigers 1912,1934,1955,2009,2016	6.46	2.99	3.47
Newhouser, Hal	1944	Puzzle Tigers	5.68	2.22	3.46
Morris, Jack	1987	L7: Tigers	6.75	3.38	3.37
Seaver, Tom	1981	Reds1944, 56, 81, 2005, 17	5.91	2.54	3.37
Walters, Bucky	1940	Reds 05/26//40/61/78	5.78	2.48	3.30
Collins, Rip	1924	Puzzle Tigers	6.49	3.21	3.28
Walters, Bucky	1939	CIN 1923-1939-1965-2012-2022	5.55	2.29	3.26
Walters, Bucky	1944	Reds1944, 56, 81, 2005, 17	5.62	2.40	3.22
Schourek, Pete	1995	Reds 25/73/80/95/10	6.40	3.22	3.18
Fromme, Art	1909	Bigwig's Reds (09/19/74/87/13)	4.87	1.90	2.97
Dauss, Hooks	1915	15,38,50,69,20 Tigers	5.45	2.50	2.95
Dubuc, Jean	1912	Tigers 1912,1934,1955,2009,2016	5.66	2.77	2.89
Heusser, Ed	1944	Reds1944, 56, 81, 2005, 17	5.25	2.38	2.87
Summers, Ed	1908	Tigers' Cobb x 2	4.39	1.64	2.75
Lucas, Red	1932	Reds 04-32-55-76-89	5.68	2.94	2.74
Soto, Mario	1981	Reds1944, 56, 81, 2005, 17	5.99	3.29	2.70
Donovan, Bill	1903	DET 1935-1945-1903-2023-1925	4.97	2.29	2.68
Eller, Hod	1918	Cincinnati Reds 15-18-62-75-15	5.00	2.36	2.64
Pillette, Herman	1922	L7: Tigers	5.49	2.85	2.64
Rijo, Jose	1991	5 Reds 1968 1969 1991 2007 2020	5.12	2.51	2.61
Morris, Jack	1981	Tigers' Cobb x 2	5.61	3.05	2.56
Lucas, Red	1927	L7: Reds	5.93	3.38	2.55
Soto, Mario	1982	Reds 1924, 1970, 2014, 2018, 1982	5.31	2.79	2.52
Price, David	2014	Puzzle Tigers	5.77	3.26	2.51
Luque, Dolf	1925	Reds 25/73/80/95/10	5.12	2.63	2.49
Pastore, Frank	1980	Reds 25/73/80/95/10	5.76	3.27	2.49
Scherzer, Max	2010	Make Sparky Proud	5.98	3.50	2.48
Fidrych, Mark	1976	L7: Tigers	4.79	2.34	2.45
Bauer, Trevor	2020	5 Reds 1968 1969 1991 2007 2020	4.17	1.73	2.44
Verlander, Justin	2011	Tigers: 1959/1962/1983/2011/2015	4.78	2.40	2.38
Scherzer, Max	2014	Puzzle Tigers	5.45	3.15	2.30
Willett, Ed	1909	Tigers 1909, 1917, 1984, 1967, 1930	4.63	2.34	2.29
Newhouser, Hal	1946	Curtis, My Man	4.21	1.94	2.27
Trout, Dizzy	1944	Puzzle Tigers	4.36	2.12	2.24
Aguirre, Hank	1962	Tigers: 1959/1962/1983/2011/2015	4.44	2.21	2.23
Alexander, Doyle	1987	L7: Tigers	5.18	3.01	2.17
Kellum, Win	1904	Reds 04-32-55-76-89	4.77	2.60	2.17
Mossi, Don	1959	Tigers: 1959/1962/1983/2011/2015	5.52	3.36	2.16
Seaver, Tom	1977	Reds 42, 71, 77, 90 19	4.65	2.58	2.07
Ewing, Bob	1905	Reds 05/26//40/61/78	4.57	2.51	2.06
Harang, Aaron	2007	5 Reds 1968 1969 1991 2007 2020	5.77	3.73	2.04
Coveleski, Harry	1916	Tigers' Cobb x 2	4.00	1.97	2.03
Newhouser, Hal	1945	DET 1935-1945-1903-2023-1925	3.82	1.81	2.01
Rowe, Schoolboy	1935	DET 1935-1945-1903-2023-1925	5.69	3.69	2.00
Fister, Doug	2011	Tigers: 1959/1962/1983/2011/2015	4.83	2.83	2.00
Donohue, Pete	1926	Reds 05/26//40/61/78	5.36	3.37	1.99
Lolich, Mickey	1969	15,38,50,69,20 Tigers	5.08	3.14	1.94
Mullin, George	1909	Tigers 1909, 1917, 1984, 1967, 1930	4.14	2.22	1.92
Coveleski, Harry	1914	Detroit Tigers 14-18-36-49-61	4.38	2.49	1.89
Thompson, Justin	1997	L7: Tigers	4.90	3.02	1.88
Summers, Ed	1909	Tigers 1909, 1917, 1984, 1967, 1930	4.12	2.24	1.88
Hahn, Noodles	1902	L7: Reds	3.60	1.77	1.83
Coveleski, Harry	1915	15,38,50,69,20 Tigers	4.28	2.45	1.83
Luque, Dolf	1923	CIN 1923-1939-1965-2012-2022	3.75	1.93	1.82
Donovan, Bill	1910	Make Sparky Proud	4.25	2.44	1.81
Cueto, Johnny	2014	Reds 1924, 1970, 2014, 2018, 1982	4.02	2.25	1.77
Dela Cruz, Tommy	1944	Reds1944, 56, 81, 2005, 17	4.94	3.25	1.69
Siever, Ed	1902	Curtis, My Man	3.46	1.91	1.55
Cueto, Johnny	2011	Reds: 1920/1964/1967/1988/2011	3.86	2.31	1.55
Ring, Jimmy	1919	Bigwig's Reds (09/19/74/87/13)	3.78	2.26	1.52
Douglas, Phil	1915	Cincinnati Reds 15-18-62-75-15	4.77	3.25	1.52
Gray, Sonny	2020	5 Reds 1968 1969 1991 2007 2020	5.16	3.70	1.46
Vander Meer, Johnny	1942	Reds 42, 71, 77, 90 19	3.85	2.43	1.42
Trucks, Virgil	1949	Detroit Tigers 14-18-36-49-61	4.18	2.81	1.37
Verlander, Justin	2012	Make Sparky Proud	3.97	2.64	1.33
Cronin, Jack	1902	Curtis, My Man	4.42	3.09	1.33
Dauss, Hooks	1923	Curtis, My Man	4.94	3.62	1.32
Toney, Fred	1918	Cincinnati Reds 15-18-62-75-15	3.75	2.43	1.32
Derringer, Paul	1940	Reds 05/26//40/61/78	4.29	3.06	1.23
Nolan, Gary	1971	Reds 42, 71, 77, 90 19	4.39	3.16	1.23
Boland, Bernie	1918	Detroit Tigers 14-18-36-49-61	3.80	2.65	1.15
Rijo, Jose	1990	Reds 42, 71, 77, 90 19	3.83	2.70	1.13
Willett, Ed	1910	Make Sparky Proud	3.49	2.37	1.12
Toney, Fred	1915	Cincinnati Reds 15-18-62-75-15	2.64	1.58	1.06
Donohue, Pete	1925	Reds 25/73/80/95/10	4.14	3.08	1.06
McLain, Denny	1969	15,38,50,69,20 Tigers	3.83	2.80	1.03
Luque, Dolf	1920	Reds: 1920/1964/1967/1988/2011	3.51	2.51	1.00
Verlander, Justin	2016	Tigers 1912,1934,1955,2009,2016	3.98	3.04	0.94
Bridges, Tommy	1940	Here There Be Tygers	4.15	3.37	0.78
Hahn, Noodles	1904	Reds 04-32-55-76-89	2.83	2.06	0.77
O Toole, Jim	1964	Reds: 1920/1964/1967/1988/2011	3.40	2.66	0.74
Cunningham, George	1918	Detroit Tigers 14-18-36-49-61	3.84	3.15	0.69
Lolich, Mickey	1967	Tigers 1909, 1917, 1984, 1967, 1930	3.73	3.04	0.69
Verlander, Justin	2009	Tigers 1912,1934,1955,2009,2016	4.12	3.45	0.67
Fisher, Ray	1919	Bigwig's Reds (09/19/74/87/13)	2.83	2.17	0.66
Sanchez, Anibal	2013	Here There Be Tygers	3.14	2.57	0.57
Verlander, Justin	2010	Make Sparky Proud	3.90	3.37	0.53
Jackson, Danny	1988	Reds: 1920/1964/1967/1988/2011	3.04	2.73	0.31
Mays, Carl	1924	Reds 1924, 1970, 2014, 2018, 1982	3.42	3.15	0.27
Rixey, Eppa	1924	Reds 1924, 1970, 2014, 2018, 1982	2.90	2.76	0.14
Scherzer, Max	2013	Here There Be Tygers	2.76	2.90	-0.14

League 7 - Team Hitting Total Comparison
.

Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Exp HR	Exp OPS	Act OPS	Diff
CIN 1923-1939-1965-2012-2022	footballmm11	Reds	89	0.882	0.752	-0.130
Reds1944, 56, 81, 2005, 17	DarthDurron	Reds	167	0.891	0.766	-0.125
Reds 42, 71, 77, 90 19	glowguy	Reds	153	0.865	0.742	-0.123
Reds 25/73/80/95/10	toysboys	Reds	110	0.881	0.760	-0.121
Reds 05/26//40/61/78	Dufferman	Reds	71	0.858	0.757	-0.102
Cincinnati Reds 15-18-62-75-15	emanes10	Reds	99	0.864	0.768	-0.096
Reds 1924, 1970, 2014, 2018, 1982	schwarze	Reds	122	0.874	0.779	-0.095
5 Reds 1968 1969 1991 2007 2020	BeAllEndAll	Reds	117	0.859	0.764	-0.095
Bigwig's Reds (09/19/74/87/13)	njbigwig	Reds	113	0.871	0.779	-0.093
L7: Reds	3dayrotation	Reds	87	0.855	0.768	-0.087
Reds 04-32-55-76-89	redcped	Reds	130	0.899	0.814	-0.085
Reds: 1920/1964/1967/1988/2011	thejuice6	Reds	101	0.838	0.769	-0.069
.
Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Exp HR	Exp OPS	Act OPS	Diff
Here There Be Tygers	barracuda3	Tigers	122	0.952	0.806	-0.146
Tigers: 1959/1962/1983/2011/2015	thejuice6	Tigers	128	0.881	0.737	-0.144
L7: Tigers	3dayrotation	Tigers	59	0.904	0.761	-0.143
Puzzle Tigers	calhoop	Tigers	87	0.899	0.769	-0.130
Tigers 1912,1934,1955,2009,2016	mllama54	Tigers	62	0.899	0.779	-0.120
Make Sparky Proud	Bill_James47	Tigers	113	0.929	0.810	-0.118
DET 1935-1945-1903-2023-1925	footballmm11	Tigers	70	0.920	0.802	-0.118
15,38,50,69,20 Tigers	kstober	Tigers	102	0.919	0.802	-0.117
Curtis, My Man	ybjsports	Tigers	91	0.912	0.801	-0.112
Tigers' Cobb x 2	nocomm999	Tigers	49	0.856	0.748	-0.108
Tigers 1909, 1917, 1984, 1967, 1930	schwarze	Tigers	66	0.887	0.790	-0.097
Detroit Tigers 14-18-36-49-61	emanes10	Tigers	76	0.911	0.825	-0.086

League 7 - Team Pitching Total Comparison
.

Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Act ERA	Exp ERA	ERA Diff
L7: Reds	3dayrotation	Reds	5.44	2.65	2.79
Reds1944, 56, 81, 2005, 17	DarthDurron	Reds	5.43	2.72	2.71
CIN 1923-1939-1965-2012-2022	footballmm11	Reds	4.87	2.34	2.53
Bigwig's Reds (09/19/74/87/13)	njbigwig	Reds	4.81	2.34	2.47
Reds 05/26//40/61/78	Dufferman	Reds	4.99	2.86	2.13
5 Reds 1968 1969 1991 2007 2020	BeAllEndAll	Reds	4.93	2.84	2.09
Reds 25/73/80/95/10	toysboys	Reds	5.17	3.10	2.07
Cincinnati Reds 15-18-62-75-15	emanes10	Reds	4.39	2.42	1.97
Reds 42, 71, 77, 90 19	glowguy	Reds	4.51	2.69	1.82
Reds 04-32-55-76-89	redcped	Reds	4.28	2.50	1.79
Reds 1924, 1970, 2014, 2018, 1982	schwarze	Reds	3.92	2.67	1.25
Reds: 1920/1964/1967/1988/2011	thejuice6	Reds	3.46	2.28	1.18
.
Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Act ERA	Exp ERA	ERA Diff
Puzzle Tigers	calhoop	Tigers	5.66	2.85	2.81
L7: Tigers	3dayrotation	Tigers	5.62	2.89	2.74
Tigers' Cobb x 2	nocomm999	Tigers	4.89	2.25	2.64
Tigers 1912,1934,1955,2009,2016	mllama54	Tigers	5.68	3.12	2.56
Tigers: 1959/1962/1983/2011/2015	thejuice6	Tigers	5.25	2.69	2.56
DET 1935-1945-1903-2023-1925	footballmm11	Tigers	4.71	2.58	2.13
15,38,50,69,20 Tigers	kstober	Tigers	4.92	2.86	2.07
Here There Be Tygers	barracuda3	Tigers	4.42	2.51	1.91
Curtis, My Man	ybjsports	Tigers	4.49	2.72	1.77
Make Sparky Proud	Bill_James47	Tigers	4.35	2.87	1.48
Tigers 1909, 1917, 1984, 1967, 1930	schwarze	Tigers	3.84	2.46	1.37
Detroit Tigers 14-18-36-49-61	emanes10	Tigers	4.20	2.84	1.36

LEAGUE 8 - HITTING
(Min 297 PA to qualify, sorted by biggest underachievers, measured by OPS difference)
.

Name	Year__	Team Name	Sim OPS	Act OPS	DIFF
McGriff, Fred	1994	ATL 1994-2012-2022-1973-1951	0.675	1.012	-0.337
Hisle, Larry	1977	Twins 1918, 1935, 1965, 1977, 2007	0.568	0.902	-0.334
Mathews, Eddie	1953	Putting on a Brave face	0.717	1.033	-0.316
Murphy, Dale	1987	Braves 1968, 87,98, 2009, 18	0.684	0.997	-0.313
Acuna Jr., Ronald	2020	Braves 62/81/01/05/20	0.681	0.987	-0.306
Mauer, Joe	2009	Kuhel & the Gang	0.726	1.031	-0.305
Goslin, Goose	1930	Washington/Minnesota Twins	0.689	0.983	-0.294
Jones, Chipper	1999	5 Braves 1958 1969 1999 2006 2023	0.790	1.074	-0.284
Drew, J.D.	2004	Mostly Millennial Braves	0.729	1.005	-0.276
Aaron, Hank	1959	L8: Braves	0.779	1.037	-0.258
Torre, Joe	1966	Braves 1915-1948-1966-2000-2011	0.693	0.942	-0.249
Ozuna, Marcell	2020	Braves 62/81/01/05/20	0.819	1.067	-0.248
Mathews, Eddie	1959	L8: Braves	0.736	0.983	-0.247
Allison, Bob	1964	Twins/Senators: 1913/1932/1963/1964/1972	0.711	0.957	-0.246
Aaron, Hank	1955	BRAVES 1947/55/56/60/95	0.662	0.906	-0.244
Morneau, Justin	2008	Washington/Minnesota Twins	0.629	0.873	-0.244
Cronin, Joe	1931	Kuhel & the Gang	0.629	0.871	-0.242
Aaron, Hank	1969	5 Braves 1958 1969 1999 2006 2023	0.764	1.003	-0.239
Carty, Rico	1970	Putting on a Brave face	0.802	1.038	-0.236
Jones, Chipper	1998	Braves 1968, 87,98, 2009, 18	0.717	0.951	-0.234
Myer, Buddy	1938	Puzzle Twins	0.685	0.919	-0.234
Jones, Andruw	2004	Mostly Millennial Braves	0.600	0.833	-0.233
Freeman, Freddie	2020	Braves 62/81/01/05/20	0.870	1.102	-0.232
Myatt, George	1945	Washington/Minnesota Twins	0.516	0.743	-0.227
Aaron, Hank	1962	Braves 62/81/01/05/20	0.784	1.008	-0.224
Aaron, Hank	1973	ATL 1994-2012-2022-1973-1951	0.822	1.045	-0.223
Mack, Shane	1992	Kuhel & the Gang	0.639	0.861	-0.222
Killebrew, Harmon	1970	MIN 1915-1924-1970-2013-1978	0.739	0.957	-0.218
Olson, Matt	2023	5 Braves 1958 1969 1999 2006 2023	0.775	0.993	-0.218
Albies, Ozzie	2023	5 Braves 1958 1969 1999 2006 2023	0.634	0.849	-0.215
Bluege, Ossie	1928	Senators 1928, 2020, 1917, 1976, 1974	0.549	0.764	-0.215
Acuna Jr., Ronald	2019	Braves: 1961/1965/1974/1993/2019	0.673	0.883	-0.210
Giles, Marcus	2005	Braves 62/81/01/05/20	0.618	0.826	-0.208
Goslin, Goose	1928	Senators 1928, 2020, 1917, 1976, 1974	0.851	1.057	-0.206
Gaetti, Gary	1986	Senatorial Twins 27/33/69/86/10	0.661	0.865	-0.204
Killebrew, Harmon	1969	Senatorial Twins 27/33/69/86/10	0.812	1.011	-0.199
Morneau, Justin	2006	Puzzle Twins	0.736	0.934	-0.198
Judge, Joe	1929	Senators/Twins 12, 29, 59, 73, 22	0.641	0.838	-0.197
Acuna Jr., Ronald	2023	5 Braves 1958 1969 1999 2006 2023	0.817	1.012	-0.195
Mathews, Eddie	1955	BRAVES 1947/55/56/60/95	0.820	1.014	-0.194
Rice, Sam	1919	L8: Twins	0.594	0.787	-0.193
Sheffield, Gary	2003	Braves 1917, 2003, 2007, 2021, 1945	0.835	1.023	-0.188
Puckett, Kirby	1988	Senators-Twins 14-26-75-88-04	0.733	0.920	-0.187
Giles, Marcus	2003	Braves 1917, 2003, 2007, 2021, 1945	0.729	0.916	-0.187
Jones, Chipper	2007	Braves 1917, 2003, 2007, 2021, 1945	0.842	1.029	-0.187
Renteria, Edgar	2006	5 Braves 1958 1969 1999 2006 2023	0.611	0.797	-0.186
Span, Denard	2009	Kuhel & the Gang	0.622	0.807	-0.185
Millan, Felix	1970	Putting on a Brave face	0.547	0.732	-0.185
McCann, Brian	2006	5 Braves 1958 1969 1999 2006 2023	0.776	0.960	-0.184
Manush, Heinie	1930	Washington/Minnesota Twins	0.736	0.916	-0.180
Milan, Clyde	1911	Puzzle Twins	0.609	0.789	-0.180
Travis, Cecil	1935	Twins 1918, 1935, 1965, 1977, 2007	0.597	0.776	-0.179
Guzman, Cristian	2004	Senators-Twins 14-26-75-88-04	0.515	0.693	-0.178
Jones, Chipper	2001	Braves 62/81/01/05/20	0.855	1.032	-0.177
Evans, Darrell	1973	ATL 1994-2012-2022-1973-1951	0.782	0.959	-0.177
Aaron, Hank	1967	Putting on a Brave face	0.765	0.942	-0.177
Gordon, Sid	1950	50,57,63,82,97 Braves	0.783	0.960	-0.177
Killebrew, Harmon	1967	Senators/Twins: 1925/1943/1967/2005/2018	0.790	0.966	-0.176
Aaron, Hank	1958	5 Braves 1958 1969 1999 2006 2023	0.757	0.932	-0.175
Morneau, Justin	2009	Kuhel & the Gang	0.704	0.879	-0.175
Hornsby, Rogers	1928	L8: Braves	0.955	1.130	-0.175
Hrbek, Kent	1988	Senators-Twins 14-26-75-88-04	0.733	0.907	-0.174
Goslin, Goose	1925	Senators/Twins: 1925/1943/1967/2005/2018	0.769	0.941	-0.172
Carew, Rod	1973	Senators/Twins 12, 29, 59, 73, 22	0.712	0.882	-0.170
Killebrew, Harmon	1964	Twins/Senators: 1913/1932/1963/1964/1972	0.756	0.925	-0.169
Jones, Chipper	2000	Braves 1915-1948-1966-2000-2011	0.801	0.970	-0.169
Goslin, Goose	1926	Senators-Twins 14-26-75-88-04	0.801	0.967	-0.166
Aaron, Hank	1964	L8: Braves	0.742	0.907	-0.165
Cronin, Joe	1930	Washington/Minnesota Twins	0.771	0.935	-0.164
Wynegar, Butch	1976	Senators 1928, 2020, 1917, 1976, 1974	0.557	0.719	-0.162
Alou, Felipe	1966	Braves 1915-1948-1966-2000-2011	0.733	0.894	-0.161
Aaron, Hank	1963	50,57,63,82,97 Braves	0.817	0.977	-0.160
Mauer, Joe	2010	Senatorial Twins 27/33/69/86/10	0.711	0.871	-0.160
McCann, Brian	2008	Mostly Millennial Braves	0.736	0.896	-0.160
Torre, Joe	1965	Braves: 1961/1965/1974/1993/2019	0.701	0.861	-0.160
Johnson, Davey	1973	ATL 1994-2012-2022-1973-1951	0.757	0.916	-0.159
Jones, Andruw	2000	Braves 1915-1948-1966-2000-2011	0.748	0.907	-0.159
Furcal, Rafael	2005	Braves 62/81/01/05/20	0.621	0.777	-0.156
Puckett, Kirby	1989	L8: Twins	0.688	0.844	-0.156
Freeman, Freddie	2021	Braves 1917, 2003, 2007, 2021, 1945	0.744	0.896	-0.152
Knoblauch, Chuck	1996	L8: Twins	0.813	0.965	-0.152
Logan, Johnny	1955	BRAVES 1947/55/56/60/95	0.650	0.802	-0.152
Heyward, Jason	2010	Mostly Millennial Braves	0.697	0.849	-0.152
Puckett, Kirby	1986	Senatorial Twins 27/33/69/86/10	0.754	0.903	-0.149
Carew, Rod	1969	Senatorial Twins 27/33/69/86/10	0.705	0.853	-0.148
Cepeda, Orlando	1970	Putting on a Brave face	0.765	0.908	-0.143
Freeman, Freddie	2019	Braves: 1961/1965/1974/1993/2019	0.795	0.938	-0.143
Mathews, Eddie	1957	50,57,63,82,97 Braves	0.785	0.927	-0.142
Torre, Joe	1964	L8: Braves	0.721	0.863	-0.142
Oliva, Tony	1964	Twins/Senators: 1913/1932/1963/1964/1972	0.775	0.916	-0.141
Torgeson, Earl	1950	50,57,63,82,97 Braves	0.744	0.884	-0.140
Carew, Rod	1978	MIN 1915-1924-1970-2013-1978	0.714	0.852	-0.138
Rice, Sam	1926	Senators-Twins 14-26-75-88-04	0.689	0.825	-0.136
Mauer, Joe	2006	Puzzle Twins	0.802	0.936	-0.134
Prado, Martin	2010	Mostly Millennial Braves	0.676	0.809	-0.133
Logan, Johnny	1957	50,57,63,82,97 Braves	0.587	0.720	-0.133
Delahanty, Ed	1902	Puzzle Twins	0.910	1.043	-0.133
Carew, Rod	1975	Senators-Twins 14-26-75-88-04	0.786	0.918	-0.132
Blauser, Jeff	1993	Braves: 1961/1965/1974/1993/2019	0.705	0.837	-0.132
Escobar, Eduardo	2018	Senators/Twins: 1925/1943/1967/2005/2018	0.693	0.823	-0.130
Battey, Earl	1963	Twins/Senators: 1913/1932/1963/1964/1972	0.715	0.845	-0.130
Travis, Cecil	1938	Puzzle Twins	0.703	0.833	-0.130
Cronin, Joe	1932	Twins/Senators: 1913/1932/1963/1964/1972	0.758	0.885	-0.127
Cronin, Joe	1933	Senatorial Twins 27/33/69/86/10	0.716	0.843	-0.127
Tovar, Cesar	1970	MIN 1915-1924-1970-2013-1978	0.673	0.798	-0.125
Teixeira, Mark	2007	Braves 1917, 2003, 2007, 2021, 1945	0.841	0.963	-0.122
Prado, Martin	2009	Braves 1968, 87,98, 2009, 18	0.700	0.822	-0.122
Bluege, Ossie	1931	Kuhel & the Gang	0.598	0.718	-0.120
Cordova, Marty	1996	L8: Twins	0.730	0.849	-0.119
Jones, Chipper	2008	Mostly Millennial Braves	0.925	1.044	-0.119
Escobar, Yunel	2008	Mostly Millennial Braves	0.648	0.767	-0.119
Crandall, Del	1960	BRAVES 1947/55/56/60/95	0.648	0.764	-0.116
Sisler, George	1928	L8: Braves	0.701	0.814	-0.113
Ruel, Muddy	1926	Senators-Twins 14-26-75-88-04	0.677	0.790	-0.113
Oliva, Tony	1970	MIN 1915-1924-1970-2013-1978	0.767	0.878	-0.111
Aaron, Hank	1956	BRAVES 1947/55/56/60/95	0.812	0.923	-0.111
Schoendienst, Red	1957	50,57,63,82,97 Braves	0.685	0.795	-0.110
Carew, Rod	1977	Twins 1918, 1935, 1965, 1977, 2007	0.909	1.019	-0.110
Myer, Buddy	1935	Twins 1918, 1935, 1965, 1977, 2007	0.799	0.908	-0.109
Puckett, Kirby	1992	Kuhel & the Gang	0.755	0.864	-0.109
Jones, Chipper	1996	Putting on a Brave face	0.815	0.923	-0.108
Richbourg, Lance	1928	L8: Braves	0.719	0.827	-0.108
Mauer, Joe	2005	Senators/Twins: 1925/1943/1967/2005/2018	0.675	0.783	-0.108
Swanson, Dansby	2022	ATL 1994-2012-2022-1973-1951	0.670	0.776	-0.106
Smalley, Roy	1976	Senators 1928, 2020, 1917, 1976, 1974	0.576	0.680	-0.104
Knoblauch, Chuck	1992	Kuhel & the Gang	0.638	0.742	-0.104
Aaron, Hank	1957	50,57,63,82,97 Braves	0.875	0.978	-0.103
Jones, Chipper	2002	Putting on a Brave face	0.868	0.971	-0.103
Garr, Ralph	1974	Braves: 1961/1965/1974/1993/2019	0.783	0.886	-0.103
Carew, Rod	1976	Senators 1928, 2020, 1917, 1976, 1974	0.761	0.858	-0.097
Holmes, Tommy	1945	Braves 1917, 2003, 2007, 2021, 1945	0.900	0.997	-0.097
Menke, Denis	1964	L8: Braves	0.750	0.847	-0.097
Oliva, Tony	1965	Twins 1918, 1935, 1965, 1977, 2007	0.773	0.869	-0.096
Mauer, Joe	2013	MIN 1915-1924-1970-2013-1978	0.784	0.880	-0.096
Holmes, Tommy	1947	BRAVES 1947/55/56/60/95	0.681	0.776	-0.095
Versalles, Zoilo	1965	Twins 1918, 1935, 1965, 1977, 2007	0.687	0.781	-0.094
Torre, Joe	1963	50,57,63,82,97 Braves	0.688	0.781	-0.093
Goslin, Goose	1927	Senatorial Twins 27/33/69/86/10	0.817	0.908	-0.091
Dark, Alvin	1948	Braves 1915-1948-1966-2000-2011	0.695	0.786	-0.091
Rice, Sam	1917	Senators 1928, 2020, 1917, 1976, 1974	0.640	0.729	-0.089
Alou, Felipe	1968	Braves 1968, 87,98, 2009, 18	0.715	0.803	-0.088
Furcal, Rafael	2003	Braves 1917, 2003, 2007, 2021, 1945	0.708	0.795	-0.087
Manush, Heinie	1932	Twins/Senators: 1913/1932/1963/1964/1972	0.817	0.903	-0.086
Justice, David	1994	ATL 1994-2012-2022-1973-1951	0.875	0.958	-0.083
Killebrew, Harmon	1959	Senators/Twins 12, 29, 59, 73, 22	0.790	0.870	-0.080
Klesko, Ryan	1995	BRAVES 1947/55/56/60/95	0.924	1.004	-0.080
Manush, Heinie	1933	Senatorial Twins 27/33/69/86/10	0.752	0.831	-0.079
Adcock, Joe	1956	BRAVES 1947/55/56/60/95	0.856	0.934	-0.078
Bostock, Lyman	1977	Twins 1918, 1935, 1965, 1977, 2007	0.821	0.897	-0.076
Bluege, Ossie	1925	Senators/Twins: 1925/1943/1967/2005/2018	0.664	0.739	-0.075
Carew, Rod	1974	Senators 1928, 2020, 1917, 1976, 1974	0.805	0.879	-0.074
Aaron, Hank	1968	Braves 1968, 87,98, 2009, 18	0.781	0.852	-0.071
Rice, Sam	1924	MIN 1915-1924-1970-2013-1978	0.754	0.825	-0.071
Correa, Carlos	2022	Senators/Twins 12, 29, 59, 73, 22	0.764	0.833	-0.069
Goslin, Goose	1924	MIN 1915-1924-1970-2013-1978	0.870	0.937	-0.067
Rice, Sam	1930	Washington/Minnesota Twins	0.800	0.864	-0.064
Mauer, Joe	2008	Washington/Minnesota Twins	0.801	0.864	-0.063
Travis, Cecil	1941	L8: Twins	0.868	0.930	-0.062
Milan, Clyde	1912	Senators/Twins 12, 29, 59, 73, 22	0.694	0.756	-0.062
Rollins, Rich	1963	Twins/Senators: 1913/1932/1963/1964/1972	0.743	0.803	-0.060
Killebrew, Harmon	1966	Washington/Minnesota Twins	0.872	0.929	-0.057
Elberfeld, Kid	1911	Puzzle Twins	0.687	0.744	-0.057
Mathews, Eddie	1961	Braves: 1961/1965/1974/1993/2019	0.881	0.937	-0.056
Bourn, Michael	2011	Braves 1915-1948-1966-2000-2011	0.685	0.735	-0.050
Smalley, Roy	1978	MIN 1915-1924-1970-2013-1978	0.747	0.795	-0.048
Teixeira, Mark	2008	Mostly Millennial Braves	0.922	0.962	-0.040
Carew, Rod	1972	Twins/Senators: 1913/1932/1963/1964/1972	0.726	0.748	-0.022
Gaetti, Gary	1988	Senators-Twins 14-26-75-88-04	0.886	0.904	-0.018
Oliva, Tony	1967	Senators/Twins: 1925/1943/1967/2005/2018	0.853	0.810	0.043

LEAGUE 8 - PITCHING
(Min 96 IP to qualify, sorted by biggest underachievers, measured by ERA difference)
.

Player	Year__	Team	Sim ERA	Act ERA	ERA Diff
Fried, Max	2022	ATL 1994-2012-2022-1973-1951	5.97	2.48	3.49
Santana, Johan	2007	Twins 1918, 1935, 1965, 1977, 2007	6.71	3.33	3.38
Burkett, John	2001	Braves 62/81/01/05/20	6.40	3.04	3.36
Pascual, Camilo	1963	Twins/Senators: 1913/1932/1963/1964/1972	5.54	2.46	3.08
Perry, Jim	1969	Senatorial Twins 27/33/69/86/10	5.84	2.82	3.02
Capra, Buzz	1974	Braves: 1961/1965/1974/1993/2019	5.23	2.28	2.95
Spahn, Warren	1953	Putting on a Brave face	4.76	2.10	2.66
Glavine, Tom	1991	L8: Braves	5.19	2.55	2.64
Niekro, Phil	1969	5 Braves 1958 1969 1999 2006 2023	5.14	2.56	2.58
Niekro, Phil	1967	Putting on a Brave face	4.41	1.87	2.54
Boswell, Dave	1969	Senatorial Twins 27/33/69/86/10	5.76	3.23	2.53
Hudson, Tim	2010	Mostly Millennial Braves	5.34	2.83	2.51
Johnson, Walter	1916	Puzzle Twins	4.38	1.90	2.48
Avery, Steve	1993	Braves: 1961/1965/1974/1993/2019	5.29	2.94	2.35
Nehf, Art	1917	Braves 1917, 2003, 2007, 2021, 1945	4.51	2.16	2.35
Merritt, Jim	1967	Senators/Twins: 1925/1943/1967/2005/2018	4.86	2.53	2.33
Shaw, Jim	1919	L8: Twins	5.05	2.73	2.32
Johnson, Walter	1917	Senators 1928, 2020, 1917, 1976, 1974	4.51	2.21	2.30
Santana, Johan	2005	Senators/Twins: 1925/1943/1967/2005/2018	5.15	2.87	2.28
Cooper, Mort	1946	L8: Braves	5.39	3.12	2.27
Spahn, Warren	1951	ATL 1994-2012-2022-1973-1951	5.23	2.98	2.25
Shaw, Jim	1918	Twins 1918, 1935, 1965, 1977, 2007	4.66	2.42	2.24
Blyleven, Bert	1974	Senators 1928, 2020, 1917, 1976, 1974	4.90	2.66	2.24
Glavine, Tom	1997	50,57,63,82,97 Braves	5.20	2.96	2.24
Ayers, Doc	1914	Senators-Twins 14-26-75-88-04	4.73	2.54	2.19
Johnson, Walter	1911	Puzzle Twins	3.87	1.90	1.97
Spahn, Warren	1959	L8: Braves	4.93	2.96	1.97
Chance, Dean	1967	Senators/Twins: 1925/1943/1967/2005/2018	4.65	2.73	1.92
Barnes, Jesse	1917	Braves 1917, 2003, 2007, 2021, 1945	4.57	2.68	1.89
Johnson, Walter	1913	Twins/Senators: 1913/1932/1963/1964/1972	3.00	1.14	1.86
Johnson, Walter	1912	Senators/Twins 12, 29, 59, 73, 22	3.24	1.39	1.85
Spahn, Warren	1958	5 Braves 1958 1969 1999 2006 2023	4.90	3.07	1.83
Johnson, Walter	1918	Twins 1918, 1935, 1965, 1977, 2007	3.10	1.27	1.83
Hudson, Tim	2007	Braves 1917, 2003, 2007, 2021, 1945	5.16	3.33	1.83
Rudolph, Dick	1915	Braves 1915-1948-1966-2000-2011	4.11	2.37	1.74
Sain, Johnny	1946	L8: Braves	3.94	2.21	1.73
Smoltz, John	1997	50,57,63,82,97 Braves	4.75	3.02	1.73
Spahn, Warren	1947	BRAVES 1947/55/56/60/95	4.05	2.33	1.72
Maddux, Greg	1998	Braves 1968, 87,98, 2009, 18	3.93	2.22	1.71
Tyler, Lefty	1916	Mostly Millennial Braves	3.73	2.02	1.71
Wolff, Roger	1945	Washington/Minnesota Twins	3.75	2.12	1.63
Johnson, Walter	1914	Senators-Twins 14-26-75-88-04	3.31	1.72	1.59
Maddux, Greg	2001	Braves 62/81/01/05/20	4.61	3.05	1.56
Johnson, Walter	1925	Senators/Twins: 1925/1943/1967/2005/2018	4.62	3.07	1.55
Johnson, Walter	1910	L8: Twins	2.88	1.36	1.52
Crowder, Alvin	1932	Twins/Senators: 1913/1932/1963/1964/1972	4.85	3.33	1.52
Blyleven, Bert	1973	Senators/Twins 12, 29, 59, 73, 22	4.03	2.52	1.51
Whitehill, Earl	1933	Senatorial Twins 27/33/69/86/10	4.84	3.33	1.51
Hadley, Bump	1927	Senatorial Twins 27/33/69/86/10	4.26	2.85	1.41
Jones, Sam	1928	Senators 1928, 2020, 1917, 1976, 1974	4.18	2.84	1.34
Pascual, Camilo	1959	Senators/Twins 12, 29, 59, 73, 22	3.97	2.64	1.33
Spahn, Warren	1950	50,57,63,82,97 Braves	4.48	3.16	1.32
Tyler, Lefty	1917	Braves 1917, 2003, 2007, 2021, 1945	3.83	2.52	1.31
Hughes, Tom	1908	Kuhel & the Gang	3.44	2.21	1.23
Blyleven, Bert	1985	Washington/Minnesota Twins	4.39	3.16	1.23
Haefner, Mickey	1943	Senators/Twins: 1925/1943/1967/2005/2018	3.51	2.29	1.22
Strider, Spencer	2023	5 Braves 1958 1969 1999 2006 2023	5.07	3.86	1.21
Jarvis, Pat	1968	Braves 1968, 87,98, 2009, 18	3.81	2.60	1.21
Johnson, Walter	1919	L8: Twins	2.68	1.49	1.19
Burdette, Lew	1956	BRAVES 1947/55/56/60/95	3.86	2.70	1.16
Maddux, Greg	1994	ATL 1994-2012-2022-1973-1951	2.70	1.56	1.14
Millwood, Kevin	1999	5 Braves 1958 1969 1999 2006 2023	3.82	2.68	1.14
Smoltz, John	1999	5 Braves 1958 1969 1999 2006 2023	4.31	3.19	1.12
Chance, Dean	1968	Kuhel & the Gang	3.64	2.53	1.11
Smoltz, John	1996	Putting on a Brave face	4.04	2.94	1.10
Maddux, Greg	1995	BRAVES 1947/55/56/60/95	2.70	1.63	1.07
Harper, Harry	1918	Twins 1918, 1935, 1965, 1977, 2007	3.25	2.18	1.07
Crowder, Alvin	1933	Senatorial Twins 27/33/69/86/10	5.04	3.97	1.07
Blyleven, Bert	1972	Twins/Senators: 1913/1932/1963/1964/1972	3.77	2.73	1.04
Ragan, Pat	1916	Mostly Millennial Braves	3.11	2.08	1.03
Soroka, Mike	2019	Braves: 1961/1965/1974/1993/2019	3.71	2.68	1.03
Maddux, Greg	1993	Braves: 1961/1965/1974/1993/2019	3.30	2.36	0.94
Johnson, Walter	1915	MIN 1915-1924-1970-2013-1978	2.48	1.55	0.93
Johnson, Walter	1908	Kuhel & the Gang	2.54	1.65	0.89
Leonard, Dutch	1945	Washington/Minnesota Twins	3.02	2.13	0.89
Rudolph, Dick	1916	Mostly Millennial Braves	3.02	2.16	0.86
Neagle, Denny	1997	50,57,63,82,97 Braves	3.82	2.97	0.85
Maddux, Greg	2000	Braves 1915-1948-1966-2000-2011	3.82	3.00	0.82
Kaat, Jim	1968	Kuhel & the Gang	3.73	2.94	0.79
Smoltz, John	1995	BRAVES 1947/55/56/60/95	3.91	3.18	0.73
Hughes, Tom L.	1915	Braves 1915-1948-1966-2000-2011	2.84	2.12	0.72
Maddux, Greg	1996	Putting on a Brave face	3.44	2.72	0.72
Leonard, Dutch	1938	Puzzle Twins	4.10	3.43	0.67
Braxton, Garland	1928	Senators 1928, 2020, 1917, 1976, 1974	3.17	2.51	0.66
Vazquez, Javier	2009	Braves 1968, 87,98, 2009, 18	3.47	2.87	0.60
Blyleven, Bert	1975	Senators-Twins 14-26-75-88-04	3.54	3.00	0.54
Smoltz, John	2005	Braves 62/81/01/05/20	3.59	3.06	0.53
Johnson, Walter	1924	MIN 1915-1924-1970-2013-1978	3.10	2.72	0.38
Santana, Johan	2006	Puzzle Twins	2.82	2.77	0.05
Santana, Johan	2004	Senators-Twins 14-26-75-88-04	2.64	2.61	0.03
Ayers, Doc	1915	MIN 1915-1924-1970-2013-1978	2.07	2.21	-0.14
Maddux, Greg	1997	50,57,63,82,97 Braves	2.05	2.20	-0.15
Maeda, Kenta	2020	Senators 1928, 2020, 1917, 1976, 1974	2.16	2.70	-0.54

I have to laugh at Kenta Maeda being ranked as the most overachieving qualified pitcher in League 8. He has started zero games, is a respectable 15/19 in saves but has an 0-8 record.

League 8 - Team Hitting Total Comparison
.

Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Exp HR	Exp OPS	Act OPS	Diff
5 Braves 1958 1969 1999 2006 2023	BeAllEndAll	Braves	188	0.947	0.743	-0.204
Braves 62/81/01/05/20	toysboys	Braves	159	0.931	0.728	-0.202
Braves 1968, 87,98, 2009, 18	DarthDurron	Braves	136	0.878	0.688	-0.190
L8: Braves	3dayrotation	Braves	119	0.923	0.760	-0.163
Putting on a Brave face	barracuda3	Braves	152	0.909	0.748	-0.161
ATL 1994-2012-2022-1973-1951	footballmm11	Braves	183	0.909	0.752	-0.157
Braves 1917, 2003, 2007, 2021, 1945	schwarze	Braves	156	0.937	0.786	-0.150
Mostly Millennial Braves	spinaldog	Braves	129	0.889	0.739	-0.149
Braves: 1961/1965/1974/1993/2019	thejuice6	Braves	150	0.888	0.745	-0.143
BRAVES 1947/55/56/60/95	oldtimer59	Braves	137	0.874	0.738	-0.136
Braves 1915-1948-1966-2000-2011	pedrocerrano	Braves	118	0.879	0.745	-0.134
50,57,63,82,97 Braves	kstober	Braves	140	0.877	0.744	-0.133
.
Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Exp HR	Exp OPS	Act OPS	Diff
Kuhel & the Gang	nocomm999	Twins	75	0.842	0.664	-0.178
Washington/Minnesota Twins	pmars2001	Twins	83	0.880	0.715	-0.166
Twins 1918, 1935, 1965, 1977, 2007	mllama54	Twins	74	0.870	0.712	-0.157
L8: Twins	3dayrotation	Twins	43	0.837	0.693	-0.144
Senatorial Twins 27/33/69/86/10	Dufferman	Twins	96	0.870	0.726	-0.143
Senators-Twins 14-26-75-88-04	redcped	Twins	91	0.870	0.729	-0.141
Puzzle Twins	calhoop	Twins	50	0.869	0.732	-0.137
MIN 1915-1924-1970-2013-1978	footballmm11	Twins	83	0.860	0.736	-0.124
Senators 1928, 2020, 1917, 1976, 1974	schwarze	Twins	32	0.802	0.679	-0.123
Twins/Senators: 1913/1932/1963/1964/1972	eman7400	Twins	121	0.869	0.750	-0.120
Senators/Twins 12, 29, 59, 73, 22	glowguy	Twins	90	0.815	0.699	-0.115
Senators/Twins: 1925/1943/1967/2005/2018	thejuice6	Twins	87	0.822	0.727	-0.094

League 8 - Team Pitching Total Comparison
.

Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Act ERA	Exp ERA	ERA Diff
Braves: 1961/1965/1974/1993/2019	thejuice6	Braves	4.70	2.48	2.21
L8: Braves	3dayrotation	Braves	4.73	2.74	1.99
Braves 1917, 2003, 2007, 2021, 1945	schwarze	Braves	4.38	2.58	1.79
ATL 1994-2012-2022-1973-1951	footballmm11	Braves	4.05	2.28	1.78
BRAVES 1947/55/56/60/95	oldtimer59	Braves	4.28	2.53	1.75
Putting on a Brave face	barracuda3	Braves	4.08	2.41	1.67
Braves 1968, 87,98, 2009, 18	DarthDurron	Braves	4.28	2.68	1.60
Braves 62/81/01/05/20	toysboys	Braves	4.16	2.59	1.58
50,57,63,82,97 Braves	kstober	Braves	4.30	2.73	1.57
5 Braves 1958 1969 1999 2006 2023	BeAllEndAll	Braves	4.46	2.91	1.55
Braves 1915-1948-1966-2000-2011	pedrocerrano	Braves	3.50	2.34	1.16
Mostly Millennial Braves	spinaldog	Braves	3.28	2.13	1.15
.
Team Name	Owner	Franchise	Act ERA	Exp ERA	ERA Diff
Twins/Senators: 1913/1932/1963/1964/1972	eman7400	Twins	4.63	2.20	2.42
Senators/Twins: 1925/1943/1967/2005/2018	thejuice6	Twins	4.76	2.63	2.13
Twins 1918, 1935, 1965, 1977, 2007	mllama54	Twins	4.11	2.20	1.91
Senatorial Twins 27/33/69/86/10	Dufferman	Twins	5.06	3.23	1.84
L8: Twins	3dayrotation	Twins	3.94	2.13	1.81
Senators/Twins 12, 29, 59, 73, 22	glowguy	Twins	4.14	2.34	1.80
Kuhel & the Gang	nocomm999	Twins	3.89	2.33	1.56
Washington/Minnesota Twins	pmars2001	Twins	3.88	2.55	1.32
Puzzle Twins	calhoop	Twins	3.74	2.58	1.16
Senators-Twins 14-26-75-88-04	redcped	Twins	3.51	2.37	1.14
Senators 1928, 2020, 1917, 1976, 1974	schwarze	Twins	3.62	2.57	1.05
MIN 1915-1924-1970-2013-1978	footballmm11	Twins	2.78	2.19	0.59

Here is a breakdown of all position players. This does not include pitchers hitting. And no adjustments were made for ballparks. It should not be a surprise that switch-hitters underperform by the least amount.
.

Bats	Usage%	Exp HR%	Exp OPS	Act OPS	Difference
Right	50%	3.8%	0.888	0.739	-0.149
Left	40%	3.3%	0.919	0.773	-0.146
Switch	10%	3.0%	0.848	0.744	-0.103

I broke down all the players by low HR rate (< 3.0%), medium HR rate (3.0% to 5.99%) and high HR rate (6.0%+). This table shows the same information as the previous table...
.

Bats	HR Rate	Usage%	HR Rate	Exp OPS	Act OPS	Difference
Right	Low	22%	1.5%	0.823	0.703	-0.119
Right	Med	18%	4.5%	0.897	0.744	-0.153
Right	High	11%	7.5%	1.009	0.804	-0.204
.
Left	Low	21%	1.3%	0.865	0.746	-0.119
Left	Med	11%	4.5%	0.930	0.773	-0.156
Left	High	7%	7.8%	1.065	0.855	-0.210
.
Switch	Low	5%	1.2%	0.788	0.710	-0.079
Switch	Med	4%	4.5%	0.891	0.766	-0.125
Switch	High	1%	7.4%	1.021	0.861	-0.160

schwarze, thank you for putting this together for us. You are the undisputed king of number crunching. If you get a chance please run the team pitching numbers for the Cards/Indians league 4. For a quick and dirty evaluation to see if your team is under/over performing, take your teams hitting rank and add it to your teams pitching rank. The lower the total the more under performing the higher the number the more over performing. For example my Dodgers would be 3 for hitting and 1 for pitching totaling 4, my Braves team is 12 for hitting and 9 for pitching totaling 21. A scale could be 1-6 = under performing, 7-18 = average performing, 19-24 = over performing.

Yep, I just realized that I accidentally posted league 5 team pitching stats instead of League 4. I have updated that post.

I wish the "Player Search" option listed opponents' OBP & SLG stats for pitchers, then it would be easy to simply compare the difference in sim-vs-actual OPS for both hitting and pitching to get one overall number.

I broke down all the pitchers based on what percentage of their real life games were starts. I categorize pitchers who started at least 75% of their total games as "SP". I categorize pitchers who started less than 25% of their games as "RP". Those between 25% and 75% are categorized as "S/R". How these pitchers are used by their owners is not taken into account.

Recall that "Act" is actual sim stats. And "Exp" is their real life stats multiplied by their sim usage. Ratio is actual stat divided by expected stat. As you can see "RP" typically pitch worse than SP.
.

Type__	Players	Innings___	Usage___	Act ERA	Exp ERA	ERA Ratio
SP	951	109658	68.5%	4.44	2.46	180%
S/R	308	24420	15.2%	4.29	2.35	183%
RP	760	26094	16.3%	4.47	2.38	188%
.
Type	Players	Innings	Usage	Act WHIP	Exp WHIP	WHIP Ratio
SP	951	109658	68.5%	1.47	1.08	137%
S/R	308	24420	15.2%	1.51	1.09	138%
RP	760	26094	16.3%	1.48	1.04	142%