Savage III Commentary Thread Topic

Brad...
1. What are you doing awake?!
2. I think that Kobe/Crash/Dwight are pretty switchable.
11/9/2020 11:19 PM
Posted by longtallbrad on 11/9/2020 10:36:00 PM (view original):
Posted by robusk on 11/9/2020 2:06:00 PM (view original):
Posted by longtallbrad on 11/9/2020 8:28:00 AM (view original):
C: Dwight Howard / DeMarcus Cousins
PF: Andre Drummond / Anderson Varejao / Cousins
SF: Gerald Wallace / Richaun Holmes / Ryan Anderson
SG: Kobe Bryant / Goran Dragic
PG: Jose Calderon / Charlie Ward / Dana Barros

I have mixed sentiments about my squad this time around. If my teams don't do well this season, it could very well be because I waited too long to grab a point guard. Kobe was a bit of a desperation pick because I was getting worried about usage and especially 3s. But I could have picked Terry Porter or Deron Williams along with Kobe and then drafted Faried in the fifth. Well, time to play with the cards I dealt myself.
Very good on usage thanks to Kobe. I think the shooting percentages look real good thanks to the front court. No doubt you will be good on boards. I actually think you mustered the assists well. I think this could end up being a very bad defense. Turnovers and fouls are fine.

I think it could end up being similar to my season two squad: great on offense, hemorrhaging points on defense.
Hmm. You may be right. Howard and Bryant are consistently strong defenders and Wallace ranges from good to great. Calderon will be feasted on by certain opponents, and I tend forget that Drummond's starter seasons are mediocre on D.
Drummond, Dragic, Cousins, Barros and Anderson are all mediocre to below average. Which is normally fine but these league tends to be real high on defense and rebounding.

The formula was enough to not be terrible and get a finals team for me last season.
11/9/2020 11:21 PM
Posted by robusk on 11/9/2020 11:18:00 PM (view original):
Posted by jcred5 on 11/9/2020 7:24:00 PM (view original):
So are we doing self evals?
Lowry/Harper
Jrue/Harper
Silas/Edge/Jamychal/O'Quinn/partridge in a pear tree
Buck/Blake
KAJ/Sikma or Blake

I certainly hope this team will do better than my S2 middle of the pack, that was really one very good team and 4 crappy teams. And hopefully better than my S1 team that I think was tied for 9th.... but we'll see. Big advantage getting KAJ. From there I decided to build the team I want and not worry as much about players falling on the draft board or picking players earlier than they had been. I've always thought Buck is undervalued in drafts and in previous drafts I was picking early 2nd, which was too early. He has a lot of great eFG, solid usage and D with good boards. Towels aren't too bad. Back to the well with Lowry because he gave me a little of everything except D and I planned to pair him with a defending guard. I like to look back at the draft and see if there's anyone chosen after Lowry that I would take in retrospect, I think the answer is no. Rondo is a better passer and defender but forces you into a 3 point shooting guard with him. Price and Porter shoot less 3's and don't play much D either. Getting Holiday in the 4th is a pretty good pairing. Mostly a good to great defender, shoots a few 3's. Clean player, solid usage. Harper in the 5th was just a value pick. I didn't 100% need him, but he was too good to pass up and a 3 guard rotation with two of them being good to great defenders helps cover for lowry. Don't love the lack of rebounding at the guard - but you have to sacrifice something and I thought there would be plenty of boards left at SF. So in the 6th I take Silas, not sexy at all unless you're into 6-7 guys that play hard nose D and crash the offensive boards. That actually sounds a little sexy to me. Felt I had usage, shooting and assists already covered so the goal here was to get heavy boards, good D and if the don't shoot it well, low usage. Silas hits all those and I'm hoping his often 97% eff at SF won't hurt much.

From here on out it was trying to grab value with so many of my starter minutes covered. O'Quinn, Edge, Jamychal will cut into Silas' time here and there and offer some things I like. I had been hoping to snag Kevin Love for bench usage but Pex grabbed him so I settled for Blake off the bench who I hope isn't the end of the world for 10-12 minutes a game. TJ McConnell won't play too much, wish I had George Hill there instead. Jack Sikma was going to be Cladwell Jones but he wasn't there. I think Sikma could be undervalued in this format. At most he'll give Kareem a blow when I can't deal with Blake's terrible defense.
It seems like depending on how the bench hits, you could bump up against it usage wise occasionally. I am guessing the shooting numbers are pretty low across the teams. I have it as a top five team in both rebounding categories despite the backcourt. Above average assists. Average defense. Below average turnovers and fouls. Middle of the pack? That is what it would appear to me, but KAJ is so effing good that maybe he is enough to overcome it. I do like what you decided to do with the backcourt.
I'll be so disappointed if i'm middle of the pack. What's this magic spreadsheet? I have my shooting averaging pretty good. If you look at an avg of one of my teams it's a little over 53% which I think is a little better than average for this league. But I like to factor usage too. The two best shooters are Kareem with 28.7 usage and 57.8 eFG and Jrue with 23.1 at 54.3, with the worst shooter as Silas at 16.7 usage. I try to incorporate a usage factor that I think suggests my team will do fairly well there.
11/10/2020 9:38 AM
Posted by jcred5 on 11/10/2020 9:38:00 AM (view original):
Posted by robusk on 11/9/2020 11:18:00 PM (view original):
Posted by jcred5 on 11/9/2020 7:24:00 PM (view original):
So are we doing self evals?
Lowry/Harper
Jrue/Harper
Silas/Edge/Jamychal/O'Quinn/partridge in a pear tree
Buck/Blake
KAJ/Sikma or Blake

I certainly hope this team will do better than my S2 middle of the pack, that was really one very good team and 4 crappy teams. And hopefully better than my S1 team that I think was tied for 9th.... but we'll see. Big advantage getting KAJ. From there I decided to build the team I want and not worry as much about players falling on the draft board or picking players earlier than they had been. I've always thought Buck is undervalued in drafts and in previous drafts I was picking early 2nd, which was too early. He has a lot of great eFG, solid usage and D with good boards. Towels aren't too bad. Back to the well with Lowry because he gave me a little of everything except D and I planned to pair him with a defending guard. I like to look back at the draft and see if there's anyone chosen after Lowry that I would take in retrospect, I think the answer is no. Rondo is a better passer and defender but forces you into a 3 point shooting guard with him. Price and Porter shoot less 3's and don't play much D either. Getting Holiday in the 4th is a pretty good pairing. Mostly a good to great defender, shoots a few 3's. Clean player, solid usage. Harper in the 5th was just a value pick. I didn't 100% need him, but he was too good to pass up and a 3 guard rotation with two of them being good to great defenders helps cover for lowry. Don't love the lack of rebounding at the guard - but you have to sacrifice something and I thought there would be plenty of boards left at SF. So in the 6th I take Silas, not sexy at all unless you're into 6-7 guys that play hard nose D and crash the offensive boards. That actually sounds a little sexy to me. Felt I had usage, shooting and assists already covered so the goal here was to get heavy boards, good D and if the don't shoot it well, low usage. Silas hits all those and I'm hoping his often 97% eff at SF won't hurt much.

From here on out it was trying to grab value with so many of my starter minutes covered. O'Quinn, Edge, Jamychal will cut into Silas' time here and there and offer some things I like. I had been hoping to snag Kevin Love for bench usage but Pex grabbed him so I settled for Blake off the bench who I hope isn't the end of the world for 10-12 minutes a game. TJ McConnell won't play too much, wish I had George Hill there instead. Jack Sikma was going to be Cladwell Jones but he wasn't there. I think Sikma could be undervalued in this format. At most he'll give Kareem a blow when I can't deal with Blake's terrible defense.
It seems like depending on how the bench hits, you could bump up against it usage wise occasionally. I am guessing the shooting numbers are pretty low across the teams. I have it as a top five team in both rebounding categories despite the backcourt. Above average assists. Average defense. Below average turnovers and fouls. Middle of the pack? That is what it would appear to me, but KAJ is so effing good that maybe he is enough to overcome it. I do like what you decided to do with the backcourt.
I'll be so disappointed if i'm middle of the pack. What's this magic spreadsheet? I have my shooting averaging pretty good. If you look at an avg of one of my teams it's a little over 53% which I think is a little better than average for this league. But I like to factor usage too. The two best shooters are Kareem with 28.7 usage and 57.8 eFG and Jrue with 23.1 at 54.3, with the worst shooter as Silas at 16.7 usage. I try to incorporate a usage factor that I think suggests my team will do fairly well there.
Those percentages in the last paragraph are just for one team though, sounds like with the best Jrue and KAJ - I think it's gonna be a problem for teams 3, 4, 5.
11/10/2020 10:12 AM
Oh man, I can’t possibly predict what seasons people will use. I don’t even try. That would take so much time. It just picks the top five season by some metric I have. You could certainly be using better shooting seasons that it assumes.
11/10/2020 10:23 AM
The hardest part about drafting Kareem is leaving a couple awesome seasons unused. I think if we created a savage left overs league after we started this one, using left over seasons, I'd do pretty good.
11/10/2020 12:47 PM
Posted by jcred5 on 11/10/2020 12:47:00 PM (view original):
The hardest part about drafting Kareem is leaving a couple awesome seasons unused. I think if we created a savage left overs league after we started this one, using left over seasons, I'd do pretty good.
I am open to this...Wilt scoring machine seasons against the leftovers could be a fun setup
11/10/2020 4:39 PM
Lebron laughs at us all as the five seasons gerry didn't use for Lebron would easily be a top 5 pick.
11/10/2020 4:54 PM
Posted by ashamael on 11/10/2020 4:54:00 PM (view original):
Lebron laughs at us all as the five seasons gerry didn't use for Lebron would easily be a top 5 pick.
And that next five after that (his 11th-15th best seasons) would be a first-round pick. I think it's tough to pick exactly which seasons are the best ten, but I'm pretty sure I would take Lebron's seasons 11-15 over, say, Harden (and probably Giannis as well).
11/10/2020 7:58 PM
11/10/2020 10:21 PM
i updated the rosters through round 7....ill try to finish them tomorrow...help out if you can...maybe we can get some evals


1. gerryred - LeBron James, Bill Russell, Jerry Lucas, Mark Price, Kyle Korver, James Worthy,
Josh Smith

2. mikee1 - Wilt Chamberlain, Shawn Marion, Robert Parish, Terry Porter, Kemba Walker, Jonas Valanciunas, Marvin Williams

3. ashamael - Steph Curry, Ben Wallace, Rajon Rondo, Carlos Boozer, Kermit Washington, Mike Conley, Clarence Weatherspoon

4. benhoidal - Shaquille O'Neal, Paul George, Serge Ibaka, Alonzo Mourning, Kenneth Faried, Clifford Ray, Mark Jackson

5. longtallbrad - Dwight Howard, Andre Drummond, Gerald Wallace, Kobe Bryant, Jose Calderon, Charlie Ward, DeMarcus Cousins

6. 20ks - Michael Jordan, Dikembe Mutombo, Donyell Marshall, Danny Green, Nate McMillan, Emeka Okafor, Don Buse

7. jcred5 - Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, Buck Williams, Kyle Lowry, Jrue Holiday, Derek Harper, Paul Silas, Kyle O'Quinn

8. albiband0 - Giannis Antetokounmpo, Elton Brand, Kyrie Irving, Alvin Robertson, Dan Roundfield, Enes Kanter, Reggie Miller

9. robusk - Chris Paul, Shawn Kemp, Horace Grant, Clyde Drexler, Andrew Bogut, Bradley Beal, Chris Webber

10. dh555 - Karl Malone, Tyson Chandler, Mookie Blaylock, Paul Pierce, Marques Johnson, Wes Unseld, Darrell Armstrong

11. goetz93 - Charles Barkley, Ben Simmons, Joakim Noah, Brent Barry, Bob Lanier, Paul Pressey, Bam Adebayo

12. jhsukow - James Harden, Jason Kidd, Draymond Green, Clint Capela, Al Horford, Bo Outlaw, Domantas Sabonis

13. bds9992 - Larry Bird, Karl-Anthony Towns, Chauncey Billups, Andrei Kirilenko, Tree Rollins, Derrick Favors, John Collins

14. zora4preside - Kevin Durant, Steve Nash, Patrick Ewing, Maurice Cheeks, Anthony Mason, Luka Doncic, George Gervin

15. dbkc - David Robinson, Kawhi Leonard, Bill Walton, Deron Williams, Anfernee Hardaway, Chris Andersen, Dirk Nowitzki

16. midge - Kevin Garnett, Kevin McHale, Walt Frazier, Jerry West, Dave Cowens, Kevin Johnson, Otto Porter

17. notoriousj - Magic Johnson, Klay Thompson, Marcus Camby, Charles Oakley, Bob McAdoo, JaVale McGee, John Henson

18. pexetera - Anthony Davis, Dennis Rodman, Manu Ginobili, Eric Bledsoe, Andrew Bynum, Kevin Love, Ed Davis

19. cmcafeeky - Tim Duncan, Dwyane Wade, Nikola Jokic, Jimmy Butler, Sidney Moncrief, Arvydas Sabonis, Cedric Maxwell

20. tarheel1991 - Hakeem Olajuwon, Rudy Gobert, Oscar Robertson, Andre Iguodala, Joel Embiid, Samuel Dalembert, Chris Mullin

21. jpevans31 - Scottie Pippen, Hassan Whiteside, Bobby Jones, Terrell Brandon, Paul Millsap, Tracy McGrady, Larry Smith

22. 24kpyrite - Artis Gilmore, Gary Payton, Ray Allen, Dale Davis, Willis Reed, Bill Bridges, Kyle Anderson

23. jkaye24 - John Stockton, DeAndre Jordan, Larry Nance, Paul Gasol, Nikola Vucevic, Victor Oladipo, Vince Carter

24. amerk1180 - Julius Erving, Moses Malone, Damian Lillard, Amare Stoudemire, Montrezl Harrell, Tom Boerwinkle, Jon Barry
11/11/2020 7:22 PM
Selected By Pick Name
20ks 6 Jordan, Michael
43 Mutombo, Dikembe
67 Marshall, Donyell
78 Green, Danny
115 McMillan, Nate
126 Okafor, Emeka
163 Buse, Don
174 Stojakovic, Peja
211 Hill, Grant
222 Hayes, Elvin
259 Richardson, Micheal Ray
270 English, Alex
24kpyrite 22 Gilmore, Artis
27 Payton, Gary
51 Allen, Ray
94 Davis, Dale
99 Reed, Willis
142 Bridges, Bill
147 Anderson, Kyle
190 Tyler, Terry
195 Smith, J.R.
238 Wall, John
243 Brown, P.J.
286 Bellamy, Walt
albiband0 8 Antetokounmpo, Giannis
41 Brand, Elton
65 Irving, Kyrie
80 Robertson, Alvin
113 Roundfield, Dan
128 Kanter, Enes
161 Miller, Reggie
176 Cooper, Michael
209 Johnson, George T.
224 Ming, Yao
257 Battier, Shane
272 Bradley, Shawn
amerk1180 24 Erving, Julius
25 Malone, Moses
49 Lillard, Damian
96 Stoudemire, Amare
97 Harrell, Montrezl
144 Boerwinkle, Tom
145 Barry, Jon
192 Teague, Jeff
193 Jones, Eddie
240 Noel, Nerlens
241 Jackson Jr., Jaren
288 Grant, Jerami
ashamael 3 Curry, Stephen
46 Wallace, Ben
70 Rondo, Rajon
75 Boozer, Carlos
118 Washington, Kermit
123 Conley, Mike
166 Weatherspoon, Clarence
171 Daniels, Mel
214 Odom, Lamar
219 Westphal, Paul
262 Humphries, Kris
267 Johnson, Amir
bds9992 13 Bird, Larry
36 Towns, Karl-Anthony
60 Billups, Chauncey
85 Kirilenko, Andrei
108 Rollins, Tree
133 Favors, Derrick
156 Collins, John
181 Eaton, Mark
204 Hield, Buddy
229 Hardaway, Tim
252 Bosh, Chris
277 Floyd, Sleepy
benhoidal 4 O'Neal, Shaquille
45 George, Paul
69 Ibaka, Serge
76 Mourning, Alonzo
117 Faried, Kenneth
124 Ray, Clifford
165 Jackson, Mark
172 Middleton, Khris
213 Biyombo, Bismack
220 Rubio, Ricky
261 Williams, Walt
268 Aldrich, Cole
cmcafeeky 19 Duncan, Tim
30 Wade, Dwyane
54 Jokic, Nikola
91 Butler, Jimmy
102 Moncrief, Sidney
139 Sabonis, Arvydas
150 Maxwell, Cedric
187 Wallace, Rasheed
198 Jones, Caldwell
235 Hayward, Gordon
246 Johnson, Gus
283 Isaac, Jonathan
dBKC 15 Robinson, David
34 Leonard, Kawhi
58 Walton, Bill
87 Williams, Deron
106 Hardaway, Anfernee
135 Andersen, Chris
154 Nowitzki, Dirk
183 Siakam, Pascal
202 Green, A.C.
231 Miller, Mike
250 Gortat, Marcin
279 Lever, Fat
dh555 10 Malone, Karl
39 Chandler, Tyson
63 Blaylock, Mookie
82 Pierce, Paul
111 Johnson, Marques
130 Unseld, Wes
159 Armstrong, Darrell
178 Johnson, James
207 McCray, Rodney
226 Ceballos, Cedric
255 Rogers, Rodney
274 Jefferson, Al
gerryred 1 James, LeBron
48 Russell, Bill
72 Lucas, Jerry
73 Price, Mark
120 Korver, Kyle
121 Worthy, James
168 Smith, Josh
169 Wright, Brandan
216 Terry, Jason
217 Tarpley, Roy
264 Sefolosha, Thabo
265 Jones, Terrence
goetz93 11 Barkley, Charles
38 Simmons, Ben
62 Noah, Joakim
83 Barry, Brent
110 Lanier, Bob
131 Pressey, Paul
158 Adebayo, Bam
179 Ingles, Joe
206 Sanders, Larry
227 Beaty, Zelmo
254 Gasol, Marc
275 Beverley, Patrick
jcred5 7 Abdul-Jabbar, Kareem
42 Williams, Buck
66 Lowry, Kyle
79 Holiday, Jrue
114 Harper, Derek
127 Silas, Paul
162 O'Quinn, Kyle
175 Griffin, Blake
210 Edge, Charlie
223 Green, JaMychal
258 McConnell, T.J.
271 Sikma, Jack
jhsukow 12 Harden, James
37 Kidd, Jason
61 Green, Draymond
84 Capela, Clint
109 Horford, Al
132 Outlaw, Bo
157 Sabonis, Domantas
180 Westbrook, Russell
205 Turner, Myles
228 Moon, Jamario
253 Ayton, Deandre
276 Lacey, Sam
jkaye24 23 Stockton, John
26 Jordan, DeAndre
50 Nance, Larry
95 Gasol, Pau
98 Vucevic, Nikola
143 Oladipo, Victor
146 Carter, Vince
191 Covington, Robert
194 Allen, Jarrett
239 Anthony, Carmelo
242 Van Lier, Norm
287 Haywood, Spencer
jpevans31 21 Pippen, Scottie
28 Whiteside, Hassan
52 Jones, Bobby
93 Brandon, Terrell
100 Millsap, Paul
141 McGrady, Tracy
148 Smith, Larry
189 Collison, Darren
196 Nance Jr., Larry
237 West, Mark
244 Bowen, Bruce
285 Miller, Oliver
longtallbrad 5 Howard, Dwight
44 Drummond, Andre
68 Wallace, Gerald
77 Bryant, Kobe
116 Calderon, Jose
125 Ward, Charlie
164 Cousins, DeMarcus
173 Dragic, Goran
212 Holmes, Richaun
221 Varejao, Anderson
260 Anderson, Ryan
269 Barros, Dana
Midge 16 Garnett, Kevin
33 McHale, Kevin
57 Frazier, Walt
88 West, Jerry
105 Cowens, Dave
136 Johnson, Kevin
153 Porter, Otto
184 Murphy, Troy
201 Tatum, Jayson
232 Porter, Michael
249 Havlicek, John
280 Hornacek, Jeff
mikee1 2 Chamberlain, Wilt
47 Marion, Shawn
71 Parish, Robert
74 Porter, Terry
119 Walker, Kemba
122 Valanciunas, Jonas
167 Williams, Marvin
170 McDyess, Antonio
215 Gatling, Chris
218 Nelson, Jameer
263 Marjanovic, Boban
266 Williams, Hot Rod
NotoriousJ 17 Johnson, Magic
32 Thompson, Klay
56 Camby, Marcus
89 Oakley, Charles
104 McAdoo, Bob
137 McGee, JaVale
152 Henson, John
185 McCollum, C.J.
200 Wood, Christian
233 Bradley, Tony
248 Diallo, Cheick
281 Lin, Jeremy
pexetera 18 Davis, Anthony
31 Rodman, Dennis
55 Ginobili, Manu
90 Bledsoe, Eric
103 Bynum, Andrew
138 Love, Kevin
151 Davis, Ed
186 Kukoc, Toni
199 Wright, Delon
234 Lee, David
247 Hill, George
282 Zubac, Ivica
robusk 9 Paul, Chris
40 Kemp, Shawn
64 Grant, Horace
81 Drexler, Clyde
112 Bogut, Andrew
129 Beal, Bradley
160 Webber, Chris
177 Plumlee, Mason
208 Harper, Ron
225 Tinsley, Jamaal
256 Chriss, Marquese
273 Nurkic, Jusuf
tarheel1992 20 Olajuwon, Hakeem
29 Gobert, Rudy
53 Robertson, Oscar
92 Iguodala, Andre
101 Embiid, Joel
140 Dalembert, Samuel
149 Mullin, Chris
188 Batum, Nicolas
197 Anderson, Nick
236 West, David
245 Davis, Baron
284 Person, Wesley
zora4preside 14 Durant, Kevin
35 Nash, Steve
59 Ewing, Patrick
86 Cheeks, Maurice
107 Mason, Anthony
134 Doncic, Luka
155 Gervin, George
182 Nater, Swen
203 Przybilla, Joel
230 Williamson, Zion
251 Beaubois, Rodrigue
278 Mejri, Salah
11/11/2020 10:07 PM
Finally figured out my teams and got them in.

Anyone have any draft regrets? For me, I know Dirk was a huge “steal” in the 7th but idk man. He’s just kinda meh. I like the consistency he gives me off the bench but I’m not sure how often he’ll be better than the opposing PF, even if most of his matchups will be against bench players. Am I sleeping on him? Never used him before. His stats don’t impress me much.
11/12/2020 1:24 PM
I’ve got a complete list of drafted rosters and should be able to post them within the hour.
11/12/2020 1:53 PM
Posted by dBKC on 11/12/2020 1:24:00 PM (view original):
Finally figured out my teams and got them in.

Anyone have any draft regrets? For me, I know Dirk was a huge “steal” in the 7th but idk man. He’s just kinda meh. I like the consistency he gives me off the bench but I’m not sure how often he’ll be better than the opposing PF, even if most of his matchups will be against bench players. Am I sleeping on him? Never used him before. His stats don’t impress me much.
Yeah I only like Dirk in progs.

My regret was Conley. I went “value” over plan and he does almost nothing I want off the bench. If he was 100% sg, different story.

I also loosely regret Boozer even with Big Ben covering his shortcomings. Keeps throwing my defensive average way down, making me sort through and try to do other things with the team and causing me to do another build. Life would have been much simpler had I gone Zo, but then I’d be poised about boards... anyway. Teams will be in tonight after another build or two.
11/12/2020 3:58 PM (edited)
◂ Prev 1...29|30|31|32|33...55 Next ▸
Savage III Commentary Thread Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.