Category A:
2005 C Brian McCann
2005 1b Conor Jackson
2006 2b Josh Barfield
2007 3b Akinori Iwamura
2004 SS Kazuo Matsui
2006 OF Andre Ethier
2003 OF Marcus Thames
1998 P Carl Pavano
2004 P Chris Young
2003 P Scott Linebrink
1997 P Chris Carpenter
Category B:
1975 C Alan Ashby
1966 1b George Scott
1924 2b Max Bishop
1987 3b Ken Caminiti
1942 SS Johnny Pesky
1981 OF Jesse Barfield
1983 OF Kevin McReynolds
1980 P Bruce Hurst
1931 P Lon Warneke
1988 P Rob Dibble
1926 P Willis Hudlin
Category C:
1924 2B Freddie Lindstrom
1929 OF Earl Averill
1923 SS Travis Jackson
1914 OF Harry Heilmann
1875 P Pud Galvin
1899 P Rube Waddell
BLACKLISTED: Edd Roush, Enos Slaughter
I could only find 2 HOF pitchers not taken, unless I am mistaken.