For the Giants I am making the commish's pick of OF Al Kaline. My rational is that the Giants already have a strong starting rotation and, especially in a pitcher's park, they can use a starter that will be around in a round or two in the 5th spot. An offensive bopper is more along the lines of their needs.
For the Phillies I am making the commish's selection of P Camilo Pascual. The rational being that some of their end line starters are going to get hammered in their park while their office is already very good.
I have a proxy for Holleybard's Pirates. They select P Bud Black.
Rattlers is up.