Savage III Commentary Thread Topic

Rank___ Owner__________ League 1___ League 2___ League 3___ League 4__ League 5__
1 (60) dBKC 13 10 10 12 15
2 (58) pexetera 18 9 13 6 12
3 (56) jpevans31 10 11 12 12 11
3 robusk 12 14 9 9 12
5 (55) jhsukow 12 12 11 14 6
6 (54) amerk1180 12 15 5 12 10
7 (53) jkaye24 10 8 13 11 11
7 gerryred 6 11 12 11 13
9 (52) 20ks 12 12 10 8 10
10 (50) dh555 12 8 10 10 10
11 (48) ashamael 9 9 11 10 9
11 benhoidal 7 11 11 7 12
13 (47) longtallbrad 10 11 9 8 9
13 tarheel1991 5 11 8 11 12
15 (46) bds9992 9 9 6 10 12
16 (45) albiband0 12 10 14 3 6
17 (44) jcred5 12 10 6 9 7
18 (43) 24kpyrite 8 7 11 13 4
19 (42) Midge 7 8 7 11 9
19 mikee1 9 5 11 10 7
21 (37) goetz93 5 6 10 10 6
22 (35) NotoriousJ 5 9 9 5 7
22 cmcafeeky 8 6 4 9 8
24 (34) zora4preside 5 6 6 7 10
11/29/2020 4:28 AM
Rank___ Owner__________ League 1___ League 2___ League 3___ League 4__ League 5__
1 (67) dBKC 15 12 11 13 16
2 (64) pexetera 19 9 15 8 13
3 (62) jpevans31 11 11 14 13 13
3 robusk 13 16 10 10 13
5 (60) jhsukow 13 14 11 15 7
5 gerryred 7 11 14 13 15
5 amerk1180 13 16 6 13 12
8 (58) jkaye24 10 8 15 13 12
9 (56) 20ks 13 13 11 9 10
9 dh555 14 9 12 10 11
11 (54) ashamael 11 10 11 12 10
12 (53) benhoidal 8 13 12 8 12
12 longtallbrad 11 12 9 10 11
14 (52) tarheel1991 5 13 9 13 12
15 (50) jcred5 13 12 7 11 7
15 bds9992 10 10 6 11 13
17 (48) albiband0 13 10 16 3 6
18 (47) Midge 9 9 8 11 10
18 24kpyrite 8 8 12 13 6
20 (44) mikee1 10 5 12 10 7
21 (42) goetz93 7 7 11 10 7
22 (40) NotoriousJ 5 11 10 6 8
23 (39) zora4preside 6 7 6 8 12
24 (36) cmcafeeky 8 6 4 9 9
11/30/2020 6:38 AM
David Robinson with the 15th pick. Amazing. That's who I was trying to grab last season with the 12th pick, but he went at 11 to amerk. But going at 15th will be hard to beat.
11/30/2020 7:59 AM
Doesn’t sBKC have the highest average finishing position the last two seasons (for owners who played both)? I think dBKC is hard to beat regardless of who he drafts in the first.
11/30/2020 10:20 AM
Jpevans drafted Pippen and f’ing Hassan Whiteside with his first two picks and yet has the highest point differential across all five worlds.
11/30/2020 10:33 AM
dBKC drafts well in most every round which makes him a strong contender in most leagues I'm in with him, made even more impressive given he does it with note cards. That said, I assume you didn't mean to be taken literally that he does well regardless of who he drafts in the first. Although, it would be interesting to see if he would get the same results with Bob Cousy as his first pick. (plug to dB's Albatross league) Maybe a good question to ask would be... to what extent does your first round pick effect the outcome? Quite a bit I think. 20% of your results could probably be attributed to your 1st round pick.

What I was saying was that to the extent your 1st round pick effects the outcome, then it makes teams that much harder to beat when players like David Robinson fall to 15. In dBKC's case, Robinson at 15 was a gift. Given Robinson's true draft value in a league like this, I'd be surprised to learn if dBKC was even considering anyone else at that draft spot. In JPs case, Pippen is not a 1st round draft pick IMO. But neither Pippen nor Whiteside are bad picks, every minute they give is playable and strong. But there were better picks still available at the time that gave even more minutes that are equally strong. JP also made strong picks in most other rounds, which contribute to the positive outcome.
11/30/2020 1:56 PM (edited)
Buddy Hield may bolster my weaker offensive teams........or not. Let's find out
11/30/2020 1:07 PM
Seems like most of my teams are hitting a wall, probably regressing to the middle of the pack.
As far as my drafting, I knew that there were better SIM guys in the pool, but I like drafting guys I rooted for, or if they were before my time, what I hear their play-style was. If I'm just picking based off of the #s, it's not me picking, it's the stats picking. Where's the fun in that? That's why I'm a weak drafter compared to most. I think my strength is rotation and game-planning anyways, so I'm going to grab dudes that I think should fit in the kinds of teams I like. That's why you'll never see me draft Melo, and some guys, like Ewing, I'll only take if they're around way after they should be. This is essentially fantasy drafting, my fantasy teams aren't entirely dictated by the numbers. (I enjoyed rooting against guys like Shaq, Kareem and LeBron IRL, but I liked watching 'em play, and they're too good to bypass).The thing I'm still trying to get better on is a way to win with my team-building approach. It'll happen, eventually.
11/30/2020 1:32 PM
Posted by pexetera on 11/30/2020 1:11:00 PM (view original):
dBKC drafts well in most every round which makes him a strong contender in most leagues I'm in with him, made even more impressive given he does it with note cards. That said, I assume you didn't mean to be taken literally that he does well regardless of who he drafts in the first. Although, it would be interesting to see if he would get the same results with Bob Cousy as his first pick. Maybe a good question to ask would be... to what extent does your first round pick effect the outcome? Quite a bit I think. 20% of your results could probably be attributed to your 1st round pick.

What I was saying was that to the extent your 1st round pick effects the outcome, then it makes teams that much harder to beat when players like David Robinson fall to 15. In dBKC's case, Robinson at 15 was a gift. Given Robinson's true draft value in a league like this, I'd be surprised to learn if dBKC was even considering anyone else at that draft spot. In JPs case, Pippen is not a 1st round draft pick IMO. But neither Pippen nor Whiteside are bad picks, every minute they give is playable and strong. But there were better picks still available at the time that gave even more minutes that are equally strong. JP also made strong picks in most other rounds, which contribute to the positive outcome.
I think my point was that you seem to be attributing dBKC being ahead of you in the standings because he lucked out and got Robinson in the first, which seems like a pretty dick way of giving yourself an out for being behind him.

My point was that I suspect he could have picked any number of other reasonable picks in that spot and still be doing quite well. dBKC is doing well because he is good at this format, not because of luck.
11/30/2020 1:37 PM
nah, I wasn't saying that at all. nor did I actually say that.
11/30/2020 1:51 PM
Posted by pexetera on 11/30/2020 1:51:00 PM (view original):
nah, I wasn't saying that at all. nor did I actually say that.
Agreed, pex said dB drafts well in every round.
11/30/2020 1:58 PM
Posted by pexetera on 11/30/2020 1:51:00 PM (view original):
nah, I wasn't saying that at all. nor did I actually say that.
Lol. You know what you were doing.
11/30/2020 2:11 PM
Sorry, jhsukow. Not true. But I understand that the bad stuff is easier to believe. I was only saying that a top player falling in the draft makes teams harder to beat. And if Lebron had fallen to the 6th pick, would we not also say that was an advantage to whoever drafted him at 6? Nothing about it is luck. He didn't have to pick Robinson at 15, he chose Robinson because he knows that was the best pick by a wide margin at the 15th spot. And to the extent that a strong first round pick contributes to your teams success.. that was a strong pick. It seems obvious to me if you take it at face value and don't read into it.

dBKC and I have a mutual respect for one another that was earned on both sides. I'm not going to be made out to be a dick for something I didn't say. Find someone else to strawman.
11/30/2020 2:33 PM (edited)
It’s all good guys, let’s move on. Pex, I do have a good deal of respect for you and I’m sure it’ll go down to the wire. There are quite a few sleeper teams that could beat both of us too tbh.
11/30/2020 2:35 PM
It's true, Pex said what he meant.

"dBKC drafts well in most every round which makes him a strong contender in most leagues I'm in with him, made even more impressive given he does it with note cards."

-pexetera, within the last few days


The suggested dig would not apply based on this, which is contradictory to the notion of any first round advantage by anyone higher in the order.

Anyone who thinks such a dig exists is mistaken, possibly because they did not read this line.

11/30/2020 2:45 PM
◂ Prev 1...41|42|43|44|45...55 Next ▸
Savage III Commentary Thread Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.