I'd concentrate on position, BA, GG and post-season records. But I go a lot by "feel". Bernie doesn't "feel" like a HOFer to me. But I'm gonna adopt a dog from the pound in the next few weeks and name him Bernie. It's been 5 years since I've been able to yell "GODDAMMIT, BERNIE!!! RUN AFTER THE BALL!!!!" I've been planning this for a few years.
It would be funny as hell.
Also funny as hell.