Well, I better jump back in now that I gave away my Cleveland team (and lost my chance for an easy re-do to Schwarze). I'll jump in with the Tigers (probably dumb, but what the hey, they're my team and I rarely get to use them)
Stealing Bill Bernhard, Stan Coveleski, and Addie Joss (the first two my protecteds from the team I gave away)
Protecting George Kell and Charlie Gehringer
I do think it would be nice to save the last slot for ybj (and what is, almost certainly, the Pirates), but it's not my call.