That's really, really strange. I see the same thing on my profile, that it did finish. But what's bizarre is that I froze while replacing a pitcher, so I noticed the freeze right away. Refreshed the screen, which took about 10 seconds, and then checked in all four Open Play rooms and the game did not appear. And your name didn't show up as logged in to live. Whatever knocked Live out for 10 hours or so last night/this morning is still screwing up the system.
Good game btown, at least I got a couple steals in!