Live draft league. Spring revival. Topic

I would like a spot.
8/30/2023 12:08 AM
Posted by jfg1997 on 8/30/2023 12:08:00 AM (view original):
I would like a spot.
Welcome jfg1997.

Please don't hesitate to ask any questions here or feel free to sitemail me. The live draft does require a selection each day for 10 consecutive days. You have a scheduled time slot of 30 mins, so you only need to post your pick in that time window. We also send proxy picks to each other if we have a time conflict.

Great start in the baseball neighbor league btw! Knowing the commitment and competitiveness of that, I'm guessing that you may really enjoy this league as well. We have plenty of archives to view from Seasons 1-2 in the football theme leagues forum (not classifieds). Change the drop box option to "last 6 months" and you'll see all the NFL Draft League topics. Welcome aboard!
8/30/2023 12:35 AM
I would like to get back in, now that summer travel is done.


Are there blacklist holdovers/repeats?

Can you tell me the team records for last season?
8/30/2023 6:22 PM (edited)
Great to hear kaniac! Excited on your return. Would you like 1 or 2 teams?

We have a current vote going on what to do with the Season 2 banned players/units. You and jfg1997 (new owner) can cast your vote in the NFL Draft League 2. Official Rulebook topic. I'll also cut/paste here the entirety of the Season 3 proposed rule revisions. You could post your vote here as well. I'll see if I can sitemail the team records to you.

Lastly, we do have some discussion on a possible double banned round for Season 4. Either, two bans per owner to start the draft, or one ban to start and one additional ban at any time during the draft. We would vote on this during Season 3. The big question is how we determine who those 24 or 48 banned players/units can be from season to season.

Banning more is fine with me, although I don't want half of the bans to be the same with each draft. My reasoning for the Yes with conditions below for proposal 3. We will move forward with the majority vote and certainly consider any off the board views or future proposals.

Proposed Rule revisions for Season 3:

1- For the banned round, you may select any OL, DL or ST with an 11 year bubble ban. This establishes consistency (as noted by spaolo and others) with the draft selections of other OL, DL or ST with 11 yr bubbles.

Vote YES to revise to an 11 year bubble ban on OL, DL or ST.
Vote NO to keep it at a single year
per the current Season 2 rules.

2- Remove the 2nd TE roster requirement for the live draft. Replace with a Flex position which could be a 2nd QB, 4th RB, 4th RB or 2nd TE.

Vote YES to a Flex roster position in live draft.
Vote NO to keep the 2nd TE requirement for the live draft.


3- What happens to the banned players, OL, DEF and ST pool from the Season 2 live draft?

Vote YES to banning on anything for Season 3. Thus, all Season 2 bans can be banned again.
Vote NO- all Season 2 banned players, OL, Def or ST will be available in Season 3.
Vote YES with conditions- a Ban on anything for Season 3, but anything banned for 2 consecutive drafts will be available for Season 4. Limit of two consecutive bans.
Vote YES to a double ban—keep Season 2 bans intact for Season 3 AND add another 24 banned players/units. 1 banned round.
(Season 2 bans become available again for Season 4 to either be banned or drafted. Hence, only previous season bans remain banned for next draft).

**************************************************

Current tally on each proposal (12 owners have voted, 4 owners left to vote):

Proposal 1 (votes cast):

11 YES.
1 NO.

Proposal 2 (votes cast):

11 YES.
0 NO.

Proposal 3 (votes cast):

3 YES.
3 NO.
2 YES w/conditions.
2 YES to a double ban
8/31/2023 11:18 AM (edited)
Not to cloud this any further! I'm copying the latest from the Rulebook topic thread. We got another off the board vote for the same option, so it is now on the ballot wrt Season 2 banned players/units:

What to do with season 2 banned round players/units? (current options and tally below)

3 YES to ban on anything again. 1 ban round.

3 NO that Season 2 bans can’t be banned for Season 3. 1 ban round.

2 YES with conditions. Anything can be banned. Max of 2 consecutive season bans. 1 banned round.

2 YES to a double ban—keep Season 2 bans intact for Season 3 AND add another 24 banned players/units. 1 banned round. (Season 2 bans become available again for Season 4 to either be banned or drafted. Hence, only previous season bans remain banned for next draft).
8/31/2023 4:24 AM (edited)
seay00, I'll take 2 teams if thats ok.


Proposal 1 (votes cast):

NO. breaks up all dynasties. I assume if team X is bubble banned 2000-2010 and also from 2012-2022 I can still use 2011 for that team.

Proposal 2 (votes cast):

Yes

Proposal 3 (votes cast):

3 YES.
3
2 YES w/conditions.
2 YES to a double ban

Ban 'em all lol
8/31/2023 11:01 AM
Posted by kaniac on 8/31/2023 11:01:00 AM (view original):
seay00, I'll take 2 teams if thats ok.


Proposal 1 (votes cast):

NO. breaks up all dynasties. I assume if team X is bubble banned 2000-2010 and also from 2012-2022 I can still use 2011 for that team.

Proposal 2 (votes cast):

Yes

Proposal 3 (votes cast):

3 YES.
3
2 YES w/conditions.
2 YES to a double ban

Ban 'em all lol
Kaniac- You are set with 2 teams.

Seems the majority wants to be able ban anyone again. It’s just for how long and how many. Hahaha. We do have 4 votes left and 2 non declared on proposal 3.

So we can have the remaining votes posted when we do the draft order election (prior to the banned round). Or, even do a revote on the 3 YES options to feel like everyone has a say on those details going-forward. Thoughts?
8/31/2023 11:36 AM
Looking for 1 new owner to join us! See page 1 of this topic for full details. Live draft Friday Sept 15th!
9/1/2023 10:45 AM
If we are picking draft tiers again I'll take a top and a bottom please.
9/2/2023 8:15 AM
great suggestion kaniac on the draft election. I was holding until the season 2 was completed, but no harm getting that up and running. On the banned proposal, you can specify which of the 4 options you want, or leave it unspecified.

I can go ahead and set up the draft order election topic for season 3. I’ll sitemail everyone tomorrow or Monday with details. We will also request the remaining votes to be posted with their draft order election as applicable.
9/2/2023 8:26 AM
Anyone checking us out to join the league- please see page 1 for full details. Live draft Friday Sept 15th.
9/2/2023 10:44 AM
A few days left should a new owner want to join. See page 1 for details. Post here if you choose to hop in for Season 3.

Live draft- Friday Sept 15th. Feel free to sitemail me any questions or post them here.
9/7/2023 5:26 PM (edited)

***Revised for Season 3**** For more, drop the classifieds and find our seasons 1-2 with topics of the live draft, rosters/divisions and general commentary in the sim football theme leagues. You'll need to alter the drop down box to last 6 months to see all the archives.

Live Draft will start on Friday Sept 15th at 10am. We begin with the banned round. See details below.

Draft League details to build "your" core team:

- 10 live rounds total. 1 banned round to begin, then 9 rounds thereafter. All rounds are ON the clock with your scheduled time slot. If miss your time slot, you can make a late pick at your earliest convenience, but the draft keeps moving per the posted schedule. Proxy lists can also be sent ahead of time to multiple owners.

- Make your draft election. You choose where you prefer to draft out of the following: Top 1-9, Middle 10-15, or Back 16-24. And, you can specify which number you want to be closer to within that tier. The elections are put into a draft order generator. The overage falls to the next tier. The only rule here is for anyone with 2 teams to not request 2 elections in the top tier.

- Divisions will be posted prior to the start of the draft. Therefore, you will know exactly where your division mates will be in the draft. Matchups matter. You play 6 games within the division, so like a real draft, you take that into account as you watch the rosters populate. Each season, we will alternate most or all of the single owners to a different division or conference, and also some of the 2 team owners to another division for new matchups each season.

- The banned round! This will start in reverse order of the posted draft order. 24-1. 24th pick starts off and may ban any player entirely off the draft grid for all years of their career. Or, they may ban any OL, DL or ST for up-to an 11 yr bubble. This is your chance to ban any player or OL or DL that you absolutely loathe to play against!

- After the banned round is complete, the draft format of 1-24, 24-1, 24-1, 1-24, 24-1 will commence for 9 more rounds. In this format, the third round of selections in the live draft is flipped to have the 24th pick begin vs the traditional snake that starts with the 1st pick. Thereafter, we go back to the traditional snake format for the fourth round of selections.

- 75 million salary cap. YES- More money than the standard 60 million in open leagues which makes it very hard to win with anything other than extreme offense and cheap defenses. Here is the place for the variety of teams, using more of the inventory and creating your own team style.

- 12 roster spots are uniquely yours: 9 position spots, OL. DL and ST. No clones. You select any non-banned position player or 11 year bubble on OL, DL or ST with your 1st round pick, no one else gets them for any year, they are off the board completely. You may select any year of the individual position players you choose in the live draft and do not need to share what season you intend to use. The OL, DL and ST do require the up-to 11 year bubble to be posted when making those selections, but do not need to share what season you intend to use.

- Up-to 11 year bubble protection for OL, DL and ST. Say you select the 1950-60 LA Rams era Offensive Line. No one else gets any year in that bubble. It is exclusive to you with no overlap. You may pick any of the LA Rams OL in your 1950-60 bubble and do not need to share which year you intend to use.

- This is not a progressive league with keepers and trades. If it works well, we hope to be a successful recurring theme where every league is a new and different roster for returning and new owners.

League format and playoffs:

- Standard 24 teams format.
- 6 playoff teams per conference.
- 3 division winners and 3 wild card spots.
- Top 2 seeds in each conf get first round playoff bye.

Live Draft format with roster requirements:

After the banned round, Rounds 1-6 with 1 selection each. Rounds 7-9, you pick two. This gives everyone 12 exclusive starters (no clones) that must consist of the following:

1 Defensive unit (11 year bubble protection)
1 offensive line (11 year bubble protection)
1 QB
3 RB
3 WR
1 TE
1 Flex position- This can be either a 2nd QB. 4th RB, 4th WR or 2nd TE.
1 Special Team unit (11 year bubble protection)

As we are adding the names to the banned list, we put the owner name by it to keep a tally on the draft position requirements. For the other 11 spots on the roster, you fill those spots AFTER THE DRAFT is fully completed, i.e, after all selections are made at the end of Round 9. Then please proceed to fill the remaining 11 spots with anyone not already drafted or listed on the banned list (to get under the 75 mil cap).

Examples:

- Once any position player, OL, DL, ST is drafted - they are off the board and exclusive to that team. Only 1 Matt Ryan in the league. Someone drafts Matt Ryan, then he is completely off the draft grid for any season.

- 11 year bubble protection applies to offense/defense/special teams units. You take the 1970-80 Pittsburgh Steelers defense, then all of the Steelers Defenses from 1970 to 1980 are off the board. Say you take the 1941-51 bears defenses off the board, someone could later take a 2006 bears defense after that. This rule does not eliminate cities or franchises, just that 11 year bubble of that particular OL, DL or ST.

- For those selections where the selected bubble overlaps franchise name changes or city relocation, we will clarify as it occurs. One of the more complicated ones like the 1995-2005 Houston/Tennessee Defenses as such: 95-96 Houston Oilers, 97-98 Tennessee Oilers, 99-2005 Tennessee Titans. All of those teams are off the draft board.

Owners:

1- seay00- will take 2 teams
2- riverratk- will take 2 teams
3- roadhouse19- will take 2 teams
4- tidealer- will take 2 teams
5- tomhanrahan
6- DCarden34- will take 2 teams
7- danpsull71- will take 2 teams
8- cellkev
9- rjk2781
10- CFSportsClub
11- 666ace
12- coolmay_one
13- Petroff- will take 2 teams
14- spaolo
15- jfg1997
16- kaniac- will take 2 teams
9/15/2023 12:21 PM (edited)
is *THIS* the commentary thread? If not, which is it?
9/10/2023 2:00 PM
I just posted over at NFL Draft League 3. Draft Commentary. We can share thoughts, comments, ideas or whatever over there.

***Anyone that is checking us out for the first time, you can see the league details just above this post, or go to Page 1 for full details. We are a fun bunch of misfits always looking to add new owners***
9/10/2023 3:37 PM
◂ Prev 1...5|6|7|8|9 Next ▸
Live draft league. Spring revival. Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.