Posted by usf_bulls on 6/9/2020 5:52:00 PM (view original):
Six weeks since the last post? Did IQs just drop sharply while I was away? (it's a quote from Aliens, so don't have a cow.)
Emma (1815) Jane Austen - Have you ever sworn that you would read X before you die...a kind of book bucket list? I had such a list. Tolstoy, Cervantes, Proust, Dostoyevsky, that kind of stuff. Most of it I had gotten through years ago but Jane Austen was still a big fat 0. Dover Publications (a great company) had a sale late last year on paperbacks so I bought a copy of Emma, generally considered her best novel. The Covid shutdown seemed like the perfect time to finally tackle an author almost universally lauded as one of the finest female novelists of all time.
What a waste. Don't misunderstand me. The writing is par excellence but I have read textbooks on chemistry which were also very well written. You don't read a 300+ page novel just to be wowed by writing skill. A novel has to have a compelling story line and be entertaining, does it not? Emma falls short on both accounts spectacularly. It was boring and predictable. Worse, it was pointless, other than being a great window into what English bourgeois life must have been like in the early 1800s, the so-called country house period. Other than the history lesson, it's many hours of my life I'll never get back.
If you have a book bucket list, good for you. If Emma is on it, think again.
I don't think I have read Emma. Sense and Sensibility is very, very good and was hard to put down. Certainly the world she describes - the world of the women of aristocratic families in late 18th and early 19th century England, in families that have fallen on hard times - is a world very far from most of our experiences, but she is able to engage us in that world to a remarkable degree, and make us care about the lives, aspirations, disappointments, sorrows, and triumphs of these women from, compared to the rest of the population privileged and wealthy families, and I write that as an avowed socialist with roots in the labor movement.
Will take a look at Emma to see if I have the same impression. Every great hitter has a slump or an off-year. Maybe Emma was hers.
I think the best two novels ever are Moby Dick and Anna Karenina. I WANT to love War and Peace, took a course on Russian Novels in college and could not finish it, picked it up again some years later and couldn't finish it, and tried reading it two years ago, and for the third time got maybe halfway through and put it down. Does Napoleon win in the end?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=34jQKSP2EMI
Later Sam finds out there is a movie version, after reading the whole thing to impress Diane.