I think I'll get his last good year and select Bill Stoneman - P.

sjis up and blue on deck. Sitemailing.

The Angels vote yes to Proposal #1 and yes toProposal #2.

Twins have already declared no on Prop 1 but see value in Prop 2 so I will vote Yes (not sure there will be great value - but look forward to someone finding teh value)

Brewers: Yes for both props. I might really need the help....

As for the AAA vote, if we truly want to have some realism, then I would argue that they are not the same, but I would also include that they be random instead of the lowest level. In "real" baseball, teams often get huge lifts from AAA call-ups, but if we have the lowest setting for AAA, they truly are nothing but inning eaters and useless ab's.

But I also know that most people on WIS hate "chance" and prefer "strategy/skill" in drafting.

I vote for no AAA clones, by the way.

Oakland A's

Prop 1 - no
Prop 2 - yes
Prop 3 - no

Astros vote Prop 1 -- Yes

Prop 2 -- No

Prop 3 -- No

Kansas City Royals

Prop- 1.... YES... I think this is fair based on team needs being different for each

Prop- 2... Yes... I would say do a new random order for waiver wire

Prop 3.... No... i like random AAA better

Those are my .02 cents

Prop 1 - yes

prop 2 - yes

prop 3 - no

1. The Giants Hate to agree with the Dodgers but NO on 1

2. Not sure yet

3. NO

Houston take Jose Cruz - OF

doggie is up and tribe is on deck

Quote: Originally Posted By luvyablue on 1/30/2009

Houston takes Jose Cruz - OF

doggie is up and tribe is on deck

Guess Cruz was taken I'll re pick Doug Rader