This post could not be converted. To view the original post's thread, click here.

We can't see their ratings. You're going to have to type out what your scouts are telling you.

And I'd remove the links and just give us ratings, not names.

That way, in case someone in your World cannot see the ratings for one of the players, you aren't giving away any information on them (that can be tied to a player name) based on your own scouting budget. You may still be giving info to people who can already see these guys, but that's somewhat unavoidable once you come to the forums.

The "SS" is worse defensively than the first 2 2B. I'd take the pitcher. 5-3-4-1-2 in that order.

I'd likely go with the pitcher as well in this case.

Take the pitcher and put him at AA. That "SS" is a 3B, at best, probably more like a RF.

By the way, players 3 and 4 are the same guy.

i would take player 4 over player 3.

This isn't even remotely close. That pitcher is awesome. With a #1 pick, he's exactly the kind of player you're begging the HBD Gods to let you see. Not only will he be great, but he'll throw a ton of innings, stay healthy, and has great makeup.

He wears makeup?

and fabulous heels

The SP HANDS DOWN. It's not even remotely close. He is one of the best prospects I have ever seen or heard of. If you pass on him, you are a RI-TARD!

That pitcher is going to be a Cy young. The other 4 have some type of flaw (whether it be average D, or an average hitting rating), but the SP has relatively no Flaws and is going to dominate games. take the SP, no doubt.

The SP will be very good, but to say he's "one of the best prospects I've ever seen" is ridiculous. His best pitch projects to 81(2nd pitch projection is missing, but prob lower). To be one of the best ever seen, he'd need at least one pitch in the 90's.

The SP should be the pick. I agree with torrone, this guy will be very good but not the best to come along.