Quote: Originally posted by vandydave on 4/22/2010all this earning your way in by beating a bunch of bad teams in a bad conference talk is awful. most small conference champions shouldnt even be there to begin with. get rid of automatic bids.
Technically I think you are right VD, although as I'm fond of saying if the qualifier "technically" describes your argument then your argument is not strong.
To me those small teams are part of the magic of the tournament, when david does defeat goliath. As a Cyclone fan I know of which I speak; in 2001 when 15-seed Hampton knocked out my 2-seed Cyclones (who had admittedly overachieved that season), while I smarted at the loss as a fan of the Cyclones, I was also--as a fan of the Game--tickled to see the joy of those kids who just went out and played with nothing to lose, and won.
Those kind of moments make a big part of tournamant memories for me, and I think for many others. And so, for that reason, while I agree that those teams are not going to win it (and by that perhaps don't belong), I want them to stay.
If we want to get rid of teams that don't belong perhaps we reduce the size of the tournament to 32 teams and simply take the top 32 teams. But I'm guessing you wouldn't favor that approach. Am I right?