Here's some stats I put together for all of the plays from Rockne on 11/14.  I wanted to do all the plays across all the worlds, but my program kept running out of memory
I'll post up another set of statistics after tomorrow's games with the engine update.  I'm really interested to see the differences.

# of penalties	Human	Sim	Total
D-IA	311.0	171.0	482.0
D-IAA	199.0	266.0	465.0
D-II	344.0	390.0	734.0
D-III	741.0	591.0	1332.0
All	1595.0	1418.0	3013.0

% penalties	Human	Sim	Total
D-IA	0.031	0.033	0.032
D-IAA	0.03	0.031	0.031
D-II	0.041	0.038	0.04
D-III	0.044	0.045	0.045
All	0.038	0.038	0.038

I considered Green = 5 and Red = 1

Avg Fatigue	Human	Sim	Total
D-IA	4.797	4.284	4.619
D-IAA	4.722	4.253	4.46
D-II	4.583	4.206	4.377
D-III	4.557	4.215	4.407
All	4.646	4.231	4.451

# of Runs	Human	Sim	Total
D-IA	2606.0	933.0	3539.0
D-IAA	1776.0	1586.0	3362.0
D-II	2313.0	1838.0	4151.0
D-III	4394.0	2308.0	6702.0
All	11089.0	6665.0	17754.0

Total Run Yards	Human	Sim	Total
D-IA	15467.0	3352.0	18819.0
D-IAA	11717.0	6055.0	17772.0
D-II	13240.0	6277.0	19517.0
D-III	23384.0	8423.0	31807.0
All	63808.0	24107.0	87915.0

I'm a little suspect of these run avgs, but I couldn't find anything obviously wrong with the way I was generating the stats

Run Avg	Human	Sim	Total
D-IA	5.935	3.593	5.318
D-IAA	6.597	3.818	5.286
D-II	5.724	3.415	4.702
D-III	5.322	3.649	4.746
All	5.754	3.617	4.952

# of Passes	Human	Sim	Total
D-IA	1702.0	1169.0	2871.0
D-IAA	1198.0	1881.0	3079.0
D-II	1428.0	2258.0	3686.0
D-III	2736.0	2814.0	5550.0
All	7064.0	8122.0	15186.0

# of Pass Comp.	Human	Sim	Total
D-IA	1000.0	623.0	1623.0
D-IAA	677.0	1031.0	1708.0
D-II	795.0	1195.0	1990.0
D-III	1445.0	1417.0	2862.0
All	3917.0	4266.0	8183.0

Pass Comp. %	Human	Sim	Total
D-IA	0.588	0.533	0.565
D-IAA	0.565	0.548	0.555
D-II	0.557	0.529	0.54
D-III	0.528	0.504	0.516
All	0.555	0.525	0.539

Total Pass Yards	Human	Sim	Total
D-IA	14078.0	8321.0	22399.0
D-IAA	10048.0	14433.0	24481.0
D-II	10937.0	16124.0	27061.0
D-III	19868.0	19529.0	39397.0
All	54931.0	58407.0	113338.0

Pass Avg	Human	Sim	Total
D-IA	14.078	13.356	13.801
D-IAA	14.842	13.999	14.333
D-II	13.757	13.493	13.598
D-III	13.749	13.782	13.766
All	14.024	13.691	13.85

Run/Pass Ratio	Human	Sim	Total
D-IA	1.531	0.798	1.233
D-IAA	1.482	0.843	1.092
D-II	1.62	0.814	1.126
D-III	1.606	0.82	1.208
All	1.57	0.821	1.169

Cool.  This is interesting stuff.  Interesting that the percent penalties increase as you move down divisions.  If that is consistent over more samples, it might validate an impact (minor) of formation practice time given more coaches at higher levels do formation practice

I haven't been able to get all the stats yet because of the new play by play summaries, but I did get this one.  I think this shows that the whole substitution thing is messed up.  Even the sims are averaging a way worse fatigue than before.  This is from Yost 11/17/10

Avg Fatigue	Human	Sim	Total
D-IA	3.775	3.765	3.771
D-IAA	3.76	3.752	3.755
D-II	3.797	3.79	3.794
D-III	3.786	3.782	3.784
All	3.782	3.774	3.778

Posted by onside on 11/16/2010 10:26:00 PM (view original):
Cool.  This is interesting stuff.  Interesting that the percent penalties increase as you move down divisions.  If that is consistent over more samples, it might validate an impact (minor) of formation practice time given more coaches at higher levels do formation practice

No it really doesnt because even the Sim's percent penalties go up when you're going down divisions.

Posted by yatzr on 11/18/2010 12:47:00 PM (view original):
I haven't been able to get all the stats yet because of the new play by play summaries, but I did get this one.  I think this shows that the whole substitution thing is messed up.  Even the sims are averaging a way worse fatigue than before.  This is from Yost 11/17/10

Avg Fatigue	Human	Sim	Total
D-IA	3.775	3.765	3.771
D-IAA	3.76	3.752	3.755
D-II	3.797	3.79	3.794
D-III	3.786	3.782	3.784
All	3.782	3.774	3.778

Can I ask where you are seeing the fatigue ratings? I thought they were in the PBP but I don't see anything there.
thx

You have to click on the little green "OX" icon to the right of the "1st and 10".  They don't give actual ratings...I just assigned Green=5, Green/Yellow=4, Yellow=3, Yellow/Red=2 and Red=1

This is only for designed run plays (the ones that say rush middle, left, or right).  JConte wasn't kidding when he said the average would be 4 yards.  What I don't get is that the human talent is obviously better on average than the sim talent.  These run averages should not be equal between human and sim

Run Avg	Human	Sim	Total
D-IA	3.689	4.013	3.795
D-IAA	3.983	4.081	4.038
D-II	4.004	3.762	3.876
D-III	3.994	3.934	3.965
All	3.918	3.933	3.925

Posted by yatzr on 11/18/2010 1:56:00 PM (view original):
This is only for designed run plays (the ones that say rush middle, left, or right).  JConte wasn't kidding when he said the average would be 4 yards.  What I don't get is that the human talent is obviously better on average than the sim talent.  These run averages should not be equal between human and sim

Run Avg	Human	Sim	Total
D-IA	3.689	4.013	3.795
D-IAA	3.983	4.081	4.038
D-II	4.004	3.762	3.876
D-III	3.994	3.934	3.965
All	3.918	3.933	3.925

holy ****

Posted by dravz on 11/18/2010 2:08:00 PM (view original):

Posted by yatzr on 11/18/2010 1:56:00 PM (view original):
This is only for designed run plays (the ones that say rush middle, left, or right).  JConte wasn't kidding when he said the average would be 4 yards.  What I don't get is that the human talent is obviously better on average than the sim talent.  These run averages should not be equal between human and sim

Run Avg	Human	Sim	Total
D-IA	3.689	4.013	3.795
D-IAA	3.983	4.081	4.038
D-II	4.004	3.762	3.876
D-III	3.994	3.934	3.965
All	3.918	3.933	3.925

holy ****

You have got to be kidding me.  This actually proves that recruiting is meaningless now.  Sadly, since recruiting was the best part of this game, what is the point of playing. 

I have one full season left on my Bethune Cookman team.  I have RS Sr QB and 8 WRs.   I am going to throw on every play regardless of D&D just to see what happens.

yatzr, it would be very interesting to to the run average you just posted compared to the avg STR avg ELU avg SPD cores for human and sim for each division. I've got your paypal for that wonderful tool you wrote.

I'll paypal you $10 if you could post that.

Wow, very interesting... GD has entered the time of the SIM... all great dynasties eventually fall I guess :(

Posted by nshreders on 11/18/2010 2:13:00 PM (view original):
yatzr, it would be very interesting to to the run average you just posted compared to the avg STR avg ELU avg SPD cores for human and sim for each division. I've got your paypal for that wonderful tool you wrote.

I'll paypal you $10 if you could post that.

I am in for $10 if you can analyze the core differentials of OL/DL and RBs.  Hell, maybe more than $10...

Yatzr for president (of foxsports)!

Yatzr, you're our savior.

so, regardless of talent you will run for the same average as your opponent.  Why not spend all your recruting money on QBs and WRs and DBs and Ks (since the engine decides if you will make a kick before you actually try it!)?