Post your list here.

See Theme League Classifieds if you want to join.

Catchers
1.1937 Bill Dickey 640
2.1930 Gabby Hartnett 609
3.1888 King Kelly 575
4.1999 Ivan Rodriguez 630

1st Basemen
1.1922 George Sisler 688
2.1906 Jiggs Donahue 690
3.1977 Rod Carew 699
4.2000 Todd Helton 697

2nd Basemen
1.1953 Red Schoendienst 660
2.1993 Mark Lemke 569
3.1975 Joe Morgan 639
4.1906 Nap Lajoie 694

3rd Basemen
1.1980 George Brett 515** not eligible
2.1922 Pie Traynor 647
3.1989 Wade Boggs 742
4.1953 Al Rosen 724

Shortstops
1.1899 Bill Dahlen 563
2.2010 Alcides Escobar 552
3.1998 Alex Rodriguez 753
4.1948 Lou Boudreau 707

Outfielders
1.1931 Al Simmons 601
2.1950 Gene Woodling 551
3.1979 Fred Lynn 630
4.1897 Fielder Jones 775
5.1983 Alan Wiggins 585
6.2009 Curtis Granderson 705
7.1977 Lymon Bostock 665
8.1943 Stan Musial 638
9.1919 Babe Ruth 641
10.1894 Billy Hamilton 860
11.1956 Mickey Mantle 686
12.1916 Tris Speaker 681

 Bench
Catchers
1.1971 Gene Tenace 213
2.1916 Walter Schmidt 213
3.1999 Jason Kendall 336
4.1955 Stan Lopata 386

CornerInfielders
1.1891 Bill Joyce 374
2.1910 Bill Bradley 249
3.2008 Mark Teixeira 234
4.1982 Wade Boggs 381

MiddleInfielders
1.2007 Jeff Keppinger 276
2.2009 Jamey Carroll 358
3.1899 Nap Lajoie 359
4.2008 Nick Punto 374

Outfielders
1.1953 Wally Westlake 273
2.2009 Brett Gardner 284
3.1949 Joe Dimaggio 346
4.1998 Rondell White 397
 

Starting Pitchers
1.1909 Christy Mathewson 292
2.1915 Eddie Plank 283
3.1942 Mort Cooper 294
4.1999 Randy Johnson 272
5.1891 Phil Knell 547
6.1912 Jeff Tesreau 261
7.1953 Mel Parnell 256
8.2009 Zach Duke 214
9.1909 Mordecai Brown 363
10.1915 Pete Alexander 402
11.1913 Walter Johnson 364
12.1910 Ed Walsh 392
13.2001 Randy Johnson 249
14.1999 Pedro Martinez 214
15.1914 Dutch Leonard 238
16.1968 Bob Gibson 305

BullPen Pitchers
1.1916 Ferdie Schupp 150
2.2006 Joe Nathan 69
3.1996 Robb Nen 83
4.1965 Jim Brewer 50
5.1967 Hoyt Wilhelm 89
6.2010 Joel Peralta 49........490
7.1931 Pete Appleton 84
8.1934 Les Tietje 188
9.1955 Mel Wright 39
10.1983 Kevin Gross 96
11.2001 Chris George 74
12.2010 Sergio Santos 52.......533
13.1999 Billy Wagner 75
14.1998 Trevor Hoffman 73
15.1980 Tug McGraw 92
16.2003 Eric Gagne 83
17.1981 Rollie Fingers 116
18.1977 Bruce Sutter 108.......547
19.2002 Octavio Dotel 98
20.2004 Francisco Rodriguez 84
21.1990 Rob Dibble 98
22.1991? Todd Frohwirth 97
23.1995 Troy Percival 83
24.2004 Tom Gordon 90.........550

r

r

NO CRAP!

C--'37 Bill Dickey
1B--''22 George Sisler
2B--'53 Albert Schoendienst
3B--'85 George Brett
SS--1899 Bill Dahlen
OF--'31 Al Simmons, '50 Gene Woodling, '79 Fred Lynn
Bench--'71 Gene Tenace--C; 2007 Jeff Keppinger--MI; 1891 Bill Joyce--CI;  '53 Wally Westlake--OF

SP--'09 Christy Mathewson, '15 Eddie Plank, '42 Mort Cooper, '99 Randy Johnson
RP--'16 Ferdie Schupp, '06 Joe Nathan, '96 Robb Nen, '65 Jim Brewer, '67 Hoyt Wilhelm, 2010 Joel Peralta

Since it's a random league, I randomized a bunch of guys from www.baseball-reference.com and plugged them in where they fit.

HERE GOES NOTHING!

C - 1930 Gabby Hartnett
1B - 1906 Jiggs Donahue
2B - 1993 Mark Lemke
3B - 1922 Pie Traynor
SS - 2010 Alcides Escobar
OF - 1897 Fielder Jones, 1983 Alan Wiggins, 2009 Curtis Granderson

Bench - 1916 Walter Schmidt C, 2009 Jamey Carroll 2B, 1910 Bill Bradley 3B, 2009 Brett Gardner OF  (yuck)

SP - 1891 Phil Knell, 1912 Jeff Tesreau, 1953 Mel Parnell, 2009 Zach Duke  (not bad!)

RP - 1931 Pete Appleton, 1934 Les Tietje, 1955 Mel Wright, 1983 Kevin Gross, 2001 Chris George, 2010 Sergio Santos  


Amazingly, they add up to a hair over $90 million ... mostly because Phil Knell is $18.8m by himself.

1980 Brett is illegal (<550 PA/162)

Here is my 187 million lineup:

C: 1888 King Kelly
1B: 1977 Rod Carew
2B: 1975 Joe Morgan
3B: 1989 Wade Boggs
SS: 1998 Alex Rodriguez
OF: 1977 Lymon Bostock
OF: 1943 Stan Musial
OF: 1919 Babe Ruth
Backup C: 1999 Jason Kendall (336 pa)
Backup CO: 2008 Mark Teixeira (234 pa)
Backup MI: 1899 Nap Lajoie (359 pa)
Backup OF: 1949 Joe DiMaggio (346 pa)

SP: 1909 Mordecai Brown
SP: 1915 Pete Alexander
SP: 1913 Walter Johnson
SP: 1910 Ed Walsh

RP: 1999 Billy Wagner
RP: 1998 Tervor Hoffman
RP: 1980 Tug McGraw
RP: 2003 Eric Gagne
RP: 1981 Rollie Fingers
RP: 1977 Bruce Sutter
(Bullpen = 508 IP)

Posted by schwarze on 1/4/2011 12:06:00 PM (view original):
1980 Brett is illegal (<550 PA/162)

I will SM shysters3 and let him know.  For some reason I thought he had 551 PA not his 515.