Rule V Season 84 Topic

Overall standings, seasons 66 thru 83 (after removing best and worst seasons)... ranked worst to best.
Rank Franchise Years _Wins_ Losses Wining%
1 Rangers 8 587 710 nyyfannova05
2 Rays 7 518 616 0.4568
3 Rockies 8 599 697 dougsdawgs
4 White Sox 10 757 863 0.4673
5 Orioles 8 617 679 0.4761
6 Red Sox 16 1242 1350 sakensei
7 Marlins 10 779 841 mussopini23
8 Brewers 12 941 1003 alleyviper
9 Mariners 15 1177 1254 nordawg
10 Tigers 8 630 667 0.4857
11 D'backs 13 1030 1077 Darthdurron
12 Pirates 4 319 3293 3dayrotation
13 Giants 12 966 978 newarkwilder
14 Royals 8 645 653 spikeboots
15 Angels 8 647 649 disco dogs
16 Phillies 14 1136 1132 sinfonian11
17 Blue Jays 16 1300 1294 pumpkinmcp
18 Braves 16 1300 1292 specsman
19 Twins 12 978 967 ff09
20 Cubs 16 1305 1288 deathdealer
21 Mets 15 1236 1194 0.5086
22 A's 14 1161 1107 0.5119
23 Astros 16 1336 1257 calhoop
23 Yankees 16 1336 1257 buddhagamer
25 Expos 16 1338 1254 tridentric
26 Cardinals 16 1344 1248 bigsteve12
27 Reds 11 933 850 BeAllEndAll
28 Dodgers 16 1359 1234 ribbentrop
29 Padres 16 1402 1190 justinlee_24
30 Indians 15 1320 1110 mllama54


Link to Rules: https://www.whatifsports.com/forums/Posts.aspx?topicID=534416
7/3/2024 8:03 AM (edited)
Season 83 Records/Season 84 Team Selection Draft Order (Timed draft begins: Tuesday July 2 9am est )
1. Ribbentrop 63-99 9am Los Angeles Dodgers #
2. nordawg 65-97 930am Seattle Mariners #
3. specsman 67-95 10am Atlanta Braves #
4. sakensei 68-94 1030am Boston Red Sox #
5. deathdealer 70-92 11am Chicago Cubs #
6. mussopini23 70-92 1130am Florida Marlins #
7. nyyfannova05 75-87 12pm Texas Rangers #
8. calhoop 79-83 1230pm Houston Astros #
9. newarkwilder 79-83 1pm San Francisco Giants #
10. ff09 79-83 130pm Minnesota Twins #
11. BeAllEndAll 80-82 2pm Cincinnati Reds #
12. 3dayrotation 80-82 230pm Pittsburgh Pirates #
13. pumpkinmcp 83-79 3pm Toronto Blue Jays #
14. tridentric 83-79 330pm Montreal/Washington Expos/Nats #
15. alleyviper 83-79 4pm Milwaukee Brewers #
16. discodogs 85-77 430pm California/Anaheim/Los Angeles Angels #
17. bigsteve12 82-80^ 5pm St. Louis Cardinals #
18. sinfonian11 86-76^ 530pm Philadelphia Phillies #
19. mllama54 88-74^* 6pm Cleveland Indians #
20. buddhagamer 98-74^ 630pm New York Yankees #
21. DarthDurron 99-63^ 7pm Arizona Diamondbacks #
22. justinlee_24 100-62^ 730pm San Diego Padres #
23. Dougsdawgs13 87-75% 8pm Colorado Rockies #
24. spikeboots 95-67$ 830pm Kansas City Royals #


# = Keepers Sent
* new owner
^ playoff team
% WS runner-up
$ WS champion

Division Alignment (Historical Winning Percentage Season 66-Present)
NL EAST: Rangers, Red Sox, Marlins, Rockies
NL CENTRAL: Brewers, Mariners, Diamondbacks, Pirates
NL WEST: Giants, Royals, Angels, Phillies
AL EAST: Blue Jays, Braves, Twins, Cubs
AL CENTRAL: Astros, Yankees, Expos/Nats, Cardinals

AL WEST: Dodgers, Reds, Padres, Indians

nyyfannova05; buddhagamer; justinlee_24; newarkwilder; tridentric; sinfonian11; nordawg; darthdurron; sakensei; deathdealer; specsman; 3dayrotation; alleyviper; spikeboots; ff09; mussopini23; dougsdawgs13; BeAllEndAll; disco dogs; ribbentrop; pumpkinmcp; bigsteve12; calhoop; mllama54;


ColeWilhoit
MLB140011
7/5/2024 11:54 AM (edited)
Player Draft Round One (timed schedule begins Saturday July 6th 10:00am)
all times - EST

1) nyyfannova05 - Texas Rangers: 10am Jeff Bagwell - Houston Astros
2) dougsdawgs - Colorado Rockies: 1030am Jason Schmidt - San Francisco Giants
3) sakensei - Boston Red Sox: 11am Joe Morgan - Cincinnati Reds
4) mussopini23 - Florida/Miami Marlins: 11:30am Gerritt Cole - Houston Astros .....................ASTROS OFF BOARD
5) alleyviper - Milwaukee Brewers: 12pm Randy Johnson - Seattle Mariners
6) nordawg - Seattle Mariners: 1230pm Frank Tanana - Cal/Ana/LA Angels
7) DarthDurron - Arizona Diamondbacks: 1pm Corey Seager - Texas Rangers
8) 3dayrotation - Pittsburgh Pirates: 130pm Bip Roberts - Cincinnati Reds..................................REDS OFF BOARD
9) newarkwilder - San Francisco Giants: 2pm Trea Turner - Los Angeles Dodgers
10) spikeboots - Kansas City Royals: 230pm Tony Fernandez - Toronto Blue Jays
11) disco dogs - California/Anaheim/LA Angels: 3pm Fernando Valenzuela - Dodgers........DODGERS OFF BOARD
12) sinfonian11 - Philadelphia Phillies: 330pm Mookie Betts - Boston Red Sox
13) pumpkinmcp - Toronto Blue Jays: 4pm Mark McGwire - St. Louis Cardinals
14) specsman - Atlanta Braves: 430pm Roy Halladay - Toronto Blue Jays............................BLUE JAYS OFF BOARD
15) ff09 - Minnesota Twins: 5pm Aaron Nola - Philadelphia Phillies
16) deathdealer - Chicago Cubs: 530pm Paul O'Neill - New York Yankees
17) calhoop - Houston Astros: 6pm Jorge Posada - New York Yankees................................YANKEES OFF BOARD
18) buddhagamer - New York Yankees: 630pm Chris Sale - Boston Red Sox.........................RED SOX OFF BOARD
19) tridentric - Montreal/Wash Expos/Nats: 7pm Yu Darvish - San Diego Padres
20) bigsteve12 - St. Louis Cardinals: 730pm Luis Arreaz - Florida/Miami Marlins
21) BeAllEndAll - Cincinnati Reds: 8pm Chris Carpenter - St. Louis Cardinals......................CARDINALS OFF BOARD
22) ribbentrop - Los Angeles Dodgers: 830pm Marcell Ozuna - Atlanta Braves
23) justinlee_24 - San Diego Padres: 9pm Jimmy Rollins - Philadelphia Phillies.....................PHILLIES OFF BOARD
24) mllama54 - Cleveland Indians: 930pm Ronald Acura Jr. - Atlanta Braves.........................BRAVES OFF BOARD

Player Draft Round Two (timed schedule begins Tuesday July 9th 10am)
all times - EST

1) nyyfannova05 - Texas Rangers: 10am Johnny Cueto - Cincinnati Reds
2) dougsdawgs - Colorado Rockies: 1030am Kevin Millwood - Atlanta Braves
3) sakensei - Boston Red Sox: 11am Mike Piazza - Los Angeles Dodgers
4) mussopini23 - Florida/Miami Marlins: 11:30am - Manny Ramirez - Cleveland Indians
5) alleyviper - Milwaukee Brewers: 12pm Eric Davis - Cincinnati Reds.........................................REDS OFF BOARD
6) nordawg - Seattle Mariners: 1230pm Darrell Porter - Kansas City Royals
7) DarthDurron - Arizona Diamondbacks: 1pm Alex Bregman - Houston Astros
8) 3dayrotation - Pittsburgh Pirates: 130pm Dan Gladden - San Francisco Giants
9) newarkwilder - San Francisco Giants: 2pm Jose Ramirez - Cleveland Indians.......................INDIANS OFF BOARD
10) spikeboots - Kansas City Royals: 230pm Robinson Cano - New York Yankees
11) disco dogs - California/Anaheim/LA Angels: 3pm Hideo Nomo - LA Dodgers.................DODGERS OFF BOARD
12) sinfonian11 - Philadelphia Phillies: 330pm Trevor Story - Colorado Rockies
13) pumpkinmcp - Toronto Blue Jays: 4pm Garrett Richards - Cal/Ana/LA Angels
14) specsman - Atlanta Braves: 430pm Mark Prior - Chicago Cubs
15) ff09 - Minnesota Twins: 5pm Rich Aurelia - San Francisco Giants..................................GIANTS OFF BOARD
16) deathdealer - Chicago Cubs: 530pm John Valentin - Boston Red Sox
17) calhoop - Houston Astros: 6pm D.J. LeMahieu - New York Yankees.............................YANKEES OFF BOARD
18) buddhagamer - New York Yankees: 630pm Don Sutton - Houston Astros.....................ASTROS OFF BOARD
19) tridentric - Montreal/Wash Expos/Nats: 7pm Ben Sheets - Milwaukee Brewers
20) bigsteve12 - St. Louis Cardinals: 730pm Lenny Dykstra - Philadelphia Phillies
21) BeAllEndAll - Cincinnati Reds: 8pm Stephan Strasburg - Mon/Wash Expos/Nats
22) ribbentrop - Los Angeles Dodgers: 830pm Ke'bryan Hayes - Pittsburgh Pirates
23) justinlee_24 - San Diego Padres: 9pm Andres Gallaraga - Colorado Rockies..........ROCKIES OFF BOARD
24) mllama54 - Cleveland Indians: 930pm Steve Carlton - Philadelphia Phillies...............PHILLIES OFF BOARD

Player Draft Round Three (timed schedule begins: Thursday, July 11th 10am)
all times - EST

1) nyyfannova05 - Texas Rangers: 10am Andre Dawson - Mon/Wash Expos/Nats
2) dougsdawgs - Colorado Rockies: 1030am Walker Buehler - Los Angeles Dodgers
3) sakensei - Boston Red Sox: 11am J.D. Drew - Atlanta Braves
4) mussopini23 - Florida/Miami Marlins: 11:30am - Bruce Sutter - Chicago Cubs
5) alleyviper - Milwaukee Brewers: 12pm AFTBOAT - St. Louis Cardinals
6) nordawg - Seattle Mariners: 1230pm Jerry Reuss - Los Angeles Dodgers......................DODGERS OFF BOARD
7) DarthDurron - Arizona Diamondbacks: 1pm Darren Daulton - Philadelphia Phillies
8) 3dayrotation - Pittsburgh Pirates: 130pm Spencer Stridor - Atlanta Braves.....................BRAVES OFF BOARD
9) newarkwilder - San Francisco Giants: 2pm Brad Keller - Kansas City Royals
10) spikeboots - Kansas City Royals: 230pm Freddy Peralta - Milwaukee Brewers
11) disco dogs - California/Anaheim/LA Angels: 3pm David Cone - Kansas City Royals.........ROYALS OFF BOARD
12) sinfonian11 - Philadelphia Phillies: 330pm Rick Wilkens - Chicago Cubs..........................CUBS OFF BOARD
13) pumpkinmcp - Toronto Blue Jays: 4pm Zack Cozart - Cincinnati Reds
14) specsman - Atlanta Braves: 430pm Shawn Green - Toronto Blue Jays
15) ff09 - Minnesota Twins: 5pm Darin Erstad - Cal/Ana/LA Angels
16) deathdealer - Chicago Cubs: 530pm Trevor Hoffman - San Diego Padres
17) calhoop - Houston Astros: 6pm Trea Turner - Mon/Wash Expos/Nats.........................EXPOS/NATS OFF BOARD
18) buddhagamer - New York Yankees: 630pm Jose Altuve - Houston Astros
19) tridentric - Montreal/Wash Expos/Nats: 7pm Wade Boggs - New York Yankees
20) bigsteve12 - St. Louis Cardinals: 730pm Mike Adams - San Diego Padres...................PADRES OFF BOARD
21) BeAllEndAll - Cincinnati Reds: 8pm Dwayne Hosey - Boston Red Sox
22) ribbentrop - Los Angeles Dodgers: 830pm Marco Scutaro - San Francisco Giants
23) justinlee_24 - San Diego Padres: 9pm Ellis Burks - San Francisco Giants......................GIANTS OFF BOARD
24) mllama54 - Cleveland Indians: 930pm Elvis Andres - Texas Rangers
7/12/2024 5:23 PM (edited)
List of Keepers/Draft Picks

nyyfannova05 - TEXAS RANGERS: TMOPOAT, Josh Hamilton, Rafael Palmiero, Alex Rodriguez, Fergie Jenkins, Jeff Bagwell, Ivan Rodriguez, Johnny Cueto, Adrian Beltre, Andre Dawson

dougsdawgs - COLORADO ROCKIES: Todd Helton, Larry Walker, Troy Tulowitski, Ellis Burks, DJ LeMahieu, Jason Schmidt, Charlie Blackmon, Kevin Millwood, Vinny Castilla, Walker Buehler

sakensei - BOSTON RED SOX: Pedro Martinez, Roger Clemens, Nomar Garciaparra, Fred Lynn, Wade Boggs, Joe Morgan, Derek Lowe, Mike Piazza, J.D. Martinez, J.D.Drew

mussopini23- FLORIDA/MIAMI MARLINS: Kevin Brown, Jose Fernandez, Gary Sheffield, Miguel Cabrera, Hanley Ramirez, Gerritt Cole, Sandy Alcantara, Manny Ramirez, Giancarlo Stanton, Bruce Sutter

alleyviper - MILWAUKEE BREWERS: Prince Fielder, Corbin Burnes, Teddy Higuera, Robin Yount, Christian Yelich, Randy Johnson, Ryan Braun, Eric Davis, Rollie Fingers, AFTBOAT,

nordawg -SEATTLE MARINERS: Ichiro Suzuki, Felix Hernandez, Ken Griffey Jr., Alex Rodriguez, Edgar Martinez, Frank Tanana, Bret Boone, Darrell Porter, Norm Charlton, Jerry Reuss,

DarthDurron - ARIZONA DIAMONDBACKS: Luis Gonzalez, Ketel Marte, Randy Johnson, Zac Gallen, Zack Grienke, Corey Seager, Paul Goldschmidt, Alex Bregman, Curt Schilling, Darren Daulton

3dayrotation - PITTSBURGH PIRATES: Jason Kendall, Freddy Sanchez, Barry Bonds, Andrew McCutchen, Jay Bell, Bip Roberts, Brian Giles, Dan Gladden, Goose Gossage, Spencer Stridor

newarkwilder - SAN FRANCISCO GIANTS: Barry Bonds, Buster Posey, Kevin Mitchell, Tim Lincecum, Madison Bumgarner, Trea Turner, Jeff Kent, Jose Ramirez, Scott Garrelts, Brad Keller

spikeboots- KANSAS CITY ROYALS: Willie Wilson, Bret Saberhagen, Kevin Appier, Zack Greinke, George Brett, Tony Fernandez, Salvador Perez, Robinson Cano, Wade Davis, Freddy Peralta

disco dogs - CAL/ANA/LA ANGELS: Mike Trout, Vlad Guerrero, Shohie Ohtani (pitcher), Rod Carew, David Fletcher, Fernando Valenzuela, Doug DeCinces, Hideo Nomo, Mark Teixiera, David Cone

sinfonian11 - PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES: Zack Wheeler, Mike Schmidt, Bryce Harper, Chase Utley, Curt Schilling, Mookie Betts, Roy Halladay, Trevor Story, Bobby Abreau, Rick Wilkens

pumpkinmcp - TORONTO BLUE JAYS: Roger Clemens Jose Bautista, Mark Eichhorn, John Olerud, Carlos Delgado, Mark McGwire, Roberto Alomar, Garrett Richards, B.J. Ryan, Zack Cozart

specsman - ATLANTA BRAVES: Greg Maddux, John Smoltz, Freddie Freeman, Chipper Jones, Javy Lopez, Roy Halladay, Gary Sheffield, Mark Prior, Craig Kimbrell, Shawn Green

ff09 - MINNESOTA TWINS: Rod Carew, Kenta Maeda, Joe Mauer, Kirby Puckett, Johan Santana, Aaron Nola, Chuck Knoblach, Rich Aurelia, Joe Nathan, Darin Erstad

deathdealer - CHICAGO CUBS: Greg Maddux, Sammy Sosa, Jake Arietta, Derek Lee, Yu Darvish, Paul O'Neill, Ryne Sandberg, John Valentin, Kyle Hendricks, Trevor Hoffman

calhoop- HOUSTON ASTROS: J.R. Richard, Lance Berkman, Justin Verlander, Mike Scott, Roger Clemens, Jorge Posada, TSMOPOAT, D.J. LeMahieu, Billy Wagner, Trea Turner

buddhagamer - NEW YORK YANKEES: Catfish Hunter, Aaron Judge, Bernie Williams, Derek Jeter, Ron Guidry, Chris Sale, Alex Rodriguez, Don Sutton, Rickey Henderson, Jose Altuve

tridentric - MON/WASH EXPOS/NATS: Pedro Martinez, Bryce Harper, Tim Raines, Max Scherzer, Juan Soto, Yu Darvish, Pascal Perez, Ben Sheets, Daniel Murphy, Wade Boggs

bigsteve12 - ST. LOUIS CARDINALS: Willie McGee, Ozzie Smith, Albert Pujols, John Tudor, Adam Wainright, Luis Arreaz, Ted Simmons, Lenny Dykstra, Jose DeLeon, Mike Adams

BeAllEndAll- CINCINNATI REDS: HWSNBN, Johnny Bench, Tom Seaver, Trevor Bauer, Barry Larkin, Chris Carpenter, Joey Votto, Stephan Strasburg, Aroldis Chapman, Dwayne Hosey

ribbentrop - LOS ANGELES DODGERS: Clayton Kershaw, Zack Grienke, Orel Hershiser, Kevin Brown, Gary Sheffield, Marcell Ozuna, Freddie Freeman, Ke'Bryan Hayes, Tony Gonsolin, Marco Scutaro

justinlee_24- SAN DIEGO PADRES: Ken Caminiti, Tony Gwynn, Kevin Brown, Dinelson Lamet, Jake Peavy, Jimmy Rollins, Randy Jones, Andres Gallaraga, Mark Loretta, Ellis Burks

mllama54 - CLEVELAND INDIANS/GUARDIANS: Shane Bieber, Corey Kluber, Albert Belle, Kenny Loften, Zach Plesac, Ronald Acura Jr., Jim Thome, Steve Carlton, Emmanual Clase, Elvis Andres
7/12/2024 5:24 PM (edited)
x
6/27/2024 1:30 PM
I Pick the Los Angeles Dodgers
7/1/2024 12:09 AM
Sorry, just saw that I had the 2nd pick… SEATTLE MARINERS
7/1/2024 7:15 PM
Hotlanta Braves
7/2/2024 9:48 AM
I'll take the Red Sox
7/2/2024 9:51 AM
I'll try those champion Cubbies
Chicago Cubs
7/2/2024 11:08 AM
Texas Rangers
7/2/2024 11:55 AM
12:30 pick

Houston Astros
7/2/2024 12:32 PM
I'll go with the Florida Marlins
7/2/2024 12:35 PM
going to try the Giants.
7/2/2024 1:02 PM
Minnesota Twins
7/2/2024 2:10 PM
1|2|3...9 Next ▸
Rule V Season 84 Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.