I have some time so I thought I'd post the "Way Too Early" poor performing players. With such a small sample size, things should normalize over time - but it's always fun to find the anomalies in player stats. (Note that last round, after 29 games, my 1912 Cubs were 13-16. They finished with 109 wins).
League 1 - 2007 Mets 6-10
This team won game #1 by the score of 2-1 after blowing a 9th inning 1-0 lead. Since then, they are 0-7 in games decided by 1-2 runs and 5-2 in games decided by 3+ runs. Their .561 Exp Win% is top 4 in the NL. '99 Pedro Martinez has a 6.00 ERA in 3 starts. '02 Shawn Green (.944 ops irl) is currently at .442. (.125/.192/.250), 500 points worse.
League 1 - 2016 Angels 6-10
2009 Albert Pujols (.327/.443/.658 irl) is currently hitting.131/.274/.262. His .536 OPS is 575 points below his real life OPS (1.101). My second worst hitter. 2001 Albert Pujols .206/.286/.349. RP Andrew Bailey is 0-3 with a 9.64 ERA with opponent slash of .435/.458/.652.
League 2 - 2000 Astros 7-9
I thought I'd try footballmm11's RP strategy with this team. It's been a disaster. Based on current usage, my ten RPs have a real life aggregate HR/9 rate of 0.54. These 10 RPs have appeared in 86 games, thrown 72 innings and have allowed 18 HRs, a rate 4 times higher than real life. Their ERA of 5.88 has actually come down almost 1/2 run in the last two games, so maybe there's some positive regression coming.
League 2 - 2013 Rangers 11-5
This has been my best team, starting 7-0, but 4-5 since. '14 Matt Garza (1.18 whip irl) is somehow outpitching '02 Derek Lowe (0.98 whip), 1.56 ERA to 5.16 ERA. I'm using three Tandems and it's working, as the regular RPs are coming in much later in the game and haven't been crushed yet. Oddly,, Berkman (1B: A-), Kinsler (2B: A+), Beltre (3B: A) have zero + plays so far.
League 3 - 2008 Padres 10-6
My two Greg Maddux are a combined 3-4. Everybody else a combined 7-2. '98 Hoffman with a 10.29 ERA. My two Mike Adams ERAs of 5.79 and 6.75. Not sure how this team is 10-6.
League 3 - 1983 Brewers 10-6
I just benched '80 Cecil Cooper (.352 irl) due to his .191/.230/.206 slash line. Who would've predicted '78 Ben Oglivie (hitting .417) would be twice as good as the superior '80 Ben Oglivie (hitting .207)? The bullpen is overachieving so far - of course the team's best bullpen arm is a short-inning season of SP Tom Candiotti (0.66 era in 13.2 innings).
League 4 - 1984 Expos 9-7
Hitting stats inflated due to playing at Hilltop. Pitching stats also inflated. Bullpen allowed 30 ERs in 43 IPs (6.28 ERA). Blew a 2-out-nobody-on-9th-inning 8-run lead. Worse sim loss in recent memory.
League 4 - 2015 Royals 8-8
I should have taken 1990 Royals (12-4). Nice pick juice. This team feels like a .500 team. Hitting is overachieving. Pitching is underachieving. Sicks Stadium has something to do with that.